Upper Crust's chicken salad is to die for--beautifully prepared chicken breast with just enough…read moremayo to hold it together and accented with green grapes and slices almonds.

Small, family-owned diner that caters to Butler county courthouse workers and visitors as it's…read moreconveniently located a short walk away. No frills, takeaway-style spot with efficient and courteous service. The menu is exactly what you'd expect for lunch ranging from the usuals like soups, salads, and sandwiches. All executed well and really good. Affordable prices.

Firstly, I want to get something out of the way. I am a genuine New York City/New Jersey Bagel…read moresnob. My experience with Bagels hails back to the old H&H on the West Side of Manhattan on Broadway. They had a world-class shipping business which the owner squandered with drugs and tax evasion. What a pity. My second favorite place in New York is Best Bagels and Coffee in Hells kitchen. Fantastic. So here I find myself moving to the Pittsburgh area and wondering if these people know anything about Bagels. I visited a place called Pigeon Bagels. The lines were down the block on a Sunday morning for that place. The bagels were just ok. They were not super bagels like New York City. They were certainly not worth waiting a half an hour to get a dozen bagels that were just ok. So I had my son bring out five dozen bagels from New Jersey the other day. That'll hold me over. Doing my Bagel surveillance, I found out there was a place in Butler that claimed to have New Jersey bagels. This morning I checked it out with very little hope of believing the hype. I had an everything bagel with lox and cream cheese, onion, and tomato. My wife tried the blueberry bagel. To my utter surprise, the sandwich was really good! If you look at my other reviews, you'll see I can be brutal when it comes to reviewing Bagels. As someone who used to live in New Jersey and who used to frequent H&H bagels, having lived in Manhattan, this baby is the real deal. The real McCoy. The genuine article. You get my point. I'll be coming to Downtown Bagels often. The price for the individual bagels are on the high side by over a dollar, but the sandwich prices are very reasonable. I'm going to give this place two thumbs up.

I love this family's dedication to fresh tasty food. The menu is amazing, you can dine in or take…read moreout. It's all fresh so call early - sometimes they sell out

Ive driven through and been to Butler, plenty of times, but until most recently , upon doing a…read morediner search discovered this place . The old automobile sign decor, milkshake bar, open kitchen concept and friendly staff, left a memorable impression. Big shout out to the couple, the hostess sat me with at the milkshake section of restaurant, and Lindsey one of the owners, for taking care of us. The food was plated to perfection, tasted amazing and the side salad, beyond anyone wildest dream of wow for a diner. Great portions of food, went with the sandwich special for the day. Lindsey, was engaging, great multi tasker and definitely shake master. She had to have done quite a few shakes as I watched and waited for my food. If your looking for milkshakes, burgers, prime rib, be sure to check Chop Shop out.

Came here with out-of-town friends after a ball game. The menu isn't too large which is good - the…read morestaff focus on good food and you don't get decision paralysis. Went with the burger after seeing others come out from the kitchen. It was flavorful and the toppings were tasty. The fries were good, too. They don't have alcohol yet (a cold beer would've made this a perfect lunch) but the iced tea was a close second. The staff were very friendly and I liked the decor. Definitely coming back.

Very nice staff!!! They go above and beyond! One man working there didn't stop cleaning and…read morewelcoming customers the whole time we were there.

I left photos.Anybody want this saggy nasty piece of floppy bread. I use the 2 top halves of the…read moresandwich to make a 1/2 a sandwich because the other 2 pieces of bread are so soaked with. I don't know what II just can't eat it. Also ordered extra pickle. Spear did not receive that and the order took 1 hour to get here. It's father's day so i'll give them that one. The manager here is incompetent and just does not care.. Oh yeah, and look at the date on the good reviews, none are recent.

I am disappointed to say that our recent experience ordering from The Hoagie Shop was not what we…read moreexpected. We ordered Tuna hoagies and they were edible. The tuna flavor was very overbearing and the amount of mayo made the hoagie inedible for me. Luckily, my husband was able to eat it the next day. Stay with their regular subs and you should be fine!

I love The Hoagie Shop. A Butler institution. Some don't like their deli meat cut a little thick…read moreand wrapped around the cheese and shoved down on top of the lettuce and tomato, but that's what the Hoagie Shop is. Great meatballs, hot fresh fries and plenty of them. You have to try the Brisket. It's so good that sometimes I crave it at night! Very tender and cooked just right. Their horseradish sauce makes this sandwich a 10! And, I'm pretty sure the 2 Hoagie Shop locations are keeping a rubber band factory in business. Lol

Had take out from here and it was great! Recommend the hot sausage hoagie Wings were goodread more

We ordered a couple of different flavors of wings and a large fry. The wings were good. Not the…read morebest wings I've ever had but not the worst. We ordered the pigeon flavor which I highly recommend. We also ordered The Most Interesting Flavor in the world. It was good. I don't know if I'd get it again just personal preference. We wanted to see what it was since the menu has no description beyond, not hot, interesting. It's a sweet flavor which I think is made up of honey, butter and season salt. I included a picture. Lastly the fries were awful. They were all burnt. I'm not super picky and believe sauce can conquer most fries but that was not the case with these. They were just awful and went right into the trash. I

Typical great service and food! Have been ordering for years. Glad this one wasn't over spiced w…read morepepper flakes! Really hit the spot!

Great food and an awesome staff. Only thing I would suggest is to advertise your specials in store…read more Nothing like going home and seeing what your eating is on special and you got charged the full price because you didnt ask for "the special of the day". Or maybe train the employees to just suggest the special. That's the only negative, but now I learned to go online before I order.

We tried to order lunch on several different Fridays from my office. Despite everything saying…read morethey would be open at 11 am, they never answered. We called a day ahead of time (Thursday at 4 pm) to ask if they would be open for lunch the following day. We were told they would be open at 11:00 am. So at 11 am we called to place a rather LARGE order... no answer and the answering machine said they didn't open until 4 pm. We give up. We'll give someone else our business.

i literally LOVE this place. I always get it when I come visit my mom. I get takeout and although…read moreit takes about an hour/hour to a half, the food explains why. It's so delicious. This is the best wedgie that ive ever had. Everything is also very reasonably priced!!