Ordered 2 pizzas on line, to go. They were done when we got there less than 15 minutes later. Great…read moreselection of cheese, sauces, toppings. They even have cauliflower crusts which my wife prefers. The pizzas were EXCELLENT . They also have Pittsford Farms Dairy ice cream. What more could you ask for? This will definitely be our go to place for pizza. We live in Brighton but this is well worth the drive.

I wish I could give this 0 stars. I work in the area and always preorder so I can pick up and get…read moreback to work. I ordered for 7P and had to wait 20-30 ins for my food. What's the point then? I wasted my whole lunch waiting for food and all the staff could say was sorry it's busy. Yah I can see that but that doesn't mean you can't figure out how to run your orders in a timely fashion. I always order at least an hour ahead and today it was 3+ hrs ahead of time. My wings were undercooked which is crazy because they were "done first" and I still had to wait 15 mins for the pizza. WASTE OF MONEY. Maybe try having a manager that isn't 16 overseeing things to ensure order flow. 1 celery stick and no sauce either. This place is a joke. Better off going to Wingsover or Wingstop.

A great place in an unlikely spot: an old Abbott's in a plaza that has seen better days. Lovely…read morepeople and good food. We found them because our regular spot for safe gluten-free food was temporarily closed and we just keep going back. They have gluten-free pastries including apple fritters--a must try! Would love to see more vegetarian options show up, but they are very agreeable and understanding if you request light cheese or no cheese. The regular pizzas are also amazing; really good sauce and crust. Highly recommended.

It had been years since we tried Arthur Jaxon but my boyfriend had gotten a recommendation about…read moretheir pulled chicken garbage plate. The pulled chicken was so good! Very smoky, not dry, very good portion size! The overall garbage plate was pretty good. The salt potatoes were a little more like soft, butter-soaked potatoes. The bbq baked beans were good. The combo of the bbq beans with the pulled chicken is quite sweet. Next time I would try another side. The corn muffin isn't bad but would be more flavorful if I stopped to dab some sweet cream butter on it. My boyfriend tried the brisket. It had a nice smokiness to it but was a little chewy/ dry. My boyfriend smokes bbq as a hobby, so he might be a little more particular than some. Something that I want to rave about is the hand-breaded cauliflower bites. I've never gotten these before. They reminded me of pan-fried treats that my Italian grandparents used to make around the holidays. They were crispy and delicious. The sauce on the side was welcome so I could enjoy them just how I wanted them. If they are supposed to be a substitute for chicken wings....well I don't know about that. But I would happily order them again and eat them on their own.

I live in the Vi'llage of Webster. There has been a coming soon sign in the old Music store window…read morefor many many months. I've had their pizza before and am very excited to have a new favorite place, especially because it's so close. What's the hold up? I hope the food makes the wait worth it.

Better than dominoes and that it's our pizza standard. A bit out of the way for us but worth the tryread more

Last Wednesday we ordered a medium pizza and dozen wings for delivery for our first try from this…read morepizza place. It was just great!!! Delivery was faster than expected and the food was really good. Best wings and pizza I've had since moving to Honeoye. Definitely ordering again 8/17/3019 Ordered for delivery again last night. Another medium pizza and dozen wings. Was excellent!! Delivery well within the time they said and hot delicious pizza with plenty of toppings. Wings just as we ordered. We will order more often!

Recently called to place an order after reading that the business has seemingly gone downhill and…read moredecided that we would give them a shot, weve been there many times but not recently. The lady when i called was the rudest person i have ever dealt with to the point i actually told her to disregard and we would take our business elsewhere. When i left a review on their facebook and a comment, they deleted their facebook page completely.

I know pizza is a personal preference, but I don't know why Mr. Shoes Pizza isn't in the 4-5 rating…read morezone. I've tried so many pizza places around Rochester looking for a good thin crust pizza and Mr Shoes wins hands down. You have to ask for the thin crust. And after the first pie, you might ask the next time to go a little lighter/heavier on the sauce or cheese. They know what you mean and can make it exactly as you like. Give them a try, if you haven't already.

The website was easy to use, and at checkout, they offered $2 cinnamon toes to add onto my order,…read morewhich I couldn't pass up. At the store, I asked for a cup of marinara because the website didn't let me select marinara and they gave me a cup for free, on top of the sauce I had selected instead! The food was delicious! I had a stomach ache prior to eating, and after eating the cinnamon toes, I began feeling so much better! Hahaha. I can't wait to order again next week! Check out their specials!

Pizzas are creative, innovative and delicious. Everyone is welcoming and friendly. Jeannie knows…read moreall the regulars by name.

You can tell from the parking lot at lunch time that this is the place to go for a couple of quick,…read moredelicious slices. Police officers, construction workers, delivery guys... They could start their own version of The Village People. The young lady at the counter provides enthusiastic service with just the right amount of moxy. Numerous options, daily specials and yummy garlic knots. Not quite the best pizza in town in my opinion but definitely above average. Go early on Tuesdays for discounted slices.

We drive about 30 mins to visit Nima's and it's worth it. The employees always make you feel…read morewelcomed including helping us adjust the dining area tables to fit our party. Love the old school pizzeria vibe in the dining area. The pizza and wings are perfect. I appreciate how saucey and crispy the wings are. The pizza is the exact thin texture I enjoy. Nima's delivers consistent quality every time. We have a lot of great pizza spots to choose from and this is up there for me in the top 3.

This is the BEST slice of pizza I've ever had ! If you want a slice of pizza that melts in your…read moremouth and every bite is absolutely delicious .. this is it. Nimas would have lines around the corner in NYC ... this is what people talk about when they say NY pizza. I miss it already!

Excellent foor and customer service. The vibe is pretty excellent too. Needless to say will be back!read more

We absolutely love getting pizza from here. The employees are always working so hard to get food…read moreorders out and help people grab quick items from the small grocery section. It's a nice little place to grab hersheys ice cream in the warmer months as well. We are very lucky to have this in our neighborhood.