What can I say they live up to the hype. We had the lobster wow its begin enough for 2 people and its delicious jam packed with other things in the lobster like churrasco. Its right on the malecon so enjoy the view and the service was very good. read more

See all

My family of 6 arrived the moment they opened and we had an exceptional experience. The service was immediate, the views were immaculate and the food. My God...the food. I ordered a lobster that was stuffed with literally the best, freshest seafood I've ever had in my life. Vibrant, succulent, juicy...finding a better lunch in Naguabo is (not to be dramatic) IMPOSSIBLE. Amongst our party we also ordered fruit frappes, pasta dishes, arroz y habichuela and our entire party was blown away by the quality of everything. Obviously, a place this good gets very busy very quickly. So my advice is to get there as early as possible, order EVERYTHING you want while you have your waiter and be patient! Food this good can't be made in 5 minutes. All in all, this was our favorite lunch spot in PR by far. I cannot stop recommending it. read more

See all

Sabado 10 de diciembre de 2026 este local está en el Malecón de Naguabo en un local que se comparten dos negocios. Recomendación al frente hay estacionamiento privado que pagas $5.00 y puedes estar todo el día. Ahora bien local al aire libre con mesas que miran hacia el mar y otras mesas al lado de la calle. El local se llena pero llegamos temprano. El servido excelente y la comida espectacular!!! Recomendado si te gustan los mariscos. read more

See all

Here's a polished, fair but honest 2-star review you can post. I kept it factual and calm, without attacking anyone personally: We came to Super Benjy's Restaurant because of all the hype on TikTok and Instagram, especially around their lobster dishes. Unfortunately, our experience didn't live up to what's being promoted online. Before even going inside, we ordered a beer and immediately noticed the staff wasn't very friendly, which already gave us a strange first impression. Since we were already there, we decided to stay and give it a chance. Once seated, it took about 30 minutes for the young server to take our drink order. Because of the long wait, we felt pressured to place our food order right away. We ordered one of the most expensive dishes on the menu, the lobster Mar y Tierra, and sadly the food was overcooked and disappointing. During the meal, the server did not check on us. We asked multiple times for butter and were ignored, which made the experience frustrating and discouraging. Despite everything, I still left an $8 tip. Overall, the experience felt overrated and overhyped by social media. There are several other restaurants on the same street that offer much better food and service. This place has potential, but based on our visit, it didn't meet expectations. I left 2 stars 1 for the food and 1 for the service. The only good thing that was interesting in a nice way was the view and the view only. read more

Super Benjy’s Cuisine - The restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Naguabo, Puerto Rico

Delicious vegetarian mofongo! My son had the fillet of chillo, which he loved. The ambiance is amazing! Right on the water, and most importantly to us, they took great care of our 11 year old. They made him chicken tenders with fries, though they weren't on the menu. Great food, beautiful scenery, and friendly service. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Disappointed by the Hype - Not Worth the Wait I traveled all the way from Maryland to Naguabo with high hopes of dining at Super Benjy's Cuisine. I'll admit, TikTok played a big role in building my excitement--after liking one of their posts, I was constantly fed glowing videos of the restaurant. Naturally, I chose to visit this place over many other options in the area. Unfortunately, the experience didn't live up to the hype. We waited nearly an hour just to be seated, which we accepted as part of the popularity. While we waited outside and had drinks at the bar, I had to go inside and check in myself to finally get a table. When we were seated, I was expecting to enjoy a beautiful beach view--that's part of the appeal, right? However, our table had its curtain drawn, unlike the other tables, blocking the view entirely. It felt like we were missing out on the whole beachside dining experience. Once seated, we waited another 50 minutes after ordering before our food arrived, and even then, six tables who came after us were served before us. My dish was expensive--$54--and it was completely underwhelming. I asked for spicy al ajillo sauce as asked by the waiter for the fish, but what I got was so overdone and overloaded with heat that it was barely edible. Worse, the dish had to be sent back because it was incorrect the first time. The tostones tasted like they came straight out of a bag--stale and flavorless. My mother's dish was also disappointing. Her fish was soggy from excessive sauce, which we both agreed should have been served on the side. For a place that markets itself as a premium coastal dining spot, the execution was lacking in both presentation and flavor. I really wanted to love this place. I came all this way and waited a long time because I believed the buzz. But the truth is, the food was subpar, and the overall experience was frustrating. If I had known how disappointing it would be, I wouldn't have waited at all. Final thoughts? Don't fall for the TikTok hype. There are likely better restaurants nearby that offer both great food and a view worth the drive. read more

Overall, the food is pretty decent if you're looking for some good lobster. The wait to order was longer than expected, however once it ordered, we did not take that long to come out. The only recommendation I have for this restaurant is that it should do a better job in maintaining it clean read more

See all

This place is literally on the East Coast of Naguabo. It shares the building with another business. However they have a unique wood fire pizza oven which they use to bake the Lobster and make pizza too. It's outdoor sitting, not formal at all. Seafood Dishes are magnificent! Bathrooms are outside the restaurant in between the two businesses. Recommend for good food in not formal Setting. read more

See all

Food and drinks were amazing and the service and prices matched the quality and taste of the food and drinks. The location provided wonderful views to match everything else. It's not a fancy place, but that probably accounts for the prices being reasonable. From now on, every time I'm visiting Puerto Rico I'll make it a point to come by for at least one meal. read more

Super Benjy’s Cuisine - Churrasco con mofongo, piña colada & brick oven cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naguabo, Puerto Rico

Arrived early and be ready to wait. The food is amazing. I had mofongo stuffed with mahi in criolla sauce it was delicious. There is no air conditioner wear comfortable clothes. We had an excellent view of the ocean. Will recommend . Can't wait to go back. read more

We started our meal with high hopes and great expectations. Before we had even sat down, the advertisements of gigantic, mouthwatering lobsters accompanied with shrimp and queso blanco had piqued our appetites. Alas, the food did not live up to what we saw in the menu. As has previously been said, the food was not worth the price. There were twelve of us in total, and between all of us, we tried most of the items on the menu. The lobster and steak received high marks from two members of our party, but the lobster and shrimp was just ok. Further, one of the members of our party got the filete dorado, and he swore they did not clean the fish. Another member of our party ordered the filete de chillo with fries, but they mistakenly brought her something else. Mistakes happen, so we did not hold it against them. Despite all of the other complaints I have, the most significant reason for my low marks was the service. The restaurant set our waitress up for failure because they did not give her anyone to assist with our table. She also did not do herself any favors by failing to bring out our drinks, though she did try to charge us for them. When I brought it to her attention that she failed to bring us our drinks, she accused me of having an attitude. It seems every accusation is a confession, because her attitude was terrible. She never apologized for not bringing our drinks and taking over an hour to bring everyone's food. The only saving grace was that she brought my daughter some cherries when my daughter asked for them. I thought that was very kind of her, and I appreciated her for that. All in all, I would not come back to this restaurant. read more

Went there today with the family, as it was recommended.....Bad decision......not a very positive experience.....We waited forever for a table.....people got served before b us...that came AFTER us.......waited more that 45 minutes for 3 fish and a octopus salad......The worst Chillo we've ever v eaten.......overpriced at $30 dollars and my nieces was almost $50!!!!!....THE Service was really bad.....the waiter ETZEL was Missing in action most of the time....Im sure he forgot to m put the order in, that's why we waited so long......The amount of $$$$$$$ Paid was definately not worth it.....I suggest you walk away from this place....​ read more

I was there Friday 5th of June 2025. I order the lobster deal with majado of Malanga. Well serve but it taste like shit. I told the waitress about the issue and he offer no insight. I end up paying 180 dol including tips for me and my wife. The food tasted like it was made with clorox. And I mean it. Please.stay away from this place. I don't think they take the time to taste their own food and that my people has a lot to say about you guys. HORRIBLE. read more

I saw this place on Facebook and followed them for months prior to our trip. The food was as delicious as it looked and worth every penny. Four of us split the lobster mar y Tierra and all of us agreed it was one of the best meals we had EVER had. Do not miss this restaurant! read more

Super Benjy’s Cuisine - Lobster mar y tierra with mofongo - Pizza Near Me - Naguabo, Puerto Rico

Delicious mojitos, awesome food , the best pizza baked in in brick oven, the best in Naguabo! read more

See all

Great location on the Malecón de Naguabo. Pizzas were good, the coco arepas are delicious, and the Piña Colada is awesome! Must visit if you're in Naguabo. read more

See all

Lamentablemente pedí un chillo. Es el peor chillo que he comido en mi vida. Le recomiendo que las salsas no bañen el pescado. El servicio fue: una hora por ser sentados y luego 45 minutos por la comida. Peor aún, llegaron tres mesas después de nosotros y la comida les llegó primero. No vuelvo. Le doy una estrella porqué no hay cero. read more

I am not an experimental person regarding food. I'm very keen about staying with a known entity and repeating a great place. So this trip for food was an 80 mile away adventure for myself and spouse. She loves lobster so a new restaurant sounds like a good idea. Well the food was just okay I have much better nearby. It was just a very busy tourist spot so food prep suffered. Most people would probably like it but like I mentioned I'm picky. Service was good considering the very high turnover of customers perhaps a different day less busy would be better. My wife wanted a grilled lobster tail. They served what appeared to be a boiled tail. Overcooked tough and Not very tasty. I ordered the red snapper it was cooked in a wood fired brick oven. Sorry but not my cup of tea. We would not revisit perhaps if it was near I'd give them another try. It was pricey plus travel distance cost over $150. For us not worth it. read more