I was staying at the hotel around the corner, ordered and picked up an Italian Combo Super Sandwich. The quality of the ingredients and service was excellent. The restaurant itself is a casual place with fast food atmosphere with not particularly clean counters. Sadly, I didn't like the flavor of the sandwich for some reason. It wasn't bad, just not great. And the prices are expensive. read more

As all Joes and Joeys, I'm a connoisseur of sandwiches. This is a top notch sandwich spot right in the heart of Yale campus. As we all know the bread is really the hero of any good sandwich. The bread on the "Super" size sandwich was remarkably good for a wedge roll. Got a custom turkey sando. Service was quick. Place is modern and clean. Parking might be tough but got one right in front, like they were expecting me. Gonna have to go back the try the award winning chicken cutlet, but I'll be the judge of that. would have posted a picture but ate it too fast. read more

I have had a deli sandwich craving all week and tried out super sandwich in New Haven. I ordered the spicy chicken cutlet super sandwich which was big enough to share. Service was friendly & quick. They offer bottled drinks and chips as well. Street parking is available as well as free WiFi and charging outlets to sit and get work done read more

Supersandwich - New Haven - Spiced chicken cutlet Super - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Wow!!! What a great sandwich. Had the chicken with eggplant. The eggplant was nice and thin sweet and super tasty, the chicken was perfectly tender. The lettuce and tomato were super fresh. Great service. I recommend very highly read more

Italiano chicken cutlet on a Skinny size roll. Delicious breaded chicken breast. The roasted peppers and balsamic made it very juicy. Really good! Nice, clean interior. Friendly staff. read more

See all

Food is delicious as are the drinks! Great location in Porter Square. We both had a breakfast Bahn Mi & they were so, so good! Perfectly balanced ingredients & the bread was to die for. Very cute little space with lots of seating though most of the seats were filled by students with laptops studying. A quiet crowd! I would absolutely go back in a second. Amazing food! read more

Friendly service, great sandwich, I would definitely come again if I'm ever in New Haven. The cashier was very chill and did not judge me even though I bought three sandwiches for myself. He asked me if I was buying for the office.. clean and chill, had a good experience! read more

SuperSandwich New Haven had been a work-in-progress for a while so I was excited when it finally opened last week! The inside of the restaurant is clean, airy, and bright with multiple long tables that are great for large groups. The employees are polite and helpful. The menu has many vegetarian options as well as hot vs cold sandwiches. I ordered the eggplant mozzarella in the "skinny" size which was about $10. It was huge!!! The fillings were stacked up high. Even though it was delicious (fluffy bread, flavorful eggplant and pesto), I could only finish half and saved the rest for another meal. There were a few minor issues (to be expected with a newly opened restaurant) - I tried to order on Snackpass but my order was canceled by the app. I ended up ordering in person with no issues, and I'm sure these kinks will get ironed out with time. I'll definitely be back for their quick, convenient and delicious sandwiches but will probably order over the phone or in person for now. read more

See all

This is a quick, order-at-the-counter lunch spot right in downtown New Haven with a huge menu of sandwiches and salads. We came here to try their chicken cutlet sandwiches and they did not disappoint! I got the chicken cutlet with eggplant and balsamic. The chicken was perfect, thin, and crispy. The fried eggplant was also great, not soggy or heavy. The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because I wish they would up their bread game to be as good as what they put in the sandwiches! read more

Supersandwich - New Haven - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

I was craving a turkey sandwich and Yelp led me here. It was awesome and very reasonably priced. They welcome substitutions and making your sandwich to your liking so I don't even remember what I got but I know it was my own turkey-based concoction and the cashier did not mind at all. She was very patient and sweet. I'd def recommend if you're in the area and want a deli sandwich. I can't speak to their hot sandwiches as I've only been the once. read more

Amazing sandwiches, reasonably priced, significant selection, quality ingredients. Who could resist? read more

I got to try the New Haven location finally and the sandwiches taste as delicious as the ones from the other location. My server was extremely sweet and friendly. I am glad to see so many new options (some being vegan and vegetarian) added to their menu. read more

Supersandwich - New Haven - menus on the wall - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

If you go here, it's for the chicken cutlet sandwiches IMO. There are other options but I think the cutlet is their go to. They only serve on ciabatta bread. It's not my favorite kind of bread but the ciabatta they use is better than others. We happened to walk by on their first night open, and the owner, Steve, greeted us outside. He was really nice. We weren't hungry but he offered us a free sandwich since we live close by so that we could try it. We could not turn that down. It was delicious all the way through. We have been back a few times since. I would give their cutlet sandwich a solid 7.9 out of 10. They have a TON of options including a lot of vegan choices, so be prepared before you go to know what you want. I will recommend that they add traditional condiments like mustard though. read more

Got the Chicken Banh Mi. Flavorful, great quality and good value. Came out in about 3 minutes and it didn't disappoint. Would recommend.

We've ordered Super sandwich several times now at my office and have been very happy! They seem to have something for everyone. We really like the size of the mini sandwiches for trays, they are the perfect size. We've also been very happy with the salads and delivery has always been prompt. read more

Very good! Exceeded expectations. Fresh tasty and good bread. I got the skinny chicken eggplant and DoorDashed it. I ate it up too quickly and only remember to take pic of half the sandwich. I will be ordering again. read more

Supersandwich - New Haven - Skinny Chicken Eggplant Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Delicious. I ordered a small chicken sandwich and subbed the BBQ for ranch. It was very filling and the chicken was perfectly cooked. I didn't wait very long either. read more

Supersandwich - New Haven - Chicken Bacon and Ranch (subbed instead of BBQ sauce). - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

When I'm telling you this is the best sandwich I've ever had, I mean it. This place is legit. I got the Chicken Cutlet Italiano, which consisted of a HOT CRISPY JUICY chicken cutlet on fresh ciabatta bread with prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, arugula, and vinaigrette (I opted to hold the roasted red peppers). It's tough for me to give five stars to a casual sandwich spot, but this place deserves it. You don't need to travel all the way to Italy; just order from SuperSandwich. read more

Went to Supersandwich for lunch this weekend. Overall, it was a bit of an underwhelming experience. The restaurant is nice and clean and there are no complaints there or with the service. We took in the huge menu board and decided on what we were going to eat. I got the sweet & sour chicken and my fiancee got the egg salad. I was really excited for a chicken cutlet sandwich! When the food came out a couple minutes after ordering it though, I was honestly let-down. I had thought the chicken cutlets were going to be cooked to order. In hindsight, maybe that was an unfair expectation but it was listed under hot sandwiches. The chicken in my sandwich was clearer just lukewarm reheated chicken. It tasted like it was pulled out of a refrigerator, put in a microwave for 20 seconds and then served. Now listen, if this place wasn't marketed as being famous for their chicken cutlets, I'd cut them some slack. But when you hang your hat on a speciality and that speciality doesn't live up, that kills it for me. The bread was decent and the toppings on the sandwich were good. My fiancee had some issues with the construction of her sandwich. The cheese wasn't melted on hers and there were brown spots on the avocado she asked for. It also was a cubed chicken sandwich, which just doesn't work great for sandwich structural integrity with the cibatta bread they serve it all. The combo just makes for a sandwich that fell apart in a few bites. Which, maybe is user error, but the chicken was also under-seasoned. I grew up in an Italian household where chicken cutlets and chicken cutlet sandwiches were a staple growing up. My standards are pretty high as a result. The result is nice, service was good, menu was extensive. You may have a better experience than me, but I personally don't feel compelled for a second visit. Edit: The owner of Supersandwich reached out to me to address the concerns I mentioned in this review. He wants me to give them another chance. In light of the effort he's making, I am bumped my review up one star until I go back and try again. Then I will update with a final verdict. read more

I had to order delivery because I was at the stats wrestling tournament. It was the biggest pain in the asss. So they do not deliver on Saturday. Uber eats it is. After having to call the restaurant twice. Regarding the order, we're having contact Uber. It was just way too much like an hour just to order. The sandwich I got was an eggplant Parm. It arrives on like ciabatta bread, which was not what I was expecting. I have this idea in my head of what an eggplant sandwich is supposed to be in ciabatta bread is not a part of what that thought is. I suspect it's not that way for anyone. I don't know what the inside this place looks like so I can't comment on that. I had to order my wife a Greek salad because she can't have gluten. She said it was great, but I wasn't really impressed with the way it looked so just so everyone knows I use a Publix sub And a sandwich from Arthur Avenue as my comparisons for sandwiches This sandwich was probably about a three on a scale of one to 10. It was good. It was kind of salty so I think the way they made the eggplant they're trying to get the water out and made it salty, but the bread sucked. It was really crappy ass bread if it were not for the bread, it would be a pretty decent sandwich read more

So delicious!! I was in town for a conference and saw the fantastic reviews for this place. I got the skinny chicken and eggplant sandwich, and it was FANTASTIC. The arugula, mozzarella and tomato were the perfect combination, and the sandwich was SO satisfying and unique. Highly recommend. read more

Ordered an Italian sub. Was v good except they put their balsamic vinegar dressing on bathe pieces of bread. Unfortunately, a ton of it. Overwhelmed the Italian meats, which is hard to do. Ruined the sandwich. Don't put so much or any of the sandwich, it's not authentic. read more

Love Supersandwich. My only complaint about this place used to be that they had limited hours, but they've recently extended them (including late night on weekends). Still nice folks making great sammies. read more

I didn't know what to expect! But I was impressed. I got the pretzel chicken cutlet and it was really good. My boyfriend got the Russian chicken cutlet and really liked his. We also shared fries. It was a great day. We will definitely be coming back! read more

I wasn't even aware that this was a BRAND NEW spot in New Haven when I ordered on one of the delivery apps. (It wasn't even on yelp at the time). I have to say, in our current world of overpriced, underserved, and general lackluster EVERYTHING, this was a ray of sunshine!! High quality food, HUGE for the prices, and even the assembly was top notch (I devoured my food before I thought to take a picture) . I wouldn't hesitate to order again! read more

Sandwich, not sure I can refer to it as "super". While the options you have are better the your average deli. It does not end up being anything extra ordinary. If in town again and need to find a place to eat. I would consider returning. Service is good and prompt. read more

It's a nice spot, nice staff, and the sandwiches are pretty bomb. Also nice and clean atmosphere.

Let me start by saying the food is great, fresh, tastes great. The only inssue i have is the delivery. out of the last 5 times I have ordered (this last time is now the end of my ordering from them) they have only once been here by the time requested (but they forgot to call and left it with security). Each time but that one time, they have been 15-30 minutes late. I've given them from 45 minutes to a full hour for the delivery. If you cant deliver in that time frame, I am not giving you my money any longer, I'll order from someplace else and get it on time read more

We love this place! Been there twice. Tried the sweet and sour chicken sandwich (had a delicious mango slaw on it) and the bahn mi chicken sandwich (also with a slaw but this one with cukes, cabbage and carrots) Both were absolutely delicious. the ciabatta bread was fresh and tasty. They have salads but we haven't tried them. Reasonable prices too. highly recommend - it's our new favorite place in New Haven! read more

Today I tried an eggplant cutlet sandwich (the eggplant mozzarella) from super sandwich and it was AWESOME... fresh, not greasy, and the pesto was delicious. Can't wait to try more! read more

HUGE sandwiches! Love all the vegetarian options here. My favorite was the tofu bahn mi and the eggplant parm

Was at a party catered by Supersandwich and their chicken cutlets were the best - ever, the eggplant the thinnest you can imagine and the meatballs in red sauce outstanding. Looking forward to visiting the store. read more