Eddie was our server then moved to bartending. His service was amazing and he was very knowledgeable regarding the menu and the restaurant. All of our food was delicious, came out on time and the drinks were fabulous! If you stop in, make sure you say hi to Eddie and we will definitely be back to sit in his section! read more

Olives and Oil - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

We held our wedding ceremony and reception here last month and it could not have been more perfect!! Brittney did an amazing job coordinating everything for us and was so attentive, communicative, and so helpful with curating everything for the day. On the day of our wedding, Deon, Kelsey, and all of the Olives & Oil staff that were working that night were the absolute best. Everyone complimented the food and drinks -- and still are a month later. We are constantly dreaming about some of the menu items we picked (especially the housemade vodka pasta, arancini, and pork belly bites). The atmosphere of the restaurant is so inviting and different than a lot of other restaurants in the area. It was absolutely perfect for our small wedding party. Thank you so much to the whole team for making our day so special and wonderful! We will definitely be back to New Haven and will have to make this restaurant a regular stop when we do. read more

Presentation and vibe at this restaurant are very good. I did find it to be quite expensive, verging on overpriced for food quality. Pasta was a bit mushy and greasy and not as much flavor as I would've expected. The risotto balls/ sauce were very good. Definitely large portions though! Drinks were very good, and wait staff attentive and friendly. This seemed like a a popular restaurant for student life , with plenty of parking at temple street nearby. Definitely a good date spot. read more

We had brunch here before a show at the Shubert. Horrible food and service was even worse. The waitress never refilled out waters. For the most part the waitress was MIA. Eggs that were served on both the eggs Benedict and the Breakfast Rissoto were very under cooked. The whites of the eggs were not even set. The bacon in both dishes was practically raw and inedible. The Italian bread under the eggs Benedict was basically a coupon and unable to be cut. With so many better choices in New Haven, don't waste your time here. read more

It was our 1st time here. We appreciated the last min accommodation for my daughter's birthday...party of 4. However, is was uncomfortably hot and humid in the restaurant. The way the ice was served left a sweaty mess of water all over the table, menus, & our stuff. No napkins or spoon for sauce or pasta. Had to ask for a spoon w my spaghetti, therefore you can tell it's not authentic Italian cuisine. My favorite, cacio e pepe was served so salty I couldn't take more than 2 bites. Drinks were average. Service was regular. 5.5 out of 10. read more

See all

The waitress was good, the food was great, we were seated on the opposite side of the bar and there were only 2 people at the bar but the bartender was so loud and obnoxious we couldn't hear the people in our party. read more

First, I definitely recommend getting a reservation. The place was absolutely packed on the Friday I went. The service was great, even with all of the people there. The wine was tasty and the food was excellent! The pasta was cooked al dente and the bolognese was very rich but the ricotta on it balanced the flavor perfectly. The portion was massive, I could have easily shared it with two other people. read more

Great atmosphere for a friend's dinner! Our waitress was very attentive and the timing of the meal progressed at a good pace. For appetizers we had the Brussel sprouts and broccolini. The brussel sprouts with bacon were delicious but the broccolini was overcooked so had no flavor. For an entree, I had the eggplant Parmesan in vodka sauce and it was a huge portion and delicious. 8 out of the 10 guests in our party took home leftovers. read more

See all

The bottomless pasta was a fun idea and Marissa made our dinner even better by being super nice, accommodating, and having great reccomendations--will definitely be back:) read more

I loved my experience at Olives and Oil in New Haven the ambiance of the restaurant was so cool and I loved the brick interior. The staff was so nice and gave great recommendations and answered all of our questions honestly. They brought out bread with olive oil (were even thoughtful enough to ask if anyone wanted it without red pepper flakes which I appreciated because I hate spicy food.) I tried the cinnamon crunch toast espresso martini and it was amazing. The drink menu had a lot of options, including an espresso martini flight which I thought was fun. Food was absolutely amazing with giant portions. I got the bottomless tortellini which was fresh made with ricotta cheese filling (I was nervous was going to be super heavy) but it was fresh, light and delicious. I started with the vodka sauce for the first round and moved to the Alfredo pesto on round 2 from the waiter's recommendation and it was 10/10. Another entree we ordered was the chicken Parmesan and it was massive, they gave a great portion of delicious chicken and the sauce was so good. I highly recommend Olives and Oil, will be coming back to try more! read more

See all

Food could've been better, it was cold. The ambiance and vibe wad good, the drinks were good and service was decent. Went with some friends when we were home for thanksgiving, which may be the reason for the food not being up to par. Would try again, but nothing to race about. read more

Olives and Oil - Calamari, flat bread, wings and fries - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

We stopped in after a show and were immediately seated without reservations. The restaurant was nicely decorated for the holidays. We were seated at one of their booths, but they had high top tables and bar seating as well. I started with the butternut squash soup which was the best part of my meal. I really enjoyed of, especially with the day being so cold. For my entree I had the steak with garlic butter which was cooked at a perfect medium rare. My girlfriend had the branzino which was a very large portion. She enjoyed it. Overall we enjoyed or meal. read more

See all

Another fantastic Happy Hour!! Fantastic food and drinks every time! Thank you to the staff for another flawless experience read more

See all

I swear every time I come to Olives and Oil it is even better than my last visit! Easy to get a reservation on a Saturday night and we were seated right away. Our waitress was very attentive and on top of refilling our waters which was greatly appreciated. Solid cocktails, the olive salad is delicious, and the garlic flavor in their Prettier in Pink pizza was fantastic. My go to is their chicken picatta but I swap out grilled chicken for their chicken cutlet which is 10/10. They have delicious pasta that you can tell is homemade and their salmon is also very tasty. read more

Stopped in for a small plate and cocktail. Small plates: Eggplant chips - OMG Meatballs with polenta and marinara - again, OMG The craft cocktail menu is dangerous - we stayed for one more than we intended. Thank you Uber! Why don't we come here more often? Oh yeah, the staff is always friendly. Thumbs up to Mia and Jake. read more

Came here for brunch with my mom. Everything was perfect. We were instantly sat for our reservation. They had such a wide variety of food options. Our server recommended a fantastic bottle of wine. We look forward to making this place a Mother's Day tradition as long as it's offered. Definitely recommend the homemade pasta! read more

We were long fans of the Seymour location and very sad when it closed. Always wanted to try this one, but never was in the area. Finally was there with some time to kill and decided to check it out. Service was good, food was on par with the other location, and overall exactly what we expected. read more

Olives and Oil - Cacio e Pepe Pasta - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Yesterday was a disappointment. At over $50PP plus a minimum mandatory 20% tip, one would have expected the food to at least be hot. Scrambled eggs..cold. Poached eggs..cold. Salmon looked dry and unappealing. Sodas cost extra, only juice and coffee included. It was supposed to be a congratulatory celebration and a mother's day coming from out of town and left wanting more. The service was non-existent. When my husband requested another drink, he had to follow up with the waitress and her response was "I'll check on it". They were not busy. I understand why. I have had pleasant a la carte experiences there, so I was truly disappointed by this experience. I would discourage anyone from going to their brunches and stick to their menu options. read more

I have not been here since their pandemic restriction days and I'm so glad I tried it again! Their food is delicious! The arancini was a big hit with the table. I thought the eggplant crisps were okay. I got the goat cheese carbonara which was HEAVENLY - so good. The service was great - everyone was very attentive and friendly. They have lots of bar seating, high top tables, and booths. Great for large parties or couples too. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

My husband and I stopped in when the restaurant we wanted to go to was closed. We were seated by the most delightful woman who gave me a lot of recommendations. First, I had a house Old Fashion that was the best I ever had. It had a touch of sweetness and was not sour at all. It was also presented nicely. My husband had a Jack Daniels on ice which was a nice pour. Appetizer was amazing! Best Brussel sprouts I've ever had. Brussels are so often over cooked and charred. These were flaky, but not overcooked. The bacon was done perfectly. Again, crispy but not burned. It had a slight sweet balsamic and topped with Parmesan, not overdone, just a slight flavor. This is where it went a little down hill. My husband got the steak and asked for it medium. It came out well done. It was still very tender and the flavor was very good. The potatoes that came with it were utterly amazing. But, the side salad of balsamic tomatoes and cucumbers was sooo delicious. Both the waitress and the hostess recommended the vodka sauce, so I ordered the chicken Parmesan with vodka sauce. The graciously made my chicken grilled instead of fried. This is where they lost me. The chicken was overcooked. I'm not a fan of thick spaghetti, but it was done perfectly. The vodka sauce, however, was not good. I felt like I was eating a cross between tomato soup and spaghetti-o sauce. It wasn't inedible, but it was not great, and very, very heavy. With how they raved about it, I thought it was going to be delicious. The service was amazing. They worked ad a team and EVERYONE was super friendly. I was between 3-4 stars and I gave 4 because the drinks were very good. The place had amazing murals and a great vibe. But overall, the overall nice staff won me over! read more

See all

Great spot for a date or group hang out! They have a bunch of homemade pasta dishes, fresh wood oven pizza, other classic italian foods, and phenomenal cocktails. They are most known for their espresso martinis! However, I wasn't really in the coffee mood so I decided to get the next popular option: the notorious pig. The drink was the perfect balance of alcohol and sweetness. It also came with a cute little keep pig! For an appetizer my partner and I got the bread with garlic spread and it was sooo good! The bread was so fresh and the garlic spread butter, chefs kiss. For entrees I got the chicken parmigiana with vodka cause and my partner got the rigatoni ala vodka. The homemade pasta was super good, bouncy and chewy with a little bite. However, both dishes were a little under salted. That would be our only critique of this place. The service was just okay, but the ambiance was vibey. I loved the decor. Overall, I would come again, especially for happy hour. read more

See all

I highly recommend Olives and Oil if you're in the New Haven area! Whether you're looking to get a drink, have a night out, or looking to get dinner before a show/concert, this is where you want to be! The service is really great, even when it's super busy and the ambiance it really vibrant and fun. I cannot recommend the Mushroom Pesto Risotto with the Crispy Chicken enough‍ Everything tastes really fresh, nothing was too overpowering, and I was able to take leftovers thanks to the portion sizes! Make sure to call ahead or make a reservation because options are limited for walk ins! read more

Olives and Oil - Basically the best cocktail - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Went for some fresh pasta with a friend. Shrimp Scampi with linguine and Spaghetti and Meatballs with red sauce. Both very good. Shared crispy, grilled brussel sprouts with bacon. The portions are big, so there was food to take home. read more

Olives and Oil - Spaghetti & meatballs, shrimp scampi with linguine, brussels & bacon - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Marissa was awesome! She took great care of us! we all got pasta dishes and the fresh pasta was amazing.

Jake (not from State Farm lol) was a fabulous bartender during our SantaCon visit. We had a great conversation which honestly made the visit worthy of 5-stars! We talked about white tea shots and as a tequila lover I'm not sure how I've gone so long without trying one. It was tasty but I think I'll be sticking to the og. Their meatballs over polenta is pretty good. The sauce ratio is perfect and it's very filling. The little pigs throughout the restaurant's decor and behind the bar are super cute. I'll be back to check them out for dinner. read more

The food was so good and it was very nice and intimate!! Everything was hot and fresh

Wanted to try this place out because the reviews seemed to talk highly of it, but my experience seemed to be the opposite. I went there with a couple of my friends for a nice dinner/drink. The food was very good, my drink could have been better. Those aside the reason its getting 1 star is because of the bartenders attitude. Didn't feel welcomed at all and it felt like he was annoyed there were so many women there. Im sure not all the bartenders are like this but this young man with a mustache needs a reality check.Don't go to this place if you are a woman, seems like men only territory with the rude service we received from the bartender. You can probably get the same food & drinks with better service and prices anywhere else. read more

The food is AMAZING! The service is fantastic and overall experience was excellent! A MUST try if you are in the area. To start, we tried the calamari that was buttery soft melt in your mouth delicious, maybe some of the best that I've ever had. Hannah, our server, brought a basket of bread with oil which was unique and delicious as well. I tried the Notorious P.I.G. drink which was tasty and came with their signature little pink pig toy floating in it. Cute, and the drink was delicious- perfect for a summer night. My husband had a crisp, cold Peroni on tap that hit the spot just right. Next, Hannah, helped us decide on the goat cheese carbonara and truffle garlic risotto. Well let me tell you... I will be dreaming of this meal and comparing future dishes to both of these for the rest of my days. My husband agreed. My only regret is that we didn't have room for dessert. From start to finish, amazing experience and if we are ever in the area again, we'll definitely be back. I would love to try their pizzas too as the cooks were working hard to make the pies. (We were so disappointed in a different highly recommended "must have apizza in New Haven" places) read more

Olives and Oil - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

First time trying Olives and Oil. The food was delicious. The waitress was so friendly and professional. She helped my son's girlfriend order based on her gluten free needs and allergies. The place is spaced out nicely and quiet enough to have good conversation. read more

My husband knew I wanted to try this restaurant and he made reservations for the Mother's Day brunch. We arrived for our 11:30am time and were told we could only sit at a high table. My husband explained that due to his handicap, he was unable to sit at this particular table. The staff said we were welcome to wait 45 minutes for a table when we could see two booths available. We asked for the booth and said would have to ask the manager. Meanwhile there was no where for my handicap husband to sit and wait. The manager came and said even though we had a reservation and two booths were empty, they were for parties of 4-6. We found this unacceptable and not accommodating to handicap people The manager then asked my husband what he wanted him to do. We asked for the booth but again were refused. My husband then said , give me $100 and we will be on our way. He said, no, what else do you want, you can wait 45 minutes? My husband said you asked? The manager gave him $100 and we went across the street and was treated with the respect we deserved. I was appalled that the staff was not sympathetic to his disability. read more

Amazing food!! Our server zach was phenomenal the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He was on top of everything and very knowledgeable of the menu. I would highly recommend. read more

One of our favorite restaurants to visit when we're back up in Connecticut. Staff has always been pleasant and the food is always great! I love the eggplant chips. read more

Met my daughter here for belated birthday brunch. I was immediately greeted at the door and was told I couldn't be seated until my full party got there. I was directed to the bar area. They really need a waiting area it was awkward waiting around in the bar. My daughter got there and we were seated. Unfortunately there was a big group of people next to us celebrating an engagement or something. They were ridiculously loud and obnoxious. One of them through their napkin and it hit me in the head. The staff did nothing to get them to settle down which was upsetting. It made for an uncomfortable experience and I couldn't even hear my daughter talking across from me. I really liked my espresso martini flight and the pizza was good but could have been cooked a bit longer and bigger for the $23 price tag. Not sure I'll go back.... read more

See all

I will be fully honest that I am currently under the weather so only experienced Olives and Oil via a delivery order. I would absolutely be willing to give them another chance in person. That being said, the food was very bland. I ordered the rigatoni a la vodka which came with Italian sausage in it and a dollop of ricotta on top. Unfortunately nothing in this dish had much flavor, including the sausage! The noodles were sort of bizarre; they were huge and undercooked. The sauce was truly flavorless. My husband ordered the chicken parm and was equally underwhelmed. He noted that he appreciated the portion size but the chicken was dry and overcooked. I tasted it and agree. Unfortunately the sauce was very average with a jarred quality. Perhaps this was only because we ordered rather than dined in, maybe we did not order their hero dishes but overall it was very average food with large portions. read more

Great place - we had apps, dinner and dessert and the four of us loved it, esp our two college kids Zach, our waiter was awesome. Very attentive, and knowledgeable of the menu and great help with our selections. Music was a little too loud but other than that we'd go back! read more

Food was horrible !!!! Cacio e Pepe was inedible . Literally took two bites. Waitress knew it!!!! Saw our full plates but didn't even ask how it was !!!! NEVER GOING BACK. So many better places to eat !!! read more

Olives and Oil - Cacio e Pepe - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

We had a great dinner, EXCELLENT waiter! Very personable and engaging, a pleasure to talk to. And of course, excellent service. Wishing Zack the best! read more

We stopped in tonight to celebrate our "Mother of the Bride" and had a few cocktails. I can't wait to go back to have a meal. Kelsey was amazing!!! She was so kind and thoughtful. Love the vibe there!!! read more

Olives and Oil - Bar area - Bars Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Service was good and the ambiance was fine but the food was underwhelming. Like Olive Garden quality. Really nothing special. The margarita pizza was very bad. My kids barely ate. I went home and made them dinner. I really don't understand why people like this place. read more

Fantastic family style restaurant. The wait staff is pretty honest about the servings. It's got a really nice super trendy environment. And the food is really really good. read more