First time in this new establishment. Service was fast and accurate. Our waitress was on point with all our substitutions/modifications on our sushi rolls. The sushi (salmon) was fresh and delicious. I ordered the OG roll and substituted the tuna for salmon and added jalapeños..... Straight Fire . Perfect place for a celebration dinner. read more

Supreme Sushi - OG Roll (salmon instead of tuna added jalapeños) - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

First time customer tonight and definitely disappointed. Ordered 2, 3combo dinners 1. Chicken terri, shrimp katzu, salmon sashimi OUR REVIEW: Shrimp katzu was a first for us and prob last. First time having ebi used vs. a regular tempura shrimp. Not a huge fan; there was too much batter. The sashimi was good. The teriyaki sauce was pretty salty. 2. Beef terri, California roll, tuna roll under their standard roll options, but as you can see received a tuna handroll. OUR REVIEW: it was an OLD cali roll so the rice was dried out and hard. YUCK. The beef was CHEWY and COLD and the terri sauce was SALTY. (I don't like my beef cut in strips but could deal with it if the other issues didn't exist. ) My tuna handroll was whatever, especially when I didn't order a handball and had a distinct conversation with the young man who took the order that they were smaller rolls "not as big as California roll size" (yes I'm aware of tekka maki's rolls). VERY disappointed and dissatisfied. Likely we'll not be ordering here again. There were too many negatives. The miso soup also needed to be re-warmed. The only thing that was good was the salad and the salmon sashimi. Miyako hasn't disappointed us, so we'll continue our business there. read more

Supreme Sushi - Old and dried cali roll. Salty terri sauce and cold chewy beef. Handroll wasn't what was ordered. Salad was good though! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

Came here today for the first time and was really disappointed. I ordered the edamame, which had a lot of salt on top, was dry, and some pieces tasted bad. I also ordered a California roll, but it had very little flavor. We also ordered a bento box with chicken teriyaki, a California roll, and tempura. The tempura was extremely oily and had a bad taste. The rice in the bento box was cold, dry, and hard. The teriyaki chicken seemed like it was taken from a rotisserie chicken and simply topped with teriyaki sauce, rather than being freshly prepared. Unfortunately, the food made me sick, and because of this experience, I won't be returning. read more

Got the 49er roll, Rainbow roll, spicy yellowtail rolls, spicy tuna roll and cucumber salad. First of all, take a hard pass on the cucumber salad. Definitely bland and not worth $8. Tasted like diluted rice vinegar and cucumber. The spicy rolls were average at best but I guess it can't be over the top amazing. The specialty rolls were cut in large pieces so we're not easy to eat. Overall just okay and at least the fish wasn't rubbery. read more

Absolutely delicious and welcoming service! Clean atmosphere. Meal was done quickly. Highly recommend.

Kicked the snot out of the he other Sushi joint. Better fish, better service, better atmosphere better everything. I wholeheartedly loved the new digs can't wait to use the patio when the weather gets warmer!! Kicker, for my fellow members of the Dead Pancreas Society get the Philly roll riceless! It was the bomb! Not on menu but if you ask like nicely they may accommodate. All smiles walking away so happy to have Supreme in my little town!! read more

Got the 49ers roll and the El Jefe roll to pick up. Rolls were a great size, they were very fresh as well as made in a timely manner. Definitely recommend this place read more

It was our first time visiting the new location. The food was so good and so fresh. We sat outside on the patio and enjoyed our sushi. Can't wait to come back and try some of the new menu items. read more

Food is delicious! Great variety. Wonderful friendly service. We especially like the sushi and the tempura. It's our go-to place in Hollister! read more

I've been to this restaurant before more than a handful of times and it seems like the quality continues to get worse every time. The sushi wasn't very enjoyable this visit and it took over an hour to get it while dining in person. Only about 5 tables (including mine) needed service since no one else was dining in at the time and it was a ridiculous amount of time. Server was nice like usual, I see her often. I just don't understand why the obscene wait time for sushi to be most likely over an hour and a half wait. read more

This was our first time here in many years and I know ownership has changed since our last visit. Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious. Our standout was the masubi, because it's my daughter's favorite food and it was amazing! We can usually only find masubi on food truck nights in Hollister. They had a great looking menu for ramen, which I will have next time since my favorite pho place in town closed down. I can't say enough about the service. So friendly and kept our drinks filled and empty plates cleared away. We'll be going back soon for sure! read more

I really wanted to try this business after a local recommended the sushi here but the ambiance was so bad that I left seconds after stepping in to this restaurant. This building/restaurant is in major need of upkeep and no one should be eating raw fish out of a restaurant with such a bad odor. The smell alone made me nauseous and I would not consider returning unless they make some meaningful change in this regard. I feel bad for the owners because maybe it's a building issue but you shouldn't be serving food here. read more

There was very little fish in the sushi, rolls were mostly rice and the taste was bland. There was more flavor from the toppings on the rolls than from the actual sushi rolls. Pricing was average. read more

Supreme Sushi - San Benito and Fantasy rolls - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

You couldn't fault a restaurant for trying any harder than they did. Very friendly, a slight language barrier, which created a slight order mistake. Nothing that can't be fixed. Maybe they shouldn't use such low cost beef in their teriyaki because it was pretty tough. The rice for the sushi was strange so small. Not sure if we will return anytime soon. Just our opinion give them a chance. read more

Supreme sushi very nice I know the sushi chef is one of the great chefs around before you could serve sushi you have to practice for 10 years before he could put that apron on and go out in public great restaurant great food decent prices please come please tip please clean up after yourself read more

I came here for the first time with a friend. The service and food were great. I would definitely recommend and return soon. read more

Supreme Sushi - Sushi roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

See all

if i could leave 0 stars i would. i arrived at 4:30 when they opened and immediately got sat. we waited 15 minutes before anyone even came to introduce themselves, after our order was taken we waited 30 minutes for our food to arrive. the fried california roll was DRY i have never had a dry california roll. after we finished our food they immediately started cleaning our table and put the check on the table. we paid and were talking for 5 minutes after and they came to us again asking if we could leave because they had a reservation of 8. if you knew you had a reservation for 8 why would you seat people in that area. poor communication between staff and poor service. never going again. don't rush you customers because you guys can't plan accordingly read more

Ordered Bento boxes- chicken teriyaki with spicy tuna roll and shrimp tempura. Also ordered eel avocado cucumber roll (8) and the spicy shrimp cucumber avocado roll (8). 4 stars because The sushi rolls were not rolled tightly and they kept falling apart before you could dip in the soy sauce. read more

We are new to Hollister and looking for a good sushi restaurant. Supreme Sushi had pretty good reviews on Yelp so we were excited to try it. Unfortunately, we never even got seated! We walked in and completely ignored. Nobody greeted us and there were 2 sushi chefs at the bar, one woman standing at the counter, and several servers that passed us while we were standing there. Not once did anyone make eye contact, say they would be with us in a minute, or even give us a welcoming smile. After waiting about 10 minutes, we walked out. I am super disappointed and there is no way my husband would be willing to go back. read more

Always fresh and hard to choose a favorite Looking forward to new location. Ahi Poke Nachos are the bomb read more

I ordered the chirashi. It was disappointing. A real sushi place gives your 5 to 7 kinds of fish. Here, I got yellow tail, salmon, tuna, and one shrimp. A real sushi place would give you butterfish, egg, eel, and roe, There was no wasabi or white ginger. On top of this, I had to pay 3.5% in credit processing fees. Staff was rude. I walked in to place an order and was not greeted by he guy behind the counter. I stood at the register and waited and waited and waited. The lady was busy packing up another order and said nothing to me. I thought this was extremely rude. The least she could have done was said that she would be with me in a minute. This happened last time, too, with the guy behind the counter. He cared more about looking at his cell phone both times than he did helping a customer. They are rude and do not appreciate their customers. I would not return to this place again. They have a monopoly in Hollister, being one of just two sushi places. The bad service and bad food reflects their poor attitude. read more

Food is good and the price is reasonable but the wait time for ordering and the food took more than an hour. I thought I came here for a quick lunch. End up took more time than I expected. The restaurant have two sides front and back, but they only have one waitress to do everything. I don't blame the waitress, she was doing her best to serve all her customers. I hope she can get good tips by the end of her shift. :) read more

Supreme Sushi - a bento box with meat, lettuce, and salad - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

See all

My son invited me to a birthday lunch, and we both ordered the same meal. We had the Bento box, which included chicken teriyaki and salmon, but we requested no teriyaki sauce. We also shared the Lion King roll. The meal was a perfect 10 out of 10, and the Lion King roll was delicious, ranking among my top favorites. The service was also exceptional, earning another 10 out of 10. Our food arrived just 10 minutes after we were seated. We will definitely be back, possibly with a larger group. read more

Fire food, always great. The price is more than I like but hey everything is expensive in Cali. I would highly recommend getting your sushi here read more

Sushi that's always on point and staff that moves like they've got secret ninja training.

Very good experience all around. First, the food was tasty -- a simple spicy tuna and cucumber roll had great texture and flavor -- a bit more cucumber for more crunch would have been perfect. we also had the Poke Bowl -- good ingredients, just the right amount of dressing. It's not a fancy setting, and that's fine with us -- more attention on the food! Service was friendly and attentive (without being overbearing). will definitely be back read more

So , it's a new owner. Some new menu items . A few of the veteran staff have stayed. Great prices. Everyone is kind , courteous , and professional . My fav roll is the AJ roll. Don't forget to tip!!! read more

I thought 1st time was fluke-- flavorful sushi rolls, fantastic service (even though we came busy at lunchtime), and decent priced. So we returned the 2nd time. Even better. We came as soon as they opened, so we had the place to ourselves. Parking can be tricky but no surprise there in Hollister. read more

giving it 5 stars to support local small businesses in Hollister. Rolls are fresh and staff is friendly. I recommend the flaming hot cheeto roll. read more

First time ordering from the restaurant under the new ownership because I have previously ordered under supreme sushi. We ordered from supreme sushi last night and it was bomb! We did take out but next time for sure I think we need to dine in. We ordered around 540p and left to pick up around 615p but order wasn't ready until 630p. It was busy, hustling and bustling from what my husband and our cousin saw. We were so hungry when the food came home so the pictures were a little eaten before I remembered to take pictures. For 4 adults and 2 kids we ordered the following. I loved that they provided all the soy sauce, wasabi etc., without asking. Caterpillar roll, california roll, fantasy roll, Philadelphia roll, 2 item bento box + salad + miso soup, flaming hot Cheeto roll, crunchy roll and a large mixed sashimi. Descent pricing, mixed sashimi was fresh, rolls were all decently stuffed, would definitely order again. Parking is street parking. Seems like the restaurant may be open all day(?) I called around 430p to see if they were open already and it was because previous helper stated they are closed 2-5pm--best to call before going if dining in. read more

See all

They have really good food there. But they denied serving me because I had a service. Dog walked INSAT down. Give me my menu and that's all they did. They were helping other people but would not walk back to my table. When I walked out and I said Goodbye. I said bye. And that's all? read more

Favorite spot for sushi in Hollister. I have been a big fan of them since they started on Instagram and were delivering during the pandemic. Great value and delicious! They are always so kind to me when I go with my young daughter. They are attentive and quick, much appreciated when I visit with her. Definitely recommend for a sushi fix in town. read more

The sushi was good. Not great but still good. The restaurant is clean and the staff is very friendly and attentive. I will say my son LOVED the unagi!! I would live to try one of their poke bowls and I will update review then!! read more

First time here but I will come back and update the review if needed. First of all, the lady that greeted and served me was truly a nice lady. You can tell from her eyes and smile. The gentlemen working behind the sushi bar were very serious making sushi. However, you glance at them and you'll get a smile. I noticed the most of the folks that came here were local regulars (except me). Would that me be next? The lunch and food here price wise is better than the other one in town, was the food less delicious and authentic? The answer is no. In fact, I like their IKA GESo here better..why? Well, here they give you lemon wedges with it that you can use with soy sauce and wasabi to dip your Geso (personal game changer and enjoyment for my palette!) and the batter has more flavor and crispier. Why did I not give 5 stars, only one constructive comment and had spoken to the nice lady server about it. So they can work on it and customers will give them 5 stars! She took it really well and promised to work on it (that should give my lost star back). I will return in a few days to see if I change my 4 stats to 5 OR not. Will I return? Of course, with family too! read more

See all

This is a great place here in Hollister. Finally a decent sushi restaurant that is local. We will be back for sure.

I was excited to try this place, but is was disappointing. The kids chicken teriyaki was burnt, the cucumber salad was bland, and it arrived after I had finished my food. The roll was good but overall I expected more. read more

I wanted to like to it because it's rated "best of San Benito". Came here with my family and the service was good, she tried her best, but food was MID! It was basic, it lacked flavor, this was more like grocery sushi. The rolls were a fair size but the dragon roll and 911 roll were tiny. I'll try to come back for the poke bowl but the food wasn't that special. Maybe I'm just used to premium sushi, I left disappointed. The ambiance was meh, they seated us in the back so it was kind of dark. For this whole experience it was well over priced. read more

Supreme Sushi - the price of the restaurant - Sushi Bars Near Me - Hollister, California

First time here we ordered some sushi rolls. The rice was dry and we also got sashimi and the quality wasn't fresh. But the service was nice. read more

First time trying supreme sushi. Placed order via instagram for delivery. Food arrived on time. Everything was delicious. Only negative was the rice. Didn't taste like sushi rice? Wasn't as sticky as I'm used to, Portions were good. Rolls were big. I'll be back to try other items on the menu. read more

So Bomb! The food, flavors, and the service were on point. Before the spot opened we ordered during Covid on delivery-quality is unmatched! You won't find any sushi/Japanese in the area of this caliber. Highly recommend. Staff was hustling on their game tonite especially the young kid bussing tables. In and out on a Friday night in about an hour and a half ish read more