I'm always on the lookout for a good NY Style pizza joint, and that's when I stumbled across Supremo Pizza. I ordered the classic Pepperoni and upgraded with fresh jalapeños. The sauce had great flavor and the crust was the proper NY Style thickness with a crispiness throughout every slice. As of now this was the closest to NY Style pizza in the SLC area that I have yet to try. Customer service was great and worked quickly to get your pizza to you! This is an order pickup or delivery only place, and there is plenty of parking if you're picking up an order! If you want a great slice of NY Style pizza then give Supremo Pizza a try! read more

Supremo Pizza - 18" Pepperoni Pizza w/Jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

Very simple but decent New York style pizza. Comparing it to similar pizza joints in Utah, I'd say it's somewhere in the middle of the top 10. Their ranch is not great, so I'd pass on that next time. read more

Supremo Pizza - 14" Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

New York Style thin crust... they absolutely knocked this one out of the park. I'll definitely have to try other pizzas here. The Bianchi did not disappoint. I don't know if it is the snow cones I just ate or the great mood I'm in but... this might be the BEST thin crust I've had in the Valley. I didn't see any seating to dine in. Service was great. Like seeing old family... read more

Supremo Pizza off 900 East serves up tasty New York-style pizza. The employees were friendly and accommodating, and service was quick and easy. There isn't seating inside, so plan to carry out your pizza and enjoy it at home. Solid spot when you're craving a classic NY slice. read more

Yes!!! So so nice to have a thin crust, east coast style pizza on the South end of the valley! Super nice people and fast Delivery! Adding to our dinner rotation. read more

Nice little take out place. Clean and organized. Call ahead to keep your wait short. We ordered a large Supremo with half no olives and they made it well. Good amount of toppings too. We liked the thin NY style crust; no flop when you hold it which is good. Prices are very reasonable. We would go back again next time we want pizza and would recommend others the same. read more

Supremo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

I'm not saying this is the best pizza I've ever had... but I am saying I would trust this place at my funeral, and every other major life event in between. I took one bite and immediately understood why some ppl can't stop eating. I went home, tried to go about my normal life, and physically couldn't--because all I could think about was this pizza. Ended up getting it the next day but was embarrassed to show face so had to press the delivery button. The crust? Perfect. The sauce? Life-changing. The cheese? Well we won't talk about that, but that's not on them, that's just my own messed up stomach ishhh At this point, I'm not eating pizza anywhere else. Other pizza is just... bread with trust issues now. read more

Supremo Pizza has great customer service, and great food. Definitely worth checking out.

Again, we LOVE this pizza and service SO much! Always great quality and in-house delivery. While the staff is AWESOME, their pizza is truly the best in Salt Lake. The very few limited negative reviews pointed out thin crust, but that is the point and what makes it so delicious: hand-made dough with the perfect chewy crust and tons of toppings. Seasonings of the sauce and dough are so perfect. I'm picky about pizza, and this is my only favorite place! So delicious! And great service!!! read more

This is based on delivery. I can't speak to the dining room experience. They took my phone call but wouldn't allow me to place a delivery order without going online. Minor inconvenience, but still an inconvenience. The bigger issue was that the pizza was really greasy. Look, I get it, it's pizza, it's going to have a certain level of oiliness to it. This was too much. read more

Quick and easy NY style pizza. Pretty yummy. Garlic knots are way toooooo much garlic but the pizza itself was really good!

This is your neighborhood pizza place. The pizza is super delicious and the employees are super friendly and help. The thin crust is perfectly cooked and stays crisp. read more

Supremo Pizza - Supremo - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

See all

We've been going here for a few years now. It used to be amazing pizza. The garlic knots are truly amazing. The pizza though, is consistently overcooked, almost burnt. I keep going back because a few years ago it was amazing chewy, New York style crust. Last 5 times we have gone, the pizza is terrible because the crust is so overcooked. Hope someone in mgmt looks in to it because we used to love this place. read more

Pizza was good. As close to New York style as you'll find in Sandy Utah. Service is always very good. Small location, take out and delivery only, a couple of chairs and small tables is all. read more

Their staff are very friendly. They have Spanish speaking employees also, if needed. The menu has a large selection to choose from and reasonably priced. The sizes of their pizzas are huge and worth the price you pay. Their pizzas have high quality ingredients and they taste amazing. I recommend this pizza place. You can order by phone, online through their app, in store, and they do door dash as well. Their app allows you to earn points towards rewards also. read more

Had high expectations for this place after seeing some of the reviews, but it's sadly average and underwhelming. We got the mushroom truffle pizza and added sausage - it was extremely oily, to the point where it was leaking out of the box. Also not as cheesy as I would have liked. The thing that really got me was the price of their side sauces. $2.50 for a small container of marinara and $1.75 for garlic parmesan dip. I thought they would at least come in bigger containers. My total was $31.XX for a 14" pizza and those 2 sauces. Don't believe it's worth the price. read more

Supremo Pizza - $1.75 garlic parmesan and $2.50 marinara sauce - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

Very good pizza! Crust and toppings are yummy. The sausage does not have an overwhelming taste. It's v mild. The favorite was the chicken BBQ! read more

See all

The flavor of the pizza was good until we found a hair in the middle of one of the pieces... pretty disappointing considering it was our first time eating here. It was it between the crust and the sauce/cheese so it was baked into it and we didn't finish the pizza. $25 down the drain read more

Supremo Pizza - 3 Cheese Pizza with hair - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

See all

Solid pizza place that caught our attention. Pizza is thin crust (at least the standard one was) and solid flavor. We always go basic to start off, so we'll be back and try some more of their specials! read more

Such friendly staff!!! Their pizzas are amazing!! Always fast and efficient and have I mentioned DELICIOUS!!!

This is the place. Their space ain't fancy and you'll "probably" want to do take out, but the pizza that comes out is top notch. The margarita pizza keeps us coming back. Parking is easy too! read more

Quality = the bestest with a nice chewy NY-style crust. They obviously use top- notch ingredients compared to horrible chain "pizzerias." I'm looking at you, Dominos, Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, etc. Employees = friendly, gracious & helpful Price = not inexpensive BUT...you get what you pay for! read more

Whoa. This place had me very pleasantly surprised. Also, another failed moment where I forgot to take a picture, but definitely not a forgettable pizza restaurant. We have been looking for authentic New York style pizza for quite some time now and I have to say this is closer to it than any other place we've tried in all of Salt Lake City over the last 15 years. Perfectly thin, foldable, not heavy on the grease and the sauce was just perfectly balanced. Sometimes sauce is too zesty and overwhelming and for somebody who (Ahem, clears throat) is in her late 40s, let me just tell you, heartburn in the middle of the night from a pizza you thought tasted great is not pleasant. This pizza did NOT give me heartburn! it's like hallelujah to the pizza Gods, we have found great New York style pizza in SLC! The price was right on point, we ordered on their website and they had the pizza ready right when we walked in the door so it was hot and super fresh. Perfectly balanced cheese. Can't wait to go back and try some other other flavor options as the picky eaters I had ordered for only wanted the cheese pizza and a sausage pizza this time around. Two thumbs up, will definitely be back when pizza is what's for dinner (or lunch...or breakfast). read more

Solid, solid, solid. We've visited Supremo twice, both last minute and both times did not disappoint! The pizzas are massive and tasty. Don't sleep on their sides like the garlic knots either; they're delicious. Also love the fact that they're open pretty late everyday, which is a treat for late night dining in Midvale. Definitely a staple in my book. read more

Don't drive by quickly or you will miss it, especially in the dark. Wish the sign actually had light bulbs in it. However this little pizza joint had awesome garlic knots. I had half of them eaten before I got home (bad idea as I spilled all over my shirt). The service was nice and it was ready when I got there. It was a little cold, not sure if they have a heat lamp. The cheese was a little gritty but I loved the marinara and crust. Ranch seemed homemade but it was a little bland. Good selection of canned drinks and a cute little seating area. They have only been open for a few months so I will be back to try the Calzone and get the garlic knots again very soon. read more

Supremo Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

See all

Amazing pizza, good staff. Ordered the pizza and got there early by like 10 minutes and went in and it was ready nice and hot and fresh. It was super good, great crust and solid flavour. read more

By far one of the WORST pizzas I have ever had. You'd be better off going around the corner to Big Daddy's Pizza. We ordered two whole pizzas for carryout and for $40+ for two 14" inch pizzas, I would have rather spent the money getting a frozen pizza. The crust was extremely tough and hard to chew. The pizza, although fresh, was just not good. We have had a lot of the local pizzas and unfortunately Supremo was the worst. read more

Supremo Pizza - Supremo - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

See all

Supremo Pizza has become one of my favorites. It's a small establishment, but if you order for pickup, you'll find that the staff are super friendly and welcoming. I've tried the cheese & pepperoni pizza, as well as the garlic knots a few times now and everything is fresh and consistently good. The pizza sauce is good, the crust is thin like NY style pizza, and the pepperoni pizza has a ton of pepperoni. They're open late - even on Sundays - which is a huge plus considering almost everything else closes early. read more

I'm from Portland, we have good food there! I have been let down consistently by food here, i got home late last night and ordered pizza, omg it was the best, it was delicious and the sauce so good! Found my fave new place! Told everyone at work too to read more

Supremo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

Meh - decent but nothing great. Dough/crust was not very good, I was not tempted to eat the crust. Sauce and toppings were quality. read more

Supremo Pizza - Pep and combo - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

The best Buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had. They got the pizza out to us fast even during a busy hour. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming, I'll stop here everytime I'm in SLC. read more

Supremo Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Midvale, Utah

I don't like giving negative reviews, and I typically don't but after getting our pizza from Supremo tonight I'm feeling like I have to. I downloaded their app to order the pizza, clicked on one of the coupons to use for my first order, and it didn't apply. I didn't notice it until afterwards and I had already paid that it didn't actually work. No big deal, bit annoying but it happens. But the reason for the low review is that the actual pizza does not look anything like their picture. There is hardly the amount of cheese on the actual pizza compared to the picture which I feel is very misleading. There really was not that much cheese at all on the bbq pizza. It was mostly sauce. Maybe it's because when you order on the app it defaults to want you to tip 18% for carrying out Pizza, and I changed it to 2.00? The staff was upset? It's possible, but Paying a 18% tip on carry out is ridiculous, I can't say that it was intentional because of that, or because they just have misleading pictures of their food, but either is disappointing. Sadly we won't be coming back here. read more

Found this place through Yelp & looked at the pictures for more details. Just the look alone of a pie showed it was NY style. Made the order & when picking it up, I saw the quality of sauce & the flour for their dough. I knew immediately the pie was going to be good. Brought the pies & wings home & tastes just like pizza from the Bronx & my wife enjoyed the wings. Excellent find in SLC. read more

I was pleasantly surprised with the Margherita pizza! Fresh tasting and solid flavors. I'd never had it with cherry tomatoes but it was nice. read more

Tasted great! A great place to get a pizza to go... service was okay, but the restaurant felt like it was filled with steam

I feel quality has struggled. I will favor Big Apple any day. It is with the extra 15 minutes in the car.

I had a sudden urge for pizza late tonight and found this place that was still open and delivering. Unfortunately even tho I was happy with the service the actual pizza was a let down. Suffice it to say, I will NOT order from them again. read more

Ok, guys.. I may have just discovered the BEST pizza in the city! I can't believe this place doesn't even have one single review? If you're like me and wish you could just fly to New York for a slice, well I have a more economical option for you. It's all about that sauce, ammirite? The thin crust with some darkened edges underneath.. I really can't relay this piece of pizza pie heaven without being tempted to purchase another one. It's located in an older shopping mall center. Service was swift, ordered online and was done pretty quick no wait. Make sure you're not sharing with too many people, you will want this pie.. all to yourself! read more

See all

I've never been in a pizza place where you don't smell pizza. Because of some seriously wrong estimates and messages from ordering through the Slice app, I had to wait 15 minutes beyond the time they sent and 10 minutes beyond when the message that my order was ready was sent so I had some time inside but the first pizza smell I had was when my order came out. It could have been because they were rushing to make my order because of the Slice messaging I got, but everything on my order was underbaked. It felt like the oven was too cold for the pizza and the garlic knots were raw dough. The sauce and toppings seemed good quality and there was plenty of them but everything suffered from being undercooked. I know New York style pizza is floppy but it's not because the dough isn't baked. If they stay in business a while and some real Yelp reviews get added, I'd try them again though. The food seemed very promising. read more

This will be our go to pizza place now. We had it delivered and it was still hot when it got to our home. The crust is the perfectly thin with the best texture. So many topping options. The wings were awesome too! read more