Best pizza restaurant I've ever been to hands down. Their food always slaps. Fast service too.

Wow! Happy to find great Pizza close To home! Thin crispy crust! Pepperoni tasted Like fresh pepperoni, very flavorful! Also ordered the buffalo wings and they were fantastic! And meaty! Sauce had a great kick too! read more

Love this pizza ! So fresh so much flavor. My favorite is the garlic knots with a lot of marinara sauce.

Found this new place by chance when perusing online maps for pizza places. Immediately wanted to check it out as since Big Apple around here closed years ago haven't had a decent NY style pizza place in this area. The pizza I ordered was very good! Sauce was great, not too much cheese. The crust was good but probably could've been done just a little more but at least not burnt (like Snowmobile pizza). Will be back to try calzones! No slices at this time. Sorry didn't leave a tip but it was take out and the prices are now high enough as it is so at least supporting the store. read more

I've tried to be patient with this place because it's one of the few spots in Utah with decent pizza (which admittedly isn't saying much). However, twice now, I've scheduled a pickup, only to arrive and be told there would be a 20 to 30 minute wait. Yet, I immediately received a text saying my pizza was ready. When I asked about it, they said it wasn't actually ready and that I'd still have to wait 20 minutes. The level of incompetence is unbelievable. I won't be giving this place any more of my business. read more

God, this place is supremely delicious! If you're looking for good New York style pizza in Utah, you will find nowhere better than Supremo!

The spot for late night pizza--the best staff! Nowhere else was open on a Sunday AND this place is open until midnight. Just opened a couple months ago and deserve a spot on the map! read more

My boyfriend and I just moved here from Omaha, NE so we've been trying to find our new favorite pizza place that reminds us of our favorite back home. We're big into the New York Style / thin and crispy, and this is by far our favorite pizza that we've found so far. ‍ read more

This guy was the best. We were passing through and stopped in for pizza. It was amazing. The opener was a hound nice kid. His pizza was super good and the ingredients were very fresh. We got a pepperoni pizza and some mozzarella sticks and it was to die for. I will be definitely going back when I'm in the area. read more

The garlic knots were amazing the staff was very nice and helpful and the food is great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We used to live in the New York area so we can be picky about our pizza. This is as good as any of the corner pizza shops in New York, and that is the highest compliment I can give to a Utah pizza place. Also - for those people like me that aren't gluten intolerant but don't do well with American Red wheat, this place is for you. They use Caputos Italian flour and I can eat it without any issues at all. Please never stop using this flour!! Love this place!! read more

Delicious ! ordered online and was so fast and they gave us a free small cannoli with our order ! Will definitely order again !

Great pizza - fresh ingredients. The crust was perfection. Nice location. Small but a few tables to eat at. We'll definitely go back for more and hope the garlic knots will be available to try... read more

Suppose I give this place ten stars. I don't live in the area, but when I visit my folks in Idaho, I must pit-stop here to get some pizza, wings, and garlic knots; the best. Especially when my six-year-old says, "This is the best pizza I ever had," I would consider her a specialist since she loves pizza. Amiable place; the owners and staff are beyond welcoming. I wish I had this pizza place close to home. read more

Just tried for the first time and wow! Got the Supremo and Three Cheese pizzas, as well as the Caesar salad. Super delicious and full of flavor - don't sleep on the salad either! This is 100% our new go to takeout pizza! read more

Really fast service, really good food. Being from out of state, it was such a nice change to have good pizza this time.

I'm leaving 5 stars because I don't want to hurt their review stats, but I'm gonna be honest here: if you can't get access to food cause everything else is closed it's not a bad option... but it's definitely overpriced for the quality. The staff was nice. The pizza itself wasn't by any means worth the price except that it was something available when everyone else was closed. It wasn't bad pizza, don't get me wrong, it just seemed to be disappointing after paying so much. Not good reheated. Supreme has redeeming qualities, and they were really nice and I'm grateful that it was available. I probably won't return unless I'm in a pinch again with money to blow. Staff: if my honesty stings, the answer is to improve on your pizza or cut the price in half. You really were nice though, and your service was appreciated. We didn't go hungry that night... but we did have a lot of buyers remorse. Sorry :/ read more

just now NEW My friends and I came from Ogden for a car meet and we came into supreme pizza. The homies here were so niceeee. The pizza was so good and they let us sit an hangout and then had us try there own recipe for garlic knots. Fcking yummy as hellll. My friend iker didn't wanna share a whole thing of sprite with the five of us so we each got individual cans. What a loser. We could've shared. Iker takes the L. Supremopizza takes the W. read more

I'm gonna be honest I really did not have high hopes with this place, I thought it was gonna be some 7-11 type of pizzas but I'm so happy I was wrong. I don't know where they came from but I'm glad they're here. The pizzas are just incredible all around along with the calzones, you really do not find places like this out here in Utah. On top of all the positives the prices are such a good bargain, giant 22 inch for around $24 is unheard of with the quality you receive. They definitely deserve more traffic and I hope the quality never drops because they will become one of Utahs favorites. read more

When you are craving pizza, this is THE place to go. It's located in the end of the plaza so it can't be missed! From calzones to the NY style pizzas, wings and garlic knots, just thinking about it again is making my mouth water. This time I ordered the supreme pizza, wings, and salad togo and I was drooling during my ride back home. The ingredients tasted so fresh and the wings were perfection. The garlic knots, smothered in butter, parmesan, and garlic making it the most savory warm knots I ever tasted. Top it off I kid you not, I love pineapple on my pizza... and I saw that they have whole fruits of pineapple ready for chopping for your pizza! That says A LOT about fresh all the ingredients are. While I was waiting to pick up my pizza, I saw so many people to going pizzas even at the late hours! I can see why people are coming here! The service is top notch and the food is even better. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! I will be back again for more!!! read more

Solid NY style slice. Very well-made pies and apps... doesn't feel sloppy and lazy like most other pizza spots around SLC. Quick on DoorDash and still hot. read more

I had the calzone and it was awesome. Next time I think I'll try their regular pizza.

Best pizza I've ever had! Staff is amazing and overall some of the best pizza I've ever had. 10/10 would definitely recommend supremo pizza!

Unfortunately this pizza was disappointing. Ordered the supreme pizza and it had little to no flavor from the sauce, the cheese, to the toppings. Also pretty oily. read more

Listen, I've never been to Italy and sat down in a pizza parlor. But this pizza has me thinking that is exactly where I am. This pizza will have you hallucinating your actual location in life. You may even start speaking fluent Italian. I did. Three times. Get the pizza. read more

This has to be one of the best restaurants in Utah, the pizza is fantastic and the wings are very good.