Such a cute ice cream spot! The ice cream was super good and the portions were huge with plenty of flavor. We got the key lime pie flavor and it was amazing. There were so many options to choose from and the shop itself was really cute inside too. The line was pretty long, but it kept moving fast. Definitely worth stopping by! read more

Oh my heavens. I will come back to the keys just for this slice of pie. Chocolate covered key lime pie. Not too sweet, and the chocolate contrasts well with the tart pie filling. SWEET BABAY JESUS. I almost made a U-turn after heading home one hour out just to go back for more pie. There is a nice area in the back with tables to sit and enjoy your treat. They also have ice cream and other desserts available. read more

See all

Yummy! Loved my cold little cup of craft chocolate & peanut butter ice cream. Excellent assortment of flavors and so many other sweet treats to savor, too. Cute shop with gifts and plenty of space to sit, as well as arcade games for the little ones. Service was efficient. Great stop to satisfy your sweet tooth and beat the heat. read more

See all

Great selection of gf desserts! Their foundation key lime pie is even gluten free and pretty tasty!

Key lime pie is worth a pit stop! One of the best slices I've had - fantastic balance of flavours! The tang hit but didn't overwhelm and the buttery crust gave it a nice caramel flavor read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Briefly stopped by Sweet Savannah's after a long day on the water. The service was great and the ice cream tasted homemade, but it had an odd after taste. Specifically the cookie butter and the cake batter really were not my favorites. I don't think I would come back here for ice cream again. I might try their pies though. read more

Great cheese cakes with a variety of flavors! We went there 4 times! No regrets even tho it's gonna take several gym visits to burn them all off! Staff was friendly and provided great service also. It was always busy so we got everything to go each time we visited. Down from west central Illinois and southeast Iowa staying in Marathon across from Sombrero beach. Great time all week and hope to be back eventually and hopefully Savannah's will still be there!! read more

Loved our ice cream and cookies from here. Also got the banana bread pudding and it was fantastic. Everyone was very nice, definitely recommend! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

March, 2025. My husband and I enjoyed ice creams at Sweet Savannah's on a hot Wednesday afternoon. With 29 locally-produced flavors to choose from, we each selected two flavors to taste first -- me, (1) the Oreo Heath Bar Crunch and (2) sugar free cherry with chocolate bits. My husband tried the (1) salted caramel and (2) guava cheesecake. In all cases, the ice creams were tasty and very creamy. We both selected the first flavors from our samples. Portions were good, and there's a cute room with tables to enjoy the treats. We were tempted by many other sweets, including cupcakes, pies, and more, as well as gifts in the gift shop. Access was easy off US 1, and there was sufficient parking. One point off of our rating because of my experience with my spoonful taste of the cherry with chocolate bits ice cream. It was a small quantity so I tasted the full spoonful at once. However, I bit down on something very hard in the spoonful. Was it a cherry? No. Was it a chocolate chip? No. It turned out to be a cherry pit that I easily could've broken a tooth on. Ok, things happen -- but even more concerning, the girl who had scooped the ice cream was completely unfazed when I told her what happened. I repeated the story to the cashier. He told me to fill out a note for the suggestions box and that he would inform management (after I told him that he should). read more

See all

On the way home I realized that I did not buy my dad a key lime pie and my husband was in the mood for some ice cream. This spot came up in my yelp as open at 9:30pm so that was great. This is a really cute place to stop by. There is a sitting area when you can just relax and have your pie slice or ice cream. You can do also a bit of shopping they have some cute items that you can pick up and take home with you. I was able to get a whole key lime pie and I was told that they are made fresh daily on the premises. My dad loved the pie he said the crust was the really good. read more

See all

So.... A rainy day in the Keys leave you little choice but to go exploring. Our efforts resulted in an extraordinary find -- sweet Savannah's. Who doesn't love shopping with ice cream, cupcakes, & coffee. Souvenirs are fairly priced without the usual gouging that happens in tourist towns. The cupcakes are made fresh every day and it shows in the taste. Banana foster has a surprise banana filling which is spectacular and the frosting is light and not TOO sweet. Perfection in a plate !! If you are in the area make it a point to check it out. read more

VIDEO GAME WALL? amazing added touch. still the best desserts in marathon and the staff is super friendly. I may eat this s'mores brownie for breakfast....dont miss the freezers, there are amazing snacks! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Nice authentic and delectable sweets. Loved their cupcakes and the fillings. Fresh and sweet. Cookies were soft and big. read more

See all

Best KEY LIME PIE around! The perfect combination of tart and sweet. Try Sweet Savannah's Key Lime Pie for a great piece of pie!

Our favorite, most delicious, key lime pie! Will definitely be back :) I wish I had a photo of the pie before we devoured it. You won't be sorry, pick up a slice or a pie today! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Wish I had a picture of the pie before we devoured it! ‍‍‍ - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

A cute dessert spot in Marathon! Sweet Savannah's was near where we stayed while vacationing in Marathon and we walked over after dinner one night to satisfy our sweet tooth! They offer a variety of sweets: ice cream, cheesecake, cookies, cupcakes, and of course- key lime pie! My toddler and I shared some oreo/reeses vanilla ice cream and my husband had the key lime pie cheesecake. The ice cream was good- pretty standard. My husband loved his KLP cheesecake and would recommend. Sweet Savannah's also sells toys and other fun gifty things :) read more

Cupcakes are good a lot of frosting and drinks were good too. Key lime pie is tasty. The cookies were really good. I thought the gingerbread cookie was perfection. The store is adorable. A lot of cute things to buy from aprons, cute funny hand towels, kids games and so much more. read more

Great spot! Young staff that really take care of the customers! Ice cream was great, brownie was fudgey and good! Cute decor with lots of seating with toys, collectibles and gifts! read more

Ice cream is rich and creamy with a ton of great diverse flavors. Fun signage and options add some variety to the aesthetic. Key lime pie is so thick and dense and the whipped topping is fresh and flavorful. Really one of the the best pies I've had in the keys. S'mores cookie was gooey and soft with the perfect ratio of marshmallow and chocolate. Cost is reasonable against portion sizes and the little shop and seating is clean and abundant. Def a must stop in marathon. read more

Great Ice-cream shop & more in Marathon, Super kid friendly and cute. Tbe ice cream shop has a large variety of flavors. The shop also has cute souvenirs, books, decorations and more! There is ample seating and a little kids corner for kids with toys. Definitely recommend if you are looking to fulfill your sweet tooth craving! The service was good. read more

See all

We stopped by Sweet Savannahs while vacationing in the Florida Keys and loved it so much that we ended up going every day for the entire week. They offer delicious homemade treats, and the cupcakes were amazing. The shop is very cute, with a nice area to sit and enjoy your goodies. We can't wait to go back! read more

I had a sweet tooth craving on our way out of the keys and Sweet Savannah's was conveniently 2 minutes down the road when I looked at where to go on Yelp. This was a little gem of a place. The inside smells of sweet delightful treats. They have lots of gluten free options and prepackaged to go items in the freezers on the left side wall of the store. They have fresh ice cream scoops and a bakery bar with fresh baked goods. I got the chocolate overload cupcake. It was soooooo goooood. I had half then and half the next day so that I wouldn't get a sugar head ache. They pile on the frosting, and the center was filled with a rich chocolate mousse like pocket. Mmmm my mouth is watering right now just recollecting how good it was. And they put it in a cute little pink box if you ask for it to go which makes it feel like a little present :) My husband had a rainbow sherbet scoop that hit the spot. Each of our items was about $4 so it's not cheap but worth it for a fun little stop in the keys. The inside of the store is so cute and they have some merchandise as well as a second "dining room" where you can sit down and enjoy the treats. There is a beautiful key west mural on the wall, and a water and utensil station. It you've got a craving for something sweet and Savannah's is nearby, make the stop! read more

See all

Interesting bakery, ice cream, and gift shop on the main drag in Marathon. My husband really enjoyed the creamy ice cream. He had the raspberry chocolate chip. We took key lime pie to go. They had regular and gluten-free. Both were some of the best we have had. Prices were fair. Nice selection of gifts and souvenirs. Fun decor and good service at check out. read more

Oh yuk! Worse key lime pie. Tasted like a refrigerator. Not sure where the key lime taste was.

What sounds so good and refreshing after seeing an incredible sunset on the Keys? Why ice cream of course! We headed over to this family fun place and grabbed a sundae. Line was out the door which lets you know that the ice cream must be good and it was. So many choices between ice cream, drinks, and supposed to be the best Key Lime pie in the area. I wasn't aware but plan to try it next time. Location is easy to find in a small strip mall. The business faces the street and in the evening plenty of parking. During the day, it might be a challenge. All I know is the ice cream was fresh, light and so delightful. I will definitely return when I am here again, read more

Sweet Savannah's - Mmmmm! Yummy Sundae! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Nice shop with a mix of souveniers, trinkets, toys and sweets. We went for the key lime pie. They claim best on Marathon for nine years. I can see why. It was a very nice slice. Super creamy custard and nice tartness of the key lime. Even better for me, they also make it gluten free. (Lots of gluten free goodies to choose from in addition to their regular offerings). Stop here. It is worth your time and money. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Gluten free key lime pie. (Couldn't wait to taste it) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

We fly all the way from Detroit to get our Sweet Savannah's Key Lime pie. Another Florida Keys classic! Support this local shop!

Traveled to Hawks Cay to celebrate a birthday in January. The cake looked so beautiful and tasted amazing. I knew I was heading back up there again, so I decided to order a beach cake for a 60th Birthday celebration. When I picked it up this past weekend, I was floored. Not only was it exactly as my vision, It was more. The cake was so detailed from white chocolate shells to the color of the sand and ocean. I ordered vanilla cake with strawberry cream filling. It was absolutely delicious. If you are looking for a great bakery, this is the place. Maybe someday they will head to Fort Lauderdale. read more

The Keylime pie was awesome. Very cute place friendly staff. when I heard their ice cream is amazing. I have yet to have it, but who doesn't like ice cream read more

What a sweet spot to stop midway between Key Largo and Key West. Their Key Lime Pie is tart with a sweet graham cracker crust, chocolate-topped if you wish! Our family of 6 ordered a whole pie. There were no chocolate-topped ones ready-made, but they offered to top it for us for free. We sat down with spoons and devoured the whole pie. They also have ice cream and other sweet treats. The decor inside is a bright island vibe with free old-school Atari-style game consoles for the kids and fun souvenirs for the adults. This is a must do every time we are in the Keys. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Souvenirs - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Paris and Matt made my birthday delightful! Things didn't go as planned today, so I was pretty bummed out, and I hadn't gotten any dessert all day, so I took my MIL to Sweet Savannah so we could both cheat on our diets. You know that feeling of being the last person holding up the staff from counting the drawer and leaving for the night? I thought we'd be those people. I can't tell you the sense of happiness and joy that radiated from these two wonderful beings. Their smiles and welcoming attitude turned my lemon of a day around. Putting Happy Birthday pins into my dessert made it overwhelmingly special. Sweet happy ending and wow to top it off that Guava Cheesecake Ice Cream was spectacular. Thanks so much, you made this old lady's day. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Paris and Matt- creating memories and spreading joy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Delicious key lime pie and oatmeal cookie. Key lime pie was smooth and chilled with just the right amount of crust and wipe cream.

So may options and they all look delicious. My daughter had the sweet Savannah which is a cupcake covered in ice cream! The employees were nice and the restaurant was clean and spacious! I can't wait to go back! read more

Sept 21, 2022, Sweet Savannah (day we picked up the cake) My wife wanted her birthday to be celebrated down in the keys with some friends. I found Sweet Savannah online. She is a passionate lover of chocolate and we wanted it to have as much chocolate as possible. We ordered a chocolate cake with 2 layers, and chocolate icing in the middle. Chocolate varieties of icing, candy etc on top. They did an incredible job. This cake was so freaking heavy. I know some say that about cakes, but I guarantee you it weighed at least 10-12 pounds on a conservative number. It took our party of 6 a week to finally finish it and that was having very large pieces. It was so rich. I could barely eat it without getting a sugar rush. The cake was an absolute steal for what we received. When my friend told me how much it was when I went to reimburse her I was flabbergasted at how inexpensive. I was imagining at least double that price for a cake like what we received. I wish their bakery was up here in Georgia near us. I'd be referring everyone I know to them. Thank you so very much to your staff for making my wife's dream come true. She said she never met a chocolate cake that was too much chocolate... She said she met her match with this cake. The only thing I would do differently next time would be for the bottom layer to have been brownies instead of cake, then a layer of icing and then cake. That would have put this cake into extreme chocolate mode. Sadly I didn't think about it until after we picked it up. I can't praise this bakery enough for the cake we received. Do yourself a favor and don't think, just order from them. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Birthday cake, some wording redacted - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Desserts were so yum. Especially the cookie butter brownie! The cookie bowl for the ice cream was hard as a rock so that is why I am doing 4 stars but everything else was good. read more

I love this little sweet shop and gift shop! The cupcake was amazing-the perfect sweet and salty punch of chocolatey goodness. They have ice cream and cheesecake and a selection of cold sodas. The gift shop is full of all those cute and funny gifts like cocktail napkins, coasters and more....plus a nice selection for the kiddos. I will definitely be back! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Yummy salted caramel dark chocolate cupcake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Great ice cream shop on Marathon Key. Generous scoops of yummy ice cream. Service was happy faces and attentive. Liked being able to sit at tables provided in a cute parlor just off of the retail / counter section. Cute shop! read more

Yelp didn't disappoint! Ice cream is delicious! We all had different flavors - so the only real advice I can give is skip the rum raisin. They will let you taste - even though I'm sure the people waiting in line gets antsy. The banana split was huge. Cute little place. They even have a few tables if you don't want to rush into the heat with your treat! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Chocolate peanut butter swirl. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

They used to sell cupcakes, but rarely make enough nowadays. They do sell ice cream, but save yourself the trouble and go to Conch Custard's instead - MUCH better quality. Would not recommend SS's key lime pie either. read more

Super cute place! Creamy ice cream and loved the coconut flavor! They also have the best key lime pie for 9yr running!!! Haven't tried it yet but from the folks eating it they said it was delish! Service was good! Cute place to seat and enjoy your Ice cream and support local artist selling cute stuff. We drove by and saw the crowd of ppl and we stopped! So delish!!!! read more