Expect long line for ice cream. The wait was a solid 20+ minutes. The selection of ice cream is crazy. They do let you sample if you're indecisive. I ordered the strawberry cheesecake and it lived up to the description. Tasted exactly like it in ice cream form. Price was affordable. Nice spot to go for dessert. read more

I stopped in for some ice cream last night & was blown away. Maybe it's because I went to a different local place recently & had bad service, but this was fabulous! The staff was very friendly and the store was clean. I got a waffle cone with party animal & cotton candy ice cream, which were both great. They were full of the mix ins & had fabulous flavor. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

Sylas & Maddy's is a local favorite for me. I have been to the Lawrence, Olathe, and OP (inside Scheels) location. It hits every time. Recently, I visited the one in Lawrence and had yet another pleasant experience. The staff are always welcoming and happy to offer samples. Despite the line being massive, we didn't have to wait too long. The selection of flavors range from the classics to inventive seasonal specials. I tried the Strawberry Cheesecake and Cookies & Cream, and both were super creamy and didn't miss on flavor. Portion sizes are generous and prices are on the cheaper side comparatively to other ice cream places! Tip: ask for a free cake cone to go along with your cup of ice cream! read more

*CELIAC / GLUTEN FREE REVIEW many GF / DF options - just ask and they'll bring out a sheet with all the GF flavors on it, and then you can compare to what's actually on the floor for the day. They got me a clean scoop and were SUPER affordable for great flavor. I got the dark side and the cappuccino chocolate chip, DELICIOUS and hit the spot :) read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Cappuccino chocolate chip + the dark side - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

This place has patrons at all hours of the day. Peeps be low-key eating ice cream for dinner at 5pm on a Wednesday. Who am I to judge, you ask? You're right I had pecans for breakfast. On warm evenings this lamp on the corner of 11th attracts many moths. Mesmerized by its sweet glow, their mouths murmur between bites of milk and cream mixture. You'd be hard pressed to find a flavor you don't like at S&M ;). My brother in Christ, you chose the cream out of 30 flavors, don't complain. Quality seems up to par but I will need to report back with an air percentage measuring tool to make sure. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - So fire I threw it away when I was done. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

Best cookies 'n cream I've ever had and the waffle cone was perfect! I've had daughters in Lawrence at KU 3 years and today was first go here, regret waiting so long! read more

Yum yum YUM! One of the cutest and yummiest ice cream places. They have so many unique flavors, you can't go wrong! Both my friend and I loved what we got. The cotton candy was SO sweet! There was a huge line, but the staff was very effective and had us out in less than 5 minutes! Super awesome place and the inside reminds me of an old diner. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Cotton candy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

The ice cream here was delicious! We went to an event in Lawrence and we stopped by. There was a massive line but the employees were efficient. They were rally friendly too. The place is huge and it's in a good location. Get the waffle cone! I worked at Disneyland for years and this place gives me Gibson Girl cone vibes. read more

See all

Silas & Maddy's is easily one of my all-time favorite ice cream spots, hands down one of the best around! It's all home-made and you can definitely taste the difference. There's almost always a line (which tells you everything you need to know), and the staff is always super friendly and patient. My go-to flavors are the Gold Dust and Cookies n Cream, both are rich, creamy, and packed with flavor in every bite. The Gold Dust is a sweet cream ice cream with oreos, snickers and caramel swirl. Cookies n Cream is a classic, but they somehow make it taste even better than you'd expect, huge oreo chunks, super creamy base, just perfect. They do only allow two samples, which I actually respect. I heard that back in the day, kids used to roll in and try every flavor just for fun, then dip without buying anything. So yeah, two tastes is plenty enough to try something new without turning it into a free-for-all. And honestly, with how good everything tastes, it's not hard to commit. If you're in town and craving a treat, you have to come try, it's 100% worth it. read more

See all

I came in on a warm Sunday afternoon, so it was naturally very busy here and had to wait about 25 minutes to order. I don't care, it was worth it, I probably would've willingly waited longer - the ice cream was SO good! They have a huge assortment of flavors to choose from so it was hard to narrow down, but I eventually settled on the Thin Mint. Now that I've had the deliciousness that is Sylas and Maddy's though, I'm going to have to come back for a sampler so I can try even more flavors. It was just that good. The shop is adorably decorated, and there's plenty of seating indoors and out. Would highly recommend if in Lawrence! read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

Had the Pac-Man and Brookie and they were phenomenal! Great service, great music, great vibe. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Pac-Man and Brookie on a waffle cone (medium) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

So much fun to visit! Love the variety and the sizes are plentiful. I just wish you could try more free samples.

My girlfriend and I were out shopping and stopped in here and thought it was super cute! To start the decor is nice and fitting to the business. You see all the cute flavors and staples on the walls, which allows you to quickly guess what you might like to try. After you decide you can try two flavors. Anna who helped us, was awesome and very helpful when our small group was deciding what to pick. We got 3 cups of ice cream and loved them. You could taste the flavor of ingredients in every bite. We would highly recommend this cute place! We will be back. read more

See all

We were here in October and my posting got submitted with the wrong number of stars so here it is again if you're in the area hope you enjoy ! Excellent ice cream and the waffle cones are delicious! Staff is friendly and helpful and the line moves very quickly because there is always a line there. Plenty of ice cream in the medium waffle cone for each of us! The ice cream is smooth and creamy, and the waffle cones are freshly made, Iloved the pumpkin pie and the turtle! The pumpkin cheesecake had big chunks of cheesecake in it. The boys had butter brickle, Reese's and butter pecan, It must've been good because it disappeared quickly. We all really enjoyed it and it was a great way to end the evening celebrating together in downtown Lawrence. So good I forgot to take pictures. read more

Ice cream is great--creamy and thick, sweet but not overly so, and they have lots of flavors. However, the layout and info could be better. The display cases don't have any labels on the glass; you have to bend down to see the labels for ice cream flavors, sometimes cramming several words of ingredients on a label size meant for a couple of words. I wouldn't be surprised if figuring out what's what is half the wait time, unless you order the same thing every time or have a solid go-to flavor. Also, some of the names are downright opaque or contrary to what you'd expect. For instance, Da Bomb is drawn in red, white, and blue on their flavor chalkboard like those fun Bomb Pops, so I was expecting something with cherry and blue raspberry. No--the flavor is cookie dough, chocolate flakes, and Oreos. Graduation Day didn't hint at what the flavor is, but the label indicated brownies, cashews, and caramel swirls. Another note: I got wrongly charged once and then when they corrected it, they double charged me, so just check your transactions. I personally like their 5-flavor sampler cup ($4.85). I don't mind mixing flavors in one cup and it's about a large cup's worth of ice cream. Their 6-flavor flight is more expensive, but the flavors are kept separate. My personal notes: Orange sherbet: good, exactly what you expect Birthday bash: vanilla ice cream with chocolate cake and sprinkles; I prefer this to sweet "birthday batter" type ice cream flavors Strawberry lemonade sherbet: mostly just tasted strawberry Strawberry ice cream: small, evenly sized frozen strawberry chunks; surprisingly good for a "standard" flavor Muddy Maddy's: Oreo and coffee and fudge; pretty good Cookie monster: no soft cookies like in other cookies n' cream types; almost peanut buttery Mint chocolate chip: disappointingly kind of meh; more bitter mint than sweet mint Toasted coconut: good, exactly what you'd expect Peaches & cream: tastes like peach gummy rings; I'm not a fan of that fake peach taste Rock choc jayhawk: basic chocolate-y goodness Queen of hearts: raspberry-covered chocolate; too many inclusions to ice cream ratio, not enough ice cream for every chocolate-covered raspberry chunk read more

On our last visit to Lawrence, a final, sad farewell stop at Sylas and Maddy's was a no brainer. A little shocked to see the line out the door early on a summer night. However, given the quality of the ice cream, it's great to see they don't just depend on the college crowd keeping them in business. The move to this location a few years ago was clearly a great idea. Much more room inside for those waiting, and overflow seating downstairs, which was packed. My daughter and I both went with our favorite Mississippi Mud, which never disappoints. I'm not a big cone guy, but I always get one here. Their fresh cones, dipped in chocolate and rolled in sprinkles, are amazing. We've got great ice cream back home in Colorado, but I'll miss coming here, as Sylas and Maddy's ranks him on the list of the best we've ever had. read more

See all

I was in LFK this weekend and I stopped in for a pre-dinner snack. They had a large selection of ice cream and toppings. I ended up with the Hawk Tracks in a waffle cone. I got a medium and as you can see from the picture, it was pretty massive. The Hawk tracks was filled with brownies, peanut butter cups, and something else that I can't recall at the moment but just know that it was delicious and rich. I also went with a fun waffle cone that was chocolate dipped and covered in sprinkles. Sprinkles are for winners and I was definitely winning! A nice thing is that they put a malted milk ball in the bottom of the cone so that it doesn't do that gross drip out the bottom thing. I feel like this is now going to be a mandatory stop whenever I'm out this way. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Medium Hawk Tracks in a fun waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

The best place in town for ice cream, sherbet or sorbet! Their flavors are unique and all so good!

Always something new on the menu. Unique flavors to fit any taste. Get there early or jump in the line that runs out the door.

Super cute ice cream parlor with in-house made flavors. The decor was fun and colorful. Easy to order and they have glass where you can see the various flavors of ice cream. Yes, I am a grown adult, and yes, I love cotton candy ice cream, especially when there are mini chocolate chips involved. Of course, that's what I got. Childish, yes, but at least I know what I like! Some of the flavors were pretty standard, and some were more inventive. The ice cream consistency was creamy and thick, yet fluffy. It was so good! Highly recommend. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Cotton candy ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

After receiving my ice cream and paying for it, I asked for a glass of plain water and explained that I need to take a pill. I'm 80 years old, and I assume that I look that age. I was refused. They only sell bottled water. read more

Great staff and great ice cream. They have a variety of flavors and the six flavor flight is worth it if you are sharing. The downstairs area is a great place to just hang out with a big group of people. read more

Wow! This little place is incredible! The ice cream is homemade and you can taste the difference. The kiddos opted for dipped sprinkle waffle cones with gold rush and Rock chocolate Jayhawk ice cream. The hubs and I opted for sweet cream ice cream. He has a walled cone and I had a milkshake. The sweet cream was very unique - you could taste the cream and it wasn't over sweet, which I absolutely loved. Being a Saturday, it was busy and there were only two working, which made the line move slow. Still, it was with the wait. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Sweet cream milkshake with whipped cream and a waffle cookie! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

Great ice cream! Long line went very quickly. Gotta go there when you're in Lawrence.

Great ice cream. Lots of awesome flavors. The only piece of advice I have is that the owners NEED to post the ice cream and ice cream ingredients somewhere for customers before they get to the serving station. This could be them posting something on the wall, laminated menus, or even QR codes on the door or inside. The line is always SO long, and no one knows what the flavors are until the get to the counter AND there's no way to see the ingredients unless you're up there. People would have their orders ready more quickly if this info was available while waiting in line. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

Came here after our dinner for some sweet treats. Definitely no line (thank goodness), but there were so many flavors to read and choose from. It was a bit daunting if you've never been there and not know the names of the flavor. The staff were nice and gave us time to look over what we wanted, however, the two ice cream sections were separated. By the time we looked at the first section they asked us what we wanted before we got to see what else was in the second section. When we did get to the second section to look, they were already helping the next customer. I felt like I was rushed and had to go back to the first area to look, which I felt bad getting into the other customer's way. I ended up getting a sample of the lavendar lemon, while I was sampling the staff said "let me know check if we have anymore". Sure enough, they didn't have anymore and didn't have enough for a serving. IMO, if there isn't enough then the whole tub should be taken away because I actually wanted it. Now I had to "hurry" and pick another flavor, which I ended up with Green Tea. It definitely does not taste like green tea and the color doesn't even look the part. It taste like bubble gum mint? My boyfriend tried it and said "you got bubble gum"? I didn't have the greatest experience, but my boyfriend enjoyed his ice cream. I had mine in a waffle cone, which I appreciate that it's house made cones and it tasted great. Not sure if it was intentional, but at the end of my cone I had a chocolate malt candy ball in there. I'm not a chocolate person, but I thought it was a nice surprise treat in there, IF that was intentional. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

The ice cream was not melting but it was certainly fire! So good! I got the Mississippi mud and it was exactly what my body and soul wanted.

Delicious Ice Cream/countless flavor's Great little shop that has sone delicious ice cream. The inside is super clean and staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. I ended up ordered 'DA Bomb' and the ice cream was super creamy and better tasting than I initially imagined. While speaking to one of the staff member they told me that the were on food network channel and I can can see why. If you looking for a date night or just a cool shop to get ice cream Sylas and Maddy is the place. Happy eating! read more

See all

My favorite ice cream would have to be gold dust. This ice cream consists of vanilla ice cream, Oreos, snickers, and carmel. Whoever created this combination is a genius and I wish they sold it by the quart because I would definitely be buying a few to store in the freezer. I like how they have complimentary water available and ALL OF THE SPACE! Sylas & Maddy's moving I think benefitted both Lawrence and the company, because it definitely brightens up this whole block. read more

See all

I love this place. Sylas and Maddy's offers many different flavors, is in a great location, and the ice cream is absolutely delicious! I used to go here at least once a week when I was in college. read more

Fun flavors and reasonable prices. Loved the strawberry cheesecake ice cream so much I had to return to get more a couple days later!

Always terrific!! Great ice cream, fantastic waffle cones (seriously the best waffle cones). Guys serving were friendly and professional, even though end of night and lots of people there. Always busy but worth the wait. Lots of tables and window seats to sit at. We love getting a scoop or two anytime we are in town visiting my college student. Wonderful products and excellent service!!! Highly recommend!! read more

The best ice cream this side of... where we are! Yellow brickle road will make you cry tears of joy.

Love this place, the ice cream is so good, the variety of flavors, the service is fast & so good. One of my favorite places to get ice cream

Never disappoints! I always think this place is more expensive than other ice cream shops, but it definitely isn't! Under $5 for homemade ice cream with tons of flavor options.... Can't go wrong. Recently I tried the blueberry cheesecake with the lemonade flavor... probably my new favorite combo! Expect to wait in a long line if it's a busy weekend evening. But it's definitely worth the wait. read more

Cotton Candy. 2x scoop. Bowl Carrot cake & espresso. Bowl. Cookie Monster & thin mint. Waffle cone read more

So so good!! I had wanted to try this place but the previous times, the line was out the door or it was closed. Went in the afternoon during the week and it was fantastic. I got the da bomb in a waffle cone and loved it. Spouse got the pink grapefruit sorbet and he loved it. We will be back! read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Da Bomb - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

See all

I'm told that a trip to Lawerence isn't complete unless you visit Sylas & Maddy's. They've recently relocated and their space is much bigger. Don't let the line intimidate you, these ice cream slingers are fast and so cheerful and welcoming! I had the Gold Rush which was a delightful caramel, oreo, and praline ice cream. The waffle cones are house made and there's a special treat found inside. All in all it was a real treat after dinner and I'm glad we were able to find it, even during the torrential downpour! read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

What is it about the Spring weather that makes you crave ice cream? If you are looking for local home made ice cream, this is your place! They have a clean lobby area and long lines. Most ice cream flavors were stocked (which is why this is a 4 star rating). The names are creative and since I could not commit to one flavor, I had a scoop of peanut butter and one of cookie dough / choc chip. Awesome all around. The server didn't quite give me full scoops.... Which was disappointing. Tasty, velvety smooth flavors. read more

Sylas & Maddy's - Choc chip/ cookie dough - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lawrence, Kansas

The ice cream is to die for I've tried the 5 scoops sampler and the turtle sundae both are great