Let me start this out by saying that I am a former server and my wife is a former bartender. I always and I mean always tip over 20% unless it's truly bad service. I have been to this location a ton and it's normally average at best. Today April 4, 2026, was a spectacular train wreck. In all fairness it was busy tonight so I will weigh that a bit in the favor of the tailgaters. So we arrived and sat at a table. I was there for 20 minutes without anyone coming to greet. Eventually we waived down a waitress named Mikayla who took my order. Nothing fancy, a large Modelo, wings and a sandwich. Fast forward 30 minutes. Never got water, large Modelo still never showed up and food is no where to be seen. I waiver her down and ask about the Modelo that is now over 40 minutes. She says she will get it. 15 minutes pass and eventually some other girl shows up with a large Dos Equis. I tell her it was supposed to be a Modelo and then I tell her to just throw it away and take it off my bill. It's now been literally forever and some other girl who isn't even our waitress comes and asks what we ordered. I tell her again my order and then tell her to just make it to go. Eventually I got my mediocre wings and chicken parm sandwich to go. In defense of the restaurant, the manager did give me a $25 gift certificate (I wanted to leave it on the table but my wife said it was rude). What am I supposed to do with the gift card? Come in and order my food again just for them to not bring it and when they do it'll be wrong. I'm not going back. read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Average wings. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

My boyfriend and I ate here a couple weeks ago. First we were greeted by the most amazing server. I hope I have her name right but I'm almost positive her name is Mikala. She was so friendly, nice, professional, and attentive. We never had to wait and she brought us everything we needed. I also wanna say whoever the cook was that night (July 19th). Was so on point too. The pizza and wings were literally perfect. We still dream of this meal and can't wait to come back. lol Heat up the ovens and fryers lol we comin! read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Today we ordered dinner online for pick up. We ordered: - Supreme Pizza - 14' White Pizza - 14' BBQ Chicken Pizza - Bone In Wings (20) MEDIUM SAUCE with ranch - Breaded Zucchini Basket Our order was ready at the front booth when we came in, in a hot bag and we were able to pick it up as soon as a server came over to help us. The pizza tasted decent. My favorite was the White Pizza. I could really taste the garlic. It had a good flavor to it. We heard they had really good pizza here. I think I prefer Barro's pizza to this. I prefer the toppings on their Barro's Special to this Supreme Pizza. The crust on the pizza here is softer and limper when I pick up a slice. read more

See all

Such a fun Sports Bar! We visit from San Diego and try to stop by every time we're in town. Great atmosphere, tons of tvs, good service, great specials and drink specials. The food is super affordable and above average bar food. Highly recommend the shrimp basket, the cobb salad and any of the pizzas. Dom is a great server. Adam is super cool too! We will be back next time! read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I've never quite had a meal like this a chicken Parm sandwich Stromboli style. It was incredibly tasty, and a unique mix of the sandwich and breading. My least favorite kind of french fries are breaded fries but they were plentiful and overall everything was great. read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Chicken Parmesan sandwich & fries - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Tailgators is an outstanding place for great food, drinks, and an amazing atmosphere. My wife and I always enjoy coming here, and it's also a perfect spot for families. The bartenders, servers, and entire staff are consistently friendly and attentive. There's no better place in the area to catch a game while enjoying excellent food and drinks. Mike, the owner, does a fantastic job and truly cares about the community, especially by giving local high school students opportunities to work and gain valuable experience. Highly recommend Tailgators to anyone looking for a great overall experience. read more

We stopped in for a quick cocktail and an appetizer. None of us have ever been there and we were hoping it was a dive, but it's not. This would be the place to watch allll the sports. So many TV's. My friend and I had Tito's and soda, our husbands had draft beer. Quit possibly the best onion rings I've ever had. Huge, super crunchy and the onion didn't pull out when you bit into it. The sliced bratwurst mixed with fried cheese curds were outstanding. Even our vegetarian friend at the brats. They were really thinly sliced and sort of crunchy. Mouthwatering! We will be back for a meal. They have prime rib! read more

Our waitress was Jessie and she was amazing. We came down here to clean out my grandparents house and we are exhausted and she noticed and was so so kind to us!! The breadsticks were DELICIOUS and the pizza was so so good too!!!!! I would 100% recommend!!!! read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Homemade Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

The service is great and very attentive. The food was good and the atmosphere was fun. read more

See all

After dinner in the area, I stopped by Tailgater and Il Primo for a drink on a Thursday evening. Located in a busy shopping center that they share with EOS Fitness and several other businesses, you may have to circle around a bit but you'll find a spot. Service (3/5): We sat at the bar and were greeted after a while. I'm not sure if they have a drink menu. If they do, it wasn't provided to us. The bartender checked in with us once or twice but we had to wrangle her when we were ready to close out. Average service. There were a decent amount of people there but they weren't close to capacity by any means. Ambiance (3/5): Pretty much your typical sports bar. Lots of TVs. Plenty of seating. Both at the bar and at tables and booths. Pretty much what I expected. Food (N/A): I had dinner prior so no food on this visit. Drinks (3.5/5): I went with a rum and Coke and the bartender asked me what liquor I wanted. I went with Bacardi. I don't love it when bars do this because it incentivizes you to pick a more expensive liquor, and as a result, have a larger tab. I also don't know whether or not they have a drink menu so I can't comment on the full extent of their offerings. I did see that they have a good amount of beers on tap which is nice. I was pleasantly surprised with the prices at Tailgaters and Il Primo. For a Bacardi and Coke, the price was reasonable. If you're looking for a spot to watch the game in a casual environment, it's not a bad choice. read more

We typically go to the location in Surprise, but after a day of OHV riding we decided to stop and check out this location. First thought was parking was a breeze even with our truck and trailer. While we did have to park a little farther out it was a short walk to the door. I loved how much larger and bright this one is. There was a sign letting us know we could sit anywhere. We were greeted as well upon entry. Our server came over pretty quick, took our drink order and gave us time to look over the menu . We ordered a medium pizza, hot wings and a garden salad. All of our food came out pretty fast and was great. Our server lagged a little bit after our food was dropped off and we didn't see much of her. I loved how many TVs, projectors etc there were so I didn't have to struggle to watch any. I was surprised it wasn't too loud either which was great to hold conversation. read more

See all

Wouldn't even give it a star, been coming here for a while. Let me start by saying they're open til 11pm. I got here around 7:45pm and as always you stand around looking like a moron for 10 minutes until a busser seats you. Anyways they refused to give me a booth lol. Yall might have good wings but until you get employees who at least slightly give a crap this place will be one of the worst experiences a restaurant can provide. read more

Had a great lunch at Tailgaters today and Jessie was on top of everything. She has great customer service, helping with drink options, etc. Thanks Jessie! read more

What a wonderful place to hang out! Jessie served us and tooK amazing care of us while Adam came by to make sure we were happy! Professional cool place to eat and have fun. Thank you and will be back! read more

Excellent, clean restaurant with friendly staff and reasonable prices. The food was high quality and came out in a timely manner. It's also a great place to watch a game with a fun, relaxed atmosphere. Our server, Analeise, went above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience. We will definitely be back! read more

The owner, Adam, must be a bit shortsighted and has thus decided to really annoy his regular customers. He has started charging (without telling the customer up front) for simple things like a few chopped raw onions or extra ranch dressing. We've been coming here for years and while the new "nickel and dime" stuff isn't going to break the bank, there are few things that annoy patrons more than surprise charges on the bill. If the restaurant is this desperate for an extra 50 cents then one has to wonder what else they're doing in the kitchen to cut costs. I wonder if the added charges add up to enough to offset the loss of goodwill and repeat business. When added to the usual slow service, these small annoyances become deal breakers. read more

Food was sub par, very disappointing. False advertising, descriptions were off, and for some reason they didn't have a food menu. Free seating, so it took them very long to get to me. Service was also bad as well, i only ordered wings and 8 inch pizza but it took them an whole HOUR to get my food. (took them an hour for 8 inch pizza, by the way.) the Ambiance was decent at least, but it doesn't excuse for the bad food and service. read more

We are a Liberty Lions Soccer family and enjoy going to tailgaters after games. The food and service are always excellent! We were just there post game on 1/14 and the team at Tailgaters took care of our players and parents. We had a large group and were well cared for by Justin (incredible Manager!), Arianna and Bri (patient, kind and friendly servers) and Casey (great bartender serving excellent drinks). We are so grateful for their support of our Liberty Lions soccer Program! read more

Love the food all my coworkers go there I live 3 minutes away The workers are awesome the atmosphere is spectacular read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - I won the 2025 fantasy football championship - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Wing and rings. Not impressed with pizza and service seems to be always lacking. Prices are fair. read more

Excellent all you can eat fish! Fast service and hot food. You can tell manager Adam is back!

The service here is AWESOME! The staff is friendly and the food is great! Great place for any occasion ! read more

Had a great experience at Tailgaters Il Primo and a big part of that was our server Mikala. She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made sure everything at our table was taken care of from start to finish. Our drinks were always full, the food came out quickly, and they checked in just the right amount without being overbearing. You can tell she genuinely cares about giving guests a great experience. Service like that really makes a difference and is the reason we'll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend! read more

I've been here a couple of times; it's a sports bar/restaurant. Usually I get a burger, but on this last visit I ordered the Southwest Mac & Cheese and added chicken to it. It also came with garlic bread. At $12.99 for the mac and cheese alone, and another $4.29 for the chicken, it is pricey, but let me tell you, it was AMAZING, and I don't use that word lightly. I've had worse tasting mac and cheese at fancier restaurants. There were jalapenos in the mix, which gives it that southwest "flair", a couple different cheeses, and the ample sized chicken pieces. They used penne pasta, not the traditional macaroni, which I rather enjoyed, as the noodles seemed to hold onto the cheese better. The portion size was perfect for me; I didn't even finish the whole thing! (Leftovers are yummy.) The garlic bread was tasty, but average. Rounding out my meal was a happy hour margarita for $4.25. Delicious! Since I visit Phoenix every year, I know I'll be back...good service, good food! 11/2023 read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Casey is the BEST MOST ATTENTIVE bartender everrr!!! If you aren't here for her and the ambiance and food you are missing out. She will make you feel like family!!! Don't skip out on your opportunity to experience the best service everrrr!!! read more

I'm a wing lover! However, we've only lived in AZ 3 years and until a month ago hadn't found a restaurant that had "my type" of wings. Last night we went for the second time and on both occasions the wings were perfection! The taste was wonderful and the wings were very crispy as I requested. Our server, Cameron, was attentive, friendly and knowledgeable! We will surely become regulars! read more

Not somewhere I would want to go again. Food is mediocre. Not worth the trip, there are many better places in the area.

This Tailgaters location is the best! From the food to the service, overall everything is great. The manager Justin is very accommodating and friendly. Highly recommend dinning here, definitely will be back very soon! read more

The staff is awesome Taylor, Alyssa and Heather are truly the reason to go there. Their service is second to none. The food and entertainment is great. Friendly customers read more

Taylor and Alyssa are great bartender's. Great service and food. Live in Waddell, but travel here for that reason. Great bar!!!

This is the spot ! Let me tell you! From the moment you enter to the moment you head home , you will have a smile on your face , issues with your meal or service get the manager , they fix issues immediately with a lot of sense of urgency , service is one of their top priorities, they have a way to keep their audience and staff entertained while providing amazing service , you definitely got to take a moment out of your day to come check this spot out! read more

The brat with fries is pretty good. I recommend upgrading to the pretzel bun. The fries are crispy and delicious. At the bar, they offer chilled Jagermeister along with a variety of beers on tap. read more

Tailgaters and Il Primo - Brat with fries - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

The pizza ordered fresh in the restaurant is amazing! Recently their wings are getting tiny and expensive. Plus they only serve a couple tiny celery pieces. Most restaurants serve carrots and celery with a lot on the plate and the wings are much bigger for around the same price. Otherwise, we do enjoy the menu variety and the layout of the restaurant. read more

Bartenders are the best in the business. I don't eat much but whatever I do is great. The prices are fantastic!

I have been going to Il Primo for 30 years and it is as delicious today as it was then. One hazard though, I can eat as much as a human bear once I get started on the pizza and wings. read more

Every single time I come here we feel satisfied with our service and our food. Casey, Aunika, Adam, Rachel, Tina, and the staff all take care of us and provide good food and service at a reasonable price. We will definitely continue coming here! read more

See all

Stopped in to watch football and get a bite to eat... had a Calzone that was pretty good. You can't go wrong to watch your favorite team play, they've got so many TV's you never have an obstructed view, no matter where you sit. Good crowd, great service, and tasty food at a reasonable price... I'll be back. Check this place out, you can't go wrong. read more

outstanding service ! thank you guys! for everything truly such a wonderful experience amazing staff with amazing service ! if your ever near a tailgaters it's a must check out! if i could give this 5 stars multiple times i would!! thank you so much the staff of tailgaters !! read more

I ordered over $100 worth of food online from this place and it was a disasterrrrr. It took an hour or more to arrive and when it did, it was cold and I was missing items. The food was so bad it wasnt even edible. I called to tell them about the missing items, and they said we could come back but that defeats the point of delivery. If you know you know. They also said the manager had just left but that I could get a full refund. So I called back the next day when they would be in and they said they had to look into it since the online delivery is a third party service and that they would call back, they never did. When we called back againnnn they said come get a gift card. Obviously I didn't bc I will never be back based on this experience, despite how diverse their menu is. read more

We visited on a Friday late afternoon. We were immediately seated. Several in our group of 6 ordered the Friday all you can eat Fish Special. I ordered a Patty Melt with fries. Our order can out as expected, my friends enjoyed their 2 pieces of fish, Cole slaw, & fries. My Patty Melt was cooked as ordered. But the meat, the hamburger, only covered about 2/3 of the pieces of rye bread it was served on. The sandwich was good, but the meat either needed to be bigger or the rye bread smaller. More fish was ordered by my friends, even though it took a while, it was brought to the table and was enjoyed by them. read more