My wife and I were in the mood for some Greek food, and I heard about Gyro Jimmy's, so I said let's…read morego check it out. Located on Voice Rd in Carle Place in the back of the parking lot. It is spacious with plenty of tables. We go up to the counter and order 2 gyros and an order of fries. We did not order drinks, and we were asked if we wanted water. So, we took the water. We sat at a table the drinks and food were brought over to us. Great service. Our Gyros were plentiful with meat, and I ordered mine with no tomatoes and my wife with no onions and good portion of fries. The Gyros and fries were very good. We finished the Gyros but not the fries. Nice size portions. We were full. When were finished we were told not to clear the table, they would do it. A quick enjoyable meal for us with great service, looks like this is going to be our new Greek dining spot. Hope to return soon. A must try if you like Greek food.

This place is great-- when the meat is not burnt. I wish they'd scrape the grill clean more often…read more Stick with the pork gyro and avoid souvlaki for a less burnt experience. Service is fast.

Love this place! The service was exceptional and they even gave me a little gift for my birthday…read more I started with a ginger pomegranate cocktail which was amazing! I decided on the bronzino for dinner, it was flavorful but the star was the rice. Full of cinnamon and various spices. I couldn't get enough! Cannot wait to go back!

Fando Q had a pretty mid experience overall. The interior is definitely a highlight--fancy, clean,…read moreand comfortable--and the service was kind and attentive, which made the visit feel welcoming. But the food didn't really live up to the setting or price point. Considering there are quite a few Persian restaurants on Long Island, the dishes felt underwhelming in comparison, especially the meats, which came across as lacking depth of flavor and didn't stand out the way you'd expect given the cost. One thing I also found annoying was how the rice was served in a separate bowl next to the kebab--it made the whole thing kind of awkward to eat and less enjoyable than if it had been plated together. That said, the ice cream was actually really good and probably the strongest part of the meal--smooth, rich, and worth ordering on its own. Overall, it's a place with a nice atmosphere and solid service, but the food doesn't fully justify the hype or pricing, aside from the desserts.

Saw this place yesterday and decided to try it out today. Been looking for a place to get a gyro…read moresandwich and/or falafel. Plus it's near home. Food was great. Loved the falafel and the hummus. Didn't taste too fried and the hummus was creamy and delish. Also ordered the gyro and that was great too. Wifey said the meat was very seasoned but everything else about it was delicious. Wait staff was super attentive and friendly. Not busy when we arrived. Seated right away. Food came out in a timely manner after ordering. Will most likely be back again.

Dry Gyro Dry Pita Dry…read moreLemon Potatoes Maybe they had a bad day? Maybe I chose poorly off the menu? It is a Greek restaurant after all so choosing any one of the above three should've yielded at least one positive result. My Pre-Covid review, if I had the time to write one, would've been the opposite of this recent experience as I recall having a fairly nice lunch at the time. Sorry Gyrolicious, I sadly will have to go with my present visit and chalk this up to a 2.5 star review mainly for speed of service, cleanliness and attentiveness.

We were in a mood for some Greek gyros and stopped by for pickup order…read more The staff Ana/George extremely friendly and welcoming. The establishment very clean and cozy. We had the lamb gyro sandwiches well done; by far one of the better gyros in the area! The lettuce and tomatoes on the sandwich were finely chopped; protein well done and sauce topped it off.

Another wonderful dinner at Greek City Grill. Everything so fresh, completely authentic and…read moredelicious. The spanakopita was perfectly flaky, the chicken souvlaki was tender and full of flavor, and the semolina cake with cinnamon was the perfect ending to the meal. The Greek Cabernet a nice surprise The people are what make this place even more special we always feel like family. The atmosphere so welcoming, and it's one of those places we always look forward to coming back to. Highly recommend!

Apparently everyone's known about this place but me. Hope it stays a little hidden. We were able…read moreto walk in towards the end of dinner service on a Saturday and get a table for two without a reservation. Nothing but great things to say. Walk in, the open kitchen to your left (seems like a brilliant use of the space layout they had to work with). Meet the smiling host, then straight into the dining room. The dining room is elevated for North Bellmore, white tablecloths, lighting, fixtures, plates, silverware - they spent a few bucks making it nice. We ordered too much, which happens when eating late after skipping lunch.... Apps: 1. The grilled halloumi was great - sometimes it can get rubbery - not here. They were served over thick sliced roasted tomatoes which held up just enough to get some grill marks as well. I could have done without the glaze, but it was still ok. 2. Tuna tartare - deep red tuna, diced, over avocado - well plated, good dish. 3. Couldn't decide on a grilled fish app, so went with the grilled seafood sampler - amazing flavor on it all - calamari, shrimp and octopus all tender and kissed just enough on that open flame. Knife work on the garnishes and plating was done by someone who cares. Diced peppers under the calamari must've been quickly pickled - they had great flavor and kept just enough crunch to make a great dish even better. For entrees - went with the grilled salmon and ribeye steak... couldn't believe it was as good as it was for the price. Salmon was delicious, juicy, and even the skin on (plated skin down) was perfect - which I can never do, especially on a grill. The ribeye was delicious - lots of rib-cap, perfectly medium-rare, even on a hot plate, and I could swear the chef might have predicted cook time to put the more rare side plate down to make it become a medium steak by the time it hit the table. And the fries..... ohhhhhh the fries..... I'm a sucker for french fries when done right, and I ordered these fries and apps alone, it would have been a perfect meal.... perfectly hot, crispy, and plentiful. Stuffed, packed up some of the entrees for leftovers, and skipped desert and coffee - it was late. But will deffff be back and can't wait to try some of the offerings on that menu. Oh and here's a tip... if you park facing the restaurant at night, turn off your headlights as you're pulling into the spot. Was it a particularly flawless night, or is this the norm? Will report back after going back - will deff be back.

We went last night for dinner. It's a seafood dominant restaurant but some good non fish choices…read more We got the 4 choice mezze appetizer. The hummus and skotdalia were standouts. They give you pita and eggplant dip to start as well. We got a greek salad with lettuce added on and it was fresh, crisp and dressing was good. I got the organic roast chicken and it came with lemon potato and steamed broccoli & cauliflower. i wish the latter had some seasoning, though. My husband got spanakopita and he said it was ok. Service was attentive and the place looks like it was recently renovated. Parking lot is small so we had to park across the street.

I called to see if open / place order on Labor Day. The employee was rude on the phone. Allergic to…read moreonions & asked specifically for none, but I was polite about it. My request was even printed on the receipt. Somehow the food comes covered in onions. (& The portions are skimpy for the prices.) Edit - he was nice about it when i went back & gave me a free sweet treat lol

This location is permanently closed as of Saturday 3/29/25 …read more Do use the online ordering system and it is a shame to see them go because they did have good food

Found our new go to spot!!! We found this hidden gem while on a supermarket run at food universe…read moreand noticed a different cart parked at the corner. We missed out on such yummy food as they used to only be open till lunch time hours... now they are open morning for breakfast till dinner. My husband spoke highly of the man- very nice and food was delicious- super fresh and non fattening, doesn't taste like food from a cart and portions are very generous. Will be back again!

I called to see if they had any open reservations today (Mother's Day) and they said yes. We had no…read moreproblems getting seated. We had already looked on the menu online and knew what we wanted to order. However, they gave us a pre-fix menu and stated that we could only order from the Mother's Day menu. It was 1 appetizer, 1 entree, soda or tea for $55 per person. If you look at the regular menu prices, this exceeds what it cost for 1 entree and 1 appetizer. We got the cheese rolls, liver, & mixed appetizer which were all shareable portions. After we were done with appetizers, it took over an hour to get our entrees. The waiter checked in and it seemed that he never gave the kitchen our orders or completely forgot about them because the food was luke warm. We got the lamb chops, chicken shish, & branzino. The chicken and tender and juicy. The branzino was light and flaky. Everything was well seasoned and the rice & salad were also tasty. The lamb chops were over cooked and a bit dry. Overall, I would say don't come here on a day you know will be busy. You may not get to order the dishes you want, experience poor service, and deal with an overpriced menu. For $55, they should have included a baklava for dessert or something.

I am extremely disappointed. The last 2 times I order the kunafe from them. Both tickets it was…read moresoggy and not tasty. I dont know if they changed their staff or chef but everything is a mess with orders now. I ordered the lamb chops with Shepard salad but didnt receive the salad- They charge $3 for that salad yet sent the wrong one. I have to find a new place now. I use to love this restaurant.