This was such a pleasant experience. Ordering via the website for pickup was easy. I got a lunch special of sandwich + fries. The food was ready when I arrive, fresh & hot. The store itself was *immaculately* clean. Somehow the fries even stayed hot & crispy on my ride home (I feel like fries from any place get soggy right away). The sandwich was a generous portion & they were nice enough to make my sandwich with the modifications I asked for. I will definitely be returning! read more

My wife and I were in the mood for some Greek food, and I heard about Gyro Jimmy's, so I said let's go check it out. Located on Voice Rd in Carle Place in the back of the parking lot. It is spacious with plenty of tables. We go up to the counter and order 2 gyros and an order of fries. We did not order drinks, and we were asked if we wanted water. So, we took the water. We sat at a table the drinks and food were brought over to us. Great service. Our Gyros were plentiful with meat, and I ordered mine with no tomatoes and my wife with no onions and good portion of fries. The Gyros and fries were very good. We finished the Gyros but not the fries. Nice size portions. We were full. When were finished we were told not to clear the table, they would do it. A quick enjoyable meal for us with great service, looks like this is going to be our new Greek dining spot. Hope to return soon. A must try if you like Greek food. read more

This place is great-- when the meat is not burnt. I wish they'd scrape the grill clean more often. Stick with the pork gyro and avoid souvlaki for a less burnt experience. Service is fast. read more

First time eating here yesterday and saw the good reviews. Figured why not. Ordered the gyro plate with tomato and cucumber salad and fries. Also got the falafel appetizer. So the gyro plate was pretty good. Enjoyed the taste of the gyro and the fries. As for the falafel appetizer it was okay. Not a fan of the hummus as it was too watery. The falafel needed some salt but it wasn't over fried. Place was very clean and plenty of seating when arrived. Service was fine and staff were friendly. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you at a table. Wouldn't mind coming back but I'll probably pass on the falafel next time. read more

See all

This place is an absolute hidden gem! From the moment you walk in the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. I came in during the afternoon and was blown away by their menu they have fantastic lunch specials Can we talk about the grilled chicken?! It is so delicious, juicy, and perfectly cooked I left completely full and satisfied. Wow. Definitely coming back! So many seatings as well you can enjoy your delicious food read more

See all

Yelps search for gyro introduced Gryo Jimmy's in Garden City which turned out to be a pleasant treat. This location is on a private road in a strip mall with little to no traffic yet offering ample parking, but this was a Monday. I don't know how parking will be for remainder of the week. Stepping inside of Gryo Jimmy's you can see that fast food casual ambiance. I loved the picturesque aesthetics as well. The dining area was immaculate and spacious offering some beautiful booth type seatting (Pictured) as well as regular seating. We were given a heartfelt hello and smile that was filled with gratitude from the gentleman and young lady that was behind the register. Looking over the menu was just a practice because we were predetermined to get a gyro. I chose a chicken gyro while my plus 1 chose the traditional gyro. We both had fries and the white sauce. At the end of ordering ordered, the young lady was kind and patient enough to ask if we wanted something else. She was not rushing us nor did she curtail the process of us ordering. She did take control of the sale by closing the sale with a confirmation of our order and threw in her suggestive selling tactics on the French fries. She remained in control by telling us to have a seat and informed us that she'd bring the order to our table. Our order came on beautiful wooden trays. Presentation is delivered sir/ ma'am! The chicken gyro was my first ever and I found it has taste worthy of praise. It was really delicious, PACKED with... Did you read that.. packed with sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, and cucumber. This was very filling! My plus one enjoyed the traditional gyro that was packed as well. The dining experience went well excluding the guy that sat next to me blowing his nose, UGH! At the end of our service we were trying to figure out if we needed to take our trays up and dump them or put them on the table. The gentleman that was originally behind the counter came and took both our trays. With grace, he bid us adieu. Gratitude noted. Impact stamped. Inspire more. Yelp more. read more

See all

Delicious, fresh, portions big enough that I could have shared with someone else. Instead I had enough for leftovers. Friendly staff was a bonus. read more

I was nearby at aldi's and wanted a greek salad so this popped up on my yelp search. I placed the order online and it was ready pretty fast. I asked for a modification-no olives and they got it right. The chicken was juicy and overall the salad was pretty tasty. It comes with pita and tzatziki sauce which was also good. I'd like to try falafel next. read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

I ordered through Seamless for pickup, and the experience wasn't great. There was an internet issue, so my order wasn't ready when I arrived. That wasn't a problem, but while waiting, I noticed a few things that concerned me. One person in the back was handling meat without gloves, and the kitchen tiles looked dirty. With an open kitchen setup, cleanliness really stands out, and this didn't leave a good impression. The gyro itself was tasty, and guy that was on break when I arrived , get off break , wash his hands and put gloves one . The other guy I don't know what he was thinking . The meat and portions where fair and the Jimmy secret sauc tasted mostly like mayo and ketchup -- fine, but not the best match for a gyro maybe just the fries . read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

Food was delicious, atmosphere looked very chill. Not crowded at all. Looks very clran. And tidy. The cashier who took my order very polite and quick. I was starving so that was a plus for me. Def delicious gyro (lamb) and grape leaves. A tad bit pricey. But delicious gyro. read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Worth the money I paid! - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

Stopped into Gyro Jimmy's in Garden City with my plus one, and we both walked out happy and full. I ordered the traditional gyro with French fries and paired it with a Snapple Peach Tea, very simple, classic, and exactly what I was craving for today. The gyro was well stuffed with tender, flavorful meat and fresh toppings. The pita held up nicely without getting soggy, which is always a plus for me. The fries were crisp, hot, and seasoned just right, dipping or snacking on their own. Service was friendly and efficient, even during a busy lunch time. The place feels casual and welcoming, perfect for a quick bite or a relaxed lunch. Overall, Gyro Jimmy's hits the spot if you're in the mood for a solid, satisfying gyro meal. read more

See all

Hidden in a strip mall off the beaten path, we have Gyro Jimmy's. We were doing some shopping and decided to drop in for a weekday lunch. Ambience: clean and brightly lit. Fast casual style like a chipotle or pizzeria. Food: Falafel - crispy and crunchy on the outside, moist and hot on the inside. One of the better falafels I've had in a while. 5/5 Pork Gyro - well seasoned chunks of pork. I would have preferred a little more fat on it, but to each their own. 4/5 read more

See all

The absolute best lamb/beef gyros!! I am consistently satisfied when I order. I've never ventured from my gyro sandwich, but my friend usually gets the gyro plate with lemon potatoes & rice, lemon soup & halloumi, and he raves about it! I love that the gyro sandwich has the tzatziki smeared on the pita so there's a perfect amount in each bite. I also love that the meat is nice and crispy. It always tastes so fresh! It's buried deep in the back of a parking lot in an area like a little hidden gem. Service is quick and they have a decent amount of seating inside. If youre in the area or shopping at the mall, skip the fast food or crappy mall food and come here. It'll become your new favorite too! They're also very decently priced! read more

Cute fast casual Greek. Consistently good food and service. Can't stop by without ordering the Saganaki read more

See all

*4.5 stars but will round to 5* I always wanted to try this place because it smelled so good from the outside. We placed a pick up order and was nice to see that folks were dining there - definitely a good sign. They also had the order ready so quickly, which was nice. We ordered: 1. Horiatiki (authentic Greek salad) - good with the right amount of feta. 2. Traditional gyro plate - healthy amount of food and the meat was tasty. I wish they were slightly larger pieces but it was fine. 3. Pork gyro plate - tasty with a bit more chew than the beef/lamb. 4. Beet salad side - delicious. 5. Greek slaw - loved the acidity. I would note that you do get some of this in the beet salad. 6. French fries - good, slightly oily. 7. Greek rice pilaf - nothing special. 8. Extra gyro - a good amount, seemed like the same portion in the platter. 9. Extra tzatziki cup - small for $2. Not sure why they gave whole wheat pitas instead of regular. I would definitely order out again. read more

Pretty solid option for the area. Big fan of caesar salad with chicken gyro and I think they did it fairly well. I do wish it had more (any?) cheese on but I enjoyed the dressing. I also enjoyed that it came with pita with tzatziki, which I wasn't anticipating. Service was super quick and it was reasonably priced for gyro. read more

Found a gem. First time to Gyro Jimmy's and it was a winner. I had a new salad. It was red cabbage, feta, grape leaves, and olives with a lemon dressing and I had gyro meat on top. Delicious. It seems to be mostly take out but we ate there. There are probably a dozen tables. The employees were very nice and service was great. We'll definitely be back! read more

Even though our order was not accurate, we enjoyed everything! The beef lamb gyro was tasty and tender . We love the delicious beet salad . Don't miss out on the Baklava. The right amount of sweetness . We order take out but they have a pleasant dining area where you can eat at the location. read more

I came in for a lunch special, and ordering at the counter didn't take too long to get the order. I did get gyro meat with pita, which was not together in a sandwich as I expected. It came with fries, tzatziki sauce, and ketchup for a complete meal. I got it to go, but there were plenty of tables for people to eat inside. It was a very filling lunch and the gyro/pita was good. The fries were a little soft. I would say it's a decent place to get some Greek food. read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Gyro meat with pita and fries lunch special - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

Came here on a god friends recommendation and holy cow. The food rivals that of Astoria's. The gyro is legit. Not those strips you buy from a food distributor. The seasoning is incredible. Tried the pork and chicken souvlaki and was hoping they weren't dried out as they tend to get dry and chewy. These were amazing. Freshly made, juicy and super flavorful. Service was amazing and the staff know all the regulars. Will be coming back here way more often. They do lunch specials for around $12 and you'll leave really full. Avgemono soup is legit. Not thickened with starch or flour. It's thin like it should be and super bright with lemon and chicken. Loaded with orzo. Highly recommend this spot. The spot itself is super clean and the bathrooms are immaculate. read more

See all

Gyro Jimmy's is the friendliest place with the best gyros you will have here on the island. We have been customers for over a year sometimes visiting more than once per week and the food never disappoints. The consistently is remarkable. The staff and owner are super friendly and the place is very very clean. We truly love it here. If you're in the area, be sure to give them a try! They are in the same plaza where QZar is!! read more

See all

Omg what a gem! My husband and I shared a Skepasti and the eggplant dip with pita chips. Everything was so delicious! It will be our new go to spot in this area. read more

I'm almost hesitant to brag about this place - I love it so much I want to keep it all to myself but truly they deserve all the recognition. The food and service is 10/10. My favorite gyro I have ever had whether traditional or chicken. My favorite is the "plates". The food is so fresh i never feel gross after eating here. They give so much for the price. And always take out from here it's my favorite take out but the seating area is very modern, clean and nice. read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Chicken Souvlaki - Plate - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

This is my first time at Gyro Jimmy's and they did not disappoint. The people were so friendly and helpful. The ambiance was nice and quiet and just comfortable. The food was soooooo goooood. I was so happy with my chicken souvlaki lunch special and hummus. My mom and I split the hummus and it was so much food we both ended up bringing half our lunch home. I am picky with my hummus because I love it so much. Their hummus was delicious!!! I will definitely be returning. You must come and bring a friend! read more

See all

Although there are quite a few casual Greek eateries in these parts, none that I've tried can compare to Gyro Jimmy's in terms of taste, quality, and pricing. My takeout order was beautifully packaged and ready on time which I always appreciate. Ordered the "Tasting Trio" (hummus, eggplant and taramasalata) appetizer to start, a huge portion of creamy goodness accompanied by a generous helping of yummy toasted pita chips. In fact the app was so large that we had to save the rest of our food for the next meal (no problem!). We both liked the hummus best but all of the dips were great. I'd never enjoyed a Cretan (Dakos) salad before so when I saw that on the menu I had to order it. Comprised of ultra-fresh diced ruby red tomatoes, creamy feta, capers, stuffed grape leaves and olives studded with large bread croutons, the salad was uniquely delicious. Got a side of the lamb/beef gyro as an extra protein, sliced thin and very flavorful. Hubby loved his gyro platter as well, especially the green beans that were cooked with savory carrots. Thank you Andie and my fellow Yelpers for posting about Gyro Jimmy's. Since it's a small place in an obscure strip mall I might never have found it otherwise, and that would have been a real shame. Can't wait to return! read more

See all

Had it not been for Mets Citi Field article (Yankees fan) about the different foods they offer, I would never know about this delicious joint. It's kinda hidden on a side alley off of Carle Place so not the best location. They need to advertise better to get the word out. Ordered the Chicken souvlaki skepasti and this thing is so goooooood!!! The flavor of the chicken, the warmth of the pita and the tasty lettuce, tomatoes and onion filling, hit me a certain way. It's like a pita sandwich cut into fourths. I'll be back next week to try something else. The gentleman that took care of us was so nice (pure vida.) My husband ordered the gyro and I can't wait to take a bite. Run don't walk to Gyro Jimmy's!! FYI, that secret sauce took my sandwich to another level. read more

Hidden Greek gem and super glad I visited this joint based on many great Yelp reviews. My go to Greek sandwich, The pork souvlaki on pita with everything and extra hot sauce absolutely hit the spot. Every single bite was packed with flavor, and the pork was perfectly marinated. The pita's charr was mind blowing good. I've eaten many many sandwiches in New York and Long Island, this is definitely up there with the best. Keep doing what you're doing. Don't change a thing. read more

See all

The food here is amazing, it is truly so delicious. The service workers are very friendly and helpful. I cant recommend this place enough.

Welcome to the neighborhood, Jimmy! I've been to Gyro Jimmy's a few times and love their food. Everything is made to order and fresh. Whenever I'm in the mood for a gyro, I usually order the lamb/beef gyro. Today, I saw that Gyro Jimmy's has a pork gyro (not to be confused with pork souvlaki). I gave it a try and dare I say...I liked it more than the usual lamb/beef gyro! I liked it so much that I think the pork gyro is now my go-to sandwich going forward! It was delicious and didn't seem as fatty as the lamb/beef gyro. The sandwich also had a perfect ratio of meat/salad/tzatziki sauce/french fries! Delicious combo. Service and hospitality were friendly and welcoming; restaurant is super clean; plenty of parking outside. Prices are very reasonable. I shall be back! read more

Food was delicious and authentic Greek. We call 30 minutes before closing and everything we ordered was fresh and hot. The restaurant is off the beaten path, so if you're looking for gyros, souvlaki and pita Jimmy is your guy! read more

Authentic tacos, everything was tasty and fresh, the place needs some update but if you care about the food, try it out!

The lentils soup was the best I've ever had!!!!!! It was so good. I also got a Caesar salad, which is also delicious. Definitely going to order again read more

Best Greek food in Long Island. Gyros are super fresh, salad taste crisp. Would totally recommend this spot and will deff come back here to eat read more

See all

Great gyros and great customer service! We visited this spot recently ordering gyros and chicken souvlaki pita wraps along with Greek fries to go. The sandwiches were made hot and fresh and the meats were seasoned well and tasted great. The fries went well with tzatziki sauce and when I went back in after picking up to ask for more sauce, they gave me extra for free instead of charging me which I really appreciated. read more

Yo Jimmy! I was going to hit up my usual lunch spot when Yelp suggested a Hot & New business. Tucked in the back of a strip mall is Gyro Jimmy's. I start talking to the manager about the menu, lots of the items we discussed are homemade. And I dig that! First time here so I ordered a beef & lamb gyro with no onions. I'm also noting, their sandwiches can also be upsized to a platter. My sandwich comes out pretty quickly. This is a pretty hefty sandwich! The meat cuts are fresh and flavorful, the pita bread has a nice toasty exterior, this is a well dressed Gyro. Day two, I invite Frank out to a Christmas lunch. I am going to have a busy few weeks so I wanted to have a nice lunch with my buddy so I suggested Gyro Jimmy's. We walk into a very clean space. Frank looks over the menu, as for me? The next item to tackle is the Falafel sandwich. Frank orders a traditional sandwich and asks for no tomatoes. Frank's gyro was loaded with tomatoes. My sandwich has two Falafel balls with covered with lettuce, tomatoes and onions. There were no french fries or sauces on my sandwich. I asked for a side of Jimmy Sauce and was also given Tzatziki and Tahini sauce. I've been here twice and honestly, I can't wait to return. There are menu items that are calling me, Avgolemono, Spanakopita Spinach Pie, Horiatiki Greek Salad topped with Gyro meat and of course, their Baklava. JImmy Gyro's is a nice spot for a sandwich along with a great price point. read more

See all

5 plus plus plus Best authentic Greek option in area. A must try! i guarantee you will enjoy and return. The interior is neat, clean, modern, efficient, and casual. The exterior is also new and modern. They are off the main road in a shopping and commercial business area. You can see into the super clean and organized kitchen. I love that! Nothing to hide! I had traditional beef and pork American style gyro platter with 2 sides and a drink. They also have chicken gyro and Greek style stacked pork gyro. I has Greek coleslaw and string bean sides. Both were delicious, so was the gyro. The service was excellent. We were served by one of the owners and we spoke with another owner while enjoying our meal. What a great way to give buy with new customers! Im in! The owners seem like experienced and successful restaurant veterans. I will return. Highly recommend this place. I would consider this place for business or personal take out and catering. Would love to see some Greek cookies and baklava on the menu. Guarantee i would be grabbing some with my meal! read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Gyro platter with string beans and Greek Coleslaw, delicious 5+++++ - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York

Hands down one the best Greek salads I have ever had. Adding the chicken gyro made it even better. The falafel was soft on the inside with great flavor and a little spice. Very clean inside with a friendly staff and outstanding service. This is on my short list of places to eat whenever I'm in the area. read more

Tried the beef/lamb gyro platter for delivery tonight. The meat was pretty good in flavor but slightly overcooked and drier than I would have wanted. The portion size was large: it can easily be a meal for 2 people. read more

The room was clean and welcoming. The manager was helpful in explaining the somewhat complicated menu. (You make your own combo.) The service was fast. The chicken souvlaki was juicy. If I'm in the area again, I'll be back. read more

Decent portions with a clean sit down area to eat at. The pork souvlaki and the French fries were seasoned well! Get the green beans for a healthy balance between the heaviness of the meats. read more

Gyro Jimmy’s - Pork Souvlaki - Plate ($16) - Greek Near Me - Carle Place, New York