Ambiance of the old converted bank is beautiful (my mom got her first bank account here). However,…read morethey overcrowd the space with many tables; taking away the intimacy on a busy night when you're elbow to elbow with the people next to you! It's often loud due to over-crowding! The service is impeccable and for the cost per dish the wait staff really is top notch. The food is delicious! I did not enjoy the bacon because I thought it would be thick slabs but it was one very thick piece, more like prosciutto. Colossal crab meat app (MP), 1/2 dozen BP oysters ($18) and Caesar salad ($18) were very fresh! 5/5 duck fat French fries ($10) .Whipped potato, creamed spinach and 5 cheese Mac sides ($16/each) are served à la carte,and delicious! Bone marrow butter ($6) = delicious. While rich and not preferred to American, the 4 oz Japanese A5 wagyu ($65) melts in your mouth. Snake River Farms 10 oz filet ($95) is delicious but pretty expensive, can def tell the difference between the quality beef and the re regular 10 oz filet ($79) but both are delicious. The regular 16 oz bone in cowgirl ($76) ribeye is marbled well and tastes incredible! They offer two course pricey fixe($29) lunch during the week, guaranteed in under a half an hour! 5/5 food 4/5 ambiance (loud/close during weekends) 5/5 (lunchtime) Service 5/5 The food is great. The service is great and the bill will be larger than many, other equally delicious high-end steakhouses! If you go out on a lunch, it will run you upwards of $300

Celebrated my birthday with family at Tellers tonight. My brother raved about this place and I…read moretotally see why. The staff was very friendly and courteous from the moment we entered the building. Our server was very patient and informative. I don't recall his name but he was tatted and handsome! All of the apps we ordered were delish. The crab cake and blue joint oysters were the stars for me. My wagyu filet was a perfect hot pink medium! My family also enjoyed all of the entrees and sides. Cheers to the bartender for a perfect creamy espresso martini. Thank u Tellers for a great experience!

My wife and I ate there about a month ago on a Saturday evening. The restaurant was very busy, but…read morewe didn't have to wait more than 10 minutes. My wife had a salmon dish. Would she enjoy and I had the 16 ounce ribeye, medium rare. Although it's not prime steak it is nonetheless very good. We enjoyed our meals and are looking forward to coming back. The only thing I wish they had was better acoustics because it can get pretty noisy in there.

Would rather turn a Veteran away than accommodate us in the empty room in the back that's "closed"…read morewhile we have 2 kids with a stroller and the place is packed with no room. We left.

As others have said, I have passed this place many a time. It is beautiful inside, The staff is…read moreextremely welcoming. Angel was at the front door, inviting us in. Maria was our pleasant, most knowledgeable server. The food is awesome. I am a new customer!

Bon G and I celebrated our Anniversary Sunday 5/3 at Piccolo Villagio in Islip. 6 pm rezzy a good…read moretime cause not crowded yet. We were welcomed and seated immediately. Our servers were cordial and answered any questions we had. Ordered a bottle of Maltapulciano de Abruzzo and it was great with our courses. For appy we split entre of their pasta special. Moved on to mains of Shortribs and Veal Scallopini Marsala..was delish! For dessert Creme Brulee made crispy with a torch! Great meal for our Anniversary...

Always on point, best customer service ever. 6 stars. Glad this little shop is nearby, makes it an…read moreeasy choice.

Great food and service. Very friendly neighborhood butcher shop. Meat and chicken are fresh and…read moredelicious. They even help you out to the car! Very good prepared foods as well.

I've been meaning to try Bayberry for a while & I saw a post about their happy hour so decided to…read moregive it a try. Happy hour at the bar is from 12-7pm with the bar bites available after 4pm. The place is very nicely decorated and exudes an upscale but unpretentious vibe. I ordered a glass of the pinot noir which was tasty and at $6 a nice bargain. I got the chickpea fries and was surprised by the texture. It was almost custard like with a slight chickpea flavor in a very light breading. Served with the harissa aioli it made for a nice app. After a while I decided to try the Filet mignon sliders, which I ordered medium rare, the bartender said they don't usually take a temp on those but he'd note it. The meat is sliced very thin but was tender and still had a bit of red. The arugula gave it a nice peppery bite. My only critic is the slider roll was very cottony, but the overall taste was very good. I'll definitely be back and will try something off the regular menu.

Bayberry is a lovely restaurant and bar with small but specific menu of tasty looking options…read more The Mr and I along with our newborn were looking for a new near by seafood locations and came across them and decided to give them a try. As mentioned they try to offer fresh, seasonal apps, handhelds, salads and entrees. The protein entree options only offer two to three chicken, pork, steak, seafood selections along with a couple of pasta infused dishes. They have a full bar, so if a beer or cocktail is wanted you do have options there as well. The Mr selected the Chilled Shrimp & Crab Stack, but eliminated the hard boiled egg aspect and thought it was light, tasty and refreshing. I opted for the Faroe Salmon with shrimp that came accompanied/on top of a risotto and peas. I thought cooked medium was perfect making it soft and fork flaky to mix along together. It was a very juicy sizable piece making it very filling. We didn't have time for a dessert, but noted they did have a few offerings there. Also noted they had very well kept mens/woman's and family restroom with baby changing table. Thanks! Would highly recommend this location to others.

If you're having trouble finding street parking keep a look out for free parking lots you can park…read morein. My friend and I were welcomed wonderfully by the staff. We got a table fairly quickly and were greeted by a wonderful waiter Dennis! He was sooo happy and greeted us with a smile! The food was DELICIOUS! The Troffolini was incredible! What made the sauce special was the sweetness of a pair. The baked clams were incredible! Not only did our main dishes look beautiful, but they tasted fantastic! A perfect place to catch up with a friend or go for a date! Thank you to everyone at Americano Pie Bar for their great service!

This used to be our go-to restaurant for years, ever since it took over the location where Gino's…read morePizzeria was. We ordered from here at least once a week, but unfortunately, the quality and customer service have gone downhill. After one major order mistake, I called to have it corrected and was met with an attitude that completely turned me off. I even questioned whether the restaurant had changed ownership because the difference in service and quality was so noticeable. I was told it hadn't, but there was a new manager whom I had actually seen at the restaurant. Despite all of that, my family insisted we give it another chance because they love one particular meal. I refused to order, pay, or pick it up--and sure enough, they forgot the salad dressing (again!) and another part of the order was incorrect. When I called and asked if someone could deliver the missing items I was met with attitude once again. Tonight, we gave them yet another chance, and, surprise, two of our pasta orders were wrong. On top of that, the food simply doesn't taste as good as it used to. I'm really not sure what happened, but between the menu changes, our favorite items disappearing, repeated mistakes, and consistently disappointing customer service, I'm officially done. I've even perfected the "favorite meal" at home on principle. After years of being loyal customers, it's extremely disappointing to say that I will not be going back.

Visited this charming spot for the first time. It's located on busy main street in Islip but once…read moreinside with the heavy 'fence' of greenery you'd never know. There is limited parking in the small lot in the back but there is street parking. There is a small bar area that was quite busy when my brother and I visited on a recent Tuesday at 7pm. I don't know if they have 'happy hour' but it seemed to quiet down not long after that. The dining area is not large but there are quite a number of tables and for a Tuesday many were occupied at that time with everyone from couples to families to singles. Complimentary bruschetta was brought along with a bread basket of a rustic bread w/olives and a white bread. There is a very extensive wine list along with a good selection by the glass. The standard menu is huge and they also had a full page of specials. We started with the crab cakes for an app and we mentioned we'd be sharing. I was impressed that they brought us each 1 plated. My brother had a Veal chop special, enough for two meals, that was stuffed with spinach, prosciutto & cheese in a brown mushroom gravy. He enjoyed it tremendously I have a chicken special that was stuffed with spinach, sausage, ricotta in a light tomato sauce. It was very tasty and a large portion. I took half home. There were also several dessert specials, we had a pistachio creme brulee which was just ok and a rainbow cookie crusted cheesecake which was outstanding. Everything from the service to the food was above average and I won't hesitate to go again and soon

Da Noi is the great Italian restaurant you might not know about. Situated on Montauk Highway in…read moreIslip, Da Noi serves Italian-American cuisine that competes with the best. Baked clams are my "litmus test" for Italian restaurants, and theirs are in my top 10. Their menu is insane! So many choices, so many specials each day, and a huge assortment of desserts. If you cannot find something to eat, there is something wrong. The bar area is very small, so don't plan on spending too much time there before you get seated. Their staff is attentive without being annoying, and their dining room is large and welcoming. Once seated, you are greeted with complimentary bruschetta and their ample bread basket. Two things I recommend ordering are their clams and if you eat rabbit, definitely get theirs when it is offered. Portions are huge and the quality of seafood is always fresh. They have a small lot in the rear of the restaurant, with both a rear and front entrance. There is also street parking available (do NOT park in the bank lot across the street--you will get towed).

We've been to Harp and Hound several times in the last year and are never disappointed. Typically…read morewe sit in the outdoor dining area but it was too cold to do that tonight. We would have sat in the main dining room but there was a private group in there so we sat at the bar. So glad we did. Our server / bartender Nicole welcomed us immediately and took our drink orders. My wife had a Moscow Mule and I had an IPA. My wife said her mule was perfect! The beer was good and the taps are obviously well maintained. We each ordered burgers and shared an order of onion rings. Our burgers came perfectly prepared (rare) and the fries were crispy and delicious. The onion rings were a huge portion and were equally good. For what we ordered the bill was more than reasonable, the food great for bar food and our server, Nicole, was outstanding. See you again soon Harp and Hound.

First time back since they reopened after the fire. Not that much has changed, though the floor is…read morebetter and there are more TV's on the wall behind the bar. I went for Wednesday Boozy Bingo. I arrived at approx 6:15pm and the place was packed but I managed to find a spot at the bar. Was served my drink quickly and given menus. There was an extensive specials menu with a few interesting choices, including :COLOSSAL SWEET AND SPICY CUBAN Bring your appetite!! Slow-braised mojo pork shoulder, grilled smoked ham, melted swiss/gruyere, Grey poupon mayo, sweet pickle-cherry pepper relish and dill pickles on pressed Cuban bread. Served with a warm mojo dipping broth and Hound fries JACK DANIELS RIBEYE SANDWICH Herb butter brushed sourdough, grilled ribeye, melted gruyere cheese, arugula and sauteed mushrooms and onions in a Jack Daniel's sauce. Served with Hound fries BLACK AND BLUE PASTRAMI Toasted marble rye, melted blue cheese, sliced pastrami. pastrami rub aioli and tangy pickled red cabbage. Served with Hound fries LOBSTER TRAP Creamy lobster mac and cheese finished with toasted old bay panko. Topped with a double smash burger on a toasted brioche bun, candied bacon, sharp cheddar, pickled red onions and an Old Bay roasted garlic aioli. Crispy onions and scallions I chose the Cuban and when they say Colossal they meant it. It could easily feed 2 even 3 people. The pork was outstanding, the ham a bit overcooked and warning the cherry pepper relish has a real kick so if you're not into spicy be ware. The fries were shoestring with their signature seasoning blend. I took home more then half. Once the bingo started it cleared out a bit but still busy. I hope some they put some of the other specials back on the menu as I'd like to try all of the above.

Very charming decor inside, I really loved the colors and detail on the walls…read more The cocktails were so tasty, although pricey, the quality and flavors of the drink were excellent. If you like yuzu/lemon flavors, definitely get the Lovefool cocktail. I also enjoyed their steak here--both their frites and sandwich. Surprisingly flavorful and tasty! I would recommend bringing cash as there is an up charge using credit card here. The service here was very prompt and food came out at a decent rate. I would definitely recommend this spot for a date.

Had a great Father's Day dinner at Bar Clementine. We've always wanted to give this spot a try and…read morewe finally did. Service was a okay, it seems that they were a little bit short staffed, but they all pitched in to make things run smooth. This is a tiny spot but it has a nice classy touch to it.

Fairfield Ballpark, Central Islip (Ducks Game)…read more I had the pleasure of trying the Piggy Fries from the Dang BBQ food truck during a Ducks game, and wow -- they blew me away! These fries were made to order and served piping hot, with a perfect delicate crispness that held up beautifully under the generous toppings. The meat was tender, flavorful, and clearly slow-cooked with care. Every bite was better than the last -- honestly, it was even better than I expected. The food truck itself was impressively clean and smelled incredible from the mix of barbecue and fried goodness wafting out. The very beautiful woman taking orders had such a kind, pleasant face that she instantly brightened my day. And major kudos to the cook -- whoever's running the grill is an absolute star. I'm already craving a second plate! If you ever catch the Dang BBQ truck at an event, do yourself a favor and order the Piggy Fries. You won't regret it.

Closing as of October 30, 2025, the other location will remain open. See facebook post for full…read moreexplanation.