I know there are mixed reviews about the food at The Bagel Mill, but I am actually a huge fan of their bagels, and I love their salted honey lattes. The reason for my 2-star review is the fact that their posted hours on Google and on their website are 7am-2pm, but on 3 separate occasions I drove the 30 minutes with my kids to have lunch, and they were closed nearly 2 hours early. A few weeks ago, we called to order ahead around 12:15, and were told that they had sold out. Lastly (and the final inspiration for this review), I pre-ordered bagels and coffees last night, and I received a call at 11:51 am from the restaurant to let me know that they had sold out and would be canceling and refunding my order. While I realize that it must be hard to estimate what you might sell each day, underestimating demand to the extent that they close nearly 2-hours early on a regular basis seems like bad business to me. What about selling day-old bagels for a discount if you end the day with leftovers rather than losing out on lunch customers? Sadly, I am now on the hunt for a new favorite bagel spot. read more

Needed a quick on the go breakfast spot and found this gem. We ordered the "California egg & cheese" on a onion bagel with added jalapeño cream cheese, sourdough cinnamon roll, and iced strawberry matcha. The bagel sandwich was great, however we wished they put more cream cheese. The cinnamon roll was a good balance from the sweet frosting and the sourdough. And the matcha drink was okay. I felt like it was lacking strawberry flavor. In the photo you really don't see any strawberry. Overall, great local spot for bagels. Would come again if I'm on the go and am craving bagels! read more

The Bagel Mill - Strawberry matcha - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

Yummy bagels. Easy delivery too. I especially enjoy the pumpernickel and their special spreads

Outstanding Pesto Bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese. Small town vibe with a cool ambiance. Service was friendly and fast. Great choice when you're in town. read more

Delicious gluten free bagels here! Bought a bunch for home and toasted and the scallion cream cheese is yuuumm.

Made a pit stop to The Bagel Mill on the way to Guerneville...and it did not disappoint! I came with some friends and we all ordered the avocado toast bagel and it was a 10/10. The avocado toast was a perfect balance of avocado, pickled veggies, and alfalfa sprouts. If you're ever in Petaluma or just passing through like myself, this is a great spot to check out read more

The Bagel Mill - Avocado toast bagel - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

Very mediocre and over priced. Bagels were good, but barely toasted, just a very lackluster eating experience. Pretty lame and basic.

Best bagels I've ever had...and I've lived in NYC...TWICE! The coffee is also amazing and the best in Sonoma county! This place is a must if you're ANYWHERE close by. read more

I really like the bagels. Chewy and delicious. All the different flavors of bagels are tasty. I have always had very good service. My favorite item to order is the spicy turkey club sandwich. This sandwich is full of flavors. I normally go for the everything bagel. The turkey is delicious. Topped with thick slices of Hobb's bacon, avocado and the spicy sriracha mayo you can't go wrong. They do not skimp on the amount of ingredients. Lots of turkey, bacon and avocado. And the presentation is always very nice. Great local restaurant!! read more

The Bagel Mill - Spicy turkey club. - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

I looove the bagel mill!! Best gluten free bagels and great service :) perfect spot to study or meet with a friend and have a delicious latte read more

Amazing coffee and bagels. Definitely recommend one of the sandwiches on the menu. The bagels have the perfect balance of crunchy exterior and fluffy inside. My personal favorite is the Avocado Toast bagel on the Onion bagel. Depending on the timing it can get busy because everyone wants one of the bagels but it is definitely worth the wait. Also the coffee is a plus- tried the seasonal Toasted Coconut latte and it did not disappoint! Staff is extremely friendly. read more

The Bagel Mill - Toasted Coconut latte with oat milk - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

By far one of the best bagels I have ever had. Been coming here for years and if you get the chance to try the Jorge special DO IT. Jorge, whoever you are, God bless you!!!! read more

The Bagel Mill - Jorge special - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

I was shocked when I heard a bagel shop was opening - there are only like three people left in California eating carbs I thought. Luckily for all of us I was wrong and bagels is just what we needed - best bagels I've ever had! The everything bagel has everything on the top and the bottom!!! Both sides equally good to eat. Then they came up with green olive spread - freakin geniuses! Why hadn't this happened before. Besides being geniuses the staff is so nice. So go to the Bagel Mill but please don't take the last everything bagel!!! read more

This place is AMAZING! As well as the FOOD! Service is Great! The one hour drive is worth it ! read more

The Bagel Mill - BYO BAGEL - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

Horrible wait time for two bagels 35 minutes. Won't ever go back. When they opened wait time was short now it's a joke not recommended to go. read more

This is a great place to take a picky vegan friend, and still be able to eat something decent yourself. Terrific bagels. Too often they are out of pumpernickel, but that's not an uncommon problem. Excellent coffee. Nice spot for breakfast. Lots of roomy tables. Great servers who know how to treat everyone with respect. read more

This is an excellent bagel shop with lots of bagels and a good amount of toppings and spreads to choose from. They also sell oatmeal and other breakfast items too so there are plenty of options to start your morning. First off, this place is like a boutique where they serve neat and things are presented well. There are plenty of seats so you can relax and enjoy your food. I ordered an everything bagel with lox salmon, red onions and scallion spread! It tasted almost as good as the highly popular bagel from Russ & Daughters bagel in New York. I would totally come back again if I'm ever in the Sonoma or Petaluma area. Their add ones and bagels could be a bit expensive than most bagel shops but still worth it and truly delicious. read more

By far, the best bagel I've had anywhere in the Bay Area. I went in on a weekday to grab a dozen bagels for a co-workers birthday. I scoured Yelp for the best bagel place and my instincts (and some amazing yelp reviews,) led me here. I was charmed from the moment I walked in the door. The smell of fresh bagels and coffee brewing set the tone. The shop itself is very cute, updated modern chic decor and has a pleasant vibe overall. I ordered a random assortment of bagels and then took the suggestion to try the olive cream cheese along with the cinnamon and chive ones I already settled on. This was the best decision ever. The olive cream cheese is so amazing. People at work raved for a week. The other cream cheese selections were also good. The bagels have this light crispness to the outside and softness on the inside. I was just looking up the menu to sneak in there today when I discovered they are closed. Oh well, everyone needs a day off. Gotta rest those bagel makers! read more

See all

Awesome! Possibly the best bagels I've had (get the toasted sesame with green olive cream cheese!)...and ditto on the coffee. Well done! (Only 4 out of 5 stars as it the prices are pretty high, but no reflection on the quality of the food). read more

GF bagels! And they looked almost the same as the gluten filled ones. They were tender, and not super tough like other ones I have tried. Well done read more

Delicious bagel and super friendly service. I asked for a sesame seed bagel and they gave me poppyseed. However, I still enjoyed it a lot. It tasted delicious and fresh. read more

My wife and I went to the Bagel Mill for a quick breakfast and was not disappointed. It's a fairly large space with tables and a long bar where you can sit. There are a variety of bagel options, cream cheeses, and sandwiches to choose from. My wife had a coffee and I had a strawberry milk and both were quite good. We both ordered essentially a vegetarian sandwich--not my usual go to but it sounded refreshing. It had scallion cream cheese, radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, sprouts and was quite good. The bagel had the nice chew you'd expect and the veggie combo was great. It came together well. Compared to other, similar type of places it took longer to get the sandwiches out. It wasn't terribly busy and I thought they would've come out fairly quickly. We weren't on a deadline or anything but did have to get back to our AirBnB to check out and hit the road. Staff was very nice. read more

I felt like the yelp photos did not do this place justice! Love my poppy seed bagel with cream cheese and lox. The latte was to die for!! They serve Ritual coffee. It was a great atmosphere. Our boys sat at played with toys the restaurant provided and I got to savor my coffee! read more

The Bagel Mill - I love you a latte! - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

I tried a couple of new things on this trip. I finally tried the very scrumptious and decadent cinnamon roll - more than met my expectations! I also took home some bagels as I usually do, but I added the roasted Shishido peppers cream cheese. Delicious! read more

SO YUMMY!! We are gluten free and really enjoyed the GF bagel options here. Cool environment, easy to order online and pick up. Awesome breakfast sandwiches! Moved out of the area and will be craving these.... read more

Always great! Always fresh! I love the owners honesty, and frankness. Makes me want to go there even more! I love everything they offer, from there seasonal drinks, to there consistent standbys. Also, love their online ordering, and being able to order in advance so my mom brain doesn't have to think about picking up the bagel bag 3 days from now. Order in advance and just grab it on my way! read more

The bagels were good service was ok. My problem is tipping. If I have a to go order that is placed at the counter while I'm standing then you call my name, why should a 15% tip be expected. The look the server gave me after learning she didn't get a tip was not pleasant. I think if I'm carrying my bag out and stood there to order. Maybe i should get a discount. If I ate in the restaurant I'm sure I would be expected to bus my own table. read more

The food, coffee, & the people are all fantastic. I'm *almost* embarrassed at how many days a week we end up getting breakfast/coffee at Bagel Mill. Almost. But it's always a highlight of our week (& sometimes a highlight 3-4 times during the week). read more

Lack of real in person customer service . The inability to take a telephone call order when online ordering fails . Marks a failed business by choice . Now it's a matter of time is all . read more

My family said they were the best bagel and bagel sandwiches ever eaten! I had the avocado toast add creamed cheese on an onion bagel. AMAZING! I said Oh my God after every bite My husband had a breakfast California egg and cheese on a pesto bagel and my daughter got a plain bagel with honey cinnamon cream cheese. I only got a picture of my husbands the rest were eaten too quickly! We will be back again! read more

The Bagel Mill - California egg and cheese on a pesto bagel - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

I did not receive the friendliest of service and was not impressed with quality of the bagels (mine was hard). Will not revisit establishment again. read more

I went there at like 9 am and got the last pizza bagel! This place is so hoppin on a Thursday morning, and the bagels smell amazing. The line isn't too long, everyone is really respectful in trying to be safe and get bageled up. Fast service, and people sitting outside on the curb eating their to go bagels. read more

The Bagel Mill - Avocado toast on a pizza bagel - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

I just noticed that this bagel shop existed when I was shopping at the Petaluma Market. The name caught my attention, and I wanted to give it a try. They have an interesting selection of fresh bagels. I was deciding between the everything or the marble rye bagel when a wonderful thing happened. I saw they offered a marble rye everything bagel. Who knew that this was possible? Toasted with plain cream cheese this delight didn't disappoint. I added a latte which was expertly made. Breakfast done right. The service was friendly, local shop, great food. I'll be back next time I'm in Petaluma. read more

Best sourdough bagel I've ever had! Someone dropped off a bag-o-bagels at work with some schmear today. So damn good. I had no idea about the Bagel Mill so I had to search it out to get to the source. So glad I did. Coffee is great too. If you love a great fresh bagel in Sonoma county, this is the place. read more

We love bagel mill, before, during, and after Covid, they have been great and never skimped on quality or customer service. Everyone behind the counter has always been so friendly. Their to go options are so easy and convenient. My go to fav bagel order is their cream cheese and greens on an everything bagel, it even got my husband to eat greens ;) read more

Super cute but piss poor bagels and cinnamon rolls. The texture was tough and seemed rubbery. We were bummed! Staff were sweet environs seemed cozy. read more

Decent taste, but incredibly stingy with toppings considering the prices they charge. There should be more than 5 sprouts when you order sprouts. There should be enough tomato to actually cover all sides. Cream cheese should come on both halves. Always disappointing. Anyone have any recommendations for an actual bagel spot? read more

The Bagel Mill - Bagels Near Me - Petaluma, California

See all

These folks work their behinds off and it really shows. From setting up web ordering, bing bang boom, to offering free (hello, FREE?) sourdough starter and everything from bagels to bake-at-home cookie dough for people missing their favorite local bageliers during quarantine, personally I've been impressed with the creative thinking, generosity, and aplomb with which they're handling everything. Can't wait to come back here in person when this is all over with--but for now at least I've got Bagel Mill bagels in the freezer and a robust sourdough starter to play with at home. read more

Talk about bagels made with love. The amount of effort and quality ingredients that goes into baking these delicious bagels shows up within the first bite. My favorites are the marbled rye and the cinnamon raisin. Having one in a breakfast sandwich version is never a bad decision. The staff are super friendly. If you're in the need to get some studying/homework done than this is also a great spot to bring your laptop and order a cup of coffee along with your bagel sandwich. Also, if your on social media they have great content on instagram, that's honestly how I found out about this joint. My only warning is that they do run out of bagels. read more

Hands down best avocado toast I have ever had! My husband and son love their breakfast sandwiches too.