I love bagels, and we made the journey over to try this place I had seen a lot about. I'm glad we did. It's really busy, filled with locals and tourists alike. From the moment we walked in, we were almost overwhelmed with the amount of options available to choose from. One of the wonderful staff members saw us struggling with what to decide from, and she made some suggestions and was incredible. She even came up to the front to the cashier when it was time to order to make sure we ordered everything we discussed about in the correct manner. From that alone, she made the experience a 5/5. Every bite we had was good, and while I moved away from the NY area, my appetite for NY bagels remains. While I'm in the city a few times a year, I'm not often in the UES. This place makes me want to go to the UES so I can try as many options as possible on the menu. I wanted to order more and more while we were there, but I made myself wait until the next time we're on the UES to do it. read more

See all

The blueberry cream cheese is SO GOOD. I was craving it later that day. I originally wanted the Lox, which also hit the spot. But the blueberry cream cheese taste was so smooth and not over powering. I loved how the taste melted in my mouth. Service was quick. I got my food pretty quickly after ordering, even thought there was a line before and after me. I came on a snowy day, but I would definitely love to come on a sunny day. This is a nice quick to-go breakfast/brunch spot. Or a nice sit down bagel spot where I can people watch and enjoy my bagel. read more

The Bagel Shop - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Got the Diablo on Pumpernickel and the flavor was absolutely fire but it was not spicy at all... but still very delicious and they give you a ton of avocado which is great read more

The Bagel Shop - Diablo on Pumpernickel - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Really awesome neighborhood bagel. Nice chewy inside. Fair prices and the service is awesome. Love supporting these small local businesses that clearly have a lot of neighborhood love. read more

The bagel shop is highly praised and was recommended by a lot of different New York travel videos that I watched. I wanted to love this place so badly and came in with high expectations but was honestly pretty disappointed. The bagels themselves were just alright (I feel like I've had better bagels from Costco) and the flavors of each of the sandwiches weren't anything special. When I came, the store was packed, so be prepared to wait in line. There are some seats available but they're very limited and it felt like everyone was hovering over each other to try to get a seat as soon as it became available. Service was friendly though. Overall, for the food and the experience here, I would say it's not worth the visit. read more

The Bagel Shop - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I love this place. Feels like a neighborhood staple, always busy but quick getting your food, TONS of options, the bagels are all really good and fresh, the cream cheese top notch, especially the strawberry and blue berry which actually have real fruit in them. The staff is nice, the other customers are nice. They have lots of seating inside (although it's a bit noisy) and even more seating outside of the wether is nice. Personally only thing I would recommend is the breakfast sandwich, I feel that the cheese isn't melted enough and there is a TON of eggs but not as much meat which is where I feel most the flavor comes from. read more

The Bagel Shop - Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Loved this place. Both were terrific. Chocolate chip bagel with cinnamon raisin was so fun and tasty as a dessert kind of bagel. The everything bagel was so good. I'd come back and try the Doritos next time! read more

See all

Food: I got the Upper East Sider sandwich on an everything bagel, which is a classic lox with scallion cream cheese, capers, tomatoes. Although it was relatively pricier, the portion size was yuge. Such plentiful amount of fish and everything was so fresh. The bagel was decent with nice sweetness, chew, and density, but not overly so. Service: Service was great! The cashier was really nice and greeted everyone with a smile. Fast to get the sandwich. Ambiance: Super packed on a Sunday morning, I loved the vibes of this neighborhood UES bagel spot. Simple name with no frills attitude. Everything was clean and seating was plentiful even with so many people around. While it's not the best bagels I've ever had, it is a solid UES spot with great options, fresh ingredients, and good customer service. read more

The Bagel Shop - Upper East Sider Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

I liked how tall and open this place was! There's a pretty extensive menu and there was a constant flow of people. There are some tables inside and more outdoor seating - though the pavement is kind of uneven. I got a toasted cinnamon raisin bagel with strawberry cheesecake ($5.72). I feel like that is reasonably priced compared to other bagel places in NYC. My friend got the Upper East Sider. read more

See all

This is my go-to bagel shop every time I'm in NYC! I ordered the Loux breakfast bagel sandwich, and it did not disappoint. The bagel was fresh, everything was made to order, and the portion size was huge. The staff was friendly and answered all of my questions. There was plenty of seating both inside and outside, which made the experience even better. Highly recommend checking this place out. This is the spot for a classic NYC bagel. read more

The Bagel Shop - Breakfast Lox Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

My go to spot for a bagel sandwich in the UES/East Harlem area! I love the bagels at PopUp, but when I crave a sandwich I come here. staff is soo friendly, there is so seating, and it's so much cheaper than Tal! I don't have a go to order, just love trying things so will try to keep a running list. - matcha cream cheese w azuki red bean on sesame bagel is 5/5 and so unique - upper east side lox sandwich was very good, ~$17 - presto pesto was good but would not get again, the egg didn't hit for me, ~ $13 read more

The Bagel Shop - Sesame bagel with matcha cream cheese and red bean azuki! - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The Bagel Shop is still a classic and top two of my favorites! I love so many of their huge varieties of cream cheese and bagels, Flagel and bialys. The Olive Pimento and the Pumpernickel Bagels are just two of my go to for a special breakfast treat. If you are visiting NYC make this a to go but be prepared to wait in line if you don't arrive when they first open. I'm highly recommending as usual. read more

See all

Upper eastsider sandwich was super yummy. Bagel was good and the toppings were a good ratio. Service was quick and the shop is spacious with nice lighting. The outdoor seating area was nice as well. read more

The Bagel Shop - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

But like why is this the best bagel place I've had in NYC thus far? Every time I walked by here there was always a huge line out the door so I decided to try it out. We placed our order and surprisingly was able to find a table for 2 and we got our bagels within 10 minutes as they shouted our name over an intercom. I ordered the Upper East Sider on a delicious toasted onion bagel. I don't have much to say about the bagel itself, but each ingredient inside had generous servings. The lox was very thick cut and fresh and went very well with the capers and tomatoes. I definitely felt very full afterward. Looks, am I happy that it costs $15+ for a bagel? Not really, but it is very delicious and I will be back for more. read more

The Bagel Shop - Upper East Sider Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese and presto pesto! Great service, cute seating, would definitely come back (I live in Boston!) read more

The Bagel Shop - Presto Pesto and everything with jalapeño cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

I had a fantastic everything bagel with jalapeno cream cheese here: a chewy texture and rich cream cheese with nice tart and spicy pickled jalapeno flavor cutting through. Service was quick, and it cost a bit under $6 after taxes. I just wish the name was easier to Google! read more

Great selection to choose from, while the shop smelled amazing to intrigue all my senses. read more

See all

This review is long overdue. This is my go to bagel place when in the Upper East Side. They have a large variety of sandwiches, bagels and spreads. There are so many options it may be a bit intimidating, but I usually do not get in line until I have decided what I want. This time I has the California Dreamin", and even though the sign clearly states no substitutions, I substituted honey mustard for lemon honey feta spread, on a sesame bagel. The bagel was fresh and perfectly toasted. The tomatoes, avocado and cucumbers were thinly sliced and fresh. The swiss cheese was thick, but not too thick, just enough to taste the full flavor. Service is fast, but patient and friendly. The sandwich was $15, but was large enough to share. The lemon honey feta and sundried tomato spreads are some of my daughter's favorites and we purchased tubs to enjoy later. read more

The Bagel Shop - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Busy place with solid fast service. Ordered bagels, muffins and bacon egg and cheese. The BEC were 8.50 each. Filling and packed. Bagels were warm and doughy. Will def try again. read more

I love a great bagel breakfast sandwich so the breakfast lox caught my eye. I haven't had egg and smoked salmon together before so wasn't sure how the combination would taste, but I was overall very impressed! They put just the right amount of cream cheese so the sandwich wasn't too heavy. I would've liked a little more lox and the bagel got soggy within 10 minutes but I still really enjoyed it! There was a short line when we got there but our food came out surprisingly quickly. There is also an option to order online. They have an overwhelming amount of bagel options. I would come here more often if it was closer, but worth the trek! read more

The Bagel Shop - Breakfast Lox Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Love the sesame and everything bagels here. I've noticed the last few times I've come here after 1pm on on weekends if they have run out of certain bagel types they don't replenish the baskets so get here a bit earlier to have your choice. read more

The Bagel Shop - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Great bagel shop. Arrived at 10am on a Saturday and was in and out with my food in 10 minutes. There was a line but it moved very fast. Not a lot of sitting inside. Bagels were amazing. However the everything bagel was very flat which was a bummer. It looked like it had been smashed. The pumpernickel was the complete opposite. Pumpernickel BEC 9.03 / 10 Everything bagel 4.05 / 10 read more

See all

Solid bagel, fast service on a weekday morning. Lox spread could have used more lox, was mostly just salty. Busy grab and go spot with some seating. read more

The Bagel Shop - Everything with Lox Spread - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

A relative of mine had an appointment in the UES and I agreed to accompany them so we needed a place to meet (and eat). The Bagel Shop was located perfectly near the place we were going to so we agreed to meet here. The Bagel Shop is literally a corner store with big windows that let sunlight flood into the interior. The exterior and interior use the classic black and white color scheme. The main seating area is an "L" shaped section on the left side of the shop while the main counter is also L shaped on the other side. The chairs are kind of mismatched as are a couple tables and that's actually kind of charming in its own way. There's even bench seating along the walls which surprised me. Another bit of wonderful NYC ambience is the parade of adorable dogs that come through the shop. I had a gorgeous doggo hanging out with its owner next to me and it was super chill and adorable. Love it! The staff at this shop is super nice. I actually arrived early and ate before my relative arrived. When they arrived we grabbed some more food for them and there was never any rush to kick us out or have us give up the table. For that, I was very appreciative. Food is also prepared super quick. Both times I ordered food I was surprised how fast my food was ready. So how is the food? I had a sesame bagel (toasted) with egg, cheese and turkey and it was fantastic. It came to me piping hot with the cheese beautifully melted. They gave me enough turkey that I needed a fork to keep the sandwich together! The key is that the bagel had the perfect texture and chew for a sandwich. Most times bagel sandwiches require you ripping the bread apart with your teeth (or a knife) but this one was perfect. My relative had a cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese and they said it was really good. I really enjoyed The Bagel Shop and would go back any time! read more

We saw the line out the door when we arrived, and that was an excellent sign. The menu here is extensive. We shared a fresh turkey sandwich on and everything bagel and I think we have an out of body experience. New York food is just so much better than anywhere else and it's really exemplified by the simple stuff like bagel sandwiches. read more

Place is usually good and staff is always friendly but I unfortunately found a piece of glove in my sandwich ): I didn't want to go back because I only had a 15 min break from work. I understand it gets super busy in the morning but how can you not notice a piece of your glove is missing /: However, don't let this hinder you from coming here. Mistakes happen and they still make good food. read more

The Bagel Shop - piece of glove in my sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

My favorite Bagel shop in NYC! The shop is pretty big with some indoor seating! There is also great outdoor seating if it's nice outside! It is also right next to Central Park so you can get a bagel to go! The service was so fast and the guy who helped me was so nice and friendly! Honestly if I could go here every day I would because it wasn't too expensive and it was delicious! I will be back!! read more

See all

It's hard to stand out with so many bagel places in NYC, but this place definitely does. This is our favorite place to get bagel sandwitches whenever we have out of town guests. The southern fry is our go to! Nothing can top it. read more

The Bagel Shop - Southern Fry Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Would still say this is a solid bagel spot, often this place is very busy and you can 100% expect a line during peak hours. My go to is definitely the pumpernickel bagel with scallion cream cheese. Another favorite I recommend is the wannabe Cubano grilled cheese. It hits all the taste buds and has a tangy kick. It's buttered and slathered in mustard, topped with pickles with ham and cheese. Always comes with a side of chips. Once I came here on the weekend, and they don't usually served grilled cheese but they did me a favor and made it anyway which I thought was really nice of them. Ambiance wise there is not much seating, just a few if you are lucky. Definitely more of a take it to go sort of joint. read more

i got the everything bagel with scallion spread! it was delicious!! service was quick - I went during lunch time so there was a couple of people there and waiting but still was fast to take my order! I also got the fresh squeezed orange juice and it was really good and refreshing. The prices weren't terrible as it came out to be like $10 total. read more

The Bagel Shop - everything bagel with scallion spread - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Hands down my favorite bagel shop I've tried here in NYC. The staff is always friendly, the line moves quickly, and the wait for your food is never too long (5-10 minutes). They put out patio seating when the weather is nice if you can grab one of the quarts tables inside. Love their bagels- lots of flavor options. Their cream cheeses are so yummy especially the maple bacon. read more

The Bagel Shop - Presto Pesto - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Loved this spot on the Upper East Side! Got the Presto Pesto on an Everything Bagel for some greens and health and took it to Central Park to enjoy. There was a great chew on the bagel and there was a burst of flavor in every bite. Thoroughly enjoyed the greens and protein present and it provided a hearty breakfast. I thought the price was quite good for the amount received in the bagel. Perfect breakfast sandwich to start off my day. read more

The Bagel Shop - Presto Pesto - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

The bagels are fresh and the coffee is HOT. What more can you ask for? The only downside to this place is that the seating is very limited. 8.1/10. read more

Pretty good bagel spot on the UES! Prices are fair, and the lines on the weekends are long. I showed up around noon on Sunday and appreciate that they still had many types of bagels still available. There is some seating, but it's limited and most people waiting in line were doing take out. I got the BEC Everything Bagel: 3/5 Eggs were perfect and soft but the bacon was a bit overcooked. Bagel itself was okay though not terribly special. It was piping hot which is nice! Blueberry bagel with lemon honey cream cheese: 4/5 The blueberry bagel wasn't too special (the blueberries felt a bit artificial for me) but this cream cheese is the GOAT! It's lightly lemony and has some sweetness and a bit of crumbliness similar to feta. This was awesome and a great flavor. read more

See all

Willing to go on a whim to say that this is one of the best bagel shops you will find in NYC. The options are endless and all so fresh and delicious! There are fantastic sandwich options loaded with protein and veggies. The menu takes up an entire wall and will take probably 10 mins to read through thoroughly. The staff is wonderful, patient and helpful with recs. They have so many vegetarian options for sandwiches and lots of seating outdoors and a few tables indoors. The line moves efficiently despite it nearly always being busy. They also have soups and salads and sides, but I loved their egg sandwiches most and ate it over two sittings because it was dense and filling, definitely start there and get your favorite smear on your favorite bagel too! read more

The Bagel Shop - Egg, feta, cheese, mushrooms and kale - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Someone once said the best bagel in New York is the one that is most convenient for you to get and still tastes good. And this is the spot! This neighborhood joint always has a line out the door, and it's for good reason. They have a huge selection of bagels to choose from, along with salads and sandwiches. I always get a bec on everything bagel or a scallion cream cheese on everything bagel, and they have been consistently great! The staff is super nice and makes your wait not too painful. (Line m read more

See all

Whenever we walked past this place, it was always crowded so we knew that it was a popular spot in the UES. We ordered the brioche and bagel for breakfast with a side of Arnold Palmer. It honestly was a simple and delicious meal that I will never forget! Loved how everything came out pretty fast and the ambiance on a Sunday morning was fantastic. They have a couple of unique cream cheese flavors that I can't wait to try one day. Food: 5/5 Service: 4/5 Ambiance: 4/5 read more

See all

I haven't had a great lox bagel in the longest time, and boy this hit the spot. Hefty fillings, fresh ingredients, delicious bagel. They have an array of fun bagel flavors and inventive cream cheeses, and a lengthy but amazing menu with all the best bagels and sandwiches NYC has to offer. Service was quick and efficient; our bagels came out super quickly. A bacon egg and cheese was $5, which is unheard of! Takeout/pickup only. 5 stars! read more

The Bagel Shop - Upper East Sider Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My go to bagel shop on the UES! Can get busy on the weekends but line moves very fast as they are very efficient! Bagels are as good as any. The tofu cream cheese also on point and feels like you're not missing anything compared to dairy cream cheese. I've gotten their lox and white fish sandwiches which are both fire. read more

Been to NYC a number of times but never had a proper bagel. We decided to try this popular UES bagel shop near our hotel. There was a long line but it went quickly. The bagels are delicious! The menu is huge with something for everyone. Thinking about returning again tomorrow morning before we leave the city. Highly recommend! read more

The Bagel Shop - Avocadeo Bacon Egg Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all