Where do I start? The cheesecake is unbelievable and definitely made w top ingredients and love!

Good selection of cheesecake. Not too sweet. Very friendly at the counter and they will help you with your decision. Plenty of seating here at Center Street Market. Looking forward to trying the other flavors. read more

See all

I've been a "The Cheesecake Girl" fan for a few years now, but I haven't been in quite some time, so I was glad to stumble on it at the Hilliard station. I enjoy their seasonal flavors & I also got a pup donut for my dog - of course she also loved the treat. read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Mini cheesecakes - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Always have to stop here to grab a treat. Love the seasonal mini cheesecakes with all the unique flavors. On this visit we tried a peanut butter and jelly cookie which was SO good. Our furry girls also love the puppy donut. read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Peanut butter and jelly cookie, puppy donut and orange Creamsicle mini cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I kept hearing good things about this place so I decided to check it out while we were at the Crooked Can. I tried their cheesecake trifle jar, a mini original cheesecake, and a birthday cheesecake cookie sandwich. The red velvet cookie crunch cheesecake trifle jar was delicious. Layers of cake with cheesecake, can't go wrong with that. There were also mini chocolate chips in it which added a perfect crunch to it. The birthday cookie sandwich was good too but I was not a fan of their mini original cheesecake. I was expecting a soft and smooth cheesecake but it was on the harder side. read more

See all

Love their treats here in Hilliard and inside Budd Dairy! Have ordered mini-cheesecakes for a birthday -- great customer service. Finally leaving a review because I'm also a fan of their social media marketing. "The Cheesecake Girl" account on social is quite funny and creative. read more

Phenomenal cheesecake and even better service! They delivered a last-minute order for me and made my day! A wonderful treasure for Columbus Ohio! read more

Now this was amazing. While walking around the building and seeing the different stores available, we caught the sign to this place and we decided to get a closer look. The closer we got, the more our mouths started to water. Everything looked great and the customer service was great, too. We decided to get the buckeye and cookie dough brownie, I think it was called that, and they were delicious. The brownie one was my favorite and I wish I had 20 more to eat. read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

The Cheesecake Girl is seriously the best cheesecake because the creativity behind each flavor. The store front is located in a cool market where you can have the perfect date night. You can get drinks, food, and dessert without going outside! The staff is all so nice. They have a huge variety of offerings. You can't leave without trying the Sweet Heat Dip. It is the most amazing dip I've ever had in my life. WOW. My favorite Mini I tried was the Brownie Cookie Dough. Awesome job to the Cheesecake Girl! read more

See all

I tried the cheesecake girl for the first time when they had a pop-up at the Budd Dairy Food Hall. Those cheesecake bites were very cute and easy to eat~ I liked they offered a variety of flavors~ I also got the berry pound cake in the container. The flavor was good, but I wish it had more cake than the creme. read more

The Cheesecake Girl - two pastries and a cup of yogurt - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

It is so amazing getting the dozen mini cheesecake bites! I checked them out at Hilliard St Market and they had so many in their showcase! I choose the white chocolate raspberry and they were out of this world delicious! Just the right amount of sweet right after dinner. Definitely want to come back and try more flavors! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - White chocolate raspberry - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

We picked up a cinnamon roll cheesecake slice tonight and it was phenomenal! My husband's favorite dessert is cheesecake and he is PICKY about it! He was impressed! He didn't even want to share with me lol So good! Will definitely be back! read more

I had been wanting to try The Cheesecake Girl after seeing others post about her items on social media. My yearning only got more intense after I personally started following her page on Instagram. After about a month or so of following her, I put in a pre-order for her "Throwback Thursday" menu. I got the TBT menu items and have been back since. I like that her items are unique and different twists on cheesecake. I personally really liked the Dunaroos (cookie slices with cheesecake dipping!) and the Zebra cakes. I do wish the Dunakroos came in a smaller size though. I also got a slice of the Black Raspberry Chip cheesecake and enjoyed that as well. I've since also tried the chocolate cheesecake and the Brownie bottom cheesecake. The cheesecakes are good, but honestly not the best cheesecake I've ever had. They aren't as creamy or as good as either Cheesecake Factory or Sweet Cheese (a local food truck). Like I said, I like that she has unique offerings outside of regular slices of cheesecake. But for the calories, I'd probably pick another place. As others mentioned on here, I do find TCG to be a tad overpriced as well. Overall, I'd try it out if you're in the area but I wouldn't go out of my way anymore to come here (I live in the Short North, so this isn't really close to me...) read more

See all

I cannot say enough about how much I enjoy The Cheesecake Girl! I have always experienced excellent customer service in this and other locations. The quality of the cheesecake is incredible, and I love the flavor combinations. There is always something for everyone, including cute treats made for dogs. My go-to is the golden Oreo funfetti cheesecake. read more

See all

I have been seeing them on social media for a while and wanted to check it out. It was a little pricey but I think it's fair for being homemade. We ordered the chocolate birthday cheese cake and pumpkin mini. The slice was smaller than expected. They tasted okay, the crust was really hard. Everything looks really good though, will have to come back and try something else next time! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Pumpkin spice cheesecake and birthday chocolate cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Incredible! What a treat to pair delicious cinnamon cheesecake with Crooked Can Octoberfest beer. My boyfriend ordered the chocolate and although he said it was good he enjoyed my cheesecake slice more. This place is constantly good and worth the splurge! read more

See all

Love Love Love The Cheesecake Girl! I finally made it to the Hilliard location to pick up dessert for Thanksgiving. Took my Mom with me and we left with way more than my preorder! They have a huge menu with something for everyone, even your fur babies! I also picked up some of the collaboration with The Buckeye Lady....cheesecake stuffed Buckeyes! Center Street Market is a cool location, lots of parking, plus several restaurants and a brewery to checkout! I will definitely me back and you need to check it out too! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - a display of cheesecakes - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

How freaking delicious! The buckeye was the perfect bite. Smooth peanut buttery flavor. That's all. Go now! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Buckeye Mini - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I have not been disappointed by anything. Cheesecake is one of my favorite things! My absolute favorite is the lemon curd mini cheesecake. I tried the blueberry doughnut cheesecake and it was delicious as well. It is very fairly priced . One piece of regular cheesecake is really enough for two people to share! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Blueberry doughnut cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

This place is addicting and sooo delicious! I love having cheesecake local to Hilliard! Stop in and grab a treat or two! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Yummmm - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I ordered the cheesecake girl to be delivered to my husband as a surprise for him. He loved it! Normally he shares things with coworkers but don't me this was too good to share! I love the rotating menu that they have. I do wish they would offer other items to be delivered on ubereats so I could send him more of a variety next time with more minis so if he wanted to share some he could! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Ubereats deal - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Yummy! I have only had the gluten free cheesecake, but if you can get that to taste really good I can only imagine how tasty the regular cheesecake flavors must be. I ate it up before I could think to take a picture. Another great addition to the Center St market. read more

Finally tried The Cheesecake Girl the other day at the Dublin Market and now I can't wait to get my hands on some more! I opted to try the new item, the Cheesecake dunkaroos. They were delicious and brought back childhood memories. The cheesecake girl is always rotating menu items which brings constant interest in what flavors/products will be offered. I have also recently visited the center street market location and tried a slice of cheesecake for the first time, amazing! I seriously recommend everything she has to offer! read more

See all

LOVE The Cheesecake Girl. This one is inside of Crooked Can! Different options everytime, limited selection though so make sure you stop by earlier rather than later if you want a bigger selection of choices. The fruit pizza cheesecake and the black raspberry chip cheesecake are my favs!!! read more

You cannot go wrong with any dessert from this place. I am not even a huge fan of cheesecake, but this is THE BEST cheesecake ever. Not overly sweet with the perfect amount of cheesiness. The minis are a great way to try out lots of flavors. They have cookie sandwiches with cheesecake filling!! The big slice of cheesecake with sprinkles and golden Oreos doesn't even stand a chance in my house. Cookie butter cups are the perfect little treat! read more

Incredible. I've been eating Cheescake girl since before she had the shop. You can find her slices in local coffee shops and some stores. Always fresh and very creative. Some might say its similar to cheesecake factory but these are all homemade and this is a small business. So many options to choose from, my favorite is probably raspberry lemon or classic strawberry. The miniature are delightful and fun. The funfetti sandwiches are to die for. She even had dips! Yes, cheesecake dips, for fruit, pretzels, or whatever you desire. Highly recommend checking it out for the best cheesecake in town! read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Literally the only place in town we go for desserts. Got the cookie butter slice over the weekend, and it was the bomb!! read more

If you want to try Columbus' best dessert spot, look no further. When I'm craving something sweet, I always head to The Cheesecake Girl - with spots in Hilliard, Dublin, and downtown at Budd Dairy, I'm lucky that TCG delicious cheesecake is never hard to find! All the classic flavors you love, and seasonal and rotating flavors that are always so fun! Plus they have Gluten Free options, and delicious dips or party packs to take to your next event. I'm always so impressed by the creativity and amazing quality - you will never go to The Cheesecake Factory AGAIN!!! read more

Amazing local-owned small business! The cheesecakes are to die for and the location is perfect. Sam keeps her flavors seasonal and fun while being delicious. The staff is always friendly and safe, too! Highly recommend looking at the Instagram for daily flavors and getting a funfetti cookie sandwich no matter what!!! (Also, if pistachio cannoli comes back on the menu ... run don't walk!) read more

The Cheesecake Girl - Outdoor seating - Bakeries Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

We are usual customers and we always buy oatmeal cream cookies at your Dublin Store. we have purchased quite a few of these since your store opening in Dublin. We really enjoy these until today 10/28/22 when to our surprise we noticed hardly any cream at all in the cookies and along with that the cookies were dry tasting. We are really disappointed with the cookies and have never had a problem before. I never thought I would have to look in the box to see what we purchased but I guess we will have to. Hopefully next time they will be back to what they use to be like, thanks.....Dan read more

Cheesecake is okay. I got there mid afternoon and the cheesecake tasted a little old. I prefer the flavor in the cheesecake rather than from the toppings. read more

So glad I stumbled upon this little slice of heaven! My husband is a huge cheesecake fan and it's a birthday tradition! I was a little last minute this year and being new to the area I didn't know of anywhere that had good cheesecake. One google search later and I found the cheesecake girl. I live in Hilliard so I had to check it out. I couldn't get a whole cheesecake bc it was the day of (they have order ahead option for whole cakes) but they have so many options sold by the slice! This actually turned out amazing bc I got to try about 5 different flavors out of the 7 or 8 they were offering that day. All I can say is this place is absolutely amazing!!! My husband said it was some of the best cheesecake he's ever had, and I agree! Can't wait to enjoy this spot for years to come! read more

I was super excited to try after following on Instagram. I got 5 mini flavors and 2 slices (blueberry donut and butterfinger). Overall, the cheesecake was ok but kind of disappointing- it was dry (especially the blueberry donut), was not a fan of the crust and after tasting it seemed over priced. read more

I have a crazy sweet tooth, and this place has become my go-to for cheesecakes. I love that different flavors come out almost on a monthly basis, or really whenever I go there. You will never get bored, and you'll get to try something new each time. I also come here if I need to bring dessert for get-togethers. Can't wait to go there soon! read more

First time ever trying! Ordered for Valentine's Day! We couldn't wait to enjoy them tomorrow so we dove in today! I got my husband the x-rated cheesecakes and an assortment for us to share. They are DELICIOUS!!! I highly recommend trying and support this local business! read more

My bf isn't a cake fella so ALL the cheesecake for him to celebrate his birthday! Everything was divine, we had quite the assortment. Excited to come back for more creations and flavas! read more

Mm, a little disappointing for the price. I got a slice of the OG cheesecake slice with a few mini cheesecakes. Everything tasted.. stale? plastic-like? Compared to my fave cheesecake spot (Cheesecake Factory), this wasn't worth the price. I did also go around 5pm on a weekday, so perhaps I just happened to purchase the dregs of the day. read more

I got a chance to try The Cheesecake Girls's desserts at Seventh Son Brewing. $8 for four mini cheesecake bites: Apple cinnamon, coffee cake concoction, Boston cream pie, and the last was a creme brûlée flavor. I was rather bummed: As the name implies CHEESECAKE Girl, two of the four were a cupcake, with a thin layer of cheesecake on top (the Boston cream pie and coffee cake). The cake part was quite dense, and a bit on the dry side. If I had a glass of milk to accompany, it would have been a great help. Truthfully, the four samples tasted, well, a lot alike to me. I'm not sure I'd go out of the way for dessert from this independent business. read more

The blueberry cobbler cheesecake is one of the best things I've ever eaten in my life 100%

I wanted to get some mini assorted cheesecakes for a birthday recently so I called in to ask about the process since you can't order the assorted dozen online and was told to just come in and pick them at any time. The problem I have is, online it shows the price as $26 for a dozen but when I got there and picked them out, it was double that. I asked why and was told that it's more when you order in person and for the assorted options. Which is understandable but is not listed anywhere on the website and was not communicated with me during the call. The cheesecakes were really good but the whole experience was very disappointing and there's a lack of communication about accurate pricing. read more