Saw on tik tok at least 8 months ago and have been waiting to try, SOOOOOOOO GLAD I DID.... I went basic with my first purchase but not disappointed what so ever!!! I got the chicken pot pie and it is to die for!!! I haven't even tried my Mac and cheese pie but I imagine it will be amazing. If you are debating on wether or not to go here... just say yes!!! read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - crispy yummy chicken pot pie - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I consider myself an expert on Coconut Cream Pie....not making them - but tasting them. THis place had one as a seasonal item on their rotating menu. If I were them I'd give it a permanent spot. Insanely delicious. They put a thin layer of white choclate to coat the interior crust. Im guessing that was so the cream filling wouldnt soak into it....or maybe just to add flavor...or maybe both. It was a big hit with everyone. Not cheap but worth it. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Cashew coconut cream - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I'm officially obsessed with this place. I've been wanting to try them out for forever, but always ended up missing them. I know they appear at the Carmel Farmer's Market weekly in the summer. But when I saw their Pi Day deal meant I could try all of their flavors, I knew it was time. And BOY am I mad I didn't come in sooner!! This is far and away the best pie I have eaten in my life. Their flavors are unique and sooo delicious!!! My favorite might be the apple, which is good because it's an always there flavor! It's next level. The homemade crust is just the cherry on top. I got a frozen savory pie to try later, and I'm looking forward to it! My preorder process was easy and though the space inside and parking lot are both small, the service was excellent! read more

See all

My friend swears by Pots & Pans Pie Company. She comes early to their stand at the Zionsville Farmers Market every week to buy a pie. So I decided to check them out as well. They offer a number of fresh baked fruit pies made with local ingredients. In addition, they have several savory options. I tried the apple cream cheese galette. The crust is buttery, flakey and melts in your mouth. The apples were fresh and deliciously tart. The cream cheese filling was subtle. I loved the galette. The pies disappear quickly, so you have to get there early for the best selection. Full size pies run $36-$40 dollars and are beautiful. The clerk is friendly and not pushy. They take cards or cash. I'll be a regular. The stand at the Farmers Market is super convenient for me. read more

See all

I have ordered savory pot pies and dessert pies from here and they are so good! It's a really easy process to order online and choose date you prefer to pick them up. The occasions they offer quiches are so good as well. The crusts are buttery and delicious. I have tried almost all the pot pies and would buy them all again. Customer service is quick and efficient. Try this place if you like all things pies - you won't regret it! read more

Just an update to say it's been such a joy to watch this burliness grow. From veggie-friendly pot pies like broccoli and cheddar to shipping their products on GoldBelly, Pots & Pans has become a community staple. I popped by this week to pick up their Valentines Day mini pie four pack and cherry heart hand pies. Their fridges are stocked with mini and full size take and bake pies as well as their popular chocolate shortbread cookie dough to bake at home. Perfect for housewarming gifts, new parents, etc. read more

See all

This is a place I visit frequently. The first here are so good and made from scratch. I have tried the chicken, the beef and mushroom, thanksgiving dinner as well as some of the sweet pies. They have some other unique flavors such as mac and cheese and biscuits and gravy that sound delicious. More recently I have been back 3 times this season for a slice of the sweet potato pie. It is so delicious and its hard to find sweet potato pie around the city (they also have pumpkin). I definitely love coming here during the colder months for my pot pie fix bc it's such a great comfort meal. If you love pie then I highly recommend. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love it always wanted to come her and FINALLY did we got our DESERT!!! we got Carmel Pumpkin Pie which we were told LIMITED time and it was deliii & the vibe felt good in there & also friendly customer service. read more

See all

This was my first time trying *THE* Pots & Pans Pie Co, and it definitely lived up to my expectations. I tried 2 different hand pies - singara and spicy sausage & tomato. I also decided to pick up their seasonal caramel apple pecan cookie for a sweet treat. The singara hand pie was cozily spiced for fall and included potatoes, cashews, and raisins. Think of it as a giant samosa with an extra flaky pie crust. The spicy sausage & tomato hand pie reminded me of a classic cream-based tomato pasta dish that everyone knows and loves. I tasted a bit of wine in the cream sauce, which definitely elevated the hand pie. And the caramel apple pecan cookie....wow! I accidentally microwaved it for a little too long so the caramel filling melted, but it was still so rich and the cookie base was super fresh. I would definitely like a re-do of the cookie since I microwaved it too long. I am definitely looking forward to their upcoming seasonal savory and sweet pies for fall/winter. Such a great company with the tastiest pies around! read more

Love love love Pots & Pans! I have been ordering pies from them over the past year for holidays, birthdays, and get togethers. Every pie I get is delicious and perfectly baked. Today I picked up my FrankenPie order and grabbed some personal chicken pot pies to heat up for dinner for husband and I, so they are a perfect spot to grab a meal and dessert. 2025 FrankenPie featured Apple Crumble, Blackbottom Frangipane, Butterscotch, Cashew Coconut Cream, Pineapple Passionfruit, and Sugar Creme Brûlée slices. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If anyone said to me that I would love a sugar cream pie, I would never have expected that. I usually think pies are too unhealthy or what not but had to give this a try on a trip. We really picked the best place to get this by because it was phenomenal! Them a really large variety of pie options. They were available but we were there for that famous to the green pie so had to take that one. Fire was served cold but that was no issue at all. It was perfectly sweet and not too sugary sweet (I didn't usually go for sugary sweet stuff). Creamy and smooth and with a perfectly flaky crust and just overall delicious. It had a creme brulee kind of a topping on top which made it even better. Husband that I open this as soon as we got into the car. Finished it in a matter of minutes and then wanted more. That's how good it was! read more

See all

pretty good Overpriced as f!!! My God if I'm gonna pay that kind of money for a pie, they better be nice to me when I'm paying for it and they were not! read more

Love love love Really good pies. Chicken pot pie is delicious! I recommend to everyone I can. Friendly. Nice leople. read more

Pots and Pans Pie Co. is an excellent pie place in Broad Ripple that has high quality pies for sale. They come in all varieties, some dessert pies and pot pies, and they sell unique flavors such as Chicken Marsala or Chickpea. I picked up a slice of their Halloween themed pie Spooky Icebox for dessert, and it was amazing. It was a chocolate peanut butter pie and the taste was impressive and impeccable. I have had the chickpea pot pie and it tasted different, but was very good. The ambiance is nothing special, just a nice pie shop that smells like fresh pastries when you walk into it. The service is wonderful from the staff and they are always willing to help you in anyway. Pots and Pans Pie Co. is an excellent pie shop in Broad Ripple and everyone should come check them out to try one of their pot pies because it is worth the value and price you pay for a pie. They are always creative in their flavors, and you leave with a smile on your face. Love Pots and Pans Pie Co. and will continue to stop by them for a slice of pie. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Spooky Icebox - Chocolate Peanut butter pie. - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pretty F-ing good pies. I especially enjoy their savory hand pies and savory pot pies, but basically anything you get is excellent. My only gripe is they feel pretty "salty" (in the metaphorical price-related way - the literal amount of salt in the pies is just right), but when you eat one you can see the ingredients are high-quality and wholesome. Take-out only, no real space to sit and enjoy your pie on the scene. read more

Stopped into Pots & Pans Pie Company with my partner and picked up the Apple Pie and the Crème Brûlée Pie to go. Both were fantastic--great flavor, perfect texture, and clearly made with care. It's a small, cozy establishment with a friendly vibe, and definitely the kind of place you want to support. We'll happily be back for more. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Apple Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Wanted to love this place. Got a Mac and cheese PIE and it was just Mac and cheese. Didn't think I would hear that sweet sound while digging into it. My girlfriend also was super stoked that I got her the broccoli cheddar one and just kidding it was ALSO just Mac and cheese. Can we exchange it after 8 months? I still have it. Love laughing love. PS: plz put something else in the Mac and cheese before my wife gets mad. PSS: don't tell my girlfriend about my wife. read more

Huge recommend. Hand pies are awesome. Filling to crust ratio is perfect. Service is friendly. Excellent for grab and go. Take and bake savory pies are delicious. It's a small place with a small parking lot but inside is clean and cute and they are well stocked for all your needs. read more

A spot I wish I had here in SoCal and also wish I had an oven to use while I was traveling in Indiana so I could have enjoyed their pies. Instead, I had to settle for pastries that were readily available, but still, those were very well made with crusts winning me over. The pies are also really well made. I had the staple which was like a crème brûlée? I forget what it was called, but I never had a pie like that before and I really wanted another. Very sweet workers & service. read more

I've had the opportunity to try a few pies now and also have made their shortbread chocolate chip cookies from the pre-made dough they sell. I've taken quite a bit of credit, honestly, for "making" those cookies. What an embarassment it will be when my friends stumble upon the dough themselves...but it's worth it for the brief taste of success. Those cookies get rave reivews. Pie-wise, the apple pie is a winner every time I get it, and gift it. You can't go wrong with it. Their ice box pies are the first of those kind I've ever had -- so, I don't know if they are better than "other" ice box pies, but I bet they are. All their pies are seasonal, naturally, and I've had the lemon shake-up flavor, and the strawberry-pistachio flavor. The strawberry was my fave. You may notice they also have *savory* pies! People rave about the tikka masala one; I, however, went for the Thai Curry Chicken -- it was super spice to me; and had very little chicken, almost none; but the flavors were *incredible*! read more

I arrived around 1pm on a Sunday. All pies were sold out besides sugar creme and icebox turtle. I now know I need to arrive earlier for ample selection. The french onion handpie was out of this world delicious. I also got two individual pot pies (broccoli cheddar & bbq mac n cheese). These took about an hour to cook. The crust was phenomenal. I thought the pieces of broccoli and potatoes in my pie were too large. If these pies were ready to eat rather than frozen, I woule get it again, however, not worth it in my opinion to take home and cook. I will be trying some of the dessert pies next time and definitely getting more french onion handpies. read more

OMG! When we were moving to Indy, this spot came across my Instagram so I knew we had to try it. My husband has never been crazy about apple pie, and then he had Pots & Pans....now he demands it for every single holiday or get together. Check their instagram for the menu, and order in advance! I like to snag a single slice of one of their seasonal flavors when I got to pickup my order. read more

This was delicious! I had it at the Carmel farmers market. It is fresh and the service was great! read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Peach cream cheese galette - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The pie crust was definitely the best. I loved the sugar crystallized on top of cream pie. My husband said the apples were mildly crunchy on the pie and he didn't mind it that way. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Apple Crumb Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I saw a TikTok featuring Pots & Pans, and I figured they would make a perfect stop for our return drive from Cincinnati to Northwest Indiana. Sadly, they didn't have the same pie I'd seen in the video, but we found a few other things on the menu we were interested in trying. The staff were helpful. The space is small, so this is definitely just a carry-out stop. read more

See all

Pots & Pans is always my go to for a great pie in Indianapolis. I recently tried their Franken Pie - a limited edition special for Pi Day! It was a tasty combination of individual slices of their monthly flavors: Pineapple Passionfruit, Sugar Crème Brûlée, Cashew Coconut Cream, Butterscotch, Apple Crumble, and Blackbottom Frangipane. Trying a variety of flavors I normally wouldn't get to try, I was in awe of the high quality of each. The standout for me was the Pineapple Passionfruit, but each slice had unique qualities and left me wanting more. The pre-ordering online process is very simple or you can buy in store day of from the available flavors. Pro tip, they also have take and bake savory pie options and their Green Chile Pork Pie is incredible. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Franken Pie - Pi Day Special - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great Pies! Love the variety, can't wait to see the summer offerings they have available! read more

I've picked up Thanksgiving pies from this spot two years in a row now, and it's become one of my favorite holiday traditions. Their Thanksgiving pie is such a creative concept, and the execution is just as impressive--beautifully made, delicious, and something you truly can't find anywhere else in the city. The staff is always efficient and helpful, even during the busy holiday rush. The storefront is on the smaller side and parking can be limited, but honestly, it's worth navigating because the quality is consistently that good. I also grabbed one of their chocolate chip shortbread cookies this year, and it might be the best cookie I've had. Freshly baked, with a unique flavor and texture combo you won't get anywhere else. So grateful to have a place like this in our city--unique, thoughtful, and absolutely delicious. Perfect for holidays or anytime you want something special read more

This place makes damn good pie!!! So glad we decided to stop by here when we were in Indy. We got sugar creme brûlée and frangipane black bottom pie slices and an awesome D&D inspired shirt with a dragon and the sugar creme brûlée pie on it. The hubs and I started with the sugar creme brûlée pie, and omg it was amazing! The vanilla custard was dense, yet creamy. The burnt sugar on top was like a chefs kiss. The frangipane black bottom pie was amazing, too. The almond frangipane filling with a thin layer of chocolate was also dense and incredibly flavorful. Their crust is delicious and flaky, but not crumbly...it holds up really well. Usually pie crust is nothing worth talking about, but all I can say is, eat the crust. All of it. This is one of those places we'll have to go to every time we're in Indy! read more

Pies Pies Pies Every month they offer a new Pie of the Month. They offer whole and by the slice. We've tried; keylime, apple, chocolate, mixed berry, refrigerator pie, banana cream They are a small local owned company that supports everyone. Please stop in and give them some love. read more

What an adorable little pie shop in south Broad Ripple! It took me a little while to get up there, but my high expectations were met! Trust the reviews- this place has excellent pies. I got a slice of key lime pie to go and now wish I'd just picked up the whole pie. It was perfectly tart, creamy and that whipped topping so gorgeous. I can see why this is one of their most popular flavors. My husband had a piece of the chocolate pie and said it was really good too. He thought the crust to pie ratio was perfect and really liked the chocolate crumble crust instead of a traditional pie crust. Super friendly staff and I was in and out in no time. Can't wait to go back and try something new and maybe pick up a savory pie too. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Key lime pie - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We got the frozen chicken pot pie to take and bake at home. The pie was great. The filling was very flavorful and delicious. The pie crust was flaky and buttery and there was a great filling to crust ratio. We got the small pie because it said it serves 1-2 and the other size serves 4-6. The smaller size is more of a personal sized pie, definitely not enough for a couple to share. I am a small person and don't eat a lot but this was not a sharable size. Can't wait to try other pies they have in the future but next time we will definitely be getting the larger size. read more

Pots & Pans Pie Co. - Small chicken pot pie. (My small hand for size comparison) - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best chicken (and biggest) that I've ever had. The owners are so friendly and love dogs. Joe read more

Came here in search of sugar pie because we were traveling and told that the must haves in Indy were pork tenderloin sandwiches and sugar pie. Pork tenderloins were everywhere we went! The sugar pies not so much!? The sugar pie was OK. My description is a creme Brule cheesecake. Not a ton of flavor yet super sweet. Definitely glad I found it to try and would recommend! Our favorite pie was the lemon cream. Sweet cream topping, tart lemon filling, really good Graham cracker crust! Out favorite ITEM was the oatmeal cream pie! Soft, sweet and delicious! If I were local I'd definitely give the pot pies a try! They sounded amazing!!! read more

See all

Best Pies I've had in Indy so far, I haven't tried the take home and bakes but the monthly rotation is always fire. The store itself is cute and in line with broad ripple vibes read more

i have absolutely thought about them several times since my initial visit. i went randomly for Pi Day and then again some days later. 10/10 decision. They've made a few changes one being no more seating inside, which doesn't bother me any. I'm super picky but I took a risk with flavors and i'm so glad. The most important pie was the butterscotch. it's described as a sweet & salty chess pie featuring miso along with brown sugar and molasses. i'm sad to say it'll be leaving the menu at the end of this month. IYRT(in april)YTL . The apple crumble is not pictured but it was my 2nd fave, better warmed up. You can order whole pies online or place a phone order for slices and same day pickups. slices are $6-8 whole pies are ~$34 My visits were simple enough. I was greeted and asked what I wanted. They were out of apple galettes both times which makes me wonder why they don't make more, they seem popular lol. There's parking right in front, this is a quick visit so I can't imagine that being a huge issue. read more

See all

Honestly, one of the best specialty food places we have in Indianapolis. Homemade pies and pot pies are hard to find and Pots & Pans does it the best with sweet and savory options that change every month. We bring a pie to every single family function we have and always enjoy the flavors we get. Their chicken pot pie is a classic and our favorite for a reason. Their store is a tiny little walk up with take & bake pies available in the freezer and fresh/slices available in a glass case. Only about 2 to 3 people can be inside the store at one time but they're very quick so the wait is never very long. read more

See all

I had been wanting to try Pots & Pans for a while but I'm not usually in the SoBro area so I've never been. But I kept seeing their February menu on Instagram and HAD to try the banana cream before it leaves for the next seasonal flavors. I ended up getting a slice of banana cream and a slice of lemon and wow they were both amazing! The lemon was so bright and flavorful, the graham crust was buttery, and the whipped cream on top was just perfect--I'm going to be watching for when this flavor comes back for sure. The shop had plenty of parking available, the fridge was well stocked, and they have great hours, which I didn't realize before. It's nice to have a place open for dessert later in the evening (til 9 most nights). The service was friendly and helpful. There are SO many other items on the menu I want to try, like the savory pot pies and the shortbread cookie dough. Can't wait to come back! read more

I'm not a sweet pie person so it seems odd for me to review a pie shop. That being said I really enjoyed the chocolate chip shortbread cookies! They were just the right size and thickness. The number of chips was appropriate for the size ratio. I noticed that they had dough available for purchase, which might be my next step. And the person that I bought the apple crisp pie for really enjoyed it! read more

So good! This place has become a holiday tradition for us... It's just not the same without a Pots & Pan pie. Or two. Or three! Amazing people and an incredible dessert experience! We have taken their pies to events and gatherings, only to have the uninitiated tell us within days, that they had traveled to Indy just to get their own pies! They are the best! read more