Got a quart of New England clam chowder- to go. It smelled so goooood!!! Could not wait to get back home so opened the container right there in the car -creamy,smooth, plenty of clams, just the right amount of potatoes- delish!!! I wanted to keep eating the chowder and probably could have! Best clam chowder I've had in a long time! read more

Amazing fresh seafood! Try the Golden Fried Combo Platter! Will stop by again when around :)))

My husband and I ordered respectively the fish taco and the fried clam strips platters. We sat outside and waited for the food to come. We waited for a while (a lot of take outs) but it is worth waiting. Very good food, good portions and great experience. Will come back! read more

Went here for the first time today and had an amazing experience. Staff is so friendly and helpful. Food was out fast and was so fresh! You can tell everything is made right then and there. Will definitely come again! (10/10 would recommend the clam strips) read more

I would say that this is as good as it gets for a clam shack, visited here a few times this past summer and was never disappointed. Service is friendly, fast, and let me tell you IT CAN GET BUSY IN HERE!!! Be patient if it does, the food is worth it. read more

We came here for the first time today, and I was between the lobster roll or the fish tacos. I ended up with the fish tacos which are served in flour tortillas, with blackened cod. There's a great sauce, fresh veggies, and overall a delicious taco. My father got fish and chips, which came with a really crispy outershell. The seafood is really fresh and the service is good. Will definitely come back read more

Whole belly clams were small and did not compare well to those of well-known seafood restaurant just across the street. Clam chowder a slight improvement but still not great. Good cole slaw and tartar sauce. Dirty garbage can to dispose of your used paper goods right near main counter was a big turn-off, as was scenic view of gas station right next door. read more

Hopefully, they read this review. Went there twice. My husband and I both felt sick. Is it the oil or the prepackaged cold slaw and tarter sauce? I see that some fried food orders were under cooked, that could be the problem. My husband thinks the oil was not Hot enough. Whatever it is, fix it. We'll be monitoring the reviews and we'll try one more time when you open in the spring. Thank you in advance. Also, the garbage can inside and the dumpster outside smell really bad. read more

Not impressed- there was no flavor here at all and no large pieces at all. For $18 I expected much better than this and served with Cole slaw which tasted funny and 2 pickle chips- weird choice. Bag of chips should be added for this price- not worth the money. read more

We have passed by this restaurant a few times, always lots of cars in the parking lot, so we decided to try it - glad we did! I had the fish tacos and my husband had the fish and chips - everything delicious! Food is tasty and prices are reasonable. We will definitely return when we are in the area! read more

Excellent food, Best lobster roll, far superior to any other place I have had one, Fried Shrimp also excellent..we love Lenny and Joe's but the quality and taste at the Clam Castle was superior. The only negatives were 20 minute wait in line to order and then another 40 minutes wait until we got our food. We got there at 6:20 p.m. on a Sat evening and the line was out the door, a lot of people stopping on the way home from the beach. Yes, we definitely will go back but will plan it on a less busy times. The quality and taste is certainly worth going back for ... read more

What a little shorline gem! The food was fantastic ! I had the soft-shell crab roll and my girlfriend had the whole clam roll. The soft-shell crab was absolutely perfecty battered and fried. The meat was sweat, and soft on the inside and golden brown crispy perfection on the outside. My girlfriends Whole clam roll was lovely, too. Naturally I had to sample it. Each came with a generous portion of homemade coleslaw and tartar sauce. HEAVEN! The only reason this wasn't a five star was we would have loved to sit outside and enjoy, but there wasn't anything out of the sun. Don't pass by this little clam shack-castle! We just looked at pictures and regret not ordering the onion rings, they looked rediculously good! Service was polite and prompt. laid back road-side beach locale. Can't go wrong! FOOD gets a ***** (five star) atmosphere is the only thing holding this place back one star. Location was great! Not even a ten minute bicycle ride from hammonaset beach!!! I heart the clam castle! read more

Had to try this place since it reopened and was pleasantly surprised, Best whole belly clams any where!!!! Service was fast and courtious ,the remodel and new air conditioning made the dining very comfortable on a hot muggy day. read more

Every time my family and I go to the shore we go to Lenny and Joe's. We decided to try Clam Castle for something different this time. The choices were similar, but slightly less expensive. The food was amazing! My wife and I split the fisherman platter with fish, shrimp, scallops, and we upgraded to whole belly clams. Portions were bigger, and the food tastier in every way. Even the fries were much better. We loved it and let the staff know. The only weakness vs other places was the lobster bisque, which was a little anemic in terms of lobster content. My kids had grilled cheese and fried shrimp, and they enjoyed it as well. We will definitely be back and would highly recommend it. In fact, I think this is my first Yelp review, and a well-deserved one. read more

I wanted to find a decent place to eat at during our impromptu trip to Madison, CT area and I am glad Yelp and other online reviews helped me find this place. Similar to what was mentioned in a previous comment, this fits the characteristics of a food joint showcased in Food Network's Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives. Limited, yet satisfactory menu for casual dining. My family tried fish and chips, fried jumbo shrimp basket, blackened fish taco and grilled chicken roll. All items were delicious. There is ample outdoor seating along with indoor. Definitely worth the try if you are in the area! read more

My family and I have never had a bad meal here since Donahue's took over. Their clam strips are the best I've ever had, very fresh. When my parents come from out of state this is always our first stop on the way home from the airport. Staff is always very polite and love the laid back atmosphere. read more

I thought it was a few dollars expensive for what it was, but I guess maybe seafood prices have risen or something. Food was good, interior was kind of meh. I'd eat here again if I was brought here but I might otherwise test out the other seafood places nearby first to compare. read more

Food was incredible! Cooked to order and full of flavor. We had both types of chowder and the bisque, which was full of lobster chunks. Fish tacos were fresh and had amazing blackened seasoning. Fried clams weren't greasy...kids loved them! Staff was friendly and place was clean. We will definitely be back. read more

I was here on July 3rd 2016. The place was mobbed with hungry holiday beach crowd. It took a solid hour for me to get my lobster roll (ct style) and I have to say it was so good I forgot about the wait. I'm not in this area often but I will make an effort to visit this place again! read more

Beware the Scallop Taco. Stopped by on the way to the beach, girlfriend had the lobster roll, which was great, and I got the scallop taco. It was two tacos, each with a Scallop and a half on each taco. Barely any seafood and mostly some veggies. For the $15 plate, it's not worth it. A bit pricey, but other than that, I've heard good things about this place. read more

Not what I expected. It's obvious that the people come for the food, not the ambience or decor: port-o-potties! Really? I ordered the blackened fish tacos, sweet potato fries, cup of lobster bisque, their famous clam strips and an Arnold Palmer. (1) we were never told that the tea and lemonade was unsweetened, especially before we ordered I said, "this is our first time here" and the cashier welcomed us; (2) DO NOT ORDER THE LOBSTER BISQUE! (3) the blackened fish taco were good, the coleslaw needs some work though, no flavor; (4) the sweet potato fries were delicious; and lastly (5) their famous clam strips were good, but I honestly had better. I gave them 3 stars because the place has potential, my friend liked his meal. The place was packed when we arrived and only drew in more people as we ate, so they get the business! My suggestion: update the building and interior, put in real bathrooms, make a second floor deck to stretch over the parking lot, keep the menu/recipes, but work on that lobster bisque and coleslaw and the Clam Castle would be set. The real question is, would I go back? Yes, I would. read more

These guys have beaten out Lenny & Joe's. Yes, true. L&J is a machine, and it's good and reliable, but the Clam Castle is an unassuming delight. Donahue's bought them, I think, three years ago, when it was pretty "divey." Back then, it was mostly known for cute girls and mediocre food. But now it's known for NICE employees, and the quality of the food is now so good we go there instead of Lenny & Joe's and that is a huge change in tradition. The thing that finally got us to change our minds and break out of that tradition (we live close by) was the summer after Donahue's took over, when our daughter worked there at the counter. She got us to try it in the first place. I LOVE the special fries, the chowder and fish and chips. But the thing I really liked the most was how happy she was there. She always felt that it was a great team environment. Growing up, there were so many places I worked while in my "waitron" phase that were dysfunctional, I really loved that she would come home from work elated at a great shift. Now she's off to finish college and move on, but whenever she's home or we're in the mood for fresh fish, we order food to go from the Castle, and it's usually her idea. How many places are there where you worked in a kitchen and ever wanted to eat there again? Well done! NOW: remember, tip the team. It's hot back there, they're doing great work, so share a little even if it's not table service! ;) read more

Ignore Lenny and Joe's across the highway and eat here. Large portions, friendly staff ( I too had an inner chortle moment over the Georgia countergirl's accent last summer), perfect breading and the best RI broth this side of..........RI. Sure, I've tried other lobster rolls from here to Niantic but this place is the overall bomb for my tastebuds. I'll be back. Again and again and again. read more

I went to the clam castle based on the reviews I saw here and on other sites. I ordered the whole clams and ended up throwing most of them out. They were overcooked and extremely oily--several paper napkins still left the taste of oil in my mouth. My husband ordered the scallops which were better cooked but not that tasty. The fries were mealy and undercooked and the coleslaw was old. Won't be going back there! read more

We've lived in the area for 8 years and drive past Clam Castle on a regular basis, but we only stopped in recently. With so many higher-end spots on the shoreline, it's easy to keep driving past the Clam Castle with it's humble appearance. Like others have said, it's worth the visit. Yes, it looks like a dive, but the interior is clean and the staff is very friendly. Our order arrived quickly. The portions are really generous. We got the Fisherman's Platter to share between three people and couldn't finish it. Everything from the fish to the onion rings was really tasty. We'll definitely stop in again sometime this summer, now that we know what we've been missing! read more

Golden fried shrimp roll, fries, cole slaw and lemonade. Tasty lunch and a great atmosphere. Close to the beach too!

Been there several times over the years. It was a lot better years ago better the new owners took over. The prices are higher and the place doesn't seem to have that old time feel to it. The menu is larger with more selections. The fish tacos are alright but you have to eat fast before all the liquids breakdown the taco shells into a mess. Not something to eat in a car. read more

Have eaten here a couple of times since new owners.. Best Fries and Clam Fritters.. Seafoods fresh and cooked the just right.. Only thing I miss is the Fish Chower. Hope they don't close for the winter! read more

Best seafood on the shoreline! Very fresh food, clean eating area, friendly staff, dog friendly (outdoor only), would highly recommend!

This was my first time here. I am a huge seafood person. I had their fried whole belly clams. They were absolutely fantastic! Best I have had in a long time. Perfectly cooked, fresh and sweet Service was quick and staff are great! A must stop for anyone passing by. A nice place to eat after a visit to the beach. read more

Our group had the fried combo platter, which included clam strips, scallops, shrimp, and fish. We also had the lobster bisque, pulled pork, and a couple of burgers. Everything, even the burgers, was amazing. The fried scallops were sea scallops, big and juicy and crispy on the outside. The lobster bisque was the best I've ever had. Buttery with large chunks of lobster. The staff was friendly enough, didn't notice they were rude at all. read more

We love coming here for seafood. Much calmer than Lenny's and Joe's across the street and better food.

Some of the best fried clams EVER. Bellies the size of Pro V 1's. That's a golf ball folks. Light batter, crisp, cooked to perfection. Not a grain of sand to be found. Only minutes off the highway. Worth the drive from ANYWHERE! read more

When you go to a restaurant and the line is to the door that is a great sign.wicked good food and fast.

We visited The Clam Castle on our way from the beach and were very pleased by the ambience, the quality of food, and service. The Clam Castle has a space inside and outside. We were inside: it was neat, clean, air conditioned and had nice music playing in the background. The service was prompt and courteous. Everybody who works at there was super helpful and friendly, and we even got to chat with the owner who inquired how we were enjoying our meal. We ordered taco platters (fish and shrimp) and lobster bisque. The platters were delicious and came with crispy fries (there are different options for sides). The restaurant has a clean little bathroom in the back (entrance from the outside). We loved the place and will definitely visit it again when we are in the area! read more

Still the same Dump as 6years ago bought well over $100.00 of food to feed the family junk had whole clams look like they were cook yesterday also sent back the scallops at$18.00 for six nope I'll take my money back really six the size of blue berries come on you had good reviews I'll never go back I guess things never change I hope people read this stuff because this place hasn't changed one bit my wife's fish dinner looked like something that was cooked at a baseball game CAUTION DONT BUY THERE FOOD IT AWFUL STAY WA read more

Great food, timely service and fair pricing. Whole belly clam roll a bargain! Tater tots are a real treat!

Best clams (whole belly or strips), clam chowder and lobster bisque ever! A regular dinner spot for our family in the summer and early fall.

Best clams...always ftesh..much better then the chain across the street and not outrageously priced either...friendly staff and just excellent food in an old style diner experience read more

This place was once a great place . HE has gotten so cheap with the portions given You are paying top dollar and you hardly get nothing Scallop rolls were our favorite, you get like six on a roll The owner needs to make improvements on the prices as well as the portions Many of my friends have stopped going. To bad, otherwise a cute place read more