Charming place with more seating than it seems there should be. Quick, friendly service. The breakfast menu has all the usuals, plus some stretch offerings like crab cake benedict and latkes. I had the crab cake bennies and they were perfection - real crab and the right ratio of crab to breading to seasoning, eggs cooked just right, and fresh red skinned potatoes as home fries. Bonus: I'm pretty sure they serve Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters coffee. Next time, latkes and FLCR coffee is in my sights! read more

Stopped in with 4 friends for breakfast. Food was very good but service was very slow. Coffee was finished before food was brought out and a second refill didn't get there until I was almost finished with my meal! Only one server who also took payment! Three of the 5's, bills, were overcharged from the menu price! The explanation was they raised prices for Fathers Day (4 days ago) and "forgot" to change prices back! Pretty convenient for them! I'd recommend them bc of the food, but watch your receipt and be prepared to wait. read more

This is one delightful restaurant. It is small but cozy. The service is beyond good - it is like having family take care of you. The food is amazing. Today I had the Greek Salad with Ahi Tuna. Tuna was done to perfection and the salad was just what you would expect - a mixture of greens, olives, pepperoncini.... and a lovely dressing. If you haven't been here - please try it out. read more

I had the best experience here on Thursday morning! Seating is available outside though we chose to sit inside. Right when you walk in, there is sanitizer available. Each table is cleared and cleaned between customers. Once seated, they bring everything you need, versus having the tables preset. Every employee we interacted with was lovely. They were welcoming, attentive and on their game. And the food...delicious!! Picture perfect plating and the taste matched. I hadn't been here in a few years and there's new ownership since I was last in. The woman who owns it now is doing things right. Kudos to her! read more

Had the ahi tuna for a third time with homemade potato chips and Jamaican frittata. Both excellent!

Small, quant breakfast and lunch cafe with friendly staff and good food. The chicken sandwich I had was nicely cooked, juicy and not over cooked and served on a decent roll. The chicken sandwich cake with a side, I chose the side salad which was crisp and very fresh. My company had the Ahi Tuna Wrap which he said was absolutely delicious and was going to come back again and have. Depending on the time of day, parking and/or maneuvering around the parking lot can be a slight problem but it's worth it for the food and comfortable atmosphere that the 5 Mile Cafe has to offer. Conveniently located near the 4 corners in the heart of Penfield and a great establishment. I look forward to visiting it again and would suggest it to anyone if they are looking for a great place for breakfast or lunch. read more

It's hard to come by a breakfast place that doesn't just serve the same old fare. I'm glad we came here. The food was delicious. Portions were very generous, my son loved the bear chocolate chip pancakes, and the Five Mile Plate was a great take on a Rochester tradition (poached eggs, sausage patties, meat hot sauce that had a nice spice to it, onion, home fries, and toast). The place as very clean, the staff was extremely friendly. We'll be back! read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Five 5 Mile Plate - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

Home cooked meals. You can substitute items on many dishes. Price was good Food was good Staff is pleasant Service is a bit slow but you should expect that when everything is cooked to order. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

Great spot for lunch, service food all great. Had a sandwich and homemade chips. Definitely will be back

This is a great breakfast/brunch spot in Penfield! The hosts are always welcoming and willing to accommodate any food preferences you may have. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

Being new to the area, and needing a good breakfast, I decided to order delivery. I ordered a basic pancake combo and a coffee. Everything exceeded my expectations! The portions were generous, flavors were incredible, and the delivery person was friendly. I look forward to doing more business with them in the future. The coffee I ordered was the "Jamaican me happy". They certainly did! read more

Great food and Family owned Everyone is so friendly and great atmosphere and again the food is good every time it's a little secret and Penfield but people are finding out. read more

The food and service is very good. I thought the cafe was pleasantly decorated. Would highly recommend to others.

Great place for brunch! We reserved the upstairs room for a surprise birthday party and had a wonderful time. Food is excellent! Thank you!

Super delicious food! Look at that tuna sandwich! Hot homemade chips. This place is sooooo good! I can't wait to return! read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Ahi Tuna Wrap - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

My cousin and I arrived around noon, we both asked for ice tea but we were told they ran out. The hostess said our server would be right over. There was only about 8 or 9 people in the Cafe but we waited over 20 minutes so we decided to leave. We walked past the hostess and a server and no one asked why we were leaving. We went to Roseys and had a great lunch, obviously I will never go back read more

What a great quaint little cafe - First time eating here and we will be back! The breakfast food was fantastic, and my husband is very fussy with his breakfast, he loved his omelet with potatoes with onions. I myself enjoyed the quiche Lorraine. Great service and great people. read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Quiche Lorraine - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

I just had Mother's Day brunch here. We were a small party of three and had a table that could seat four tucked away in a room upstairs with only 5 tables. So the noise level was low, great for conversation! The food was all excellent and the table service provided by Andre was too. I highly recommend the Jamaican Bowl. We also had regular and stuffed french toast, and steak and eggs, no complaints to be made about any of those, it was all excellent. Intimate, family run, super friendly, felt like visiting with friends. Outdoor dinning on their patio looks like a nice option on warmer days. We will be back! read more

I was in Rochester on business for the morning and wanted to try a new place for brunch. I found The Five Mile Cafe here in Yelp. What a great find! I love Eggs Benedict but am not fond of Canadian bacon. The kitchen accommodated my request to make my Eggs Benedict with Lox instead of Canadian Bacon. It was plated beautifully and absolutely delicious! My companion got the Corned Beef Hash. He also asked for it prepared a specific way. The kitchen was very accommodating. And the food was delicious. On a whim, we got the Latkes as a side to share. So glad we did. The prices are reasonable. The atmosphere was intimate but spacious. Andre was friendly and gracious. We'll be back! If you are in the area, I highly recommend you enjoy a meal here. read more

First timer here and I ordered the crabcake benny. The server made sure to let me know that the crab was real and not imitation, the restaurant uses blue crab. Delicious and filling meal. The hollandaise sauce was not overpowering. Great balance of tastes read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Crabcake Benny - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

The Duchess & I were out one Sunday looking for a place to grab a sandwich, and all of our usual haunts were packed. So, I fired up Yelp and went a lookin'. We saw all of the great reviews for the Five Mile Cafe and thought we'd check it out. Nestled off Rt. 441 in the village of Penfield, the Five Mile Cafe is a place you need to check out. It's right next to the Charles Finney School, in case you're looking. We throughly enjoyed our meals there. I dug their grilled chicken sandwich and the Duchess was thoroughly pleased with her Greek Salad. While I don't ordinarily review restaurants on trip #1, I thought the Five mile Cafe deserved a shoutout due to their ambiance, quality of service and food. 4 Stars! read more

I usually take pics of food but I completely forgot to after I saw the food on my plate. It is an amazing find! It's a tight space but the food is so good that you won't mind how close the tables sit to one another. I had a slice of their cinnamon French toast and it was by far the best I've ever had. It was a thick slice of cinnamon swirl bread. It was crunchy on the outside with a read more

I was visiting my sister from NYC for the 4th of July weekend. Decided to take my 11 year old niece to this place since the reviews were good. It did not disappoint. Granted we had to wait a bit since the place was busy and understaffed. Nonetheless, the food was great and the team was doing the best that they could under the circumstances. I highly recommend supporting this wonderful establishment. read more

This place is outstanding. Can't wait to go back. I had the tuna melt and it was very good. Emphasis on Very. My friend had the quiche and remarked she could eat another one it was so good. A little hidden gem in Penfield. read more

A friend and I had a recent reservation for an early lunch. I think we must have hit an off day. They have an extensive breakfast and lunch menu, with breakfast items served until closing. We both ordered pancake combos. Both of our meals were overcooked and relatively flavorless. My coffee was surprisingly weak. I asked for another cup that was also weak. Water was never delivered as requested. We decided that we would give the cafe another try based on the positive reviews we read. The owner is very nice. It's a cozy place. There is plenty of parking in the back. read more

The Five Mile Cafe is such a cute spot! The food of delicious and the staff was very friendly! We highly recommend!

This is a favorite spot of mine to escape from my kids for breakfast in the morning. The restaurant is located in a renovated house and it's always clean and well-maintained. The coffee always features a daily flavor that's always a welcome change for me from regular coffee (Coconut Macaroon and Jamaican Me Crazy are my favorites). My waitress does a great job of keeping the cup full, and since I've always had the same waitress (Lisa), she's always warm and friendly. While I usually favor their pancakes, today the Hungry Man special sounded too good to pass up. A wrap that had fried eggs, hash browns, caramelized onions, sausage and cheddar cheese. The wrap was huge. AND IT CAME WITH A SHORT STACK OF PANCAKES. Short stacks at this cafe equal two pancakes the size of Shaquille O'Neal's face. The meal was a literal love letter to my belly. My wife was unable to finish the same special, proving once again who the pig is in our marriage. Some people may have a problem with the prices on the menu, but my wife and I agreed that everything tasted so fresh that it was worth it. There's a lot of love that goes into the service and the food at The Five-Mile Café, and I plan on coming back again and again and again! read more

The Five Mile Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Penfield, New York

So, this was another "find" on Yelp after being unable to get into a different place that we frequent, that was fairly close and I'm so glad it was!! This is a house that was converted to a restaurant and so cute! . We went without a reservation one Sunday morning and did have to wait outside for about 15 mins. Worth the wait.. this is an absolutely adorable place which I think is family owned and operated (heard a girl talking to another customer about her mother's purchase of the property) This is a small, adorably quaint place that has lovely people taking care of their clientele...it also had really good homemade food!! I got the grilled veggie and scrambled egg wrap which was delicious... filled with zucchini, peppers, mushrooms and the eggs and cheese then finished on the grill.. mmm... and caveman bf got homemade corned beef hash that he thought was delicious, with eggs and toast. The staff was incredibly friendly however it took A LONG TIME to get our food. We could have cared less on any other Sunday but we had an appt that day so were a little anxious about our food arriving with time to spare for us to get to our appt. It's made to order and delicious so take that into account if u go.. it really is worth the trip and any wait. Will be back!! read more

Everything was fantastic! Very classic and wonderful foods. 　I had a good romantic branch today. read more

See all

If you are not looking, you may drive right by the restaurant. If you do you will be missing out on a wonderful dining experience. It is not a high end type place, it is a very clean and bright greasy spoon type restaurant. That said it may be one of, if not the best diner type places in the county, heck the state!! read more

I decided to use DoorDash to get a omelet from here. Reviews looked good so I decided to try it out. I ordered the chicken fajita omelet. It looked yummy. As soon as I took a bite of the omelet, if I had chewed any harder I would've knocked a filling out. But whatever I decided to try another bite. Within two seconds I spit it out. The chicken tasted spoiled and it had an AWFUL taste and smell. There goes a $17 dollar meal in the trash. I'm disappointed and I won't be spending any money here. And to make matters worse, I'm hungry. read more

Cute place but food was just okay. Server was too busy eating her own lunch to check in on us.

This is a great family owned local breakfast cafe. Nicely decorated with some outdoor setting. The food is always top notch!

This is such a gem. We ate outdoors. The servers and even the cook were all so friendly and inviting. The layout of the building and the road puts the outdoor seating out back which is quieter and further from the road. Our food came out quickly and was very neatly presented including a cute little egg shaped piece of watermelon. We look forward to returning. read more

Great home like experience. More than your average cafe that has pastries, this cafe has a full menu that is flavorful and satisfying. I highly recommend when meeting friends for breakfast or lunch. read more

Amazing breakfast/lunch cafe, family run, precise and friendly. Absolutely everything was perfectly cooked from crab Benedict (wow!), breakfast sandwich, biscuits and gravy, potato latkes. Delightful outdoor seating too. Grateful for this place! read more

Just updating my review to add another star. We come here often and consistently have a fantastic breakfast. This place is a gem!

Sorry for the delay, I was here a few weeks ago, for a late breakfast, (Friday morning) Great place, really friendly and helpful staff and delicious food. I get back to Penfield periodically to visit family, and I will definitely return. read more

Stopped here based on our location and Yelp reviews. We had our 2yr old grandson with us. We were warmly greeted and seated promptly. We for got a drinking cup but they could supply a small cup and water. The kids menu was good kid food. The adult menu was very nice. We ordered a cobb salad and a chicken salad sandwich. My wife said it was one of the best chicken salad sandwiches she has had in a long time. The cob salad was good and I could share the tomato and cucumber with my grandson. He took his time with his chicken fingers, dill pickles tomato and cucumber enjoying all then folks around him. If you are in the area this is a good place for lunch! read more

My wife and I have been eyeing this place for the three years it's been open, and I'm happy to say it was worth the wait. The atmosphere was very inviting and the food was simple but very delicious. We met the owner I think, a very nice man named Andre. We will be back and look forward to trying breakfast! read more