Came on a raining Sunday and it wasn't awfully packed. You place an order in the front and are given a number where you can choose to sit at any table. We did a combo for two which included one entree, one pizza and two drinks. Our Caesar salad came out first and we got to enjoy it while our pizza came out. The lettuce was crisp and the Caesar dressing was really good! The pizza had a ton of toppings and was so interesting in flavor as I've never had Alfredo sauce as my base before (ordered the Bulldog). But it was really good and flavors went well together. I love that everything is self serve, such as plates and utensils. I love that you can go get your own fountain drinks. Even the take out boxes are there if you have left overs. Such an efficient and nice place to go get pizza. The ambiance reminds me of an older European establishment and it's just a vibe. Really good for groups and family. read more

The ambiance sucks. The service sucks (atleast from the old hag that likes to work the till) The only saving grace here is the pizza and salad. Absolutely delicious. To the old hag, presumably the owner. You're very uninviting and your heart is as cold as an icebox. Be nice to the kids. One day you're gonna mess with the wrong one and some lady will correct you in the rudest way. read more

I have been here for several big friend group hangs and the service is always great. The meal for one continues to be a steal. Very easy to walk into on a Friday evening. They have an extensive pizza menu, with traditional and non traditional pizza options. I continue to love the five sisters pizza and caesar salad. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area! read more

We dine here on a weekend and it was not too busy. It has a old school vibe and seems like a place were most local hang out. Love the staff and ambiance. We tried their half-half pizza, spaghetti, and ravioli. Pizza was good. The spaghetti and ravioli were not so great. The marinara sauce were watery and meatball was dry. The ravioli has same watery marinara sauce as well. We'll stick with pizza read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Cute Place and Delicious Food! The vibe is like you're outside in Italy or somewhere like that. Cute and welcoming environment with a lot of seating. You can even stand outside and look in a window to the kitchen and watch them cooking and baking. The service was a little slow, but there seemed to be only 1 cashier and 1 guy delivering the food when it was ready. You also have to wait a bit for the food but it's because it's all fresh - worth it. Enjoyed my pizza and will be back! read more

See all

Perfect family spot! Was able to finally try this pizza shop that's been around forever. To start, there is much more seating space than I expected. It is a full restaurant inside which I had assumed it was mostly takeout. Service was excellent, they're really kind and will bring your food to the table. Food is just about the same as your classic pizza place. Nothing fancy but still pretty good and perfect for a family outing. Some arcade games including claw machines etc. Would visit again. Rating: 8/10 read more

See all

Customer Service: 10/10 Ambience: 10/10 Quality of Food: 11/10 Selection of Food: 11/10 Overall Experience: 10/10 Vicky helped us out at around 7:00pm on Friday, 11/14/25. She was friendly! We almost always see her every time my boyfriend and I come to visit. This time, I tried the Crabby Bill's pizza, which had shrimp, real crab, mushrooms, green onions, Alfredo sauce, and mozzarella. I was really craving a savory, seafood pasta and this really hit the spot! I love that this restaurant always has interesting pizza topping flavors and combinations. I got a strawberry lemonade Calypso drink to pair with it. They have a great selection of drinks to choose from. My boyfriend had gotten one of the classic meat pizzas, which he always enjoys very much. The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe is a cozy restaurant in the middle of the Main Street of Redlands. Its decorations are reminiscent of an old family restaurant, with its walls being painted like you're walking down a historic street. The atmosphere is very cozy and warm. I love coming out here every time we come this way because there's always something new to try or something delicious to choose again. We've only really ordered to-go, but one of these days we'll have to dine in and try their beers on tap! read more

See all

I went there the other Sunday and it was great Pizza. I had a good time however there was a young man who just started and he forgot my bacon on my salad, but still the ambience and the service was still great and I would really recommend it. I love the pizza Pizza Hut oh the pizza was excellent had great pepperoni on it. Salad was good so yeah I recommend going in there getting your share it's fun atmosphere it's like you pay first you sit down you find you a table. We stayed there for about 2 to 3 hours just talking and having a great time so I recommend. read more

It's been years since I ate here after they closed the Yucaipa location which was a long time ago lol ... so I was looking forward to retrying my old favorite-The Old Prospector- it was still very good just needed a lil more sauce and I think it would've been perfect. The cheese bread is really good. I'm definitely going make my way back to try some more. The lady who worked the counter was very nice and helpful. So definitely definitely worth checking out if you're looking for good pizza and a strong menu of options that u won't get anywhere else. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious I had eggplant/ ricotta and olive oil my husband had pepperoni/sausage/mushrooms and jalapeños- we accidentally left a bag of toys for are grandkids they were able to locate it and call us (Thank you) friendly service read more

Tried a pizza called The gouda and it was insanely delicious it had cashews in it they have a unique selection of toppings i even saw raisins for a suggestion this place will not disappoint read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - The gouda pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

The The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe in Redlands is a fun spot, especially if you like pizza places that get a little creative. The menu is packed with unusual toppings and inventive combinations, which is impressive, although I will admit my brain tends to shut down once there are pages and pages of options. I played it safe and went with a simple pepperoni, and I was very happy I did. The pizza was really good, with a pie-style crust that had just the right balance of chew and crisp. It ended up being a solid win for my family on our last visit through Redlands, and I would happily go back, even if I stick to the classics again. read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

Located in the heart of Downtown Redlands, my partner and I stopped by this little pizza spot hidden away on State St. Looking deceptively small from the outside, we were surprised to see how spacious the interior seating was. We got our food relatively quickly. The pizza was good, if a little bit too oily. The place itself offers many deals online so we'd also recommend checking those out as well We also ordered a platter of buffalo wings(not pictured) which we also finished. We couldn't help but notice the pretty pizza boxes everyone was taking home. read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - California Surfer Pizza 12" - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Who gets just a salad at a pizza place? The hubby and I do! Lol! We ate well for lunch earlier in the day elsewhere and just wanted a salad in the late evening. The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe is located the bustling downtown Redlands. We were walking around and saw the descriptions of the salads on their menu. Redlands is famous for the oranges. So we chose the citrus salad which is a mix of fresh greens, tomatoes, mandarins, grilled chicken, sliced almonds, green onions, and mozzarella cheese. The dressing is their own citrus poppy dressing. Refreshing and delicious! There are plenty of tables and chairs and booths. We sat in a booth. The Pizza Shoppe is very family friendly. In fact, there was a nice family seated near us playing a game. Service was good. 4 stars in 1.1K reviews to date is accurate! We would return and try the pizza. read more

See all

Such a cool spot! Awesome if you have kids too! The happy hour is awesome and I loved the boneless wings! Service was friendly and welcoming. I loved the little kids area because it kept my little guy busy and happy. The pizza was awesome and they don't skimp on toppings! I did a make my own and honestly didn't take pics of anything because we were so hungry we just ate it all up! I look forward to trying the salads next time! It was a cool retreat from the hotness outside and it was clean and comfortable. There's fountain drinks as well as canned beverages and wine and beer. Lots of seating for both big and small parties! I've never eaten inside but was super happy. Just be prepared for a HUGE menu with tons of choices!!!! Not a bad thing! read more

This place is trash! I want my money back and I didn't even pay for the pizza! First time here so I walk in and we're not greeted or acknowledged. A worker walks by and we ask if we can sit anywhere and she said yes. Asked if we needed a menu and mind you there are 4 of but proceeds to only bring one menu! There are a lot of different choices which is cool but nothing seemed very appealing. Anyway, we go On to order a meal for 4 which the price wasn't too bad but I got why. The citrus salad had no flavor, the dressing tasted like water I took 2 bites and left it. The cheese pizza lacked any flavor just had a ton of cheese. The entire meal tasted like cafeteria food! The restaurant and decor are cute it has a theme going on but I wouldn't recommend this place at all. Customer service and food are both lacking. read more

The crust is one of worst ever. No chew and worse than many frozen pizzas. I will say the tomato sauce is really good, similar to pizzas I've had in Italy and the cheese seems to be of good quality. Overall very disappointing given the reviews. Will go elsewhere next time . read more

Lots of options ... I mean like a lot. Every pizza combination you can think of and all the ones you never would. Food is descent but with so many odd pizza options it can be hit or miss. The ingredients and quality are good, just can be odd to get a peanut butter bacon pizza but do what you feel. Menu can feel overwhelming so look at it ahead of time. Service isn't bad but not waiter style so expect to get your own stuff. read more

See all

I come to downtown Redlands every two weeks since I get my eyelashes done here, and one of my favorite things about this area is how many hidden gems it has. I am always pleasantly surprised anytime I try a new place. So setting wise, the restaurant itself is pretty dark which I didn't mind since it's so hot right now. It's super kid friendly and they have a lot of toys in the waiting area to keep kids busy if you happen to be waiting. I ordered at the counter- they do take Apple Pay, and then ordered a small personal pizza to go. I had a really hard time deciding on my toppings because I personally have never seen SO MANY unique pizza toppings and pairings. The pizza was hot, fresh, very cheesy and damn near perfect. I will most definitely be back! I honestly haven't stopped thinking about how good it was. read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

Was here with my coworker for lunch. It was her first time. It wasn't too busy when we got there. She got the eggplant Parmesan pasta and I got the half blue apple salad. She enjoyed hers. My salad tastes great as always. Sweet spot in Redlands for some pizza and desserts. Great for everyone. read more

See all

Hadn't been to this shop in years! My husband is super picky with pizza and he LOVED it! We got a medium pizza with pepperoni and jalapeños. We also got cheese raviolis with Alfredo sauce and a half salad with ranch dressing. The reason for the 4:5 stars was on the order being brought wrong :/ we got regular sauce on raviolis and those take a while to come out. We sent it back and when they brought the right order they also forgot the garlic bread and that took a while to come out. It was such a bummer. But the food was delicious!! Holy cow it was so fire. read more

Can't stand the hundred versions on the menu. Less is more. I want to build my own pizza but there's no options for just regular pepperoni or hamburger or sausage. Just the Peter Pepperoni and there should be options for less read more

Love their pizza... good price... clean... staff are friendly...ample staff place to eat... parking is hit and miss.

The coziest pizza shop! This is a must when stopping in downtown Redlands. The ambiance reminds me of when I was little and going out for pizza with my family. The pizza crust is DELICIOUS. They have vegan & gluten free options that are fantastic too. Staff is always so friendly - this is a must! read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Pizza is horrible and sauce tastes like it was from a can, little ceasers is better by far and it was 28 bucks for a lg w with two toppings I was going to bring it back but my husband said no just chalk it up as a loss just know that we'll never go there again if I had seen it before he brought it home I would have told him bring it back in there be careful what you get these days you really got to look at it before you or taste a slice before you buy a whole pie I guess I'm spoiled being from back east with New York style pizza this stuff was bad though just FYI wouldn't even give it one star but you have to give it something read more

Really truly not very good, the staff was pleasant, helpful, and kind but I was shocked at how strange the crust was. It felt like I was eating a frozen pizza, wasn't very good at all. The decor was also dark and dated, I'm just not a fan. read more

The pizza was delicious but what really stood out to me was the staff and the environment. This truly felt like a sweet, family owned business. You felt like part of a small town where everyone treats you like they've known you forever. The staff was so kind and patient with our large group. My daughter & niece loved the small kids area - who knew knobs and steering wheels would keep them so entertained?! We don't live nearby but came on a fluke.. but I'd drive all the way out here again to eat some great pizza at a very welcoming place. read more

I've had a lot of great pizza and this spot isn't it. Maybe the pasta and sandwiches are better but this pizza has had me sick to my stomach since yesterday. Pretty sure I got food poisoning read more

The atmosphere is nice. The employees are welcoming and helpful. The pizza was just ok. The dough seems to maybe be frozen, or just stale. This also includes the cheese bread. Ingredients on the pizza did taste good, I think the sauce can use a bit more flavor to it. The wings here are pretty good, but the best thing we had was the salad. Which is not good seeing its a pizza shop and not a salad shop. I doubt we will be back here again. Hopefully these reviews get read by the owners and make some changes to their items. read more

As an adjective, "gourmet" describes food that is expensive, specialty, or high quality, often requiring expert preparation. This pizza staple is well on its way to delivering pizza of the gourmet class to Redlands locals. The three of us decided to stop by this local eatery for a snack, to which we agreed to all split one 7" Peter Pepperoni Pizza. Whoever Peter is, he is one lucky guy to have such a delicious pizza named after him. This pizza had a well baked chewy crust topped with cheese oozing and crispy pepperoni strips! Although we waited quite a long time to finally get our pizza, the time passed by fast when spent with good company. We also enjoyed the cozy atmosphere of the restaurant suitable for a meet up with long time friends and casual dinner date. read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Peter Pepperoni Pizza (Size: 7") - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

We had a really good pizza (gay 90's) and antipasto salad. Both the pizza and the salad had great flavor and was very tasty. It had been a little while since we have gotten Gourmet Pizza and I was really glad to know they have not missed a step. I highly recommend this business. read more

Food: My bf and I were in the mood for something more luxurious than just a typical dominos pizza, he was specifically craving seafood toppings, and wow the crabby bill's pizza really hit home run, it was creamy the generous amount of crab and shrimps, loved the avocado piece on top too! We also got it's a gouda pizza, which tasted great with the BBQ sauce underneath, but couldn't really taste the actual gouda flavor. We ordered everything through uber eats, by the time we got our food, the sweet potato fries were no longer crispy and a bit soggy unfortunately. But all in all, very satisfying meal indeed and willing to go back to try more menu items! Price: depends on the size and flavor of each pizza, but I think it was around 10$ for 7inch and $17 for 10inch, which I think is reasonable for some fancy gourmet pizza that you can't get anywhere else Ambiance: nice little restaurant in the heart of downtown redlands, looks like it's dimly lit, wouldn't be bad for a casual dinner with friends or partner Service: can't say much since I ordered through doordash and for to go, but doesn't seem like there would be any issues Parking: there are parking spots all along downtown redlands streets, but you can always park in the public structure across from martha green eatery or public lot across from molinos coffee read more

See all

If you can think it, they'll do it. This is pizza like you've never imagined before. The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe specializes in.... Unorthodox pizza toppings. You can always do classic pizzas too but carry on. Crabby Bill's is the winner. Garlic butter, crab, shrimp, avocado, and whatever else on a pizza. That's a winning combination if I ever saw one. This is a must have. That's it. That's a Gouda is exactly how it sounds. Gouda cheese on pizza. It's got chicken and other stuff too but frankly, the gouda cheese wasn't all too strong after everything else comes together, probably cause of the bbq sauce. Sweet potato fries are, well, sweet potato fries. Eat it with ranch. Carry on. All in all, this is a pretty solid pizza place if you want to try something different, some might be too outlandish, some work surprisingly well, it's up to you to brave these new wonders though. read more

See all

Great food and service. Grandson had a great time playing games and playing on the landline phone

Love this pizza place! I don't even need to avoid gluten, but their gluten-free pizza is amazing! We get the No Kissing Tonight - pesto sauce, garlic,... and we add on cashews. The owner, Scott, is so hospitable and kind. His staff look happy to be there. Nice atmosphere, very clean, and good music playing! read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

Was in the Redlands area for a couple of appts and had a craving for pizza. It's one of my favorite dishes and I take my pizza selections very seriously . I don't like stingy toppings. Looking at all the pics on yelp helped me make a decision to choose this place but I was not expecting the overload of choices the menu alone provided. They put any and everything on pizza. I wish I would've found this place when I was pregnant. It would have been a dream. Needless to say, there is something for everyone. Rather you want to keep it basic or you want to kick it up a notch and live on the edge, this place is for you. Walking up to the business it looked fairly small but it's pretty sizable on the inside. It has a nice ambiance and it looks like it'd be a fun night out with the fam. The workers are super nice and patient. I recommend looking over the menu before you go. This isn't a fast food order. Thank God the people here are kind and patient. I definitely would refer anyone here if you're looking for a legit pizza. The 7' was more than enough. I thought it would be mainly dough but the pizza is layered with ingredients and it's juicy so keep your napkin close. I had to hold one under my chin while I was biting my pizza. Totally worth it!!! read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - Gluten free BYO 7' pizza (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom) and 7' old prospector. Both loaded 2 inches high with ingredients. - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

This was our second visit to gourmet Pizza. It was every bit as good as our first try. Tonight we tried the 12 inch pizza and a picture of beer for $34. Our pizza was the Jack Spratt, and it was muy delicioso. I love the fact that you get to choose your table. The dining room, mimics, an outdoor patio, surrounded by local establishments, complete with bistro, lighting, strung across the dining room room. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. from the order taker at the cash register to the person delivering the meal. read more

The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe - 1/2 size Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

This used to be my favorite place to come with my children and unfortunately, on a Wednesday afternoon I came in with my daughter's to have our usual girls dinner and I never felt as awkward as I felt today we ordered boneless wings with an extra large pizza and three toppings waited a whole hour for our food to be delivered to us, but before then one of the young ladie let us know that unfortunately, our food was given to the table next to us with absolutely no empathy. Walks away and still is gone for another good 20 minutes definitely not coming back. I felt very awkward as I was the only minority in the restaurant. Another lady comes and delivers the pizza. I do let her know that I would like to take it to go walks away again without any empathy puts my pizza in a box and it says you're welcome without me even finishing acknowledging at least that they did this for us as I stood in the front by the cashier, waiting for my daughters to come out of the restroom the two ladies that were at the cashier look at me with a smirk and walk away and make sure that no one is near the front as I walk by them. Come on gourmet pizza let's do better our customers matter our customers that are here supporting this amazing pizza parlor for years. Shame on you! read more

One of Redlands' funnest pizza destinations--creative, varied, and community-driven. Perfect for adventurous eaters or laid-back pizza nights. Insanely creative pizza combos--seriously, peanut butter + bacon? Worth a try! Huge menu variety: build-your-own, vegan/gluten-free, desserts, pastas, salads. Chill atmosphere with local beers on tap and fun weekly deals. Crust can be hit-or-miss--it leans more casserole-like. Seating fills up fast, especially on market nights or weekends. read more

Wow I am pleasantly surprised by how delicious this place was! I am vegan and it's hard to find vegan pizza that's good and this was it!! They have vegan options that are hard to find online. They have vegan cheese, vegan pesto, and vegan meatballs sub. You can make pretty much anything vegan by substituting what you want. In the pizza the vegan one is the large pizza. It has vegan pesto, tomatoes, basil, red onions, angel hair pasta and vegan cheese. So delish! The regular items are very good too. The medium size is mini pearl pizza and the smallest one is a chorizo breakfast pizza. Highly recommend giving this place a try!! read more

See all