How have I never reviewed this? It helps that Mill Tavern is close enough I can get there on EV... Seriously it's worth the drive, and the wait. There's not many places around this small intersection to get good bar food - burgers, wraps, salads, apps, and some entrees. Never tried anything I couldn't pick up, but everything is good. Their burgers are fantastic and you can dress them however you like with their "Boss Burger" - three choices for one price, extras and premiums are reasonable. Great tavern fries, great homemade sauces too. I can tell it's a pretty popular hangout spot because everyone seems to know everyone else including the bar staff, it makes the place a little loud sometimes but everyone's friendly. I haven't even mentioned the bar - great service, great beer selection including on draft, and friendly faces. Funny I don't know everyone, I've been coming here since it opened. Maybe I need to drink more. Anyway will be back again soon. read more

Visiting from out of town we went there for their fish and chips. Didn't disappoint and really hit the spot! Nice neighborhood bar.

My favorite place. The best damn bar food on the north side. Go on a Thursday and catch trivia, it's a great and fun evening! We love this place and frequent it regularly. The fried pickles and mushrooms are a must! read more

the food was good. doesn't make sense to charge $3.50 to upgrade ruffles chips to fries. the large fry is also $3.50 for barely a handful. the service was good, we got one of the newer waitresses. it was pretty busy on a friday which is expected, didn't wait too long for a table. read more

My food is consistently good here. Doesn't matter what you get...it's always tasty! Drink specials are written on the board and they always have good specials. Drinks are traditionally fast and strong (just what I like!). Servers are attentive as well. read more

The Mill Tavern - Club and onion rings - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Stumbled upon this place to watch a basketball game. Great food (try the Jellystone burger)! Excellent service!

Very good, they make their own clam chowder which is one of the better ones that I've had. They batter their own pickles and mushrooms The Ruben rolls were very good and the chicken sandwich was very good, the buffalo suace has a nice kick. The service was very good as they were quite busy at the time. The had a steady carry out business Definitely will be going back. read more

been coming here for a while and the wings are usually pretty good, until today , i'm all for a daytona style wing but if all i taste is charred wings im good. looked like they were short staffed , would've been nice if the girl helping refill drinks got to our table too but i guess we weren't paying customers either. read more

The Mill Tavern - daytona style wings - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

I have come to enjoy this place, especially seeing Shannon and Heather! They make u feel very welcome and with me being a woman I can easily say that I would have no problem coming to this place by myself and feeling at home! I have stumbled onto this place with the intro of a friend that comes regularly here. It is small, cozy, has TVs for your enjoyment, TouchTunes jukebox, and pull tabs. It is a full service bar with 10 beers in tap and bottled beer, liquor and wine. The hand battered mushrooms are my favorite and you gotta try them! read more

This is our all time favorite restaurant in the area. The food is all fresh and absolutely amazing. It is by far the best food in the area. The staff is always so nice and helpful. The place is cozy and welcoming with lots of TVs. read more

Food is always good here! And we received good service too. A great place just to get food pub food!!

First time visitor, in town for business and wanted a friendly and relaxing bar. This place nailed it. Bar staff was super friendly and chatty. I was there close to close and they were super attentive to make sure I had all I needed while they were starting to wrap up for the night. read more

Even though we've lived here in Westfield for nearly three years, we only started frequenting The Mill just recently, mainly because we have a teenager and you have to be 21 to dine-in. So, we've been getting carry-out, and we've been very pleased. The Mill has everything you would expect in terms of bar food, but I find that the food quality is a notch above average. I usually get the Buffalo Chicken wrap, along with fries. The take-out packaging is always consistent, and they haven't screwed-up any of our orders in over 8 visits. The staff is always very friendly when I go inside to pick up the order. Nice work - keep it up. read more

Food and atmosphere is good. Drinks seem very expensive. A double of Wild Turkey on the rocks was $18. C'mon man. A fifth is $21.

Only have done carry out but food has been very good and wait time is reasonable. Definitely a new favorite local place.

After finding this gem a few years ago, it has been our go to place for a meal after our bi-weekly grocery trip. Food is always excellent and the waitstaff is amazing. And for the cooks, well, this very picky New Yawker gives 5 stars to them! That is something you can't say about any establishment post-covid, you all kept it consistent from pre-covid times! Excellent! Keep up the good work and see you all soon! read more

Stopped in after Saturday afternoon garden shopping & received great service and delicious tavern food. Light tempura breading on fried pickles and full button mushrooms left me wanting to order more. Spicy Garlic wings crispy and not heavy with overly thick breading. Definitely worth coming back for these alone! Enjoyed trying the seasonal Curious Traveler shandy - the hint of pumpkin spice is great pairing with fried foods and incoming fall weather. Super angus burger list includes a burger with a special "suicide" sauce - guessing it's more hot than an evening at Hefner's mansion with broken a/c... Healthy wraps and a whole page of salads to balance an evening's liquid calories. Looking forward to bringing friends for a crazy karaoke night or a weekend making our own fun. read more

The Mill Tavern - Spicy garlic wings and Curious Traveler Shandy at The Mill Tavern - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Took my Mom here for a casual birthday lunch. Even though they were slightly understaffed everything was amazing. The Avocado Egg rolls are a must and the beer on tap is ideal. I wanted to try everything in their extensive menu but settled on classics Buffalo wings...Oh my lawd they did not disappoint. Perfectly grilled chicken wings, great size and the blue cheese mmmmmhmmm. I cannot wait to go back and try more of the menu. The staff was amazing, the food was incredible. Can't wait for my next visit! read more

All around great place for friends to gather. Great Food( My Favorite is "The Last Mill and Testament" Burger. Wonderful staff that makes you feel special and the owners are there working right alongside of the staff and you can just tell they have fun and truly enjoy what they do and the people around them which gives the place that "Cheers" feeling( I know some of you aren't even old enough to know what "Cheers" was but for those of you who do, you'll understand when you visit the Mill. GREAT Halloween and ST. Patty's day parties also! read more

Great to have a tavern in the area. Food and drink specials can be great, especially love the Bison Burger. Food overall is great and there are frequent coupons in the mailers. Caddy is an awesome bartender. I prefer sitting at the bar opposed to tables. Whenever sitting in the table area service seems especially slow and inconsistent. Plenty of televisions so can be great for games! read more

I look at this place in two categories. First off, it is as homey as the bar we all loved in "Cheers." Secondly, Toby Keith of country music fame wrote a song that contained the lyrics, "I like my truck, I like my girlfriend, but I love this bar. It's my kind of place." If you can imagine either or, you can get a taste of the quaint, hometown feel this bar provides. It's tucked into a neighborhood shopping center where the locals go. I observed lots of friendly people and the employees seemed to know everyone that came in the door. It's very comfortable with the right mix of TV and music playing. Now, to the food they serve. It's a mix of burgers, chicken, and fish. Today's menu contained chili which was a black bean/beef combination full of flavor and so good. Later the Westfield burger arrived perfectly cooked medium as I requested. My wife had the BBQ chicken salad which she could not finish due to its size. Saving the best for last, Nancy was our server. She was pleasant and attentive with a friendly smile and chatter about Arizona where she recently returned from. She makes one feel at home and welcome and I noticed the other employees behaving the same way with their customers. Needless to say, it's not hard for me to give this place five stars for the comfort factor, food, and folks. It will be a mistake not to give The Mill Tavern a spot on your to do list. read more

Nice neighborhood-type bar that's located in a busy shopping center. I've had several lunches at the Mill Tavern and the food has always been great. Back when I lived in the area and was working from home, I'd call them up and place a carryout order for lunch and it was always ready when I arrived to pick it up about 15 minutes later. I got addicted to their Club Sandwich, which is what I always ordered, but you can't go wrong with anything on their menu. read more

Nice little neighborhood tavern. Nothing fancy, but I really think it is a welcoming place, especially for the regulars. I met a friend for a beer and they had ample selections and the prices were fair. The service was fast and friendly, too. read more

The Mill Tavern - Menu - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Food good. Atmosphere typical bar. Nothing special. Clean, good service, Chef had hair put back & wore a hat. Chef looked professional. Appreciate the cleanness of this place. Had the tenderloin. Quality pork with very good breading, however, the oil that it was fried in left a slight off taste. My spouse had the Mill Creek salad which was also very good. I would stop in again for lunch. Total price $25.47 which included two soft drinks, not including tax or tip. read more

Food is pretty good, service is a hit or miss. Last few times we were there late they shut the bar down two hours before stated closing time. I can understand that to an extent, but each time there were still 5 people in bar. Very "townie" still... could have a great place in a growing area... read more

The Mill has EXCELLENT food! It's a quaint little local bar, with excellent service and fabulous food!!!

Local watering hole with a good beer selection and better than average local bar food. This is the kind of place where you can kick back after work with a beer and an Indian-style tenderloin. The ambiance is nothing special pretty typical for a local place. Gets very busy and kind of loud. read more

A local friend introduced me to the Mill Tavern a couple weeks ago and since then, it has become one of my weekly stops for lunch! The style is very casual and laid back and the wait staff are extremely friendly and timely. I have not had a bad experience yet! The food is delicious and easy to order whether you call in and pick it up or dine in read more

We love the Mill. Food is fresh and hot. Wait staff are attentive and busy! Love the pickles!

Love love LOVE The Mill and I'm so glad they've been able to make it this far through the pandemic. I think this may have been the first place in Westfield my husband and I ever went together before moving here. We ended up moving right across the street and we love going whenever we get the chance. We're both from small towns and this place feels like home. Also, all the servers are amazing, which makes the experience 10x better! read more

I really just want to say Alisa did an awesome job today. The place was 3/4 full and she was working by herself both behind the bar and the dinning room.. she did her very best to be attentive everyone and did an excellent job serving everyone and taking orders. Along with that she was very pleasant and happy. She was not flustered or upset by the fact she was going it alone. You have a very good employee there and she deserves a raise or a bonus for her hard work. read more

Quick service and wifi, too! Good beer selection and the whiskey selection is adequate. Good bar food. The burgers are fresh pattieed and the cooked to order, and they are the bomb. Best thing? No kids ever. That may be close second to the fact the bartender knows how to pour a Guinness! read more

The Mill Tavern - Beer thirty or a quarter past Jameson.. not sure.... - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Friendly atmosphere, mature customers. Bar and restaurant setting. Food is excellent, hot and fresh to order

As people from Saint Maria Goretti have said time and time again, this place feels like our parish bar! I have been there a couple of times with some guys from the parish, and every time I go in, I'll see someone I know from the church or our neighborhood. It's a great local Westfield bar. It's also a great place for a quick drink with friends or to watch a game. Their menu is big, and everything I have had there has tasted great. I'm glad to have a place like this so close to the house. With 3 kids, my wife and I don't get a chance to go out often, but when we do, this is a nice place to grab a beer, talk, and be close enough to home, where if the kids light something on fire, or get into the knives and cut the babysitter, we can be home in minutes! read more

Decent sized space that is over 21 only. Great after work / dinner place. Wooden walls with beer mirrors. Few high too tables near front windows. All lower eating tables opposite the bar. Bar on east wall. when bar with classic Wooden rail. Though the bar back is nothing special. Enough TVs to watch the game. Light padded seat with wooden back. L shaped 15 or so stools. The food is average average to above-average depending on what you get. Perfect for Lent with fish specials every Friday. Enough beers to make most people happy. Great, friendly service. read more

What a pleasant surprise! Here I was, driving through Not-quite-Carmel, looking for something to eat. Everything in this neighborhood -- absolutely everything -- is one of two things: A cheesy subdivision with homes that have as much individual character as the neighborhood itself or a strip mall, which is somehow completely fascinating by comparison. To me, this is hell. I recognize that others may disagree. De gustibus non disputandum est. So you can imagine my surprise to find the Mill Tavern, with its decent beer selection and oh-so-delicious eats. I had the Golden Eagle -- crispy chicken fillet with just the right amount of wing-style-sauce and melted cheese. My companion had a burger with jack cheese and bacon and a side of truly outstanding fries. They have Sun King on tap -- which isn't as good as it could be, but far better than the Bud-ish alternatives. Too bad about the location, though. read more

Several months later I'm still loving this place and upgrading it to 5 stars because they've added on to their menus and have some AMAZING food! Great beers on tap and special, great service! I had a ribeye sandwich and it was probably the best ribeye sandwich I've ever had! Perfectly cooked. Be sure to check it out! read more

The Mill Tavern - Ribeye steak sandwich, fries and a Sam Adams! America! - Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

The reviews were pretty misleading. The food was ok at best and I felt as though I could have made a better choice instead of driving out here. Forgettable. read more

If the eclectic friends I've hung out at The Mill with are any indicator, it is far from discriminatory, so give this great little place the benefit of the doubt. In fact, I'd call this place extremely welcoming and diverse compared to your typical Hamilton County establishment. Anyway, The Mill has excellent pub fare. Many if not most items are fresh and homemade. Their menu is huge, and everything I've tried has been fantastic. If you like breaded mushrooms, these are the best I've ever had. Also love the horseradish cheese dip. They've got great drink specials, and a wide selection of all the latest microbrews to keep the snobs and hipsters happy. I'd describe the atmosphere as 'upscale dive bar'. It's always very clean and pleasant, but ambiance reminds me of what I'd envision a bar inside a Cracker Barrel to look like. Love that it is smoke-free since ironically, most 21+ establishments in hoity-toity Hamilton County are not despite neighboring Indianapolis banning smoking indoors a few years ago. They also have pull tabs which are always fun for a minute - won $500 once :) And hey, if you're a local, watch your mail for some nice coupons. Soccer parents: give yourselves a sanity-check, and sneak in here during an upcoming practice. You won't regret it! read more

Great bar. Came into town for baseball and found this place. Bartender knowledgeable and attentive. Great selection of drinks. Didn't eat, so can't comment on the food read more