Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    3.6 (16 reviews)
    Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac Takeout or Delivery

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac Photos

    THE NY PIZZA PLACE - TAMARAC ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    Recommended Reviews - The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Andrea F.

    Yummy and tasty pizza for starters! I ordered the thin crust NY style pizza and a meat lovers pizza, as well as the side order of meatballs. No option for delivery so I did pick up. The girl working was super nice and friendly. For 2 large pizzas and a side of meatballs was 72$ so it is alittle pricey here. I brought the pizza home to my dad and his 2 friends that were fixing something at my house. My dads 2 friends happen to be from NY city so I was very interested to see their opinion on the pizza. As for myself, I loved it and thought the pizza and meatballs were delicious. My dads friends said it was good, but not quite like in NY but they did love the meatballs. I will order again but not too often since its alittle more expensive than I would like.

    Laura R.

    Told my hubby I was in the mood for pizza so we ventured out to try a new place. Got take away pizza slices and a Diet Coke from here. Easy to park right up front. The pizza slices were gigantic and paper thin with a hint of garlic sauce and that's the perfect combo since I hate doughy pizza. Not the cheapest but good size and tasty.

    Melissa R.

    This pizza was a HUGE disappointment! What went right - the pizza was ready when I arrived to pick it up and the dough was similar to what you'd find in NY. What went wrong - everything else. I ordered a 20' pizza with half pepperoni. The pizza looked and tasted like it had been sitting out waiting to be sliced and single served. They serve single slices there. The cheese was hard and glued to the pizza and the sauce was absorbed into the bread and cheese. So basically the sauce was non-existent. Also, the cost was excessive when considering the quality. Maybe it's the expense for importing their dough? I'm from New York and I can't stand behind this product. I was so hopeful.

    Jarid P.

    Picked up a pizza last night, first time trying NY Pizza Place. Placed my order online and it was ready super fast. Went in for pickup and staff was friendly, place was clean, and I love that they pizza by the slice. Very please with the pizza I got, my only regret was that I got a 14" instead of a 20" but that's on me!

    Very clean
    Doug R.

    11/19/2025 Wednesday Night, first time here and not a bad place . Im glad I came and that we have this pizza place here, cuz sometimes I just want a slice not a whole pie. I had the 2 slice amd drink special for $11.77 the slices I had were The Brooklyn, I've never tried that flavor before but it was really good and it had me wanting a 3rd slice....but no no no, I came for 2 . Lol. This is a must try and we will be back. Oh the service was good as well too.

    Sandra M.

    Excellent NY-style cheese pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and perfectly cooked, and the garlic knots were soft, flavorful, and delicious. Service was great and the turnaround time was super fast. Everything came out hot and exactly as ordered. Definitely coming back!" The art is amazing and fits the restaurant very well. I love that there's a lot of eating areas.

    Burnt hard Pizza Yuck
    Angie B.

    I stopped in to grab a couple of pepperoni slices for lunch as I was shopping at Publix. How could you mess up two slices of pepperoni pizza? The crust is hard. The pepperoni is burnt. The pizza is dry.This was horrible. I don't know what happened. I don't know if he let the reheating of the pizza stay in too long, but this is ridiculous and unacceptable won't be back. This was just lunch.

    Pizza has more sauce then cheese good acid reflex meal

    See all

    5 months ago

    Helpful 7
    Thanks 1
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of El M.
    0
    12
    0

    22 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Pizza was good, but price was $28 for a small cheese pizza and 2 drinks, a little pricey for cheese pizza.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    Review Highlights - The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac

    “Service was great and the turnaround time was super fast.”

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 2,665 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Magic Cow

    The Magic Cow

    4.8(182 reviews)
    3.1 mi
    •$$

    They say curiosity killed the cat -- but in this case, it led me straight to happiness in a waffle…read morecone. The Magic Cow in Coral Springs has a 4.8-star Yelp rating, and their sister store in Davie is apparently one of the top 10 ice cream shops in the entire United States. So naturally, I had to see if the local legend lived up to the hype. (Spoiler: it did. And then some.) The moment we walked in, I was hit with that nostalgic mix of sugar, laughter, and magic that says you're about to make a very good life decision. The owner greeted us like old friends -- warm, funny, and clearly passionate about what he does. You can tell every scoop that leaves that counter has been crafted with pride. Now, about the ice cream. I went with the Carrot Cake flavor -- and let me tell you, it wasn't just ice cream; it was an experience. Folded into it were ribbons of caramel and bits of pie crust that somehow made me rethink all my previous dessert choices in life. One bite in, and I'm pretty sure I saw colors brighter than usual. My wife went for a combo of Better Batter Cake Carnival and Chocolate Batter Better, and to call it "excellent" would be an understatement. This flavor pairing was pure joy in stereo. I'm pretty sure she stopped listening to me talk for a good five minutes, which is the ultimate compliment to any dessert. Bottom line: The Magic Cow isn't just living up to its reputation -- it's churning out happiness, one scoop at a time. If you haven't been, fix that immediately. Your taste buds will thank you, your diet will forgive you (eventually), and your inner child will do a happy dance.

    Indulged in a brownie sundae here a few days ago. It was a nice treat and although the brownie…read morewasn't the best the ice cream itself is phenomenal. Light on the tummy & tastes entirely homemade and high quality. The owners are retiring and have an advertisement on the window selling this long running small ice cream shop. I hope whomever does acquire it, keeps the quality of the ice cream up to its current standard as well as preserves the quirky and quaint aesthetics inside. I implore you to experience it for yourself before they sell it, if in the area.

    Photos
    The Magic Cow
    The Magic Cow
    The Magic Cow

    See all

    The Baked Bear

    The Baked Bear

    4.7(106 reviews)
    6.0 mi
    •$$

    Stopped in on a Friday afternoon because it was a hot day in Florida and the ice-cream looked…read moreyummy. It was cute spot in between Cheesecake factory and Cviche 105. I felt a little hot inside, the door was open though so maybe thats why. There were about 6 chairs facing the window for customers to sit abd enjoy their ice-cream. The staff greeted us nicely and they allowed us to try samples. They sell cookies and ice-cream. You could purchase those individually or in an icecream sandwich. Cool idea. They had nice ice cream flavors but not what I wanted. There was a blue one which I though was a cookie monster but it was something else. I really wanted the cookie monster. They had a cookie monster cookie but not the ice cream. I loved the cookie options. Walked out with a carrot cake cookie for $3 which tasted exactly like carrot cake. They warmed it up for me. It was yummy yummy

    Free samples are a dangerous thing. One minute you're "just looking," and the next thing you know…read moreyou're standing at the counter ordering ice cream like it was your idea all along. That's exactly how The Baked Bear got me. Hook, line, and sinker. If you've never been, the concept is simple and brilliant. High-quality ingredients and a build-your-own dessert approach. Cookies, brownies, cones, ice cream, toppings. You mix, match, and create something that feels a little more custom than your average scoop shop. And the ingredients really do deliver. The cones are nicely crisp, and if you've never had one of their ice cream sandwiches, start there. They'll build it with warm cookies on the outside and freezing cold ice cream on the inside, which might be the most satisfying hot-meets-cold dessert combination ever created. Warm cookie. Frozen ice cream. Zero regrets. For my order, I went with the berry crumble and strawberry cheesecake on a waffle cone. The waffle cone had a great crisp to it, and the flavors were light and refreshing. You got a nice hint of berry without it being overpowering. If anything, I would have welcomed a little more berry punch, but it was still very enjoyable. We also tried the campfire s'mores, which absolutely popped with bold flavor, and the cookie dough, which was fine but a little more average compared to the others. The one area where things felt slightly limited was the flavor selection. They offered around a dozen choices, but many leaned heavy into chocolate territory. If you're a chocolate lover, you'll feel like you hit the lottery. If you're looking for a wider range of lighter or fruit-forward options, the variety could be better. Still, the concept is great and the ingredients are excellent. Tip: do not accept the free sample unless you're emotionally prepared to buy ice cream immediately afterward. Four stars. Great concept, excellent flavors, just a little light on variety. Definitely worth the trip even if the sweet tooth hasn't kicked in yet.... Oh, and it's okay sometimes to have dessert for dinner... and this would be the place for that!

    Photos
    The Baked Bear - Front

    Front

    The Baked Bear - Menu

    Menu

    The Baked Bear - Toasted s'mores ice cream with cookies and cream cookie and biscoff type cookie

    See all

    Toasted s'mores ice cream with cookies and cream cookie and biscoff type cookie

    Cookiehead Bakery

    Cookiehead Bakery

    4.3(65 reviews)
    4.2 mi

    Dessert stop at Cookiehead Bakery (Coral Springs)…read more I was craving something sweet before dinner, so I decided to check out Cookiehead Bakery around 6 pm. I'll be honest--I was expecting a bigger variety of cookies (and maybe some brownies), but at the time they had about 8 cookie options and 2 muffins available. Flavors included: walnut chocolate chip, classic chocolate chip, sugar cookie, Nutella red velvet, golden Oreo cookies & cream, Dubai chocolate, and lemon blueberry. They also offer soft serve, milkshakes, and coffee, which is a nice plus. I went with the last Dubai chocolate cookie ($6.42 with tax). The cookie itself was a little on the dry side, but the chocolate topping was really good and flavorful. Overall: worth trying if you're in the area, especially if you want something different--but I'd love to go back earlier in the day to see a fuller selection.

    Walking into Cookiehead Bakery at 7:30 PM felt like entering a business that had already given up…read moreon itself. The sign says they're open until 10 PM, which apparently is more of a philosophical concept than an actual operating hour. Inside, it was so dim and lifeless that I genuinely questioned whether I was trespassing. No one at the counter. No sound from the back. No sign of human life at all. If a tumbleweed had rolled past the cookie case, it honestly would have fit the mood. And that cookie case? It looked less like a bakery display and more like the aftermath of a clearance sale nobody cared enough to restock. I stood there long enough to go through the full emotional journey from hopeful dessert run to "should I call someone to report this place missing?" before an employee finally appeared out of nowhere like they'd been summoned by confusion itself. Now, maybe I'm being a little harsh, but the vibe was unmistakable: I was interrupting absolutely nothing, and somehow still felt unwelcome. So I did the safe thing and ordered the chocolate chip, figuring if your signature cookie can't deliver, what are we even doing here? A cookie eventually appeared, and after all the suspense, mystery, and accidental haunted-house atmosphere, the payoff was... fine. Better than a gas station cookie, sure, but that is such a low bar it's basically underground. At these prices, I'm expecting bakery magic, not "slightly upgraded convenience store." The whole experience felt like the cookie version of showing up to a party after everyone already left. Dim lights, dead energy, and one lonely chocolate chip cookie trying its best to carry the reputation of the entire place. I've had worse, but not by much. Two stars. One for being technically open, and one because the cookie did, in fact, exist. For what they charge, mediocrity shouldn't feel this committed.

    Photos
    Cookiehead Bakery - Nitro cold brew on tap.

    Nitro cold brew on tap.

    Cookiehead Bakery - Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake

    Cookiehead Bakery - Scorch's Smores

    See all

    Scorch's Smores

    The NY Pizza Place - Tamarac - desserts - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...