We never cook the night before Thanksgiving, so we find a fun, new spot to check out to give the kitchen a break! The Olde Cedar Inn was this year's spot! Plenty of parking in the lot attached to this spot! The interior is small, but very nicely done! It was VERY festive for the holiday season! I understand it was the night before a holiday, but they were definitely understaffed. The three staff members (2 servers and a bartender) were, at times, sprinting through the restaurant to keep everyone happy! They did it with a smile too! Kudos to them, but management should help them out with additional staff on busy days. (We had a reservation for 10 people, they knew it was going to be busy). The food and drinks were alright...the Brandy Old Fashioneds weren't very boozy and the fish fry, while cooked well, didn't have any special flavor. We also waited almost an hour for our appetizers: cheese curds, calamari fries, and zucchini blossoms. I will say that the broasted chicken looked very good, but I didn't have any! Overall, a good bar if you're in the area and wanted some drinks/food but I don't know that it's worth a special trip! read more

See all

Had a group of ten people for a 75th birthday for my spouse. Had reservations at 5 and the waiter was ready to take drink and dinner orders. All the adults order's ribeyes and were done to perfection. The entire staff were friendly and quick to resupply cocktails. I highly recommend anyone wanting a great dinner experience, make a reservation. You will not be disappointed! Steve Ansay read more

Adorable spot, nicely decorated for the holidays. We arrived at 3pm and were the only ones in the seating area. Unfortunately the service was extremely slow. The food was good but nothing spectacular. Got the AYCE shrimp and broasted chicken with their "oven browns" which were underwhelming. I would give the spot another try but would order something else. read more

The Olde Cedar Inn - Inside - New American Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

Some of my most memorable meals have been had in a little side of the road joint that I wouldn't expect to make a lasting impression and Olde Cedar Inn did not disappoint. It is a smaller place and you do feel cramped at the tables. I actually had to move so the waitress could get to the table behind us. We had a reservation so we were able to get seated right away which was a plus! Just plan ahead for that! The prime rib was delicious and, well, pretty prefect! I have wanted to go back for more since we had it! The side salad was standard and the twice baked potato was good enough, but that prime rib keeps people coming back! The fish was on the drier side in my opinion, but the breading was good and it was not soggy. My son ordered the ribeye which was prepared as requested and was very juicy! We would order the prime rib and steak here again! We finished the meal off with a grasshopper because, why not!?!? Yummy little treat not always offered by restaurants anymore. Great service, friendly staff, and good food! Give it a shot for yourself in you are ever in the area. read more

See all

My husband and I love Olde Cedar!!! Mary serves the best homemade desserts and Anthony always has a special Corona Premier ready to go for me. It's cozy, the food is great and so is the service! read more

$100 for 5 dinners and staff couldn't be nicer. Let us cut our own cake and provided free plates, knife and lit the candles. All the food was pretty large portions and served piping hot. read more

The Olde Cedar Inn - Walleye was mammoth - New American Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

First time here on 3/22/25. Was so looking forward to a great steak dinner. Boy BIG MISTAKE! The homemade soup was thick and hardy but no flavor, may I suggest some seasoning! We ordered the Ribeye and shrimp combo. The shrimp arrived hot and fresh. I must say that was the best thing of the dinner. The steak was awful! Mostly fat and tendons? very little meat. Although cooked as ordered had a weird flavor. I personally think it was old and a bit off. Both my husband and I did not even finish 1/4 of the steak. With prices that high quality and flavor is not too much to ask. The twice baked potato was obviously instant with some cheese mixed in. Will not be back and do not recommend. read more

Went for dinner with friends. It had been highly recommended. Small place but we had a reservation and got seated quickly. I had a steak but it had a fair amount of fat and gristle. They don't have good steaks like new york which i prefer due to less fat and gristle. The steak was ok. Our friends ate sandwiches and i think they thought they were pretty good. Portion sizes were good. But i don't think any of the 4 of us are planning a return visit. There are enough restaurants that knock our socks off that we don't have to settle for anything less. read more

My usual go to for an all you can eat fish fry on Fridays is currently closed for lunch due to cutting hours for the current COVID-19 pandemic, so that led me to seeking out a different place for lunch on a Friday off from work. When I pulled up to Olde Cedar Inn I realized I had been here before, but could only remember that I didn't particularly love whatever meal/experience I had at that time. Regardless, I stayed and ended up having the all you can eat haddock with french fries. There's only one restaurant I've ever been to that has decent crinkle cut french fries (coincidentally that's the restaurant I mentioned above that's currently closed during lunch). Olde Cedar Inn is just another one on the list of bad crinkle cut french fries. Yes, they were cooked fine. No, they had no flavor at all. I'm so thankful that there was ketchup on the table because, even though I'm not normally a ketchup person, it was needed. There were other potato options available when I ordered, but unfortunately potato pancakes was not one of them and I regret not choosing anything else. This alone cost them a star on my rating. The breading on the haddock was certainly crispy. Unfortunately, it also absorbed much of the oil that it was cooked in so the plate was a bit greasy. I was also surprised at just how much the breading overpowered the flavor of the haddock, which isn't a unflavorful fish. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. Nothing was done to distance customers and neither of the two staff members I saw were wearing masks at any point during my visit. As I've mentioned in other reviews, I don't care if you don't want to wear a mask to protect yourself during the current COVID-19 pandemic. That you won't wear one to help protect your customers or try to seat customers apart from each other is flat out irresponsible. The place was fairly empty when I got there, but as my meal progressed more people came in and the staff was constantly trying to sit customers at tables right next to each other instead of intentionally spreading them out. Now that I'm leaving a review I have a reminder as to why I've decided to not go back. Hopefully you will avoid Olde Cedar Inn as well. read more

See all

We had a reservation on 6/2 for 11 people. Got seated promptly and got our sodas/coffee and ordered. We waited 1 hour and 20 minutes for our food. Many people that arrived after us got their meal and left before we were even served. No explanation no "I'm sorry". Very difficult with several elderly and two young children. Food was okay-nothing special just chicken and burgers. Would not visit again. read more

Quaint restaurant that my cousin's family and I love to go to. Andy says it is the best Prime Rib he has had in years. I loved the broasted chicken. If you like a small area restaurant you will love Cedar Inn! read more

I had been hearing that it was hit or miss here but I see no evidence of any real miss. This is a small, no frills but charming, spot (The bar area is a bit more festive with some great outdoorsy decor). We stopped in mid-week for lunch. I had the Mushroom Swiss Burger and it was delicious; juicy and cooked to a perfect temp medium. Two of my lunch mates order different chicken wraps (one grilled and the other breaded) - they both really liked them. You can get homemade chips or, hello...Krinkle Fries! Krinkle Fries are never wrong. Never. Another in our party, ordered a Taco Salad. It was the one thing we found a little different...typically Taco Salad is served in a fried tortilla bowl. This order came out on a bed of tortilla chips. I'll quote him: "I mean, I ordered a salad and got nachos but okay...nachos are cool." We weren't sure if this is always how it's prepared or if it was improvised and the taco meat, itself was delicious, but the overall presentation and lack of additional toppings you would want on either a salad or nachos was noticeable. Service was fine. Although a little slow- it was slow because our server was doing everything- front of house: bartending, waitressing, hosting and checking people in/out, etc. Seeing her hustle and still smile and treat people warmly - made any of our impatience subside. She was great. We all agreed we would be back. Looking forward again for lunch or dinner. read more

Broasted chicken is some of the best I've ever had. The staff was attentive and the drinks were well poured.

Good food baad service. Ayce smelt fry people seated after us got smelt and drink refills.we had to try to almost tackle someone to get refills. They need to stop forgetting about tables for 2 read more

Great service every time. Love the tap beer options. Highly recommend the fish fry Fridays, the other menu items weren't anything special but the fish is as good as it gets! read more

We've been going here for years and the food is consistently delicious and the service is always friendly. We love their wings, fish fry, ribs and burgers. I also love their lakeside delivery service. They bring your order to the boat launch via golf cart. Pro tip: order a boozy grasshopper ice cream drink for the boat. Yum!! read more

There was a substantial wait and it came recommended so we were excited. Beer selection was modest and cocktails were more classic than craft. If you're down with the "same old same" than this might be the visit. Food was okay at best. Haddock and perch was very fishy. Burger was just meh. Everything was super greasy. Fired foods are classic "bar food" classics. Poured from a bag into the fryer, nothing more. Service was not so good. Very much of a "I don't care" attitude This one, regrettably, won't make into our rotation read more

Seemed like a very popular restaurant . We went on a couple different recommendations. We both had fried fish. We both found the fish and the fries overcooked. Might be a favorite for others, but we would not recommend. read more

We had reservations for 4 PM but several of our party were VERY LATE due to an airplane that landed late in Milwaukee! The staff was so kind to us, they worked hard to serve us and provided both a wonderful meal and fantastic service! I can't compliment them enough for their graciousness to us. THANK YOU OLDE CEDAR INN for making our out-of-state guests feel so welcomed! read more

Stopped late on a Sunday afternoon. It's not just a tavern and but not quite a restaurant...it's an inn. Nice bar and 11 tables. Very clean and comfortable. Staff were very friendly. My wife ordered the broasted chicken. She reports the chicken was crispy and moist. Could use just a bit more seasoning in the batter, but other than that it was delicious. Unless you are really hungry, order the 4 piece dinner and skip on the all you can it. I had the gourmet burger. Really really good. Ordered it medium rare and that's what I got. A few other things we learned talking with locals...the Friday Fish is very popular. Wednesday pasta night is also big. And if you like ice cream drinks, they offer over 30 different kinds. read more

The Olde Cedar Inn - Burger with all the fixings - New American Near Me - West Bend, Wisconsin

Unless your a local..don't bother! Ordered the black and blue burger was disappointing and doesn't include fries or chips. 10.99 for a burger. Smoking burger was good. People came in after us and had faster and much better service. read more

Went here for a Friday fish fry and we were really disappointed. The wait was over an hour and a half - we were expecting something over an hour but not that long. It could have been cut down to about an hour but a table of four that was finished sat for an extra 45 minutes taking. They knew people were waiting but apparently didn't care and no one from the restaurant stepped in to offer them seats in the bar or another alternative. Our food was mediocre and definitely not worth the wait. The cole slaw was terrible and the perch was bland. The baked cod was cooked well but also under seasoned. With so many other options in the area I would steer clear of this place especially on a Friday evening. read more

We just had a late lunch here, it was our first time visiting.... but the first of many! The broasted chicken was amazing, the prices are very reasonable and the staff was great. Our 3 yo wouldn't sit still so the staff let her help clear the tables She loved it. Thank you to the the crew working today. You made our little girl's day and really made us feel welcomed . Looking forward to our next visit already! read more

First of all, I really like this little hole in the wall joint. The Old Fashion's are terrific, it's a lively place and the entire staff is there to make the crowd happy. The fish fry and chicken are ace. However, we were referred to them for the "smelt" fry on WED's and although the flavor was okay, the light-battered platters of fish were mediocre as far as actual "fish size" go. In other words, the smelt were mostly very flat, limited on fish meat itself, hard deep-fried crunchy bits. I felt like we were simply filling up on over-fried breading itself and that was disappointing. read more

I have never sat down to eat here we usually order our food to go. I have never had a bad meal from here. Our food is always hot when we bring it home, and everything always taste so good! We order the chef salad and split it up between 6 people very big, and filling. read more

As a first reviewer, I really enjoyed their Friday Fish Fry as well as their food. However, the restaurant itself is small but they make up for it by having their bar filled with a wide selection of liquor. In conclusion, I would recommend this place for anyone who like fish and their delicious meats. read more

Stopped in when our initial destination didn't pan out. The cheese curds were the best I've ever had. My husband and sister agreed with me that this was a very nice find. The staff were very friendly and attentive and the food was very good. read more

Good portions of perch and broasted chicken! Make reservations as it is very popular! Friendly atmosphere! We will return!

The food is fabulous ! I dine in once a week either a Friday or Saturday evening. The Friday night fish fry's are terrific with very generous portions. The Saturday night Prime rib is great as well. If you are a lighter eater the small is perfect. If you are a normal eater the medium is good for you. If you like to take some home then get the large. The large is so big and thick there will be enough to eat tomorrow. The waitresses are very helpful and care about their customers. read more

Excellent. We consider this a "find" & will be returning with a friend who is a professional chef. Homemade creative soups and great Key West walleye. Cocktails also suburb! read more

Ordered black and. Blue burger. Burger was delicious but the bun was a bit dry. My friend had the rib eye steak sandwich and said it was very good and said she would order it again. Very nice atmosphere and service was good. read more

Overpriced. The food was okay. Service was slow and had to ask repeatedly for drinks or anything we needed. Was very loud and noisy.