I've been a regular customer since 1994 (originally their Harrison store) by now frequent their Tryon location. Love their pizza, and Stromboli read more

People!!!!! Please get this pizza it's absolutely BANGIN deliciousness!!!! Plus the guy gave me a bonus piece of 1 I've never tried so major thanks to him!!!! I come from Benson to get this because its THAT DAMN GOOD!!!!!!!! They also have lotsa other yumminess to eat too if ur not a pizza pie fan! read more

3.75 for Cheese Slice. Great Budget Friendly Option. Fresh handmade pizza. The dough, sauce and cheese are fresh for the price. Pizza a little on the greasy side, I don't mind though, personally. I will be back! read more

See all

Still yummy after all these years just more $$$ though unfortunately. But for an occasional treat, by the slice, it hits the spot. read more

See all

I grew up in Brooklyn, so I always approach "NY style pizza" with apprehension. The first thing I noticed was that it smelled like a NY pizzeria. The pies and the Sicilian looked like I remember, so my hopes were high. The staff were super helpful and quick. And when I finally ate that slice, I was instantly transported back to Brooklyn in the early 90's. By far, the best pizza I've had outside of New York in 30 years. Highly recommend! read more

The best pizza in the area (I'm slightly biased being a NY ex-pat). Always good, remarkably accurate ready estimates for online orders, some NYC decor, and friendly staff. read more

Pizza is always great! I have been getting pizza from here for years! Staff always friendly . Highly recommend

So I found this place by accident and I'm glad I did was in cary for work and wanted something quick and close so I decided to try it anytime I see ny style pizza I laugh being from nyc the pizza never looks or taste like nyc pizza but I soon as I walked in the smell took me back home to the bronx the decor was also a great reminder of my city and somethings I miss about home I talked to the manager/owner for a minute but when I saw the slices I knew the pizza had a chance that first bite was heaven the cheese pull was awesome the crust was crispy it wasn't doughy the sauce was just right I really enjoyed my pepperoni slice at this gem of a pizzeria so next time I'm in cary I know where I'm stopping thank you for the experience oh sorry no pics it was gone before I thought about it Please check this place out if you want a ny slice read more

This place has fantastic pizza but unfortunately the staff is where it falls short. I prefer NY pizza to anything else so I try to stay away from "fast food" pizza and have loved this place for years. I recently had a delivery driver get very confrontational with me. As a solo female, I am very cautious of the situations I put myself in and this one made me feel unsafe. I did call the store to let them know and was met with more animosity. I hate to say it, but I will not be ordering from this location ever again. read more

This has been our go to pizza place for the past 30 years and was always a great experience until last night. Ordered large cheese pie and it was almost inedible. Very little sauce and almost no cheese. read more

Pizza spot on food every New Yorker would know pizza like this is just like back home

I'm a bit disheartened to write a comment about our recent purchases. My half of the pizza always requests onion & I always add a note to request that it be THIN SLICES. Thick chunks of onion actually makes a pizza very unpleasant in taste, in my opinion. I feel if I'm paying nearly $40 for a pizza (plus tax/delivery/tip) that I should at least like my pizza. I'll stop asking for onion when I order from them again, and picked off the onion chunks that I paid for, of course - but would hope next time they'd take a moment to call a customer (before just throwing on whatever they have around) to see if they're ok with an alternate item than what the customer specifically requested. read more

This is hands down our absolute favorite pizza place! We always head here when we want a pie. The owners are great to work with on events, and they are supportive of our community! Additionally, when we moved to Cary we were so worried about finding authentic NY style pizza with great flavor. This pizza is consistently the best! We love Original NY! read more

I am done with these guys, spent way too much money for subpar pizza. They don't respond to complaints so why bother.

*** update*** The pizza is now better than the garlic knots. The garlic knots weren't as good as I remember them from two years ago. Not sure if it was because I ate them after they had cooled down a bit. BUT the cheese pizza, Omg. So freaking good. I would 10/10 recommend getting a slice. read more

The Original NY Pizza - Best Garlic Knots in Raleigh !!! - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Food is always good. Service is good. Always a great place to go for a pizza or sandwich.

I got the almost everything pizza, and there was barely anything on it, especially not pepperoni. So disappointed. This has happened my last two times. I spoke with management and asked why it was different from two years ago when the pizza was overflowing with plentiful toppings. And by the way, of course the price has increased dramatically. I'm done with New York pizza. read more

Good pizza even cold. nothing earth shattering but very solid choice. It's a great slice and drink spot to me.

Great crust otherwise so-so. Looks like more take out business than sit down. Clean restaurant and pizza maker/server/cashier (all in one) was pleasant and accommodating. read more

Pretty good pizza. The crust is thicker than what I expect for NY pizza but it was chewy and crunchy, with a great taste. I also ordered a Caesar Salad which was good. The service was decent. My family and I went there for a late lunch on a Friday afternoon so it wasn't too busy and we didn't have to wait too long for our food. Ordered the Meat Supreme pizza, size X Large, so it was a good size for all 4 of us. They have stromboli, calzone, and different kinds of pizza. They also have a few sweets, too, like cannoli. Their lunch special is well priced. I would come here again if I want a pizza for lunch and I was in Cary. read more

The Original NY Pizza - the interior of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

This is probably the closest thing to NY style pizza that I've gotten since moving here. We ordered a medium cheese pizza and it was obviously the best it can be since it was fresh but honestly felt like something was still missing from true NY pizza. The service we received was excellent and the guys behind the counter are super nice! I am still on my hunt for the best pizza but for now this is the one I'll be going for when I'm craving a good slice. read more

See all

The usual NY greasy 2 slice walk-in order. I'm sure it would be much better if I had ordered a fresh whole pie. But I was feeding the belly not the soul. Very convenient to Wake Med Cary- when you're tired of vending food. read more

The quality of pizza is very good. However I ordered 2 large pepperoni pizzas at a total of $48. Just for 2 one topping pies. Absolutely ludicrous. Instead I opted to get 2 Costco pizzas at $21. Less than half and the pie is slightly larger. The only main difference is Original is thin and Costco is a thicker crust. Customer service skills are low at Original. There was no apology or how can we earn your business offer. These places are outright scamming the consumer. We rarely eat out and opt to cook at home at a fraction of the cost of eating out. These places will keep taking advantage of consumers until we all stand up and stop buying from them. Force them to return their prices to reasonable levels. read more

One of the best NY style pizza places left in the Triangle. Their pizza consistently tastes great every (!) single (!) time (!) and their toppings are awesome too. Love the NY posters and wall decor. The only thing missing is an arcade machine. I really miss the shop that used to be at High House Crossing. They were closer to where I live and they would deliver. I really wish they would come back but the rental greed must be just too much, I guess. read more

The Original NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Great pizza always, true New York style. A classic cheese slice from this place will get you right.

Decor is nothing special but the pizza is fantastic. I got a few slices of cheese. The crust is thin and crisp and toppings light making it a fantastic combination. Prices and service were also welcoming. read more

The Original NY Pizza - a jar of nuts and a salt shaker - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

See all

This was my first time trying this even though I've lived in Cary my whole life. My boyfriend just moved to the area and wanted pizza but not "just pizza", he wanted "real pizza." I'd seen this place when I get groceries at Lowe's, and decided it was time to try it. Oh, my god, we are never going back to fast food pizza ever again. We got 3 small things to split. An eggplant parmesan pizza, a stuffed veggie pizza, and their "pasta pot pie." We ate ourselves silly that night. The eggplant parm pizza was definitely the fave a the cheese was rich and not greasy and the crust was so good that even my boyfriend ate them, and he usually doesn't. The stuffed pizza was cheesy with well-cooked veggies and reheated great for my lunch the next day (my coworkers were jealous). The pasta was very different and was rich with ricotta and a meat sauce that was, simply put, a pizza lasagna, but with ziti. And we loved it. Everything about this was wonderful. And their online ordering is super easy and let me choose when to pick up, so the whole experience was a huge win for me. We will DEFINITELY be back soon. read more

See all

Great pizza! Fast delivery! We had an extra large pepperoni, a large cheese, small white garden pizza and Greek salads. Everything was delicious!! And truly like NY pizza. read more

I am from New York and this pizza was pretty good, living in NY most of my life I know good pizza and I am glad I found a good pizza place here read more

I'm constantly on the prowl for great pizza and consider it to be a foundation food. After moving into the Raleigh area, I immediately went straight to NY Pizza on Tryon based upon the reviews I found on the web. And it pretty much delivers on its name. While I'll always have a special place in my heart for New Haven style pizza, NY style is a close second. At NY Pizza they sell by the slice or you can get a small or large pie. I stick with the basic cheese as a purist. Good pizza requires a good crust and NY Pizza does it right. Thin with a little bit of chewiness. Sauce and cheese coverage is good, balanced evenly between the two with good ingredients. The pie itself is quite large with big, foldable slices. At $13+, it's not cheap but worth it if you need a quick fix. Outside of pizza, they've got calzones (which look pretty good) but that's about it for the menu! You can do pick-up or sit inside the small seating area, service is decent but can be a bit slow at times. The kids working the joint are nice but not always on top of things. I've had to wait an additional 15 to 20 minutes for my pie due to slow service. Overall, I like the place and would recommend it to people looking for NY style pizza. Rock on! read more

This pizza is pretty good. Only knock is they could sometimes cook it a smidgeon longer. The taste and quality is there though. 7.4 on the one bite score. Very happy to have these guys nearby. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in the area. Living in New England for the past 17 years, I frequently visit New York City. This pizza is spot on! read more

Due to a communication error we ended up with a pizza different from what we thought we ordered. I reached out to Original NY Pizza and they immediately said they would get a pizza out to us. I told them to please charge us for the "incorrect" pizza as I was sure someone may eat some of it. They refused to charge us and had the replacement pizza to us in under 30 minutes. We order here often and this is just another example of how well they take care of their customers. Thank you! read more

This is my go-to pizza place. Pizza is about as good as it gets! Johnnys is their high end pizza competition and I take Original NY pizza any day. Pizza is really good. Only downside is their wings. They are REALLY bad. Like "I can't believe they are selling these things" bad. My suggestion would be fry them up and: Medium = Franks + butter Hot = Franks + a little butter BBQ = Sweat Baby Rays Its pretty much that simple. Whenever we're getting pizza and wings I always get pizza here and wings else ware. read more

This has to be the worst pizza I have had in 25 years in the triangle. Look at how the toppings separate from the crust. No taste, little to no cheese......the worst read more

The Original NY Pizza - a slice of pizza on a blue plate - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Pizza is great hot. Occasionally, the kids just don't get it hot enough. Still love it. Restaurant doesn't ever actually seem clean. read more

Overall ok pizza but I only tried the white slice. Being from NY this fell short. Not enough ricotta and was just lacking flavor. read more

The Original NY Pizza - White slice - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Good pizza!! Quick pickup and a good deal. 18 inch cheese pizza and garlic knots for $20. Would recommend. read more

The Original NY Pizza - Cheese pizza & garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Cary, North Carolina

Great food great service!! Always on point everytime I go there food is very good . Great quality and great prices, restaurant is also very clean read more

Maybe the best pizza I've had. Been here multiple times. A tad inconsistent but overall great.