Excellent Dutch apple pie. Was going back one fur Thanksgiving but since my cupboards are bare, it was cheaper and easier to pick one up.

Bright and friendly shop with amazing blueberry slab pie! All the other treats are delicious, too! We got blueberry slab, a key lime tart, a thick truffle and a delightful, huge sugar cookie bar AND coffee, all for about $15. We seek out Pie shops everywhere we travel because we make a lot of pies in our home and want to compare and discover new things, and this place impressed us. We love places where you can get single servings of pie, and that's a great option here. But they do also have full pies, cakes and other custom options. read more

See all

Let me start out by saying that the only reason I'm not 5-starring the store is that I've only tried one item...so far! I needed a peach pie for a friend's birthday party, and, you know how sometimes you'd just rather have a root canal than bake? Yeah, so that was me this time. I looked up a couple of bakeries near me, and they didn't seem to sell what I needed, so I dug waaaaay back in my brain and remembered "The Pie Place". While no longer convenient to me, it IS pretty convenient to the birthday girl's place, so I ordered my peach pie, which I'd pick up about an hour before the party. One note: the little strip mall in which the store is located is a nightmare to exit due to traffic and lights, but this was, as it turned out, a small price to pay. The store itself was not busy when I got there. It's very bright and clean, and oh my GOD, the baked goods on display!! I would have GLADLY just pulled up a chair and dug in, but, decorum, you know. The pie was $20 ( no tax if you pay in cash!), which I didn't think was bad given the place, the item, and the high cost of EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE! I never looked at the pie until we opened it at the party, but it was GORGEOUS! Latticed with twists of sugared pie crust, STUFFED with peaches. And it tasted as good as it looked! I liked the fact that it wasn't super sweet--a lot of pies ARE, to disguise the fact that the fruit tastes like sawdust. Just really pleased with this, and another special occasion will have me heading back! read more

I have found my favorite pastry shop in the Pittsburgh area in The Pie Place. I find their offerings exceptional because everything is fresh, well balanced and most importantly, not overly sweet. The women that work there are professional, knowledgable, and always in a great mood. I have traveled a good distance to savor one of their pies or brownies with a delicious cup of coffee. I've ordered pies from them and they are always done on time and were actually still warm. I can't say enough about this hidden away little gem. read more

We tried the Chicken Pot Pie that I purchased frozen and cooked t home. WE LOVED IT! Let me start that if you are on a cleanse diet, this isn't for you. It is DECADENT with a double butter crust and a rich, creamy, chicken filling. It tastes homemade BECAUSE it's homemade. The only suggestion I would make is to suggest an internal temperature for doneness; I took it out at 125*. read more

Place is amazing, great idea with the take home pie kits my daughter got a kick out of the concept!

Excellent baked goods (a bit pricey but worth it). But more importantly, they did a great job with handling my daughter's 7th birthday party. We had the unusual situation of having every kid rsvp yes, so we had 14 kids (their limit is 15). We did the cupcake decorating party. Each kid decorated their cupcake box when we got there. They learned how they make the icing, and then each got to decorate and take home 4 cupcakes. We had pizza, and they each got an additional cupcake to eat there to celebrate the birthday. The staff was great with this bunch of boisterous little girls- very patient and kind. read more

I just fell in love with the pie place and I feel like this will be a long time affair. While I've been trying to stay away from sweets, I had a craving last Saturday that wouldn't go away so my husband and I decided to pick items up from here. I had tasted some of their pies before from work but never been in. We went in around 20 to 7 and they still had a decent selection. The associate working told me they don't sell slices of anything but have minis available in mostly every pie flavor. I opted for a mini banana creme & chocolate peanut butter pie and also got a fudge brownie. While ringing me up I was told that since it was national pie day I could select a free mini fruit pie- such a nice touch! I went with Apple. We ate the brownie on the way home because I couldn't resist and it was honestly INSANE. Hands down the absolute best brownie I've ever eaten and I've been having dreams about it ever since. Seriously, I've told anyone who will listen about this brownie. It's the perfect combination of fudgy, gooey, soft, decadent, rich flavor. The pies were good too but both my husband and I surprisingly loved the banana creme the most out of the other flavors! It wasn't too sweet and had the perfect amount of banana flavor. We shared everything but a mini pie is enough to get a taste for things and will also fill you up quickly bc the flavors are rich. No doubt I will be back (probably tomorrow) to try some other pie flavors and of course, get a brownie. Seriously people the brownie is life changing! read more

Everything here is made in house and is done very well. Everyone here was so very nice and seemed to take great pride in their work. There were several desserts to choose from, even though we had arrived later in the day. Some of the prices were a little more expensive than what you could find elsewhere but we were very pleased with what we got!! (New York Style Cheesecake) read more

Decent pies. Crust isn't consistent and sometimes it's thicker than I like. Big fan of the cobblers and the mini pies are super cute and make for nice gifts. Hope to visit your booth at the farmers market this Spring. read more

With a name like the Pie Place, who would have thought that they actually have a large selection of sweet treats to purchase? Not I. That's why I had yet to visit the Pie Place. When I did stop by, I was surprised by the selection! Cakes (slices), brownies, cookies, cobbler, cupcakes, mini tarts and Betsy's ice cream! (That's right. You can get your Pittsburgh Pride right here). I decided on a brownie, a slice of almond tort cake, a square of the apple cobbler and (of course) half a pint of Pittsburgh Pride ice cream. After trying it all, I have to say the almond tort cake was moist and delicious (I have no idea how they sell it sliced and it still tastes that good) but, the Apple cobbler was fantastic warmed with whipped cream. Overall, the quality was wonderful but quality comes at a price. Each item I purchased was near $4 each. So, go there and try everything but know that your wallet will be a bit lighter than you'd like. read more

I was so happy to find this place to provide dessert and some snacks for a shower I was planning. I ordered two cream pies, brownies, apple strudel, and pepperoni rolls. All the items were oversized, so I appreciated (when ordering over the phone) being talked through how many I would need to feed 30 people. Everything tasted divine. The only minor problem was how the pie crust just crumbled and made cutting the pies into scooping the pies (still a fun way to eat!). Everyone couldn't stop talking about how perfect the pepperoni rolls were too! When I went to pick up the order, the inside of the shop was adorable with so many desserts and treats. The place looked to be decorated for a kid's birthday party too (makes mental note for future parties). read more

This place is great! They don't do pie slices but they have minis of most of their pies. Also, they have pie pops! read more

The Pie Place - Pie pops! - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

So thrilled Pie Place participates in the Green Tree Farmer's Market! The cinnamon buns are super! Love their fresh fruit tarts but the light, delicious crust crumbles easily. If you buy & haul home do w/care! Looking forward to trying more of their goodies. Fresh fruit crumble, pepperoni rolls and much more. Prices very reasonable, excellent quality, all fresh. Stopped by the store a few years ago but haven't been in a while due to traffic & construction detours mostly. Bottom line, this is a great little bakery. If you can't get to their store then check the website for other Farmer's Market locations that may be closer to you. Shop local, buy local and support small local businesses like The Pie Place. , read more

Recently ordered a double layered birthday cake with raspberry filling for my 8yr old. Her theme was "the movies." Ordering the cake was extremely easy, quick, and pleasant. They had no problem with the design of the cake for the theme. The price was extremely reasonable, pick up was very easy and the cake looked amazing and exactly what we had ordered. By far one of the best tasting cakes I have ever had. The cake was moist, fresh raspberries for their filling and we had so many comments of how delicious it was. I highly recommend The Pie Place for any future cake orders. read more

I ordered a few pies for Christmas. It was the first time I ordered pies there and I will not go back! The cream pies had the toppings falling off of them. They tasted fair! The fruit pies Di not look very appetizing! I had 30 people for a Christmas party and my guests ate the other desserts , but not the pies. read more

Finally tried this place with much excitement just to be let down. I got my favorite, a lemon meringue pie. Unfortunately, it tasted of just sweet on top of sweet and zero tart (or lemon flavor at all if I'm being honest)to balance the pie. Also, it seemed as if they hadn't made enough merengue to cover the entire pie. 18 dollars for a tasteless pie. Would not recommend. read more

When I visit friends, this place is a must! The name speaks for itself, all homemade and super yummy :)

The baked goods are very high quality and ample in size. The pies are delicious, especially the Dutch apple pie. There are also coffee options, pepperoni rolls, and much more. The service is fast and friendly. Great music playing in the shop! read more

The Pie Place's New York cheesecake is incredible and my personal favorite. I've also noticed the prices are very generous with respect to portions. Very clean and friendly atmosphere. Highly recommended. read more

I ordered a peach pie for Father's Day and we thought it was just okay. The filling was fine -peaches were just the right texture and the sweetness was just right. But the crust was absolutely tasteless and dry and it had no luster or shine to it (guessing they didn't do an egg wash). It was nice to not have to worry about baking dessert, but for 17$, I expected a really great pie. I wish I had just gone to Costco. read more

One of the best bakeries in the South Hills. I always liked Bartram House but found this place to be a lot better. The name throws you off because I only thought they served pies. Excellent cupcake selection and those cupcakes were awesome!! read more

If you are craving pie, or any dessert frankly, this is a place you should check out. I have had this bookmarked since I moved to the area 3 months ago and finally got a chance to check it out this past weekend. Not the most exciting interior, could use a coat of exciting paint to cheer the place up! The cases were filled with whole pies, mini pies, cookies, crumbles, cakes, biscotti (the biggest I have ever seen!) and more. We went with a mini pecan pie, mixed berry tart, mini lemon meringue pie and a peanut butter cookie. The cookie was disappointing, hardly any peanut butter flavor. I was really looking forward to that so I wasn't thrilled :( The pies and tarts have pretty thick pastry, thicker that I think it should be, however, it is very flaky and does have nice flavor. I loved the filling in the pecan pie but would pass on the mixed berry next time, too many seeds in that one. My husband got a serving of the cherry cobbler, he said it was terrific, a little tart and a nice and sugary crumble to compliment. They had a 15% military discount. read more

The absolute best pie in Pittsburgh! This little bake shop has a ton of heart and a passion for pies. They are beautiful, handcrafted with love, and delicious. Seasonal flavors and classic staples, this is the only place I'll go for my Thanksgiving pies or pies for my Dad, who prefers them over birthday cake every year. They also have an assortment of cake, cookies, and strudel. An absolute Pittsburgh gem! read more

Everything that I have tasted in this shoppe is fantastic. Double chocolate cupcakes, fruit tarts, brownies, and they also have some gluten free items. Marybeth is super nice also. I highly recommend this local business! read more

I can't find anything bad about The Pie Place. I get my pies from there every holiday and they have always been amazing. Also, the pepperoni rolls are absolutely amazing. I think the pepperoni rolls may just be the best thing there they are so good. I highly recommend it. read more

Oatmeal cookies are great and coconut cream pie, too! Nice selection of breakfast treats. Always place an order for any holiday and get rave reviews from dinner guest whenever I serve one of their tarts. My go-to bakery. read more

DISGUSTING PIES AND BAD BUSINESS PRACTICES! This place is the worst! Bought a peach pie here one evening. Went to eat it the next morning. And it was loaded with mold. My wife took it back that morning. The owner told her that it was our fault for not storing properly for the 12 hours we actually had it at our house. She asked him to explain how, even if we had not stored it properly, it could have a disgusting amount of mold on it. He finally gave her our money back after an extended confrontational discussion. STAY AWAY! read more