Visited Jamestown for the first time... the moment we walked in we knew we were going to like this place. Sam, the bartender, greeted us like we were family. Had their Goulash & stuffed shells with homemade meatballs for dinner. Delicious!! Went back for lunch the next day to try their "The Big Guy " beef on weck. Definitely a must if you visit. Should we ever come back here, this will be the first place we stop!! read more

My Wife, my Son and myself trekked to Jamestown to visit The National Comedy Center. We parked in a ramp and headed for the destination. My well traveled son pointed out the Pub. We entered. It had the throwback ambiance that I like. The Bartender let out with a sincere greeting. Such hospitality, the waitress that lead us to our table was more than cheerful and welcoming. Once again my reaction was;" Such hospitality." My son pointed out they don't take credit cards. My reaction? Oh Hell thats not very hospital. My point? You're in the hospitality industry! Heavens above be hospital! My Wife and Son enjoyed their selections. I would have enjoyed my Ziti with Vodka Sauce much more if the sauce been hotter. On our way out the waitress bid us a cheerful and sincere farewell. The Bar Keep expressed their gratitude. For me the attempt at hospitality fell short. You know why. read more

always fun at the pub, good Italian food at reasonable prices. fun old atmosphere that reminds you of the early days in Jamestown New York.

What a wonderful little treasure hidden in downtown Jamestown New York. We stopped and asked a local where a good place to eat was and he recommended this place and I'm very glad he did, the food is wonderful it's a nice little cozy place with a great atmosphere and a lot of great choices they have some specials on the board and wonderful desserts and a lot to drink a lot yeah. read more

The Pub - Eggplant parmesan sandwich yummy - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

A true pub. Cordial. A fabulous Beef on Weck. It was an amazing find near the Luci and Desi Museum. It's definitely worth the stop!

The Beef on Weck was excellent. It's a nice traditional pub. The service was good. Looks like a lot of locals frequent the pub.

Reslly enjoyed our visit. Super friendly staff. Prompt service. Excellent food. A "must see" on you list if things to do in Jamestown. They say the peanut butter pie is very good. read more

We found this restaurant from another Yelp review. There were 4 of us. We tried stuffed banana peppers, sausage ravioli, beef on weck , and Angel hair pasta with meatballs. Everything was excellent. The bartender was a great conversationalist too. He gave us some great tips for the area. We enjoyed our dinner so much we went back 2 nights later. The food and people who work here make this a great place. read more

Anyone looking for the "enter as a stranger, leave as a friend" kind of place, must visit The Pub. Be sure to glance at the menu and make a selection of what to fill your belly with. You won't be disappointed. FYI - CASH ONLY (ATM onsite). You'll have the high likelihood of meeting a few local patrons and be ready laugh, not at them but with them. So thrilled to have been recommended to stop by and check it out. Well worth it and will be sure to stop by when I'm in the area again. FYI - CASH ONLY (ATM onsite) read more

The Pub - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

The Beef on Weck was awesome and I highly recommend it! This place was a great find off Interstate 86. The Asiago and Artichoke dip was pretty good but would be great if it was served with Italian bread instead of nachos. read more

The Pub - The Pub bar - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

LOVE LOVE LOVE. Favorite place in Jamestown for sure! The bartenders and servers are so friendly and make you feel at home! The bar is set up in an unconventional way and you will love it! Now let's talk about how amazing their food is. Every single soup is fantastic and without a doubt must be homemade (I forgot to ask). They have simple and fun appetizers as well as everything under the sun for entrees. The weekends are incredibly busy so try heading there on a week night! read more

The Pub offers a sort of lounge atmosphere to it, conducive to good conversation and relaxing drinks at reasonable prices. In fact, it is a little more upscale than the average bars in the area generally catering to a more 30 something age group. The best food is the beef on weck, but it's all well done, sitting in its juices in a stainless container. It certainly isn't anything like the beef on weck you'll find in other places equipped with a carving station, but since there aren't any such places in Jamestown, this is about the best beef on weck you can find. read more

I am glad we found this little gem in Jamestown. It has a nondescript front but don't let that deter you. It was packed on this Friday evening. We both had pasta - me stuffed shells with meatball and husband had penne with meatball. Both excellent with the smooth red sauce. I am so glad we found this restaurant. Don't forget to check out the diner next door for breakfast. Friendly staff, fast service, good prices and good food. read more

This place is awesome, you have to check it out. We were visiting to see the Lucy museam, national comedy center and stopped here for a bite. The artichoke dip is great and the greek salad and goat cheese salad are great! Also the staff is super friendly and ever a little funny. read more

Fantastic bartenders and such a brilliant idea that they can make most meals in front of you. Do not skimp on dessert. The peanut butter pie is delicious. read more

We stop into The Pub whenever we get a chance, it is always a wonderful experience and with the best food, great drinks and a perfection of service. Thanks Sam and Ashley! read more

The Pub - Osso Buco with mashed potatoes. - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

Really enjoyed this place while in town for hockey. Excellent service and most of us got pasta dishes for a late lunch. Cash only!

Not too many choices to eat in Jamestown when we were there to visit the Lucy Museums....Stopped in here and was quite surprised.....the service was excellent and quite helpful..Our server, can't remember his name....was so friendly, gave us some tips around town. Cash only.....but so worth it..Watch out for parking in Jamestown...There is only a 2 hour limit, unless you pay the meter... Had pizza, excellent the roast beef on weck.... Def. the best stop in Jamestown read more

How about a total step back in time to the golden era of postwar America? It feels like you walked back into 1949 or so. Sandwiches and a bar, no credit cards. Red naugahyde booths with Formica table tops, faux brick on the walls with smoky beer mirrors and fish tanks. Music and TV at reasonable levels, and people can hear each other speak in normal tones. In Manhattan they'd spend a fortune to re-create this; this place just still is. The atmosphere makes up the whole experience. Bet it'd be terrific to come in in the middle of winter. Beef on Weck was just fine, they serve the local craft beer, which was great too. read more

The Pub - Basic old school. - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

After receiving terrible service at Lisciandro's, my sister and I decided to eat at The Pub. We received wonderful service! I had their Rachel. It was delicious! The only thing I'd change is that I'd offer French Fries as a choice instead of potato chips. read more

The spicy pepper soup is the best soup my wife and I have ever had. Hands down. It is some combination of pepper, beef ,cream and rice. Wow. That was just the beginning of our experience. Best beef on wick I have ever had, then hot stuffed peppers. The staff and bartender were outstanding. I highly recommend this place. I will even say this even as we were sitting there for lunch and the fire alarm went off somewhat interrupting our lunch. I would sit through five fire alarms for this atmosphere and food. read more

I'm a local and I love this place. The Pub is very similar to a pub that you would find in the UK. The interior is intimate and quiet. You can sit down to cold drinks, amazing food and great conversation. A lot of the food is made from scratch and does not disappoint. My favorites are the Pub burger and Mary's Lasagna. Try the ice cream lasagna if there's any left! read more

The Pub - Pub burger - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

See all

Walking in my initial impression was, this is going to be an Irish Pub, with all the beautiful wood, booths, and leaded glass. But apparently this is an "Italian" Pub and the food was really good although it is not fancy and prices are reasonable. We were told everything is made in house and it tasted like it. The choice of pasta sauces were all excellent and very smooth. We actually went back the next day and ate again we enjoyed it that much. Being in W NY I had to try their beef on weck. Bun was fresh and meat tender but I could have used a side of au jus. Not sure if that is traditional presentation but plain meat on a roll with a little horseradish just seems to be missing something but it was still good. Wife loved her pasta and meatballs in spicy sauce. Next day I got the stuffed hot peppers with roasted pepper marinara and wife got mac and cheese. Hers very creamy and we both were very happy. Another thing I appreciated was the portions weren't way oversized as is the case with many restaurants that serve pasta. I don't need 5 lbs. of pasta for $17, just give me an adult portion for $9.99 and call it a day. Drawbacks: understaffed and the bar tenders not only serve drinks but assemble plates as there is a steam counter behind bar with prepared food hot and ready. This led to longer waits than you'd normally tolerate but you could see they were hustling back there. Also, it is cash only. read more

Went in on a whim the atmosphere is awesome the staff is friendly and the food is delicious. Oh and the bartender knows how to pour a pint of Guinness read more

Let me first say: OLD SCHOOL ITALIAN. Stuffed shells and Sausage ravioli with salad. ( quite a nice side salad , actually )Hubby said, "I'd come back" and I agree! I was so "Jonesing" for Italian! When you are used to crusty Italian bread, their local serving is really sub-par , but you don't come for the bread-Right? Several sauce choices makes it interesting and the price is right! Cozy place! read more

If you're into Styrofoam plates, plastic cutlery and microwaved food, then this is the place for you. It's probably best to go to the pub to get drunk and watch sports... don't take a date here for food. First of all, I like the atmosphere of the place. It looks nice and feels very 'old school.' Other than that, this place is way under par. Don't expect to be able to pay with a credit card. This 'old school' establishment won't accept them. Don't expect to find a working ATM in Jamestown either. We ordered a rueben and a meatloaf sandwich. Both were literally microwaved behind the bar. The meatloaf sandwich was two slices of pre-made meatloaf on bread. Served with chips and a pickle. Same for the rueben... ham and cheese on bread with chips and a pickle. All microwaved, and served on Styrofoam plates. Obviously, this place is a local favorite. I don't get it... an $8 sandwich should at least be prepared from scratch and put on a plate. read more

The Pub has been a Jamestown institution for quite a while. I have been told my first "visits" here were in utero, so I guess I have been a long-time fan! Sadly, an electrical fire late in 2013 caused extensive damage and The Pub was completely destroyed. Kudos to the Lisciandro/McCusker family, and the support of Jamestown and government agencies, for bringing The Pub back. The inside looks like a wonderful modern update of the "old" Pub. With the dark woodwork, beautiful wrap around bar, sandwich station, and cozy booths, you can take a seat for a drink, or have your whole family meet up for a casual dinner. The menu features sandwiches, Italian favorites, pizza, burgers, salads, and other basic fare. The center of the bar is a little sandwich station where you can see your sandwich made up in front of you. I had a BLT while my mom had the eggplant parm sandwich. I had mine on a whole wheat pub roll which was soft, moist, and super tasty. I loved the fresh, ripe tomato and they gave me a squeeze bottle of mayo so I could add my own amount.. My mom said her eggplant was cooked perfectly and she liked the Italian white bread and the sauce was not too sweet. We both got a side a chips and our total w/ waters was under $15. We liked seeing different items, including vegetarian, of all types. About 8 beers on tap, including local Southern Tier, and many others in bottles. Large liquor selection. They don't overstock, so some popular menu items may run out. I look forward to some more trips to The Pub in the future! PS: There was a sign as we walked in that they are cash only right now. Not sure if that is going to change. read more

The Pub - The Pub's post re-opening menu. August 2014. - Pubs Near Me - Jamestown, New York

The Pub in Jamestown, NY has the best bar food I've ever had in my life. Owned by 60s NFL legend Jim McCusker, with great recipes from his wife Mary, it's one of America's greatest watering holes, in my humble opinion. Western New York State is famous for their beef on weck sandwiches, and the Pub's can't be beat. I highly recommend getting anything with Mary's sweet pasta sauce on it, especially the eggplant parm sandwich. Really, there's nothing there I wouldn't suggest. I eat there whenever I'm in Jamestown and can. The owners' nephew Sam is one of the best bartenders on earth. read more

This is a nice, low-key place to grab lunch or dinner. You can choose to sit at the bar, a tall table alongside the bar, or at the booths in the back. The restaurant is kept clean at all times (including their restrooms). They have a nice variety of foods to pick from on their menu for very reasonable prices *win*. I really enjoyed their reuben sandwich! I really want to try their burgers at some point, so I'll definitely be back. I like how the sandwiches are served with potato chips. Their waitress and bartender were also very nice and welcoming. At night, the pub becomes a fun bar with fun people - you won't see drunks in this place, unlike other places in town. The bartenders are fun and make great drinks. The only negative about the place is that it's cash only, however they do have an ATM in the back. I'll bet they can keep their prices down because they don't take credit. Overall, it's a great place to try if you're in town, whether it's to grab lunch, dinner, or a late-night drink with friends. read more

Great spot. Wonderful food. Really nice people. If you want a local vibe, have lunch or dinner at The Pub. Huge bar where you can watch sandwiches being prepared. All else comes from their restaurant next door. Everything - just about - made from scratch. Who knew an "Italian Pub" could out-do an Irish pub? Bring cash or use the ATM on site. They don't take cards....yet! read more

Great downtown lunch spot. It is a little weird watching the bartender finish the food prepped in the back, but man is it good. I love when they have fried cardoons! read more

Remodeled after a 2013 devastating fire, this place is the place to go to see and be seen by the Jamestown influential. A very long bar that was built so you can talk to everyone about politics and sports. Great service and an absolute must stop for a western New York Beef on Weck tradition. The menu is small, but diverse and are usually posted out front. CASH ONLY! Tell them Norm sent you. read more

First time at the Pub. Marie and the rest of the staff was fun and and so helpful. Everything from pasta to wraps was delicious. Make sure and try the stuffed peppers. We will definitely be back read more

The best thing about The Pub, one of the staples here in Jamestown, is the eclectic atmosphere that can be found depending on the day and time you happen to pop in. The jukebox is amazing and (most of the time) the clientele and/or the bartenders do an excellent job of creating playlists for you listening pleasure. That being said, you have to learn The Pub's atmosphere. Do you want low key sport watching of your favorite college basketball team on a mellow weekday evening? That can happen. Do you want a good group of your 30-something friends having some libations and good laughs? This is possible. Do you want to be overrun by the younger generation begging for shots and playing Spice Girls? I have witnessed this... and then called it a night. read more

Fresh delicious food. Eggplant was wonderful. Great employees and good drinks. Definitely recommend

I love this place. The guy that runs it is a cool welcoming guy. One of the best pizzas and burgers in town. Hands down the best beef on weck locally. Nice strong horse radish and fresh big buns. Love this place. Beautiful inside too. read more

Great place. Great service. Great beef on weck. Great peanut butter pie and brownie sundaes. Great beer too!

My mom, grandma, and I stopped in here for lunch. It was FREEZING in the restaurant, which is a big no-no for my grandma, but I'm so glad we stayed. The server was extremely friendly. She gave us recommendations for the most popular/her favorite dishes on the menu. My grandma (who's had three heart attacks) ordered her typical chicken tenders (because clearly she's a rebel). My mom and I decided to split two of the recommendations - the beef on weck and the meatball float. We both really enjoyed the beef on weck, but there was SO much meat on the bun it was a bit overwhelming. Neither of us could quite finish our halves. The au jus made the bun soggy immediately so it wasn't really the best dish to take home for leftovers. The meatball float...oh my god the meatball float. We LOVED this dish. It's so rare I find both meatballs AND sauce that I love so much. This place really nailed both. We both talked about how, even though my mom lives over an hour away, she needs to come back ASAP and get meatballs and sauce to go. For dessert, we were interested in the walnut pie. They were out, so we ordered a brownie. The server offered some caramel drizzle and walnuts to top the brownie and it really made the dish. The service, price, and food really impressed us and we'll be back. read more

Fantastic place. Great pizza and Bloody Mary. Will definitely go back. Super friendly staff and great service. Wish they would deliver to my house in Pennsylvania. read more

All their food is heated in a microwave LOL and isn't that great. I would just rather continue eating my own home-cooked meals then eat that crap which is a shame because I enjoy eating out once and a while ,but I surely won't be coming back to this place read more