Great find as we traveled through Jamestown, NY! The Beef on a Wick was epic and the craft beer on draft was exceptional! Save room for the homemade peanut butter pie...! Our waiter couldn't have been nicer or more helpful. Would definitely go back! read more

Love going to The Pub for a Friday afternoon cocktail or a Saturday evening dinner. The food is great, and the service is always with a smile. Highly recommend! read more

Had the pot roast and a couple Phin n Matts! Was outstanding, place was filled with locals! Will stop next time we are in Jamestown.

What an awesome place! Found thanks to Yelp reviews and they did not disappoint. Food was great, cra - walnut chicken salad sandwich on rye was amazing! BBQ pork was also really good. Seems they have specials everyday and everything seems to be made on-site. Oh and the gentleman at the bar; I believe owners son....was awesome. Such great service and hospitality. Definitely a place to check out and come back to...oh and did I mention Southern Tier beer! Ummmm yes. Check it out..you won't be disappointed! read more

Great spot for a beef on weck and a pint in downtown Jamestown. Comes with all the condiments you could need/want, but I opted for a healthy scoop of horseradish. It did not disappoint. The Southern Tier beers are a staple in the area, and they are served up frosty. read more

What a cool place!!! Very nice bar and great dine in seating for a pub. Wasn't very busy as it was a Monday night but the service was spectacular! Appetizers and desserts seemed to be made on site. Delicious!!! Be sure to bring cash as they don't take credit or debit. read more

This is a what you should expect from a local tavern! Awesome food and drinks. Joe you made my trip to Jamestown, New York so much better by being such a cool bartender. read more

Three words: sausage lentil soup! We ordered extra it was so good! Everything is homemade and you can taste that. The name is deceiving; decor is pub menu is homemade Italian. Really clean really homey vibe. read more

I had one of the best roast beef sandwiches of my life in this fantastic little wood appointed pub! Yes, the name matches the decor! Very comfy and not too dark in the middle of the day. The bartender greeted us immediately and took our order. A nice lady came from the back and asked if we wanted refills. We eat out 2 -3 times a week and that level of service is very rare! The bartender came back a couple of minutes later to ask if we needed refills but they were already full! My wife enjoyed her Reuben as well. She said that it wasn't greasy like a lot of places make it. This place is less than a block from the Lucy and Desi museum. I highly recommend it!! read more

This place was incredible! The guys behind the bar were fantastic- I have never seen people work so well together and keep everything going smoothly. Even as they got extremely busy, they continued to hustle and make sure everyone was taken care of. P.S. Hugh Dillon's look a like works here! read more

Great meals and great suggestions. Neat family owned place for years, kinda like Cheers. We didn't see the sign that says cash only. But, would definitely tell you to try it. They have quite a bit to offer. read more

Came up for a weekend winery trip and found this place on Yelp. Great service and very courteous! Fantastic food. I got "the big guy" which is what they are known for. Fantastic and the prices aren't too bad. Very much recommend. Enjoy! read more

First time going to the pub with friends from out of town excellent experience super friendly and food was really good will definitely return! Homemade pie was stellar! read more

Old school place where the bartenders still wear shirt and ties. Good beer/wine/food prices! Great staff that treat you well.

Back again 2 years later. Everything is still the same. This place is so awesome. The food could not be any better same with the service. I will never go anywhere other than the pub when in Jamestown. read more

My husband and I were in for lunch. The food was very good, staff was friendly and the prices were reasonable. Would definitely return.

We had a great server and the food was really good. They don't accept credit cards though so go with cash. The menu choices were very good so it was well worth it. read more

First time in Jamestown and we had lunch at the pub. Wonderful people. Food and drinks was great. Thanks

The Pub was a nice little bar in a pretty much empty town. The bartenders were friendly, and good servers, and the prices were great. Wasn't the best bar I've ever been too- but far from the worst. read more

Best Beef on weck sandwich in town! The service is always great and the staff are very friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting! One of our favorite places to go for a cold beer and lunch! read more

This place is wonderful. Sammy the bartender/host is a great guy and makes everyone feel at home as do the rest of the staff. The beef on weck is incredible as is everything else. Honestly didn't know what to expect when entering from the street and I suspected it'd just be a local dive and told my wife I'd give the signal if we're making a hasty exit- man was I wrong!! The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the bar itself (recently rebuilt) was beautiful. Will definitely come again! read more

Stopped here while visiting the National Comedy Center. Sam was super friendly and the "Big Guy" roast beef sandwich was amazing. Didn't want to leave, but we had more to see at the center read more

Excellent place to dine and/or drink! Only issue is space, i wish they would expand i into the next door too. I highly recommend their whiskey sours, and canoli pie when it is available. read more

All the good things said by others about this place are true. Adjust your expectations and you'll do okay. A genuine local dive that's much better than a dive, thanks to sensitive remodeling after a 2014 fire. Terrific pizza and beef on weck, excellent old fashioneds, and super friendly service. On business travel, came here to watch Monday Night Football, have dinner and a beer. Had a blast sitting at the bar, watching 2 large TVs and getting the inside story of Jamestown from a wonderful young native bartender. A memorable evening. read more

My husband and I stopped by The Pub yesterday on a whim.... we hadn't been there in over 30 years and what a surprise! We sat at the bar and had a bite to eat.... and yes.... Mary's sauce can't be beat! As mentioned in the other review, nephew Sam the bartender is awesome! We left there feeling much like the customers on "Cheers"... maybe it's no coincidence that the bartender's name is Sam! The food was yummy and moderately priced. To us.. it was the excellent service, the warm atmoshere, the friendly folks at the bar, and talking to the owner and Sam that made our stop so special. Look out... we're coming back soon!!! read more