4.5 stars! Love The Mill! Have been coming here for years…read moreand the food is consistently wonderful. Brunch, Special menus for holidays, dinner, cocktails, dessert-it has all been top notch. This is a gem. Menu changes regularly so there is always something fresh and new. Prices may seem a little high for the area but the food and drink justify it. On my most recent visit we got 2 appetizers, two entrees (one was steak with shrimp add on), 3 desserts, and 5 cocktails for $250 which was not outrageous. Portion sizes are great. Food is full of flavor and cooked perfectly. We have sat on the restaurant side a few times but normally sit in a booth on the bar side. There is also a small patio off the bar in good weather. Bartenders are friendly and engaging. Plenty of parking and easy to get to. Only reason I knocked it a half star is the service on the bar side can be slow or feel forgotten about sometimes but it just depends on the time of day and if the bartender is having to do double duty or if they have dedicated wait staff in that area.

We wanted to support local and found this place on a local search. They didn't have the best…read morereviews, but my husband and I just wanted a place to nibble on some food and have some drinks before meeting up with other friends. When we walked in, we had the option of going to the bar area or restaurant. We chose the bar. The place was spacious and had ample seating. We sat down and a gal came to our table to ask for our order. She immediately came off as very standoffish, but, all good, we were there to relax and enjoy. We ordered wings to start off with. Mind you, it was happy hour which she mentioned herself. Cool, thank you. The wings were decent but some were soggy. But it's all good. We then ordered an entree and more wings because we were hungry. Did another dozen wings in the buffalo sauce. Our waitress, Kalidawn, reiterating the wings were 2 orders. Didn't make sense but it did in the end as she was trying to separate the orders as "half orders" to charge more? When in reality, it was the same buffalo flavor for the dozen wings so it wasn't a "half order". Really? You're going to do all of that to get you an extra few dollars? She was already rude, dismissive, and bothered from the beginning. We try to look past these things but she was truly excessive. It's like she wanted to make a statement and hated that we weren't regulars. We ended up getting sick after eating here. The service was beyond disappointing and the food sucked, but we also got sick which was the cherry on the cake. We will never be back and hope others think twice. And to find out, Kalidawn is the manager at the restaurant. So don't even bother trying to complain about her horrible HORRIBLE service and attitude. She runs the place which makes sense as to why I'm sure they're struggling. Do better.

Perfect place for a fast in and out lunch!! The $12.99 lunch burger is perfect and super fast. BLT…read moreis good but takes a minute to prepare as it should. I've recommended their burger special many times to others who need to find something fast and run. Only downside is their hours are confusing because not everyday is the same.

Food marginal at best. Steak ends, more bread than meat. Patty Melt like anywhere else. Nothing bbq…read morein this place. Terrible drinks. 7-up flat. Bartender didn't agree or fix it. Well vodka the worst in martini. AVOID this place. Not worth $89 tab at all.

Took my family here on a whim. We drive by Bootleggers all the time so figured why not try it out…read moreand support the local economy, you know? Went in on a Saturday evening so the place was busy but not crowded. There's a wrap around parking area where we scored the second to last parking. Walked in and sested ourselves in the center of the dining area, sharing another half of a larger table with a nice older couple. They seemed to enjoy our kids. My kids loved the arcades and somebody handed them a couple quarters, but the machine ate a quarter and left my boy hanging. Theres also little vending machines too. The servers were nice enough, not too fast not too slow. The gal who served us did well and accommodated for my kids which I thought was kind of her. The food - the portions are large! For the price you get a lot of food and it's all very yummy. Burger dip, french dip, patty melt, these are all of my bar staples and theyve got them! One of those uses mushrooms and I wonder if you get it without. My wife ordered their larger burger and enjoyed half of it - taking the other half home. The kids meals are $7. Yes, you read that correctly. THE KIDS MEALS ARE SEVEN DOLLARS! My daughter pounded the fish, my youngest son ate his burger, and my middle son ate his chicken strips. My kids got soda with their orders, while my youngest got a giant dank looking chocolate milk. The fries are potato cut style - I guess Five Guys style is closest - and a little on a overdone side for my liking. But they tasted good; my daughter's sweet potato fries were very good. I saw a neighboring table with the tater tots - those looked really good. Your choice of dipping sauce is offered. BBQ or Ranch is best. Remember the large portions? You get a ton of fries per meal, even the kids get a boatload of fries each. Kids can order PB&J, mac and cheese, and other bar bites if desired. My meal, a burger dip, was very good. Wally's makes a legit burger dip and Bootleggers was slightly better than that. The au jus was outstanding. Swiss cheese, really soft well toasted hoagie roll, seasoned beef. I would definitely order it again. There's a special every night and Saturday night was $15 8oz sirloin + fries. Seems to rotate specials. We saw several people order the sirloins and it looked good. We almost ordered one to let the kids split and test it, but decided against it not having tried the food at Bootleggers yet. The beer was good - $7.50 for a Seven Seas IPA. I ordered two. Nice and cold, clean glasses, decent head. No complaints to the bar whatsoever. I noticed Bootleggers seals soft drinks with a wrap top versus a lid. Don't see that often. Atmosphere is a dive bar. Pool table, darts I think, pull tabs, a couple TVs. The bar area is gated off. Was clean enough inside, wasn't expecting spic-and-span or anything. Family of five all ordered meals, two beers, tip, was about $75ish all-in. This is fantastic value, especially for a kid-friendly down-the-highway bar. I might argue Bootleggers is a top value + family-friendly dining option in the area. No kids after 9PM. We will definitely go back. I wish this place would lean more into their kitchen and add a few more diner-like options. The turkey bacon sandwich and Motherclucker (BBQ chicken) were in this arena and both sounded very good. We really enjoyed our meals.

The staff was very friendly and nice but the food I'm sorry was just salty and greasy no thank youread more

Visited from a recommendation. Safe to say it lived up to its given reputation. The service was…read moremoderately fast despite the busyness of morning to lunch switch + Sunday happy hour. Server was quick to take order and no mistakes were made while maintaining their pace. The middle of the room tables were somewhat close to each other but the chattery atmosphere made it so conservations were still relatively private. The staff were pleasant and accommodating. Upon requesting it, a movie was put back onto a television after being automatically switched. As for the food, I 100% recommend the Nachos Grande subbed with Sirloin. Great price during Sunday Happy Hour and big portions for a single person. Best split between two. Their hibiscus specialty cocktail was tasty even if I personally dislike hibiscus itself.

The service was great, given that they were really busy with a Birthday Party of 30-40 people. Our…read morewaitress was fantastic, when she felt that she took too long to get to us. She apologized profusely when she did not need to apologize we were having so much fun, listening to all the bands play. Every Tuesday is open my day work bands come in and people come in and sing. It was great. The food was delicious and as far as I could see you when food came out of the kitchen it all looked wonderful if I was not a diet I'll try everything they have on the menu just to see how good everything taste. I observed all the other waiters and waitresses, and it was remarkable they would carry food and trays full glass of water around people and hustle. The building looks wonderful. I can't say enough about Bonney Lake Tavern if you can go to it, I encourage you to go.

Catering Review : We were planning an intimate wedding with…read moreonly 36 guests, and honestly, finding a caterer was one of the more discouraging parts of the planning process. Many local caterers had very high minimums, which I completely understand since spring and summer weddings are their busiest season. What frustrated me wasn't necessarily the cost--it was the lack of follow-up, dismissive conversations, and unanswered inquiries. That all changed when I contacted Mama Stortini's. Almost immediately, I received a response from Maguire, who expressed genuine interest in hosting our event. Over the next several days, he worked closely with me, answering questions and helping me bring my vision to life. Maguire is top-notch. He was friendly, patient, knowledgeable, and professional. Most importantly, he made me feel valued as a customer, regardless of the size of my event. Once we booked, I was introduced to Brittany Blakeney. What a wonderful person! Brittany was positive, genuine, and incredibly helpful throughout the planning process. She assured me that everything would go smoothly and that I would have nothing to worry about on my wedding day--and she was absolutely right. She detailed our event so thoroughly that by the time we had our final planning call, I hardly had any questions left to ask. When our wedding day finally arrived, the catering team was on time, prepared, and ready to go. The setup was beautiful, the food display was impressive, and the food itself was absolutely delicious. I am disappointed that I forgot the names of the two young gentlemen who served our guests because they were amazing. Although I didn't have much time to interact with them during the event, every interaction I did have was impressive. They were professional, courteous, friendly, and attentive. Whoever hired them made an excellent choice. We received so many compliments from our guests about both the food and the service. Mama Stortini's played a huge role in making our wedding day special, and for that, we are incredibly grateful. Thank you to Maguire, Brittany, and the entire catering team for helping make our wedding day so memorable.

We had a wonderful lunch today at Mama Storrini's in Puyallup. Our server Amy gave us great food…read moreadvice and some of the best service I've had in years, probrably since I was in Tuscany Italy. And the food was as good too. The Tuscan salad and bruschetta were some of the best I've had anywhere, including Italy. The pasta was spectacular too. And the desert, creme brule and gelato was top notch. I haven't been to Mama's for years and I'll make sure I enjoy it again much sooner than that. Thank you again Amy for the great advice and service.

The bartender is amazing here. I took a chance on a drink i never had and I was pleasantly…read moresurprised. The food is generously sized. I will still get something different next time. Should've taken the bartenders suggestion haha. Beware the clientele can be a bit sketchy. Dont stay after dark unless you can defend yourself properly. Ill just leave it at that. Definitely a great place for a bite and a drink or 2 during daylight hours.

Atmosphere relaxed and service great. Generous portions, great good. Highly recommendread more

This was our first time to the Puerto Vallarta it was recommended to us…read more We were very impressed and pleased with the service, the food and everything overall. We had a party of 5 with and infant, some at our table had eating restrictions that were accommodated with ease and that was huge for our table so thank you for that . The wait staff was always cheerful and quick service We will be back

Large restaurant with plenty of seating, even if the parking lot is full they probably have room…read more The wait staff is friendly and attentive, staying on top of chip refills The portions are good and the food tasted fresh and well prepared. Lots of cheesy on the birria tacos and most of the meat was nice and tender. The tortillas were great, crisp in spots and soft in others, very flavorful overall. The steak had a good char on it, which is great and the rice and beans of both types were good. Overall a good typical Mexican restaurant that we will keep coming back to.

Breakfast time on a Monday; Greeted and seated quickly…read more Server was prompt to take our orders. They were polite and friendly. A server that seemed to enjoy their job!! The food came out hot and fresh! Real food!!! We all agreed that our various meals were good and the portions were generous but not overwhelming. For me, one standout was the sausage gravy I got as a side for my potatoes!!! Guys, this gravy was the real deal!!' My southern granny taught me how to make gravy so I KNOW good gravy and this amazing! The restaurant was clean, decor was your basic country/train decor which was fine. Soft country music at the perfect volume: ie we could hear it and still hear our conversations. All in all, a great experience that we will come back for.

Easily one of the best restaurants in all of Puyallup (and the state of WA!). If you're looking for…read morehearty comfort food then this is the place to be. We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for a late breakfast and had a fantastic meal. Eggs, breakfast potatoes, sourdough toast, and to top it off-lemon blueberry French toast. Seriously, YUM! Prices are affordable as well and our wait to be seated wasn't long at all. We will definitely be back in the future! Maybe next time for dinner!