After a wonderful meal next door at The Sicilian Butcher, our waiter suggested some dessert, but little did I know they had a whole bakery connected to the restaurant. I can't speak on the customer service as we never left our table and our waited just walked over and got what we needed. We were pretty stuffed from our massive meal, but we decided on sharing a cup of gelato just to satisfy our sweet tooth. I peeked inside as our table was right at a little walkway from the restaurant to the bakery. Gelato is just one of many things they serve here. They also have all your typical Italian desserts. Cakes like tiramisu, pastries like Italian flag cookies, cookies like Italian wedding cookies, cannolis of different varieties, and of course gelato. What was suggested to us if we wanted gelato was the hazelnut flavor. I was expecting a little cup for the 6 of us just to get a taste, but what he brought over was a massive serving. I don't know how many scoops it was or even how much we even paid, but we all got plenty with some even left behind. Now this gelato was life changing. Probably the best I've had in the states. I know it's gotta be way better in Italy, but I'll take what I can when I can. Think of a Ferrero Rocher but in gelato form. It was delicious and I couldn't get enough of it. It wasn't overly sweet and it had a little crunch with bits of chocolate and hazelnuts. My sweet tooth was extremely satisfied after having dessert here. I have literally been thinking about that gelato since I left Phoenix. Luckily this company has locations in Texas so I will definitely be seeking out this gelato soon. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

As a born and raised New Yorker, I take food very seriously... and Italian pastries even more so. Just before Christmas, I was traveling from New Yawk (visiting my parents) back to Phoenix to attend a family dinner at my partner's parent's home in Scottsdale. While I was still in NYC with my family on XMas eve eve, it hit me... I need to bring something besides wine everytime I go to their home. Nor a Southern dish. I wanted something unapologetically New Yaek. And what's more New Yawk than a box of classic Italian cookies? After asking a few Yelp friends where to find the best Italian cookies in Phoenix, The Sicilian Baker kept coming up. I called them last minute on Christmas Eve eve, having never been there before, totally sight unseen. First of all, their voicemail is hilarious. Truly. If you do nothing else, call just to hear it. It will instantly make you want to order something. Once I reached a real person, I explained my situation, that I wouldn't be able to come in beforehand, I needed a beautiful cookie tray for about 14-16 people, and I had a few must have preferences. Without hesitation, they said, "We got you." I was assured it would be ready when I landed on Xmas eve. Sure enough, after my partner picked me up from the airport, we headed straight to The Sicilian Baker. Parking right out front, a huge plus. As soon as you pull in, you're greeted with Frank Sinatra playing, not just inside, but even in the parking lot. It sets the tone immediately. We walked in, gave my name, and within minutes a lovely young person brought out my tray. Ten minutes later, we were on our way. Easy. Efficient. Warm service that made me actually grab a small box of cookies to drop my besties home on the way outta there. I didn't even realize at first that there's a sit down restaurant next door where you can relax and enjoy something. Great to know for next time ;) . Now, let's talk about the cookies. Yes, they are on the pricier side, but every single dollar was worth it. The tray was robust. Classic Italian pastries across the board like lobster tails, tri-colored almond cakes, cannolis, and all the favorites you hope for when you're trying to impress a room full of potential inlaws. And impress it did. The moment I walked in with that tray, it was a hit. People were already claiming which pastries they wanted, plotting what they'd take home, and hovering before dinner was even finished. There was more than enough for 16 people, grand is the only word for it, which is my style 1,000%. To this day, they're still talking about those cookies which makes me phenomenally proud (and humbled). I say this in all my reviews, "I hate almost everything. I'm discerning. I'm critical. And when something truly represents what I stand for - quality, authenticity, and heart, I will shout it from the rooftops". The Sicilian Baker delivered New York level excellence in Phoenix! Do not walk, runswiftly to this place if you need a gift, a show stopping dessert, or simply want to treat yourself. I cannot wait to go back. Highly, highly recommended. read more

Fast service and good selection even at 430 pm! Tried the gelato ( salted caramel and orange) both delicious, but it was the lobster tail and Sfogliatella pastries that I love and can't find outside of Boston! We enjoyed outside on a nice afternoon. Want to come back for dinner some time soon to the sister restaurant. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Sfogliatella yummy - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Cutest decorated Italian Bakery!!! Best cannolis and Italian pastries!! Always so fresh and lots of varieties!!! Lots of flavors of gelato as well!! Another hit from Chef Joey!! read more

See all

Came across this Italian bakery in Phoenix. Cookies were so delicious and their coffee was amazing. Avery was wonderful assisting customers and was super helpful in selecting desserts. Can't wait to go back! read more

Really good tiramisu! We did not have the best service, it was a busier night so I think that was why. Would recommend stopping here for dessert if you are in the area - they had lots of options! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Lilly was great. Very friendly and very flexible with our order. Offered her recommendations of the honey nut macchiato. Very clean on the back side of the restaurant. Small tables for coffee and small pastries! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Coffee menu - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Even though I was stuffed from lunch next door at the Sicilian Butcher, I couldn't leave without getting a gelato. My only regret was getting a single scoop. There was a bit of a wait but the dark chocolate Gelato with pieces of waffle cone was a most definite yummy treat! Helpful service and casual spot to get your sweet fix if you love gelato and all things italian desserts. Along with some of the most amazing canolis and cheesecake, this is a wonderful dessert spot! read more

See all

This is a great local Italian takeaway bakery. Their cannoli bar offers shell and filling customization with about 12 flavored ricotta cream options (vanilla, pistachio, espresso, lemon, cookies & cream, etc.) and even flavored shells like white chocolate or confetti. We love that they make the cannoli's on demand so they are never soggy or stale. Also, don't sleep on the gelato as it is amazing as well. read more

I had a favorite things party to attend last night and needed to bring a dessert. While I've eaten at Sicilian Butcher more times than I can count, it was my first time going to Sicilian Baker. I walked in and oh man did all the desserts look amazing! I chose a random sampling of: lemon meringue pies, chocolate caramel tarts, wedding cookies, mini cannolis and regular cannolis. The guy working was super friendly and helpful, and I was REALLY popular at the party with all the tasty treats!! The space is small but it's clean, it displays little slices of heaven, and is totally worth the visit! read more

See all

The pastries here are amazing! The service was a few young ladies who didn't want to be interrupted- each time had a question one would answer quickly, then turn back to their private conversation they weee having by the register. I had to literally interrupt each time I had a question, and when I wanted to place my pastry to go order. As in- they could see me approaching and did not break eye contact with each other or stop talking in subdued tones.. not sure why they thought I was approaching the counter if not to speak with someone and order. But I can't allow their professional retardation to keep me from the exquisite lobster tail. I love how the pastry chef fills the whole tail! I had custard cream all the way into the narrowest pastry! It made every single bite heavenly. You've got to try this place. Super fun ambience too! read more

Found this amazing Sicilian bakery in Scottsdale from Yelp. It was a short drive from the mountains and after a 2 hour hike we were hungry. Jayden took great care of us at the make your canoli bar and were even able to try a few flavors before settled on a key lime and pistachio one. They also have the traditional flavors or can get nontraditional ones such as nutella, key lime, pistachio etc.... We bought a few wedding cookies and their lemon cookies were to die for.Just the right amount of tangy sweetness. The bakery is set up to also accomodate dessert for their adjacent restaurant the Sicilian Butcher. Will absolutely come back and so excited to hear will be opening in Texas with 3 new locations in Houston. read more

See all

Got to surprise a friend with wonderful goodies made with love. Great customer service.

One of the best dessert places in Phoenix. I tried the cheesecake, cannoli, cookies, and other treats over three visits. Desserts are all better than Defalcos or Cheesecake Factory. There is one major issue- they have no location in Atlanta!! read more

oh my God! These cookies are AMAZING! Wow! I am heaven! Highly recommend. Everything was amazing. Will be back for more :) thank you to the baker read more

The Sicilian Baker - Mini cannolo, sfogliatelle, and some cookies! Fantastico!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

The service was very good but the products (assorted Sicilian cookies) were a colossal disappointment. Nothing at all like the authentic Sicilian Bakeries in New York. I am a pure bred Sicilian from Philly and New York. Nope - don't let the name fool you. I am only judging on the Sicilian cookies not their entire menu. read more

Friendly service. Lots of options. Free samples! Great desserts; both ice cream and pastries! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Very nice and attentive service! The worker was so nice and explained everything so well, she was great. I ended up getting a variety of the cookies, some gelato, and a custom Canoli. You can add half flavors to the canola and each scoop of the gelato which is cool. Lastly, my favorite part is that this place's deserts were not very sweet. Rarely, can I find places that don't make overly sugary sweets which is the standard American palate, but this place has the right balance of a not too sweet desert. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

Excellent Italian bakery! Everything we tried was wonderful, but the tiramisu is something else...the real deal. Also the best rainbows I've found in Arizona. Everything is such high quality perfection. read more

See all

Delectable location adorning modern charm. Worth a stop for either gelato and/or take away box of cookies. Love the rolling pins and whisks hanging from the ceiling. Parking in the area is a bit of a challenge. No line, no wait, no hassle. read more

See all

This review is strictly for the Lobster tails and gelato. The guy who was helping us was nice and friendly! We got one chocolate and vanilla. It was big and it really looked like a lobster tail but in pastry form. It tasty like a crispy croissant but with delicious filling! We took it to go and it was still crispy and light. I was expecting it to be soggy from the filling but to my surprise it wasn't. Generous amount of filling. My daughter had the Gelato and they had a good variety of flavors. We got mint chip and cookie butter. It was so good! Refreshing and great flavors! We will definitely be back to try some more desserts! read more

We stopped by as I was craving a morning pastry. Sicilian Baker is next to the Sicilian Butcher. The Baker offers custom filled cannoli, various italian pastries & cookies as well as espresso and coffee. The decor is a 10 very cutely decorated with rolling pins and mixer wisks hanging from ceiling or as light fixtures. We ordered 2 pastries; this is the basis of my review. Sfogiatelle (almond filled) and chocolate cannoncini (cream horn). They were very heavy, and both were chilled vs. room temp. The almond in particular had too much filling; I had to discard half the filling. The chocolate cream was lighter and tasted good. The pastry dough itself was a bit bland tasting. The variety or cannoli ricotta based fillings are clearly displayed, and this may have been a better choice. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

I expected New York Style Italian cookies and they weren't even close. But the bakery has been in business for a very long time, so they have managed to please many more people than just myself. I am only able to judge the cookies because that is all I sampled. read more

Such a cool idea! They have a case that looks like it would hold ice cream but it holds different flavors of cannoli fillings! The staff was friendly and nice and offered for us to taste many of the flavors. They also suggested combos they like best, which is always a nice touch! The space is cute and clean, directly next to an Italian restaurant that also looked delicious. I ended up getting a pistachio crusted shell filled with half pistachio and half "seasonal" which was amaretto. This was a special and delicious experience that you can't get just anywhere! Highly recommend! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Cannoli filing options - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Disappointed in our food today but have always enjoyed our meals in the past. Today, 5/1 we had lunch and all our chopped salads were missing cheese and only incorporated a very small amount of salami (one diner had two cubes). The sandwiches were suppose to be dressed with a vinaigrette but the chef forgot that and very little deli meat on the sandwich. I think today maybe was just not a good day. Wait staff were very attentive and no complaints. We will try again but we're disappointed today. read more

I sometimes skip cookies but oh my goodness, the cookies here are a real treat. Amaretti cookies have the perfect amount of chewiness and crunch to them and they're not overly sweet. I only bought 1 almond cookie. It was not overly inspiring but it was 75 cents. #worthit You can choose your own cannoli shell and cannoli fillings. Omg. The traditional is good, but I'm on a pb kick right now so the peanut butter filling is my favorite. I like it with a chocolate dipped cannoli shell. Yasssss. The chocolate hazelnut tart was a huge hit at our house. It's a crisp sugar dough shell with a rich chocolate ganache and topped with a candied hazelnut and chocolate decor. So rich you can share it or keep it all to yourself. You can never go wrong with the rainbow cookies. I buy at least 2 every time. Rich and delicious almond cake with just a little bit of chocolate. So so good. Tiramisu- kinda pricey at $13 but it's very good. It's not an overly "wet" tiramisu where it feels like the cake has lost its texture due to over saturation, and it wasn't dry leaving me wondering where the coffee was. Basically Goldilocks, it's just right. Not too sweet, not too much coffee. True to its name, it does pick you up. Service is always friendly here, they are patient when you get the deer in the headlights look when you're trying to decide what to get or with indecisive children. Don't skip this place if you like to treat yourself. It definitely helps make life sweet. read more

See all

Simply Delightful. Best tiramisu I've ever had. Extremely fluffy and creamy. Don't walk. RUN. read more

Great selection and delicious! It's a great place to grab a coffee or latte. Coffee is rich and delicious. The pastries are wonderful as are the lemon Italian cookies. Tatum was a pleasure and told us about the pastries and provided wonderful service. Will be back very soon. read more

Very skimpy wine pour. I should have sent it back. Definitely not worth the price. The food was okay.

10 out of 10. Top bakery. Staff is awesome. Product is amazing. Thank you so much for your customer service.

The cannoli's.... !! Fast, knowledgeable and efficient staff delivering fantastic Italian deserts and pastries.

Parking is ample. Service is excellent. I ordered an expresso gelato for $4.50. A pretty good price and genuine expresso with coffee beans in it. The assorted box for $18 is very good. The cookies I believe are typically $1 and for 20 cookies in box assorted of all 4 types of cookies a very good price. My main visit was for fruit tart. I have been to Las Vegas, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Portland, San Diego, etc to try out fruit tarts. The crust was thin and delicious, the cream was different, the fruits fresh,. The only thing that was questionable to me was that it was $10 for an average size small tart. Most places have been less than $10. Overall Service was good, read more

See all

Came specially for desert and wasn't disappointed with a lobster tail with Nutella and gelato, yum read more

The Sicilian Baker - Yum treat, totally worth the drive - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

I found the Sicilian Butcher to be a small chain of Italian dessert stores throughout the Phoenix area that came highly recommended as a result of local blogs and list. What I found was a clean storefront that offered a shortist of some of the most common desserts that go well with lattes, cappucinos and limoncellos. This is looking specifically at their desserts. Mini cannoli - this was a bit lackluster in flavor, specifically within the creme. I found the outside crunch to be excellent, but didn't wow me in any way. I do this is good for one person, although the regular size would be good for one hungry person or split between two people. Italian wedding cookie - this was a hard cookie that is very common, but didn't seem to have the sweetness or softness of the traditional wedding cookie. I don't think this was as great as it could have been. I would opt for this over a cannoli, however. Latte - served to go, I found this to be a very light latte without much espresso strength. While this may have been the case with the oat milk option, I hoped for a bit more, and for it to be a bit hotter. I do think people really like this place could use more than a great decor, but a bit more in flavor for the desserts. I did like the clean atmosphere, steadfast service, and availability. read more

You can't go wrong with anything here. From cannolis to napoleons or a lobster tail! I can never get pictures as I eat it all too fast. Finally I remembered before devouring this lobster tail. Go to Sicilian butcher for you're main meal and then stop in the bakery for treats!! read more

See all

Great addition to the Sicilian Butcher right next door! Great service and several flavors of Cannoli filling annnnnnd Gelato! I loved the options of cannoli shells and that they will box the shells separately from the filling for to go orders without a fuss!! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Today's Cannoli flavors - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

The best dessert I've ever had!!! Paola and Jaden provided amazing customer service!!! You have to come here, will NOT regret it!!! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Dolce duo - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

It's very disappointing that they don't sell bread. The pastries are okay, but pricey. Their name should be Sicilian Sweets or Pastry, not Baker. read more

I love this bakery everything is delicious. The cannolis are amazing. They have a really good white chocolate raspberry mocha that is Devine. Customer service is usually on par there's a lot more young people working there than I remember before. The he gelato is delicious and if your hungry go next door to the Italian butcher to get some pasta beforehand. Love the vibe inside as well. read more

Sunday afternoon, having a BBQ, all set, but forgot about dessert. I've passed this place 100 times. Well, finally I stopped in. The store is very cute and has an array of bakery goods along with a Gelato counter too. Not knowing the process of ordering, it was explained to me by a very nice gentlemen behind the counter along with giving me tasters of the Creams offered. I noticed all employees wearing masks. I ordered 6 Chocolate dipped Cannoli Shells, 3 filled with pistachio cream and 3 filled with Regular Cream and a secret dessert for just me, the Napoleon. Coming from NYC with Little Italy in my back yard, this place has some big shoes to fill and indeed they did for an Arizona supplier. I will say for me, the Chocolate Dipped was a bit too rich, though my guest loved them. Next time I'll stick with the traditional shell. To note: my Napoleon was heavenly! Atmosphere: small, clean, following store covid rules. Service: excellent. Desserts: heavenly read more

The Sicilian Baker - 6 Chocolate dipped Cannoli Shells, 3 filled with pistachio cream and 3 filled with Regular Cream - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all