Carol made the most exquisite cupcakes for a Make-A-Wish reveal party. She asked for our wish kid's favorite color and flavor (turquoise and vanilla!) and made these incredible treats. Thank you, Carol, for always going above and beyond. Carol is easy to work with and everything I've had from her (cookies, cakes, etc...) have been top notch. read more

The Sugar Gallery - Vanilla cupcakes w buttercream frosting - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

All I wanted for my birthday cake was a simple Lilikoi cake. Carol baked an amazing cake. It was yellow cake with a delicious Lilikoi filling and icing. It was so good! Thank you for making my day special. read more

The Sugar Gallery - Lilikoi Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me

Carol and her custom cakes are amazing! We were coming in town to celebrate our mom's 60th birthday and wanted a delicious cake to celebrate her. Carol had great ideas, for flavors and decoration. We ordered a coconut cake with pineapple filling, and vanilla buttercream. An 8 inch cake was the perfect size for our group, and the edible glitter on top added just the right amount of sparkle! We highly recommend Carol's cakes - they are delicious and beautiful. Thank you Carol! read more

See all

I got my incredibly gorgeous Halloween cookies from the truly amazing artist that is Carol Saiki at https://www.facebook.com/TheSugarGalleryKauai I had a great talk story with her when I picked up my cookies yesterday. She is an amazing culinary artist that supersedes any baker I've ever dealt with here on Kauai. Please check out her FB page and give her a like! Mahalo Carol for your artistry! She's also at the Wed. afternoon P-ville Farmers' Market at the Makai Golf Course! read more

The Sugar Gallery - Custom Cakes Near Me

There are not enough words to express how much we appreciate, Carol. I was looking for someone to make my daughter's wedding cake and I happened upon her via the internet. Greatest find ever!! It was a destination wedding so the planning was a little tricky. Carol was truly a Godsend. She spent an endless amount of time helping me figure out countless details including the transportation and care of the cupcakes/cakes, how to serve them, how to present them beautifully and how to keep them from melting in the warm July climate. Carol's work was not only beautiful and better than we imagined, but the cakes were delicious. Our guests were raving about how good they were. I started this wedding planning looking for someone to help us with our cake and came away from the wedding as a huge fan of Carol. She was truly one of the best parts of our wedding experience. Thank you for EVERYTHING, Carol. You are a gem on this sweet island of Kauai. read more

The Sugar Gallery - Custom Cakes Near Me

I was at a Farmers market in Princeville on December 22, 2021 when I noticed a bakery stand. I found a slice of pineapple cheesecake and bought one. I then got myself a business card with the name The Sugar Gallery. The slice of cheesecake was delicious. read more

The Sugar Gallery - a piece of cake and a fork - Custom Cakes Near Me

What an amazing cake!!! We ordered a custom cake for our 14 y.o. Bday and it was wonderful!! Not only did it look magical it is the best cake I ever tasted. Everyone in our party loved it. Highly suggest the sugar gallery for al of your cake needs. read more

See all

I first met Carol at a fair in Kauai several years ago. She had a booth where she sold slices of cakes. I love carrot case, so I ordered a slice. Coming from the Northeast, I am spoiled with 'David Glass' and his beyond mouthwatering, to die for, carrot cake. After my first bite, I knew I had found the ultimate carrot cake - it was sweet, but not too sweet, moist and decadent. What was that unusual flavor in the cake?Pineapple. We have a world winning carrot cake here. Carol not only makes outstanding cakes and cookies, she is an artist with her decorating design and detail. They are almost too beautiful to eat. Secret - I ordered an entire cake for my birthday and had a slice for breakfast, lunch and dinner, until it was gone. Now that's a real present. read more

Saw Carols ad on Kauai Buy and Sell and messaged her if I could order Bridal Shower Cookies for my daughters shower. She provided the most perfect cookie we asked for. You need cookies for any occasion, call this wonderful lady, she'll create it for you just the way you want it! Thank you again Carol! You will definitely be my cookie lady from now on. read more

The Sugar Gallery - Bridal shower cookies - Custom Cakes Near Me

Carol is amazing and makes the best cakes and cookies!!! They are beautiful and delicious!!! We use her for all our family celebrations. She recently made an adorable assortment of cookies and a cake for my son's first bday - she nailed it. read more

See all

Carol was wonderful to work with! I found her on yelp and contacted her (only a month before!) my sister's wedding to see if she could make her a cake. Carol was so helpful with her suggestions and she always responded very quickly to any questions I had. We chose 3 flavors for the cake - chocolate with raspberry filling, red velvet and lilikoi. They were all delicious! Carol did a great job of using a fresh lei to decorate the cakes. She even delivered the cakes to the reception in Kapaa! Thank you Carol! read more

The Sugar Gallery - Beautiful and delicious cakes! - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

Our chocolate cake with haupia filling was not only delicious, but it was also beautiful. It was exactly what I wanted. Thank you, Carol! read more

The Sugar Gallery - Custom Cakes Near Me

Amazing carrot cake with very fresh ingredients. Not too sweet and very savory. Carol was very helpful in getting our order and had it ready perfectly when we arrived. Couldn't recommend more highly if you need sweets in Kauai. read more

I am a TOUGH critic and picky with desserts and pâtisseries, and I swear to you you will want to take a piece of something from here to share with everyone you love(or want to be loved by :P). I've tried the "best" carrot cake of many cities/areas and they were mostly overrated, always feels like something is missing. However... THIS carrot cake from IS the best carrot cake, not only of Kauai but of the world, just w.o.w. Then I tried the chocolate mac rhum pie, ooooh dear delicacy! Peeeerfectly put together, balance of the flavors and texture was flawless! Not one ingredient overruled another. Every bite of it made me hear singing angels. What to say about the chocolate cake as well... it didn't win an award for no reason. Intoxicating, will make chocolate lovers feel like on a cloud. This is my top three but everything is just amazing(ooh I forgot the yummy sweet potato pie but how much can I write?). The nice lady baker is kind and makes magic! read more

I found this incredible baker at an artisan market, and fate was smiling on me that day. My group purchased two slices of pie, Hawaiian sweet potato and chocolate haupia. We sampled the pieces after walking away, and immediately went back to the stand to purchase additional pieces. We also tried the chocolate rum macadamia nut pie, another excellent life choice. Days later we couldn't stop thinking about this pie, and contacted the baker to determine where we could acquire more. What happened next was some of the best customer service I have encountered. The fine baker not only let me know where she would be hosting her stand next, but she also let me know that I could pick up pie from her home at my convenience. Obviously, we could not wait. I apologize that there are bites taken from the accompanying photos. Waiting was simply not an option. read more

See all

I loved her butter cookies and her decorations on it. I believe she is the best cookie and cake decorater. Unbelievable, she put her time in each cookie and her cakes. Wow!!! Fantastic job Carol. I'm going to Order one of your cakes next. It was nice meeting you today. Aloha Pam Jardin read more

I contacted Carol via email from Los Angeles to make and deliver a cake for me. Working with her was a pleasure. The cake was beautiful and reportedly absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend Carol and this bakery. I was impressed by her creations online and she did not disappoint. Thank you Carol! read more

This cake was absolutely amazing! It tasted just as good as it looks! Carol was so easy to work with and quick to respond! One of the best (if not best) cakes I've ever had! My mom loved it! Carol really went above and beyond!!! read more

The Sugar Gallery - Death by chocolate cake - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

It was our towns First Saturday celebration, so happy to have Discovered the best Tropical Carrot Cake I've ever had! The sweetest couple with lots of yummy options. She also does custom decorated cookies and cakes for all occasions! Can't wait to taste all the rest their goodness read more

The best sweets on da island, and I wasn't disappointed the next time I ran into these great folks either...delicious sweet sweet delights!

FLAVORR wise it wasn't as bad. But overall it was a really sweet cake with a really sweet frosting. We specifically asked for something light and not to sweet....It was too sweet for anyone to finish even a slice. decorations was ehhh. We wanted a naked cake with just frosting in the middle of the layers but Carol told us that those kinds of cake are for weddings. She kept convincing us other options but we specifically wanted a naked cake even if the event we were going to wasn't a wedding. When a customer tells you what they want you go with it and do as they wish. Because its all about making the customers happy and making there money's worth. In the end we never got our naked cake, instead we got a dense cake, with a really really sweet buttercream frosted which we DID NOT WANT NOR EVEN ASKED FOR, we wanted a whipped cream for the middle! Along with that we wasted our money an entire cake! I know this may sound a bit extreme but we were really disappointed and I felt that this needed to be shared!! read more