EXTREMELY chaotic show that starts things off with a free shot. They kinda use the audience as…read moreprops which can be fun if you're into that sort of thing. Definitely not for everyone, but I had an amazing time here. Morgan did a great job, as did everyone in the cast!

Read all the reviews and thought this would be a fun night . A show with laughs , involving the…read moreaudience. So I bought tickets and invited friends to come along . One couple was pretty much uncomfortable because in some of the scenes it was not expected what they would use as a prop. The one thing I have to say the actors were great . Amazing how they can memorize such a long script .

I came here last Friday night and enjoyed coming here. Pro is that it's spacious, but also an…read moreintimate and cozy venue. The make you put your group's cell phones in a bubble poly-mailer bag that they seal up before you go inside. They had a terrific lineup of 8 comedians that made me laugh so hard. For drinks I had two Berry Martinis, yum. They have fantastic staff and our server was friendly. Great mc and crowd. Highly recommend for a comedy show option in NYC!

Holy shit - easiest 5 star ever. We went last month during our NYC trip and the show was amazing,…read moreevery comedian was on point, I cried laughing. It was a last minute decision to go so originally we got in the 9pm standby line for Fat Black Pussycat. Unfortunately we didn't make standby twice when we waited at 9pm and 11pm. Luckily, we were offered to go to the 11:45pm comedy cellar show instead. Yes please! So happy it worked out, especially on a busy Saturday night. It was the 2 of us & we shared a table with 2 other couples who were such a vibe to chat with. 2 drink minimum. The show started around midnight and ended around 1:30am. Definitely recommend to catch yourself a comedy show here! I'll be back next time I'm in NYC

So many brilliant minds have crossed this stage, an honor to have been here…read more We got to see: WIL SYLVINCE, BRIAN SCOTT MCFADDEN, DWAYNE PERKINS OPHIRA EISENBERG and KEVIN DOMBROWSKI hosted. Food is bar food, two item minimum, ambience is that of an OG comedy club. Needed this moment at this point in time. As hard as it was to laugh, they each got me to do it. Much love to all brave enough and committed to making sure we laugh at all times.

Went to see Godfrey this week! Very organized getting in. The have staff waiting to take you to…read moreyour seat after you check in. A lot of seating is cushioned and benches. It can be a little tight but you get to know your neighbors quickly. I was happy that they had Flower Power, IPA. My friends ordered wings and tenders, they weren't impressed. They said it's just bar food. That's sad, because I have had great bar food. But I would definitely return to this venue for comedy and drinks!

We saw Daniel Weingarten Saturday night in this small intimate club on 78th street off Broadway…read more Typical cramped room small tables and wooden chairs not making for comfortable evening. Servers came around right away and we ordered Berry Seinfeld and the Tracy. Tracy was a rum drink and you tasted the alcohol so no complaints. *** If you check in on Yelp you get a free house shot which was vodka peach schnapps and some juice, also not bad. Ticket prices were reasonable and they have an $18 drink minimum. All drinks are $16 and under so you need to buy at least two. The show itself was very good and the headliner hung out after so we had a photo opportunity and a nice chat. I would definitely go back to see another comedian.

Great time, and place to gather with friends for a laugh. Highly recommend while in the cityread more

Enjoyed seeing Spirit of the Game there. Fun musical about Ultimate frisbee. Good staff and a…read morewell-designed venue.

I'm wondering if the sound system is set by the venue, or if the show's producers exert control…read more Here's why I ask, and also my quandary in awarding stars: the storyline of our show was pretty much relayed by song. But the sound was so loud, what they sang was garbled, making it difficult to understand and follow. "Do you get this?" I asked my friend. "I can't make out what they're saying!" she responded. So -- very unlike me -- we left during intermission. I don't want to malign the show. The script (from what I gathered) was clever and the performers, talented. The theater itself is a nice, informal off-Broadway venue: a bar in the lobby, comfortable seating with good views throughout. I'll give Asylum another try. I've noticed they feature some interesting productions. (I'm sorry I missed "Naked Magicians.") But for last night's experience, a regrettable three stars.

Came for a comedy show and had a good time. Unfortunately the tickets listed the start time as 30…read moremin before doors even opened so we were ridiculously early. They should fix that. We were confused when we first walked into the bar, but turns out the comedy club is tucked away in the back corner. There's a two item minimum but the good news is that you could order from the bar, then continue the tab through the comedy show. I got a mango margarita and pear cider. Both were solid and yummy. Comedy show was small and intimate, even though the comedy space in the back is quite large. They were competing with the FIFA game, so I understand. Nice casual bar and would be down to come back for another comedy show.

Delicious fried chicken sandwich! and they're always attentive and kind!…read more I also love all the celebrity portraits on the walls and some seatings they have are really cute. I like coming here with my friends a lot.

Mary Santora was a WRECK. She bombed and nobody thought it was that funny. She trauma dumped her…read morefamily problems to the crowd, talked politics, heckled the Bible, and then acted confused why we weren't laughing. Zach McGovern thankfully saved the show because he was HILARIOUS! But they will charge you $20 per person for snacks even if you don't order $20 worth. This along with Mary Santora's bombshell failure show and sheer lack of comedic talent is keeping me from ever going back again.

Love the comedians but I don't love the $20 minimum and 18% automatic gratuity. This was already on…read moretop of a $40 ticket. I came alone and ordered a mocktail for $13 and a water bottle for $6. I didn't meet the minimum so they charged me $1 additional and then gratuity in top of that. It was $25 total A suggestion to expand the food options for people who don't drink alcohol. tough for a person going solo.

We had a great time! I will acknowledge that I am an easy laugh. I love laughing, I love comedy…read moreclubs, etc. As others have mentioned the place is a little sketchy, so I wasn't surprised by it. If you encounter someone selling tickets on Broadway with the Comedy Central sign it's worth the money. They are very serious about the two drink minimum, but the drinks were reasonably priced so that was a good deal. We also had an order of hummus and pitas. There were 4 full pitas and a decent amount of hummus - and the pitas were hot! I would have order led more drinks if our server had ever come back but he was really busy. All in all, worth the money!

It felt like they oversold their capacity because small metal chairs were crammed next to each…read moreother. At one point one of the servers got frustrated trying to move between them. To be fair to the comics, the crowd was weird and one obnoxious guy kept interrupting. There is a strict two drink minimum, but the drinks are relatively cheap. It is strictly enforced because we wanted to leave early and had to wait to find someone to check out.