The food was delicious! Service fantastic. We ordered…read moretakeout. Wings, Margarita pizza and Rock Star pizza. We had leftovers the next day, Soo good! Love the crust

Long wait tone, over priced, incorrect orders, terrible customer service from owner and staff.read more

We ordered to-go a few nights ago and we were thrilled with our food. We just recently moved to the…read morearea and wanted to try something local. The staff members were very sweet both on the phone and in person. The place was packed when we picked up our food but everyone looked happy and no one was waiting. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip and the Yo Joe pizza. The dip was probably some of the best we have ever had! The pizza was a perfect balance of crust, sauce, and toppings. We will absolutely be back!

Actually, I thought 3.5 *s would be best for this favorite spot of my son and his family. There…read morewere so many great things, but a few details that disappointed me. I will discuss the service, ambiance and the food. My experience with the food was the Caesar Salad, Lasagna, and tastes of food from those at the table. Service was great. Our server was attentive, answered our questions and even brought me some extra pepperoncini when I asked for them. She was pleasant and patient as we pondered our selections. When my adult son asked about what was tap, she brought a taster for him. Across the street from the courthouse, on the square of a town founded in 1809, the restaurant inherited a period building with brick walls. I have been in Italy and I can say that the decorations were authentic. This MAY have been a church in a previous life, but there are a few clues, particularly to loft at the front of the building. A spiral staircase leads to it, about a story and half above the main floor. Closed to visitors, I understand at times it is a live music stage. Food was good - very good, just not good enough to warrant a full 4*s. So here are my picky comments. Lasagna was a large portion and well balanced for flavor. I'm used to pasta, even in lasagna to be more al dente. For the price, there was not enough meat to satisfy my taste buds or wallet. We opted for the family sized Caesar salad,which again, was good. I'm used to more garlic as well as a more flavorful and more abundant dressing. Two pizzas also came to our table and the four diners enjoying them, liked them much. For a wood fired oven, I am more used to a more prominent smoky flavor - from my small taste. Toppings were adequate and looked great on the pie when they came out. Chianti is only available by the bottle. I would have liked a single glass. It could grow on me if I lived or worked in the area. I would not object to going back with my party when we visit, but a 75 minute drive is not worth the trip.

Great food--- we had the bbq pizza and it was so good. Fast service and good economical. We will be…read moreback.

I am not a fan. The pizza was your basic frozen tasting pizza and the dessert was idk what kind of…read morecanned pie mix up but I will not return.

Great Beer Selection and the Animal Pizza is one of the best around! Bartenders are always…read morefriendly and service is great. Not to loud..

We moved out of state and this is by far the best pizza we've had!! The staff is super friendly and…read moreit's a fun joint to eat at!!

Incredible pizza !!! Exactly as I ordered with extra olives. Crust is fantastic! Yummy??!read more

The pizza was hot fresh delivered on time! Tasted amazing!! There prices are somewhat affordable as…read morewell!

This is the best pizza place in Cookeville maybe TN.. it has won multiple awards and taste like the…read morereal NY style pizza.. I lived in ny for about 4 years and they have some of the best pizza.. I would recommend BIG Tony's to anyone..

I heard this place was decent and wanted to give it a try…read more I ordered specifically all the pepperoni to be touching each other. 2x -3x whatever the up charge was I'd be ok. Well as you can see by the pictures it was worse than Dominos and 3x as much. The garlic knots were ok as were the Cannoli chips. Will I return? No. Service guaranteed my order to my details but seriously failed to get it done.

Just traveling through and stopped here for a pizza dinner. The hostess gave us the option of…read morerooftop but we selected downstairs since it was raining. Service was quick and friendly. Our waitress KaShonda made what might have been a three star experience easily a four star. The menu warns that the Chicago style can take 45-75 minutes so we were quick to order it before appetizers. The food was tasty. Ordering two pizza styles is a challenge and our Margherita NY style originally came out over cooked. (Probably waiting on our other pizza to finish). KaShonda was apologetic and was quick to make the situation right. When a new pizza came out it was fantastic. I would return when back in the area.

Sunday evening (Father's Day) service was great, but the Kitchen was SO EXTREMELY SLOW. it took…read moreover 30 minutes for the first entree, an additional 45 minutes for the second (pizza) to arrive, and another 25 minutes for the final entree..? A large part of choosing to dine here was their Gluten-free menu, which was very tasty...but as a family, we'd like to dine together. I'm understanding, but several other tables that arrived after we ordered entrees were eating before two pizzas could be baked?!? Ridiculous. Will honestly not go out of my way to dine here again. I feel bad for the server (it was her birthday) and her team and management let her down.

Awesome Pizza! Fresh ingredients and cool vibe! Staff makes you feel right at home. Will definitely…read morego back again to try their other flavors.

The best stone fired pizza! Quality ingredients and so good! The atmosphere is very inviting and…read morethe owners are great to chat with!

This is a delicious pizza that is pretty consistent and never disappoints. I always order a…read moresausage pizza and a sandwich they call a "Chicago grinder" which is a version of a steak sandwich, and those are pretty tasty as well. This pizza has a different taste than many others but it's worth a try. Place has dine-in (Well, not now due to you know what), which is a "help yourself" type thing, you know, get your stuff at the beginning of the meal as nobody is coming to check on you. Lol! That's fine by me, it's a pizza joint. Good satisfying pizza.

Stopped here on the way to NC to grab a bite. Food was average at best. Ingredients were not the…read morebest of quality. My wife got a chicken sub and questioned if the chicken was real. Once was enough for me.

What a gem! We were leaving Nashville and wanted to get breakfast but every place we stopped at…read morehad an hour's wait. We decided to keep going towards home and the I Exit app showed this restaurant. It had good reviews so we decided to give it a try. They serve breakfast all day and even though it was 11:30 that's what we wanted. We chose the Country Boy breakfast with tenderloin. I asked if we could get grits instead of hash browns and our server said sure. We split the breakfast and it was more than enough food for splitting. The coffee came right out, hot and fresh. The food came out shortly after. I can't say enough about how delicious it was. We will definitely stop here again because our son lives in Nashville so we will take this route often. The restaurant was clean and the decor had a country vibe. The servers were very pleasant and efficient.

Food was excellent. We had the BLT and the COD fish dinner. We especially liked the Cole slaw…read more Service was quick.