This place was amazing! I was recently visiting friends in NY and we went out to this pizza shop. It really earns its name. Everything was delicious! We got salads, pizza with fun toppings, nachos, truffle fries, gelato and more! It's rare to find a pizza place with ambiance, delicious food, and great wait staff! If you're in the 5 towns in NY, this place is definitely worth the visit! read more

The cauliflower Mac and cheese is probably my favorite thing on the upper crust menu. So good! It tastes delicious, it's a big portion, and you get to have some veggies! read more

The Upper Crust - Cauliflower Mac and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

Great for easy kosher dairy meals. Wide variety on menu and service was quick and attentive!

Delicious amazing food. Went with my family and it was so incredible! Such a wide variety of options and everything was so yummy. The vibes are lit, a chill wonderful and spacious "cafe" type place. Waiters were so sweet and attentive. The "pepperoni" pizza was PHENOMENAL! And so was everything! Will definitely be returning the next time I'm in the area. read more

The Upper Crust - "***Pepperoni pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

See all

Came with a group on a busy Saturday evening. I ordered the Mediterranean Salad. It was a nice sized portion, fresh and tasty. I also tried some bites of the cheese pizza:thin crust with generous cheese, nachos Veracruz: crispy chips with cheese smothered with avocado and purple onions, cherry tomatoes, and jalapeños, and the Italian Nachos: oven roasted nachos smothered in white cheese with a marinara dipping sauce, and also tried the zucchini noodles with a butter garlic sauce. Some other dishes ordered (I didnt try) were Mac & Cheese balls, French onion soup, seared tuna, penne a la vodka, and pizza with vegetarian mergez and red bell peppers. Everything looked appetizing when served. Service was good considering the place was absolutely packed. The only negative were the very filthy bathrooms. I did speak with the manager about this and hope it was addressed at some point. read more

The Upper Crust - Mediterranean Salad - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

See all

The Upper Crust is absolutely delicious!!! I came here with my family a few months ago and we all enjoying everything. The atmosphere and service are excellent, welcoming, and the staff is understanding and patient. All of our food came within minutes of the other dishes, the coffee was perfectly hot. It was a great place to reconnect with family with amazing food! read more

I love upper crust its my favorite restaurant there foods the best there pizza And nachos are my favorite foods there overall the food in uppercrust is 10 out of 10. The service is amazing super quick it takes under 20 minutes to get amazing fresh food. And the Ambiance is amazing its so chill its alive its a good vibe and it looks beautiful. read more

A Kosher restaurant in a beautiful neighborhood in Cedarhurst, NY If you are not familiar with the area, it is worth taking a few minutes to drive down some of the side streets to appreciate the architecture of the residential homes in the area. No cookie cutter homes here. Upper Crust is a lovely restaurant with modern decor. The menu is design to make sure there is something for everyone in your party. We ordered a backed Ziti, a pizza pie and blacken tilapia fish dish. All were perfectly prepared and delicious. The service was fast and friendly. I am happy to have discovered this place and since i have a brother who practices strict Kosher. This will be our go to place when we come downstate to visit. read more

See all

The food at upper crust is so good. I could eat it every day. Their service is pretty fast and the people are very nice. The dining is nice i would recommend read more

I have to say to start with the experience i had was not good. we called up for a reservation, As we had 12 people in our group. They said on the phone no problem come down, but they did not take reservations. We got there and there was a table set up for 12, And the manager said that was for another group who had a reservation?????????? Wait a second did they just tell me they do not take reservations????. we sat there for over 15 minutes before then other party got there then we waited another 35 minutes before we finally got two tables not near each other. the service was extremely slow and the food was not that good. unless i had to i would never go there again. shame on you upper crust for making different policies for different customers????. read more

Kosher in the house! this place is a keeper please someone tell me why all the Koshers on central cant be like Upper Crust friendly waiter greeted us and let us take the table by the window quick attentive service brought us our drinks soon after our pizza and salads arrived hot fresh thin crust cheese pizza to accompany our roasted beet salad beets, greens toasted almonds blue cheese and craisins our water was always full good pizza go have one read more

See all

First informals for a $20 pizza this is extremely small you can't even allow these people to put a box together how do you make pizza for living in your box is folded backwards please don't be like me and trust these people to make a simple margarita pizza I mean holy shit this just looks like a regular cheese pizza I swear to God this is unacceptable this is by far the worst piece of garbage I have ordered ever.. read more

The Upper Crust - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

See all

The service was SLOW. We had plastic cups with NO ICE so our drinks were warm. When the food finally came, they brought the appetizers and entrées at the SAME TIME, who does that? The food wasn't even that good and was salty. read more

The food was actually good . The decor was nice . They have no liquor except for some wine that you have to get by the bottle . My biggest disappointment with the place is that they literally kick you out we got there around 830 and around 950 they brought us a check and multiple times told us we are closing . It was actually really rude how much they wanted us to leave it completely ruined our night . We saw people trying to come in and they were turning people away at 930 . So I'm giving this place a 2 good food but rude service . read more

Came here with my husband, brother in law and sister in law on a Saturday night. Wait was kind of long. Food was pretty good too, we all enjoyed it. The nachos were delicious, they had real pieces of avocado. PizzAs are all made with a brick oven. The buffalo pizza was a hit or miss with some of us, I personally liked it, it was creamy and good, others didn't like it as much. Portions are big. Service was decent too. They didn't honor the 20% off check in that's offered on yelp. read more

See all

One Friday morning over the summer we desperately needed to find Shabbat dInner because our oven and stove weren't functioning properly. My brother ordered the teriyaki salmon entree with a few sides, and I built a salad. The salmon was very tasty, but my salad did not taste fresh at all. Also, it was extremely expensive, so I'm not sure if we will ever return there. read more

I am fuming, this is the second time that the upper crust has screwed me. Just trying to enjoy a nice night tonight, decided to order Uber eats order the tuna steak Uber driver came and the whole dish was not there. I called upper crust immediately and they nonchalantly said "oh we don't have the tuna" no apology no I'm sorry, nothing. They let you order from the menu on Uber and it says nothing about not having the dish, or giving you an alternative. So this total moron answers the phone and doesn't even have the common decency to say I'm sorry, all he states in a monotone is "what would you like me to do sir we don't have it" Thanks for being unprofessional, unreliable, and ruining my Saturday evening. Guess it was worth pissing off a reliable loyal customer and getting a one star yelp review. I will not be ordering from upper crust again. read more

Amazing food! Amazing atmosphere! I have been there only a few times, but I pass by a lot and I always see a line of people who are willing to wait for available table and they don't want to go anywhere else. Very kind and friendly personal. I would recommend it to everyone! It's kosher and it's amazing! read more

Delicious food! Amazing prices! Lots of parking outside! Great Waiter service and customer service! Ask them for there phenomenal nachos with cheeses it's WOW!!!!!! Eggplant Parmesan delicious! read more

The Upper Crust - Best Eggplant Parmesan Ever! - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

See all

I wasn't sure I would like kosher Italian food but I had the baked ziti here for lunch and I will say I think it's the best baked ziti I ever had as good as in any Italian restaurant . They use vodka sauce and the cheese was browned it was perfect loved it can't wait to try again ! read more

Phenomenal. I had the Jerusalem pizza. It was the best. The atmosphere is amazing and the food is superb.

I was there last night . The food was amazing . I had their nachos and avocado salad . For main course I had their eggplant Parmesan. It was delicious. The waiter was very friendly . Eggplant Parmesan was a big portion that I could not finish it . I had it with Ziti . It was very fresh and well cook . I also had a cheese cake . I will recommend this restaurant to my friends and my family . I will probably go back to this place soon . read more

Let me tell you, The Upper Crust was certainly fantastic. Firstly, the price is hard to beat. Every item I have tried was so fresh and yummy. Team made sure every thing was all right. Overall, I love The Upper Crust. read more

Upper crust is a very nice restaurant with great food and great staff but when I got my nachos they were burnt so I asked for a replacement and the manager was extremely rude about it and he said that's how they always make it and he's not doing anything about it.... read more

Great food great people and a GOAT of server named Gabe who make sure all our needs are fufilled and would 100 percent recommend him for anyone. read more

This place charged me 43$ for a pie and fries. And the catch is when I went to get the pie, it was 12 inches! and the fries were microwaved, doused in truffle oil, and sprinkled with parmigiana. Disgusting. read more

The food was great, seating was comfortable and immediate for our party of 7. The staff was pleasant. The only problem was that the food came out to fast, barely started our soup when the main dishes came out. That should be our biggest problem read more

I ordered the branzino dinner from upper crust, which comes with a side of sautéed spinach and whipped truffle potatoes. The branzino was TERRIBLE, it was the driest piece of fish I ever had in my life. I couldn't finish eating it because it was SO DRY. I don't know what they did to get it so dry, because branzino is a very moist and succulent fish. They forgot to give me my sautéed spinach. I asked to switch the mashed potatoes for truffle fries, and they put the fries in a container with fish, which makes the fries soggy. It's standard practice in restaurants everywhere to put fries in a paper bag so they don't get soggy. That's Restaurant 101. I wasted my money on this terrible food, and I will never eat the lower crust, again. read more

The Upper Crust - Nasty dry fish + soggy fries =Yuck + inedible. - Pizza Near Me - Cedarhurst, New York

I would have given 4.5 stars for lack of attention by wait staff in regards to refills and following up consistenly after ordering. On one occasion the wait to order after given menus was a bit. But nothing that would deter me from returning. And granted they may have been busy with other chores, i just tend to down the small glass portion faster than others. Food is fresh and the items and well balanced and offer a bit for everyone. Great selection of appetizers and salads. Pizzas are well done in a brick / wood fired oven. Pastas offer a selection of both dairy and vegetarian selections. And did i mention the menu has a well balanced mix. This place has a little something for everyone in the family. A little pricey but id rather pay a little extra for a experience that doesnt dissapoint. Find a seat away from the door when its cold out, tends to be a draft which can be uncomfortable. Keep it up. read more

Pizza is delicious. Service is quick. They didn't honor the check-in and receive 20% off and claimed that was only for mobile orders. They gave me the tax off instead. LOL. read more

Great food, plenty of seating space and staff is super friendly!! We were super indecisive about what dessert to get so they offered to combine it together and make it our decision easier and the pie tasted amazing!! read more

See all

No. That really sums up my experience there today. My friend and I waited for 15 minutes just to get a table. Once seated, it took a while for the server to take our order. My food came pretty quickly, but my friend's food took forever to come. All the surrounding people got their food before us, even though they arrived and ordered after us. read more

Dined with my 2 children and 3 cousins at the Upper Crust. Everyone loved their food and I truly enjoyed the creative nature of the menu. I had their aloha pizza and it was great! All the ingredients seemed fresh and the staff was very accommodating. 4 instead of 5 stars because we ordered the salmon egg rolls and only 2 came. I felt like for an appetizer this was just not enough for the price tag. Maybe the server could have told us when we ordered for a group of 6 that this came with only 2 pieces? Also, they only take a few reservations every night, which I don't quite understand. A reservation is a reservation. Two different levels of customers?? read more

It can get pretty crowded, especially in the back part of the restaurant. However they did recently open an extension, so this may have helped with the overall feeling. Food can be hit or miss, but mostly hit in my experience. A bit on the expensive side compared to, say, an Olive Garden or something, but isn't all kosher food? Overall, a pretty great restaurant that could become excellent. read more

Absolutely horrendous after being told to pick up in 15 minutes we waited an hour for our food. To start the lady on the phone had attitude she messed up half our order. When we actually sat down to eat we were all so frustrated everything was cold tasteless and just pure gross. When we called and asked for a refund of 182 dollars they said they don't have the authority to give us more then 50 so now I have to chase the main office to get my money back. So it's just great really they took almost 200 dollars for me and gave me disgusting food that no one can eat. Never again, I DO NOT RECOMMEND! read more

Usually I like this place. Tonight I tried a new salad it was avocado with the bbq sauce drizzle and I woke up in middle of the night feeling very very nauseous have bad heart burn from this salad and feel like I got a stomach virus or something because I am feeling really awful. This salad gets a thumbs down from me. The flavors don't go together I wish I would have gotten something else read more

Really disappointed. Came here once about 1.5 years ago, got extremely sick from the food. Had an extremely long day and wanted some comfort food and after looking at yelp reviews decided to give it one more shot. Called in advance to make sure they could seat 2. We told the lady we would be there at 9:15pm since we don't live in the area, she told us as long as we are there before 9:45pm we will be seated. Drove 40 minutes, got there at 9:16pm.. at 9:18pm the waiter told us we can't be served since it's past 9:15? We told him to double check bc we drove all this way and even called to confirm! At that point, the manager approached us and told us that he can't seat us..! I told him I would be writing a review and he quickly apologized and offered us a seat. We left. We will never go back or recommended. Great restaurants down the block.. with much better service! read more

Delicious food although there was a misunderstanding by our waiter. He forgot to bring the appetizer we ordered. Would definitely go again. read more

My family absolutely adores this restaurant, My kids have lots of food options in the area but this place wins hands down,

All kosher restaurants should learn from The Upper Crust. Fast seating (even without a reservation), friendly waiter, quick attentive service, food fresh and hot moments after ordering. Nothing fancy, just a wonderful dining experience. read more