We went here over Memorial Day weekend. We were greeted by the host and shown to our table immediately. Our server Andrew was very accommodating. My daughter and I shared the crab cake salad and they gave us two different dressings since our taste isn't the same and we shared the lobster quesadillas. Both were my favorite meals of our whole trip. We sat outside and enjoyed the scenery looking out over the water and docks. read more

See all

Patricia was our server, excellent Service. We picked this restaurant for its location and reviews on the clam chowder. Both good. Nice view. Good food. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - View from the dining room and outdoor seating area. Across from an active harbor. - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

I heard from the locals that this was a sister restaurant to Colombo's, so I had to try it. Friendly staff when I walked in. Torrey the bartender was awesome. Very attentive. She made sure my glass was always full. I met the chef as well. Mark might have been his name. In ordered some clam chowder, wow was I impressed. Then I had the lobster we quesadillas. The amount of lobster and the sauce geez he nailed it. My friends also ordered the salmon with potatoes rare. Absolutely full of flavor. And salmon tacos I believe. The menu is pretty well balanced. Might have a new place to hang out. Prices are reasonable. Emanates are clean. Staff is wonderful. A lot of locals. Great atmosphere, everyone knew everyone. I'll definitely be back. Love that place! The peanut butter pie and oysters with shrimp, couldn't be any fresher! read more

See all

6 of us came here for a late lunch as we liked the name and were told it had good food. We called and spoke with Scott, the manager, to make reservations and had to change them a couple times due to bad traffic getting there, and he was super accommodating. I had a turkey wrap with no bacon and it was really good and my wife had a Side Caesar salad that she really enjoyed. Our 4 friends also enjoyed their meals. We are glad we went there and should we be in Hyannis again just might come back read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Sign outside the restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

We sat outside and had a beautiful view of the harbor, such a great setting! The only downside was that one of us ended up sitting directly in the sun and started to feel the heat pretty quickly, so keep that in mind if you go on a sunny day. We started with a cup of chowder and now I see why it's award-winning: creamy, flavorful, and absolutely a must-try. The giant lobster roll was good, not great. It was fresh and generously portioned, but the flavor fell a little flat for me. If you're not already a lobster roll lover, you could probably skip this one. The fried seafood platter was huge, and our favorites were the shrimp and clams. If you love a variety of fried seafood, this is definitely the dish to get! read more

See all

Tried Black Cat Tavern in Hyannis while exploring Cape Cod. It's right near the port, so it's a bit touristy, but still worth checking out. We had the Hyport Burger, baked scallops, and a bowl of clam chowder. All were really good the chowder especially. Creamy and flavorful, definitely one of the better ones I've had on this trip. The burger was juicy and came with all the right toppings. The scallops were baked just right, not dry at all. Portions here are huge. We didn't finish everything except for the chowder that was gone fast. The place has a chill, nautical vibe and there was a live singer the night we went, which added to the mood. Our server, Katie, was super nice and helpful. Prices are on the higher side, but expected for the area. Would I come back? Maybe but I'd also want to try the other restaurants nearby next time. Rating: 3/5 Check out their other dishes too, I saw stuff like lobster roll, fried clams, and baked stuffed shrimp on the menu that looked pretty good read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

We really enjoyed our visit to The Black Cat Tavern. The location is great, right on the water with a lovely atmosphere. The lobster roll was massive and absolutely delicious. We also ordered the seafood tower, and everything on it was fresh and tasty, except for the tuna, which wasn't our favorite. Service was decent, our waitress was a bit scattered at times, but nothing that took away from the overall experience. The only real downside was the small table we were given. With the amount of food we ordered, it felt cramped and a bit awkward. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

My family and I dined here during our recent Cape Cod trip. The location was within walking distance from our hotel. We were seated on the front deck, but still had views of the water across the street. I ordered the Fried Cod Melt with French fries, and the Banana Cream Colada. The food was good - the filet of fish was big and crispy, while the colada was refreshing and wasn't too strong. If we stay in Hyannis again we will be back! read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Banana Cream Colada - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

Came here before getting on the ferry to Nantucket (walkable). Came during the off season, but it was such a treat to be able to sit outside and see the marina. The clam chowder was delicious as was the lobster quesadilla. The sauce on the quesadilla truly makes it so worth it. Staff were friendly and helpful. read more

See all

It actually makes me upset that i even have to write this, but i do not want someone to experience what i did. I go to this place several times a year. This mother's day weekend Saturday night pouring outside, a man met us at the door, having dinner? Yes, they sat us down. 15 mins into sitting we hear that man say "dont close the kitchen" i begin with are you closing? The man says yes but the kitchen is open! Great! Have an amazing dinner the food is always great! See a woman across from us (manager giving looks, staring at the table) then hear just want to clean up for mothers day! So we say ok we can finish our drinks at the bar, they said yes! Go to the bar to be completely ignored by the bartender. After 20 mins i say to the bartender talking to 4 other people with full drinks, are you closed? He states Yes! What..... Why seat us if you are closing and why give looks because we haven't finished eating. Why let us go to the bar then... SMH Bad Management! Sorry this was the worst experience i have ever had there. Food Excellent, Management do better! read more

My friend and I came here with no reservation for dinner and we were seated right away. We didn't realize we were in the harbor shack which is separate from the full restaurant haha. It was hard to tell from the way we walked in from the parking lot on the side, we just walked up the first set of stairs we saw with a hostess stand and thought that was the full restaurant. The tavern part is next door but we enjoyed the shack! We had delicious mudslides and I really liked my sandwich! I was grateful they had gluten free bread! read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Mudslides - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

We sat in the Shack Out Back. They had live acoustic music on a Wednesday night around dinner time. He was very entertaining. Played some Tom Petty without me even requesting it. Our server was super sweet and attentive. Started with the oysters--they come with cocktail sauce and lemon by default, but ask for the mignonette (trust me, do it!). Hands down my favorite oysters I had on the Cape. Tried the lobster bisque too. Not a ton of lobster chunks, but the flavor was still amazing. I'd totally get it again. The hot lobster roll was the main attraction. It was delicious! So warm and buttery and flavorful. Large portion. I ordered mine with sweet potato fries. YUM. Very happy with my choice! read more

We were disappointed. The restaurant was very loud. Our server was not friendly. The food was OK. I thought the chowder was very good and served in a coffee cup which at first was confusing but when I thought of "a cup of chowder" very cute. I ordered steak tips, which were a little tough and I wasn't expecting teriyaki flavor. We also had baked stuffed shrimp. The stuffing was spicy and the shrimp were a little bit bland. The host was very nice and quite funny. read more

See all

Their "award winning" clam chowder is cooked in bacon stock. They don't even disclose this in the menu. Watermelon Spritzer was bland and tasteless. Shoe string fries unfortunately live up to their name. The only nice part of our lunch was attentive and courteous staff. Would not go back again. read more

Went on a Thursday 3:30 late lunch early dinner time frame. Very friendly waitress. Lobster bisque was delivered quickly and delicious! Could have been a bit more lobster meat but we loved it. The crab cake was also so fresh and flavorful, loved it. Buffalo tenders great and spice just right. Chicken quesadillas good however they used dark chicken meat as opposed to white and that detracted the taste a bit for me, but it was still good but not excellent. Would have liked a little guacamole and sour cream w it but got salsa and sriracha Mayo. Casual atmosphere and enjoyable vibe. Would definitely return. Pricey but that's the area, so expected. I took one star off for the dark chicken meat used in the quesadillas, but that's my personal preference for white meat. read more

See all

Maddie our waitress was amazing! We had such a great experience. We made a reservation in advance and were seated promptly. We sat outside and had a great view of the water. We had lobster, fish, soup and grilled cheese! Everything was full of flavor and the seafood was so fresh. Bathrooms were clean and well stocked. Parking was a pain, but that's the cape. When we return, we will be back! read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Relaxed atmosphere, good food, we really liked this place. Really good Old Fashioned, great fried fish platter, and service was excellent. What really impressed me was that I paid cash, and apparently some of the bills stuck together. Rather than pocket it the server came back and asked if I meant to leave all that, which was very classy. Speaks highly of the restaurant and staff that they looked out for their customers like that. Highly recommend. read more

Loved the award winning chowder, huge lobster roll and wonderful service! The decor feels like you're on a yacht. Would definitely go back

Some locals recommended we have dinner here, & it was a great tip. All outdoor seating near the water, so pretty! The service was great, I needed help finding gluten free options & one of the servers provided me with a handwritten multi page list of options, including things they can make thats not on the menu. Therefore, I ended up with a delicious plate of grilled scallops. My wife had the fried oysters. I took a bite & it was the best fried oysters I ever tasted & I hate them. Clam chowder was delicious too. Considering the location, it could be a serious tourist trap. But it wasn't! Huge portions for the price, I would return. read more

See all

Surrounded by dozens of appealing restaurant options in the bustling, tourist-friendly heart of Hyannis, my mom and I chose The Black Cat Tavern on account of its convenience to our lodging (the Hyannis Travel Inn), a glowing recommendation by the affable and knowledgable concierge at our front desk, as well as - admittedly - its fun and slightly macabre name. Boy, did we pick right. Maybe we should play the lotto tonight too, because this place is a total winner. We sat outside, which isn't always synonymous with attentive service, but that couldn't be further from the case at The Black Cat. This is a tightly run ship (nautical pun intended), and the service is impeccable. The entire staff is so welcoming, so diligent, and so kind...and fun! Cape Cod is a vacation destination, of course, and it's a breath of fresh sea air to spend time with employees who seem to be enjoying their experience as much as their sunburned customers. Our server was Olesya, and she's an absolute dream. I don't know if there's such a thing as National Waitstaff Of The Year Awards, but if she isn't at least nominated at this year's ceremony, I'll boycott the whole thing. In short, I can't recommend this place highly enough. The food is great (the chowder!), the portions are generous (food AND booze!), the price tag is way more reasonable than its nearby competitors, and it's a place you'll feel so comfy and looked after, you won't want to leave. A rare restaurant experience in the best of ways. Thanks Olesya, thanks team, see you again next year (if not sooner). read more

Excellent service, delicious food and perfect martini ; you won't go wrong having dinner here ! read more

See all

Andrew, our server, was helpful in guiding us in selecting a perfect dinner. Our food was delivered hot, promptly , and was delicious. Our drinks were also well-made. We went back the next day for dinner, too!! read more

Dined here recently and had a good experience. Got a burger, chicken ceasar wrap, and some drinks. Food was good, and the drinks were even better. Good service. Would return. read more

See all

We had a great patio dinner in late September, the Black Cat deserves much better reviews than I have seen here. Blackened swordfish was delectable with a creamy sauce and so rich. Has been ordered the shrimp scampi and when the seafood the scampi arrived, the server owned the mistake and gave it to him for the shrimp price. It had huge chunks of lobster in it and he was thrilled. I also had a side of grilled asparagus to go with my scampi, I ordered it after the fact when I saw the dish had no greens. And was very happy with it even if it was late. I had one craft cider and then I had to have another craft cider, it was so good. No dessert, we were completely stuffed with no leftovers but would absolutely recommend the black cat tavern. read more

See all

4 of us arrived around 1:00 on a Wednesday and there were a few tables outside and plenty inside as well as at the bar. SERVICE:We sat at the bar, and Uros took very good care of us. He is pleasant, attentive and ensured he checked in on us throughout our meal. FOOD: The fish and chips were excellent. Flacky fish, thin, crispy fries and yummy cole slaw. The cornmeal cod was ok, not quite melt in your mouth texture. $29, it would have been better if accompanied by some type of rice or potato. It was a pretty presentation. BAR: Comfy seats, beautiful wooden bar. After we left I realized I was charged for a more expensive wine than I ordered, but that is on me for not catching it before settling up. First pour was the end of the bottle and a bit short, second glass was an average pour, $13 for La Crema. ATMOSPHERE: Indoors and outdoors are very inviting. Indoor decor is pretty cool. Parking can be a bit hairy. There is free valet parking, but it shares a lot with the ferry parking and was a bit confusing to navigate where we needed to go, as the first lot was full and was tight driving to the adjacent lot. They were able to accommodate us after the second try. Friendly attendant. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Cornmeal Cod, just ok. Could use a side, $29 - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

We had a lovely dinner here on 3 November 2025. The restaurant is beautifully decorated for autumn. We sat by the fireplace. I had the Award-winning Clam Chowder, and it did not disappoint. Our server (I believe her name is Leone) was very polite and friendly. We told her about our black cat named Sherry. We rescued her from a no-kill shelter where she had been living for 10 years. Leone was so moved by our story that she gave us some Black Cat coaters and stickers. We would come back again because the food was really good and we had great service. Highly recommended. read more

Had an hour to kill before picking someone up at the ferry , I see a sign saying " award winning clam chowder " I sat on the porch and ordered a bowl of chowder and a coffee . Took a while for the two hostess standing there find a waitress to take my order . I thought the chowder was small for a bowl, but looking online a bowl is 8 to 12oz so there good . The chowder was mediocre at best , definitely not award winning but hot and ok. Ordered a 2nd cup of coffee and waitress didn't bring me any cream . They serve the cream in a little plastic cup , enough for one coffee. All in all it was ok , definitely wouldn't spend $20 on chowder and coffee there again . read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Bowl of chowder next to my cup of coffee . - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

The tuna tacos were wonderful! The flavor was great. Service was excellent! We sat on the porch on our first visit was a nice ambiance. They had heaters. Their Chocolate Dream martini was great as a dessert. read more

See all

Great service from Janee D. Very good martini Ordered the ahi tuna app. It was good, entree came as I was half way through my appetizer . Hate that! Baked stuffed scallops "extra crumbs, baked potato with sour cream, coleslaw " Scallops were dry, not many crumbs, sour cream was a pourable sauce(?), coleslaw was good. Carrot cake was Delicious, as was the fresh decaf. read more

Food, excellent. This place was great, a total must visit if you're a tourist. The servers were doing their best because the place was jumping. They also provided my wife with this tiny receipt that was a hand written Gluten-free menu, she died of laughter but was very grateful! I think you guys should just print some GF menus up on printer paper & take it to Staples & have a few laminated. And tell the servers to let guest know there's a gluten-free menu available upon request. This would have saved my wife time from mulling over her options on the regular menu. Overall, this place was great. Lots of food for your money. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Black Cat Tavern sign - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

we asked to sit inside for a more upscale dining experience as opposed to sitting in the garden and they were able to accommodate us very quickly which was greatly appreciated read more

See all

Delicious seafood and appetizers!! A bit crowded at the Hyannis pier, but the service and the food are excellent. For lobster lovers the lobster salad is as great as a lobster roll, but without the extra bread. Great place to bring visitors. read more

Absolutely perfect! This place was recommended by the trolley driver, George. My wife has celiac disease so we have to be extra careful. The waitress and the hostess both understood the assignment. Our meals were prepared, absolutely perfectly! Both of our meals were outstanding. I have no relationship with this establishment or anyone there. I am just a visitor. I could not have asked for anything more. read more

See all

No confusion here haha. Owner's reply is funny. Educate yourself on the difference between a cash discount and a surcharge before ripping off customers and putting staff in bad spot. Just raise your prices and build the cost of doing business into your menu. Bad expectation setting. Cheap. Wont return read more

We were so excited to try The Black Cat Tavern when visiting the Cape! It was recommended by a friend and did not disappoint. Here is what we had and how I would rate: - Cesar salad (7/10) - Clam chowder (8.5/10) - Fried seafood platter (10/10) Their Claim chowder was very thick and creamy (which I love) and their fried seafood platter was delicious. From the fries to the fried scallops, it was so tasty and just the right amount of batter for the fried seafood. Overall, definitely check out this spot if you're in the mood for delicious, no-frills seafood! :) read more

See all

When you go to cape cod, there are a plethora of places to get a lobster roll, but if you want get THE BEST, look no further than The black cat's lobster roll! So fresh and so tasty! The martinis were great! Service is so warm and friendly! I brought my dog with me and they brought him a fresh water bowl and gave him lots of belly rubs, which he loved! It's right by the bay, so you can feel the nice breeze on a hot summer day. The interior is gorgeous and timeless! Will be back for sure! read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Staff was not knowledgable about their menu, took 30 minutes to find out the price of a lobster. Food was underwhelming especially for the price and service. read more

It was our first trip to the area. Not much was open in November 2024. The black cat tavern was a really nice place for lunch on this chilly day. The restaurant was clean and the staff were very friendly. The chowder was really good. We would definitely go back. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

The service was excellent. The server came over to check on us and offered more drinks. The view looking at the ocean was so pretty. Although there was a street covering it so that kinda sucked but it was mostly nice. The food was AMAZING. I got the Fish and chips. The cod was cooked PERFECTLY and tasted amazing. The Burgers are excellent also. Best burger I have ever tasted. Their tacos are very nice. Definitely recommend. read more

The Black Cat Tavern - Kids Fish & Chips - Seafood Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

stopped by for Mothers day meal last nigh.Really cool boat themed decor. Friendly bartender made us some tasty cocktails.I had the stuffie as an app and it was delicious! My wife had the Halibut with lobster sauce with risotto. She is still talking about how good it was My swordfish was good,only thing is the mash was coolish not a big deal. Great overall experience,we will be back! read more