Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Thirsty Pagan Brewing

    4.3 (287 reviews)
    ModerateBreweries, Pizza
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Thirsty Pagan Brewing Takeout or Delivery

    Thirsty Pagan Brewing Photos

    Business Info

    THIRSTY PAGAN BREWING ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Thirsty Pagan Brewing

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Pepperoni pizza with feta personal size
    Annie D.

    Great local spot for pizza and live music. They also host various other events like trivia. We stopped in on a Saturday for lunch as my dad liked the local band performing. We got the loaded pretzel bites and a personal sized pizza with pepperoni and feta. I love that they have personal sized pizza options so everyone can get something they like. Food was good and it is a cool location being in an old train depot.

    Best pizza in the tri state area. Been going here for years and they haven't changed a thing about the quality of their pizzas (which is exactly how it should be)

    Burnt wood black beer
    Johnna H.

    Just came in for a beer and snack. Our group got the stuffed mushrooms, loaded pretzel and a personal pan pizza. The mushrooms were delicious with some taste of garlic. Loaded pretzel was good too but like mushrooms more. Personal pan even though small was perfect! I washed it down with a craft beer. Come give them a try.

    Rueben- after a few bites
    Diane C.

    Excellent service, a creative menu and a good selection of beverages. The reuben appetizer was even better than the calzone, which was excellent! Give this place a try!

    Exterior view from the road

    Hands down, some of the best customer service I've had for a large party. I reached out to Deb via email about hosting my daughter soccer team for a team family dinner on a Friday evening. She responded to my request in less than 24 hours. She was very kind and helpful. She graciously gave me time to gather final numbers and call her back about 3 days before the event. We had 40 people, choose to do the salad, pizza, and soda option. They also were able to accommodate with Gluten Free pizzas too! We asked for food to be ready and served right at 7pm and they were set up and right on time!! We had one other server Shana helping. Both Deb and her were smiling and cheerful! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this venue to groups of all sizes. The building is a historic train depot and they did a wonderful job keeping the original charm of the building while turning it into a beautiful venue!! Thank you Deb and Steve!!

    Personal pizza with sausage, red peppers, and onions.
    Pete G.

    This was a nice stop on a weekday night when I was passing through town. They have live entertainment, which worried me at first, but it turned out delightful- a solo singer/acoustic guitarist with real talent. The personal pizza (I chose sausage, red peppers, onions) was quite tasty. The tomato soup special tasted a bit too much like pizza sauce, which was a little odd (but OK). Staff were very friendly, but unable to properly recommend a smooth tasting beer out of their collection (I'm sure they do better with IPAs).

    Mickensie W.

    This was some of the best pizza that we've had! The crust was amazing. Loved that the patio was dog friendly as well. Awesome menu with lots of options. Pizza, calzones, a large selection of brews. I liked being able to do a personal pizza with 3 toppings. Their homemade sausage was bomb. We definitely will make this a regular stop when we go up north again!

    Outside seating area
    Denise F.

    Stopped in twice while camping in the area. Place was recommended by my nephew who has played music there a few times. He knows we like quality craft beer and pizza. Man, we were not disappointed! Nice selection of different brews, tasty pizza, breads and salads, friendly capable servers. Unique setting inside and out. Plenty of parking. I treated myself to some merch. Owner Steve there the 2nd time we were in and he was incredibly personable and knowledgeable.

    Welcome to TPB!
    Lyn H.

    This place is such a vibe! It's like a eclectic hippie took a Green Mill and made it their own. Came on a Wednesday eve and it was moderately full and a epic mustache guy strumming on a guitar. All the young (good looking) staff were attentive and kind. Seemed clean and family friendly(ish)! There are a few tables outside and did see a couple with a dog. Food came out promptly and was good. Brownie for dessert was just OK. Despite my mediocre brownie - I would recommend and will definitely be visiting again!

    Cheese bread
    Kellie D.

    We were in town for Grandma's Marathon and picked this place for our post race dinner. We could not have picked a more perfect place! There was a short wait of 15-20 minutes when our party of four arrived. We went to a bar for a couple beverages while we waited. I ordered the Lawn Chair cream ale and, to be honest, it was one of my least favorite cream ales I've had. Still, any beer is good after a marathon. We were seated within the 15-20 minutes they quoted. We ordered the cheese bread as an appetizer which came with a cup of dipping sauce. I love pizza sauce so that was a great plus. We ordered second beers. This time I had the Dreams of Orange cream ale. Now that one was a wonderful cream ale! Then we all ordered pizzas. Husband and son split a large pizza. The waitress warned them that it was very big and I told her that we'd just run a marathon. She said even so she didn't think they could eat it all. Darned if she wasn't right! It was the thickest, most topping filled pizza I have ever seen! Granted it was not cheap at $42 but they loved it and did have leftovers. Son's girlfriend ordered a 10 inch pizza and I ordered a gluten free spinach and feta. Mine was fabulous, especially for a gluten free and also came with delicious dipping sauce! It was the perfect post race meal! I highly recommend it if you're hungry and like beer and pizza.

    Jen S.

    Upon first looks on the place it seemed kind run down. Not a very clean location on the outside. However, we decided to sit on the patio. The drinks and food were pretty good. If you are looking for some unique breweries check this place out.

    Good friends, United in Wisconsin
    Andrew H.

    After a trip to the Minnesota high point, this was EXACTLY what we were looking for: Staff: outstanding service and very friendly. (this is WI so, that's a given.) Beers: average selection of standard beers, but some great seasonals! Food: they make pizza, but it is 100% their own. I don't even know how to describe this style of pizza. It's think, but it ain't cakey and it certainly ain't deep dish. It's unlike any pizza I have ever had. Ambiance: the best aspect of this brewery, live music EVERY NIGHT. Don't hesitate to cross the bridge into 'Sconi!

    Chicken alfredo pizza sub red sauce and missing chicken

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Best pizza in the twin ports! Great service and friendly atmosphere. They have amazing cheesecake too and you can't beat the price :)

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 8 of 8

    Ask the Community - Thirsty Pagan Brewing

    Do you serve bloody marys?

    Yes, we serve bloody mary's and mimosas all day, every Saturday and Sunday!

    Is this place kid friendly at all during regular dinner hours? My son is 2.

    Yes, we are kid friendly all the time!

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Breweries 548 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bent Paddle Brewing - Nice patio area

    Bent Paddle Brewing

    4.6(85 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    I had heard great things about Bent Paddle Brewing's taproom - and it did not disappoint. A huge…read morestage with music set up outside and the inside was extremely expansive. Bent Paddle Brewing Company is a family-owned and operated craft brewery and taproom in Duluth, Minnesota. The brewery opened in May 2013 and uses Lake Superior water to brew it's beers and hemp beverages. Bent Paddle's mission is to create a unique craft beer experience while also being sustainable for the business, employees, environment, and community. And they deliver on it all. I got a flight to enjoy some of their more limited offerings. Munchin Pretzels: An Oktoberfest beer brewed with traditional German Malts and Hops. I get toasted bread malt character with a bit of sweetness, but rounded out by a hop bitterness. The malt profile is definitely the forefront and I wished I had a pretzel to go with it. Infinity Stuf: An Oatmeal Stout that they went all out with 100 pounds of Oreos. Nutty oatiness, chocolate, and medium fullness. I appreciate it not being a Pastry Stout, but still get lots of Oreo character. A Beer of Their Own: A Hoppy Pale Ale brewed in collaboration with a Bar Of Their Own in the Twin Cities. Tropical fruit forward - primarily melon and cantaloupe, with a nice finish. Stratarado: A Hoppy Pale Ale brewed with Strata and El Dorado (get the name?). Tropical fruit, pineapple, some sweetness on the tongue. Liked this one a lot. ______

    Checked out Bent Paddle while in Duluth. I'm not from the area, but I was already well acquainted…read morewith their tasty malt beverages before I visited. They have all kinds of beer. I like a crisp, refreshing, clean tasting pilsner, and theirs has been perfected. The place has a nice atmosphere to sit down indoors or outdoors and just hang out, whether it's a date or just with friends. I will be back when in Duluth again!

    Photos
    Bent Paddle Brewing
    Bent Paddle Brewing
    Bent Paddle Brewing

    See all

    Warrior Brewing Company - Entrance

    Warrior Brewing Company

    4.5(10 reviews)
    2.7 mi

    I was quite excited to see what Duluth has to offer on our recent first visit (especially as a fan…read moreof Bob Dylan's music). Researching different parks, restaurants, coffee places and breweries, Warrior's art caught my eye. Curious to try the beer behind the bottle, we had the chance to drop by on our way southbound to Minneapolis about a month ago. Despite being in a multi-business strip mall, Warrior commands its own space the second you walk in. The owner was incredibly laid-back and welcoming, offering suggestions base on taste palate and providing a couple of free small samples before committing. I'm open to try any style myself, from the lightest table beer to the most robust barrell-aged stout; Warrior's selection runs the gamut in bold, distinct contrast. I highly recommend the flight (even if you're not the biggest beer fan, you have to appreciate the sword-shaped serving board). Personal standouts were the Barbarian Imperial Stout (much less harsh or boozy than you might expect) and the Samurai Red IPA. A short drive southwest of downtown, don't miss Warrior on a trip through Duluth. I may have to battle that commute from STL to make another visit myself someday.

    Great backstory. This is the location of the former Lake superior brewery. The beer was pretty…read moregood. Super friendly service. No food but a nice outdoor space, you can have dogs outside. Nice merch

    Photos
    Warrior Brewing Company - Keep following the signs

    Keep following the signs

    Warrior Brewing Company - Interior

    Interior

    Warrior Brewing Company - Games

    See all

    Games

    Anchor Bar - Between the three dollar pitchers and the pile of meat in the Gallybuster. You won't leave here unsatisfied like she does!

    Anchor Bar

    3.9(399 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $

    Can't recommend the Anchor enough! The nautical themed establishment at the north end of Tower Ave…read morein Superior perfectly blends what I expect from a Wisconsin dive bar along with the vibes of Lake Superior. The beer was very cold, and I was pleasantly surprised that ordering a "tall" got me a pitcher. The jalapeño cream cheese burger was the most recommended item to me, and it lived up to the hype. I'm in Duluth more often than Superior, but the Anchor is definitely worth the trip across the bridge.

    This is a highly recommended place. We went and sat in a nook . They have very interesting decor…read more This is definitely a super dive bar which is not my thing. Everything looked super cute but there were coloring and crayon scribbles on everything. It was on the books, the tables the displays etc. I asked a local friend and they said this is normal. When the waitress went to take our drink orders she was ok slightly rude. We looked at our friend and he said they aren't known for their service and can be a little rude. I asked if it's like Dicks Last Resort and he laughed and said no. I think she was okay after that and was like a standard waitress at more restaurants after . I would just say dont expect bending over backwards to make the customer number 1 service . I'm okay with that. They have some very interesting and yummy selections for burgers . I got excited for a blue cheese Burger. I will say that my Pattie was very well done and the bun was on point. The blue cheese dressing top.... Not what I want for a blue cheese burger . I was expecting the blue cheese crumble. The fries... bomb! Definitely get fries. Do I want to go back? Maybe if can sit outside on a nice day. Sort of got the ick sitting inside but it's because I'm not a dive bar kind of girl.

    Photos
    Anchor Bar
    Anchor Bar - ANCHOR bar's famous bacon burger with fries and sautéed onions added

    ANCHOR bar's famous bacon burger with fries and sautéed onions added

    Anchor Bar - The Ole standby...pitcher of beer for the table

    See all

    The Ole standby...pitcher of beer for the table

    Thirsty Pagan Brewing - breweries - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...