Love that this is a locally owned and operated shop! Pittsburgh's suburban neighborhoods are desperately begging for bagel shops. Out here in the North Hills, we've been stuck with chain options -- so when Three Brothers Bagels came to Shaler, it really helped fill a void. This place is a great destination for all kinds of bagels, bagel sandwiches, baked goods AND really, really good soup. My personal favorite so far has been the potato leek soup with bagel croutons. It was so good that I'd love to see it become a menu staple rather than just a special. As for the bagels themselves, the selection strikes a nice balance of savory and sweet, and the spreads and fillings follow suit. What I especially love is that the sandwiches go beyond just breakfast -- there are creative, lunch-style options that set them apart. And yes, their bagels are chewy and might give your jaw a workout after a whole sandwich, but honestly... isn't that just what a bagel is? Tip: Make sure you get there early or plan to order ahead this place is SO popular and regularly sells out. I'm also looking forward to seeing their food truck out and about. Highly recommend for anyone in the North Hills looking for quality bagels, sandwhiches, soups and some genuinely great baked goods! read more

Pretty solid bagel place, definitely one of the better ones in the Pittsburgh area! They got a small shop, but they're definitely slinging a lot of product very quickly so get there earlier and prepare to wait a little bit too, but it's pretty worth it! The different types of bagels are good, Jalepeno cheddar could have a little more Jalepeno in it, but solid. The real highlight was the sausage egg and cheese, the sausage being freshly pressed and made in house really made it standout, definitely recommend! Overall, it's a real good spot for a bagel sandwich, plus they got coffee and some other treats that people were raving about, def will try next time! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Sausage, Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

OK I will admit it the BLT is addictive. I learned my lesson and put my online order in early this morning. I decided to try their soup. I thought the price was a little high for the portion size. The potato leek soup was chunky with homemade croutons. Very good. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Potato leek soup with homemade croutons - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

As soon as you walk in the smell was terrible, I tried to think maybe it was the yeast from the bagels but it was awful. None of us liked the food and the service terrible staff was ignorant read more

We arrived at the plaza and saw the Three Brothers Bagels sign in an Arial font face. We walked in, and inside was packed and kind of noisy; all tables and seats were occupied. We ordered different bagel sandwiches and orange juice. They unfortunately do not have decaf. While waiting, we kept an eye on anyone about to leave a table. Thankfully, a family was leaving, so we stood next to their table and sat there after they left. They called our names, and we got our food and sat back down. We ate half of our bagel sandwiches because they were so filling. My Reuben was particularly yummy. The establishment got quieter as the morning busyness lessened. For the price and the delicious sandwiches, it was worth the drive. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Reuben - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Amazing east coast style bagels with a great vibe and friendly staff. The bagels are freshly made daily and have the perfect balance of chew and denseness. Can't really go wrong with any of their spreads, breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Seeing Taylor ham on the menu was a plus as someone from Jersey. read more

See all

great bagels and so love the location. The staff are friendly and always happy to help .

Three brothers had really great reviews so I wanted to check it out. Start to finish, the experience took 1 hour to get 2 bagels toasted with cream cheese. 35 minutes in line waiting to order. Then 25 minutes after I ordered to get 2 bagels. They were super busy. I feel like they should limit their uber eats, DoorDash etc orders if they don't have capacity to timely complete orders. Or they need to limit the orders coming in since they cannot keep up. They do have online ordering for in store pick up so in the future that may be easier. Additionally, people were receiving items at different times. Saw a guy get his coffee drinks and didn't get his bagels for 30 minutes after. The staff was super kind and friendly. Everyone was very focused on pumping out orders. It was very hectic. I do praise the staff for putting up with this style of operation. When I got the bagels, they were not toasted that well. I noticed this with other peoples bagels. I don't think they have a sufficient toaster for their operation. Probably need 2-3 of those toasters and on a longer toast setting. The bagel was very average. It was a decent bagel and the cream cheese was good. The ratio of spread to bagel was good. The bagel definitely left me wanting more. I felt disappointed I had waited so long for something that was a little lackluster. Also! Their bagels are wicked expensive. $5 per bagel with spread is wild. To get one container of cream cheese it's minimum $7. I was shocked by this. Biggest takeaways: they want to be able to meet the demand of the customers but by rapidly taking business from every corner of the market, they aren't able to deliver quality consistently. This isn't the place it used to be. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Everything Bagel & Spread - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

I went once for breakfast. I got the bacon, egg and cheese on a cheddar jalapeño bagel. I am a sucker for a cheddar jalapeño bagel. This was so good. Then I went back for lunch a few weeks later and got the turkey club on an everything bagel. And I think more sandwiched need to be made on bagels. I added onion to mine and got American cheese instead of Swiss. The staff was so nice both times I went. I found parking easily. They were sold out of some bagels when I went for lunch. I will be back to try more. read more

See all

Wow! I think this is easily THE best bagel sandwich I have ever had ! I went with the pastrami egg and cheese . Highly recommend!

This is one of the top 3 best bagel spots in Pittsburgh! Highly recommend going. The bagels are made so fresh, and they load their bagels with cream cheese! They have many different options to choose from, and everything is so reasonably priced. We got the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese and the sesame bagel with jalepeno cream cheese. The jalepeno cream cheese was very tasty! However, the veggie cream cheese needed some more salt/seasoning to taste. The service was very good, and we got our bagels very quickly. Heads up, they sell out fast. read more

I stopped by here earlier today with my wife and our twins for our morning coffee. Every weekend we try to hit up a new local coffee shop and on this morning we decided to go to Three Brothers Bagels. While technically not a coffee shop per se, they do serve coffee. This also wasn't my first visit, although it was way more crowded this time around. Besides the crowds, the shop had a number of places to sit as well as a bright and open interior. There is a clean and modern feel with white walls, natural wood accents, and black and silver fixtures. Bagels are displayed in baskets above the prep counter, while pastries and cookies are showcased up front in a wood-framed glass case. A large printed menu hangs over the prep area with a clearly marked list of spreads, bagels, and sandwiches. It is a functional space and well-organized even with the bustle. On this morning I decided to go with a 16 oz salted caramel cold foam cold brew for my drink and then the pastrami egg and cheese sandwich on a cheddar and jalapeño bagel, while my wife went with the classic lox on an everything bagel. The menu described mine as fried egg, house-smoked pastrami, and cheddar on a bagel, and my wife's as smoked salmon, tomato, red onion, capers, herbs, and choice of spread. From the time we ordered until our food was ready ended up taking 35 minutes. While the seven employees working were hustling, I wish I had been told it would be that long, especially since I had young children with me. Once we got the food, I will say that it was good. The bagel had a nice exterior and a good chew, while the salty savory pastrami and cheddar worked well with it. My wife also enjoyed her lox and her bagel. As for my coffee, well, it wasn't as good as expected. The foam was a bit on the thinner side and didn't stand up to the bitterness of the coffee as much as I would like. Then the flavor of the foam was a bit salty but I got nothing as far as the promised caramel. So from that standpoint the coffee was disappointing. The bottom line for me is that I might head back here again in the future. While I thought that my food was good, the coffee was just ok and the wait was long. read more

See all

Have wanted to come and grab some bagels since the shop opened! Well today we got our 1st half dozen. Growing up in a New Jersey I have high expectations for bagels, and you have met them! Light crunch to the outside & perfect texture on the inside. The flavor of the French toast bagel & garlic herb were amazing! Definitely look forward to many more bagels. The store was well staffed & hustling! Keep up the good work! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Our at home lightly toasted French toast bagel & Garlic herb! Enjoyed splitting them! - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

Pretty good bagels, however, the last two times I went to the store I couldn't even get one. Couple weeks ago I went and they were closed for like a week...I thought there was 3 brothers? One wasn't available? The other day I went and they were out of bagels....it was like an hour before closing ...all you sell is bagels, you'd think making enough would be the priority so as to not have to turn away customers. I love locally owned small businesses, and the bagels are good, but not THAT good. read more

I was on the other side of the shopping center at Acrospire. There was a morning yoga session and Three Brothers Bagels was the recommended option for brunch. I ordered online--everything bagel with egg and avocado. It was ready within 10 minutes. The bagel still had some fluff after being toasted. The egg was cooked with the right amount of runny-ness. I appreciate that they cut the bagel sandwich in half, made things easier. There are daily bagel options that they offer. Unfortunately, it's not on the online menu. Good to know for the future as a jalapeno cheese bagel does sound fun! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Update, I've now tried the babka, and it is transcendent. It's worth the price tag, the loaf yields a TON of delicious bready goodness. I've also revisited several times now for sandwiches and bagel dozens to go, and each time has solidified how great this spot is. The bagels are just as excellent upon taking them home, freezing them, and then re-toastng as they are fresh in the shop. What a gift! read more

Good bagels and coffee! We got the turkey club and the cheesesteak, both really good but would definitely suggest the cheesesteak. Cold brew coffee was good and decently priced. It was very busy so calling ahead would be suggested. We walked in on a Saturday morning and only waited about 15 minutes but no tables were open to sit down. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Turkey club - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

My favorite bagel spot in PGH area. I always get the tuna salad bagel but their BEC is perfect too. These bagels are consistently chewy and good. Would love to see a homemade gluten free bagel in future! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Tuna Salad - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Me and my girlfriend come here often. Always a good experience. The bagels are delicious! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Bacon, egg & cheese on an egg bagel - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

I ordered delivery and got the turkey club on an everything bagel and a bacon, egg & cheese on a plain bagel. The turkey club was delicious, fresh ingredients, great flavor, and super satisfying. Can't wait to dig into the breakfast bagel tomorrow. If it's anything like the turkey club, I know I'm in for something good! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Turkey Club on an everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

It's been great watching this small business evolve since they opened. It's really a nice thing to see. So many places chain a stake in the ground and never have the insight that they need to pull it up or get rid of it all together. Great, stable staff which makes for consistent quality. If I could make one recommendation it would be to focus next on coffee. It currently seems like an afterthought. read more

Yum!!!! Delicious bagels! I got them at Mechanic Coffee in Verona. Super chewy but also light and fluffy. The flavor was so good! Their store isn't too far away from me so now that I had a taste, I'm determined to make it to actually visit! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Everything and Sesame bagel - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Living within walking distance from this place is both a blessing and a curse. It's too good and we probably get food here once or twice a week. My partner and I work from home a lot, and on a busier workday, it's easy for us to justify ordering online and grabbing the pickup order for breakfast or lunch rather than struggling to make something at home. But anyway, what's to like? There's really nothing subpar here. The bagels are fresh and chewy, the sandwich selections are out of this world and the cream cheese flavor options are pretty epic. There really aren't any wrong choices here, but my favorite sandwich is by far the Taylor ham and cheese breakfast sandwich. I had no idea what Taylor ham was before ordering it here. (it's pork roll and basically a bacon/ham hybrid) It's a Jersey thing and consider me converted. The Taylor ham is crispy, the overeasy egg runny, and my favorite bagel here is the asiago, although plain or everything is solid, too. They do run out of certain bagel flavors a lot of the time if you come in later in the day. Other go tos include the tuna salad, the smash burger and the veggie bagel with jalepeño cream cheese. My husband loves the cheese steak and he loves the Cuban when it was on the menu. Did I mention we get takeout here a lot? A few more tips: Be on the lookout for specials and limited run items on their Instagram page. Order ahead online if you can! It makes pickup quick and easy. Their website is very straightforward. Order on a weekday and not Saturday if you can help it, otherwise you're going to be waiting for awhile. It gets very busy on Saturdays. They're closed on Sundays and Mondays, so we can't eat here everyday, but I can't fault them for wanting a break. ;) The biggest struggle for me recently has been finding things here I can eat now that I'm pregnant. But trust me, my first meal after delivery will be that beloved Taylor ham with runny egg. read more

Absolutely delicious bagel spot in Glenshaw! Freshly homemade bagels, a variety of creamy spreads, or grab a breakfast or lunch sammy! Had to have a bacon egg & cheese sandwich- Fresh local ingredients make the bagel, cooked to perfect eggs, crispy bacon and melty cheddar. They have a few seats for indoor dining and offer togo as well. Check out their website for online ordering & their Instagram for specials & sell outs!!! read more

See all

Three Brothers located in a little strip of stores nice bright clean shop with places to sit friendly service and WOW amazing legit good bagels Originally from Long Island I know a good bagel when I eat one and there are legit they have bagels, cream cheeses assorted bottled beverages coffee I also saw cookies and muffins you know a good bagel when you can eat a plain one on its own these are the best husband loves the everything, the pumpernickel are awesome too go have a bagel read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

My husband and I were so excited to finally find a good BEC spot after moving from NYC to the Burgh! These are definitely the best bagels we've had so far here and their bialies are even better - I highly recommend getting one with their pastrami, egg, & cheese! We went kinda late on a weekday so there wasn't any line & we got our sandwiches fast, but I'm sure it gets crowded on Saturday mornings. I only wish they were open Sundays as well! read more

In my humble opinion and non-exhaustive search, the best bagels in the Pittsburgh area! Always fresh and a great selection. Be sure to get there early as they can sell out. read more

Love me a BLT. Great food. Fast service. Lovely cafe. If you have the opportunity be sure to come up to Shaler and stop by! read more

See all

Update: 6 months later and this is still my favorite bagel spot for a lox and shmear! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Lox breakfast sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Their bagels are absolutely amazing!!! The everything bagel is covered top and bottom unlike other places where it's just the top. Probably the fluffiest bagels I've ever had. You can tell they were freshly made. Definitely our new bagel joint. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - So fluffy and freshly made - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Delightful in every way! Bagels, service, sandwiches - kudos to the owners! Pittsburgh needs more fantastic locally owned businesses like this. read more

I haven't enjoyed a bagel this much in Pittsburgh...ever. So so good. They were fresh, delicious and huge! I went with a specialty cream cheese but think next time I want to go classic. I've been thinking about when I can go back ASAP read more

See all

I am a frequent patron of this establishment. I have been treated fairly and properly every single time I have been there. Some days the line is longer than others, but everyone is supper helpful and diligent with orders. The bagels are awesome, and I highly recommend you stopping by and getting one. read more

This is the best bagel place in town! I've been really sad about the Pittsburgh bagel scene since I moved here and wow!!!! Thank you Three Brothers!!! The line is already out the door, great BEC with good chewy bagels with a crunch on the outside! I get the sesame or Cacio e Pepe! Best to get the bagels to go, and also pre-think your coffee decision- the coffee is pretty standard with cream and sugar station on the side. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - a display of pastries - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

Three Brother's Bagel is such an awesome addition to the Glenshaw community! The space is welcoming and the staff is so kind and hardworking! They have a variety of bagels, bagel sandwiches, coffee, and homemade cream cheeses. The bagels are warm and fresh everytime. Soft inside and crunchy outside - 10/10 every single time. Love stopping by for a quick breakfast or grabbing a dozen to go for friends, family, and coworkers! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

I'm from the city but was in Glenshaw pet sitting and decided to grab a Saturday breakfast at Three Brothers Bagels. Wow, it was SO good. My lox bagel was bomb (best I've had in the city or surrounding areas) and the cold brew was perfect. Also whatever that sauce is that they have available on the side is so good. It's like sweet and spicy. I'll be back for sure. I literally just finished the sandwich but I would eat a whole 'nother one if it was sitting in front of me. read more

See all

As a transplant from Northern NJ, it's nice to finally have a real NY style bagel place that serves real Taylor Ham, egg, and cheese sandwiches. The bagel itself is nicely chewy and large. The staff is friendly and I've never waited too long for my food, even on busy days read more

Read the reviews, so I had to check it out when I was in the area. They were very busy, but the line moved pretty quickly. I ordered the plain and a blueberry. Unfortunately, they were out of blueberry. However, the plain I got was delicious. The service was very friendly. I'm definitely coming back in the future. read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Service Counter and Menu Board. - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

As a NY transplant in Pittsburgh 20+ years I'm excited to have just discovered Three Brothers, which is by far the closest thing to a NY Bagel I've ever had in Western PA. Nice legit chew on the outside, soft inside. Maybe you'll try making pizza?! Strong recommendation! read more

Three Brothers Bagels - Sesame bagel with scallion cc, lettuce, tomato, red onion & avocado. - Bagels Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Best bagels in the Pittsburgh area! It's now our go-to bagel shop. If you sit in the back at the right time of day, you can watch them slicing and dicing ingredients (all fresh). Everything is from scratch. read more