Came here while visiting family. Was totally blown away by the quality of the food and service. Definitely old school red sauce establishment with all the favs done to perfection. I had a veal Sorento that was delicious. My wife had the flounder Francais. Good wine list too. I would have taken pictures but i left my phone behind! If you are ever in Carmel, this is the spot! read more

I came here for a bite to eat . Surprisingly, the Chicken Calzone was actually very good. I was hoping it was good because I thought the price of it was very expensive, it came out to be $18.00. I was just very shocked by the price. After having a couple of bites, I was pleased with how it tasted. It was very delicious. read more

Prato Restaurant & Pizzeria - Chicken calzone - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Unless you're from the area or they know you, you will be treated like a third class citizen. I run a couple companies in Connecticut and would never treat people the way myself and my family were treated today. I have family who works at the hospital in town and was looking for a nice Italian restaurant close by was super excited to eat here from the moment we walked in,We felt out of place almost like we were bothering them. I'm a big guy and we simply asked if we could have a table instead of a booth we were told everything was reserved. At that time, there were only two other tables filled the place was empty .Another waitress came over and said that those tables weren't reserved until 7:45 PM at this time it was only 4 o'clock. my family ate and by the time we left, those tables were still empty. Seems crazy to me once again if you're not someone, they know you are not welcome there. read more

have dined here in back several times it was fine food good service good However I have gone there several times early on Saturday and Sunday for slices and drinks. I felt like i was at a day care 5 or 6 young children running around behind the pizza counter touching things as well as behind the bar , true kids will play so it obvious that these children belong to some of the people working there , I assume they were eating early both times its unprofessional and not safe to have young children playing tag and hide and seek at a place of business plus its annoying to patrons. Not good business no matter who or whom they belong to . read more

Hands down my favorite Italian restaurant in Putnam county. The food is always delicious. The service is amazing , you are greeted with a warm smile & treated like family. The ambience is cozy, warm, inviting & a little taste of Italy. I've never had a bad meal. The seafood is always fresh. No matter what dish I order it's always a large portion & the prices are very reasonable. 5 stars read more

Update! I tried the chicken parm wedge. Really delicious! Lost a star for the meager portion of chicken, but I cannot take away from the taste! Highly recommended! Also, the packaging was in an aluminum circle with the plastic top - big plus for me as the cheese stays where it's supposed to.... read more

See all

friday night pizza..alll dough bubbles not so good..have pic but cant post crust..no flavor...dont know what's going on...very inconsistent read more

Prato Restaurant & Pizzeria - cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

Amazing fine quality Italian food, the veal is so tender you can cut it with a fork. I've had the shrimp, sole , salmon, chicken, pizza etc all fantastic, 5 star rating, weekends are very busy , I like going during weeknights for nice quiet dinner. read more

The pizza is really good here. I've been looking for a good pizza place in the area ever since sauros changed hands and this one hits the mark! After trying other places in the area, the only ones worth going back to is Prato and maybe Gappys. I think this place has great pizza. I'm extremely picky because I grew up in the pizza capital. (CT) sorry other places you just don't hit the mark in NY but this place is tops. read more

Nice place. Place has a dining area and two booths if you're looking for a quick bite. There is another room where there was a party or something going on. This was a Saturday, so it was crowded at times. We sat at the booths, so no comments on the in dining experience. The regular slices are good. The vodka slice is excellent. The garlic knots are on point. The menu selection is good. The fridge is okay. A somewhat decent selection, but not the deepest. Only staff interaction I had was with the guy in the front who took my order. As mentioned, the place got crowded at one point and it was near madness, but he was still attentive, friendly, and worked very well under pressure. Place is nice and one I'd easily return to. When I do, I plan to dine inside. The food I had was good and I look forward to more. read more

See all

Excellent dining experience for our party of 12...from drinks to appetizers, dinner and dessert! All of the food was delicious with generous portion sizes. The server was great, and she anticipated all of our needs: extra plates, refills, to-go containers, etc. We enjoy eating here in a smaller group and were happy to share it with extended family! read more

Wonderful ambiance, authentic Italian cuisine, and service even being short staffed that night was attentive and wonderful! Friendly, at home feeling. read more

We have been back a few times since the ownership change, not sure why everyone keeps referring to this for, in our opinion food and service are still very good, we have had no complaints. We started with the Calamari Scarpiello, it was excellent! How the Calamari still had some crisp after being in the sauce is beyond me. I had the Veal Marsala and my wife has the Chicken Prato, they were excellent as well, we chose the Penne pasta and it was al dente. Definitely a go to place. read more

I order from here all the time. The Caprese Chicken is amazing. The pizza and salads are great too. read more

Food is amazing, staff is super friendly! When you walk in you feel like you're sitting in Italy. Love it!!!! read more

Prato Restaurant & Pizzeria - Manicotti - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

Always great food and service! Thank you for a wonderful venue for my daughters special day!

To start I had the stuffed artichoke filled with breadcrumbs, garlic and sauce. Very large and fulfilling. My appetizer was followed with a house salad with various greens and vegetables. Then, my salad was followed by a large succulent pork chop covered in a light brown sauce and red & green peppers with a hint of heat coupled with a side of white rice. Absolutely tasteful and tender... A must try. The wait staff, servers and bus staff were one of the best and kindest group I have ever experienced. The ambience was that of a restaurant in the heart of Italy. A must try! read more

I love this place. We stop by often and the pizza is always crispy where it needs to be and decent size slices. We also stopped in to dine one night. Service and food was excellent. Our portions were healthy and very filling. I recommend ! I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and my husband ordered the chicken parmigiana. I had to bring some food home because it was just such a good portion! We will be back soon for dinner! read more

Staff is miserable, counter guy coughed in his hand then picked up my slice to put it in the oven . I said really . He looked at me like a jerk off and said what. I walked out before it got worse. Stay away. Health dept should look in kitchen read more

Pizza is okay but not the greatest. Ordered a large pie and wasn't too thrilled pizza didn't have a good taste to it.

New owner. The second time is here and they have not missed the beat. You wouldn't even know that their new owner. The wine was a little more expensive per bottle but all in all we still had a great dinner. read more

Decent food but dont order uber eats from here, they do not make the food until you show up for some reason.

Our new stomping ground when traveling from NYC from now on!! Food is on point and the young men working could not be more kind! Stopped by for a quick bite after skiiing one night and left just wowed!! See you again soon Prato! read more

New owners, food not as good and service was lacking, I'll give them a chance but they should make it known it is under new management read more

We took our friend couple here for watching our home while we were on vacation at their direction of a great place to have dinner. They are Italian, we are not. We do love Italian food though! We picked out a black olive loaf bread for the table which I had never experienced before and it was delectable. We did ask for butter as I'm not into the whole olive oil thing, too bitter for my taste no matter where I am just get me actual olives. We all had appetizers, entrees and desserts. Everything was spectacular. I was surprised when my chicken parm came out with ziti instead of spaghetti to which was my own mishap at not actually reading the menu and then ordered a side of spaghetti. I am a snob with my pasta despite being gluten intolerant and paying for it later in the night, each pasta has its place and ziti imo does not tread well with chicken parm. Just as fettuccini shall only be graced with Alfredo. Anyway let's roll some pictures. Would definitely go back. Our waitress was the best and she was on top of everything with such grace and gave advice on her favorite dishes as well! read more

Prato Restaurant & Pizzeria - Mussels - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Had a wonderful dinner here Friday night with my lady and my parents. Wasn't quite as busy as I would expect for a Friday night but we're in the dog days of winter so I guess that's to blame. Started off with a few appetizers for the table - calamari, cold antipasto and a couple of stuffed avocados. If you've never had there stuffed avocados they are an absolute must have. For dinner both my lady and my mother had the eggplant rollatini. My pops had the lasagna and I had the penne vodka with grilled shrimps. All the entrees were delicious. My only critique would be that the food took a long time to come out. I don't know if there was a mishap in the kitchen because it wasn't that busy but you're willing to look past it when the food is as good as it is. All in all a 5/5 experience. A couple of double Makers Marks and I was feeling great on a Friday night. read more

Excellent Italian in an unassuming storefront that has pizza up front but a well appointed dining room in the rear. Excellent friendly service. Full bar. Some rate Italian specialties such as fried zucchini flowers. Chicken Regina remarkable. read more

Everytime we order a salad, they forget ingredients. It it's not the canberries or Pecans, it's the sliced egg on the Cobb Salad. Its everytime. The Salads aren't cheap so the least they can do is not forget to put what goes in it. also they didn't even give us bread like they used to. Ever since it has been sold, it has gone Down hill. All they guy says is oh he forgot I'm Sorry. Well three strike your out!! read more

Excellent, excellent food. Great, great service. Staff very, very nice. Well decorated back room.

I was a weekly customer and my recent experience left me feeling not only insulted, but disgusted. My usual salad had an enormous and live fly buzzing around the bottom. Absolutely filthy! When I called the manager to let him know, he not only rejected my reason for calling because "we don't have flies here this time of year", but then proceeded to hang up on me. No apology or accountability whatsoever! Will not be returning. There are far friendlier and cleaner pizzerias in the area. read more

DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE ONLINE...twice they messed up my order and were unable to resolve my issue . The first time they blamed the Slice app for the missing items in my order which had to be cancelled and reordered then wait and pay the slice app again . The second time I ordered my food it arrived cold and again missing items . I called the restaurant and the arrogant moron told me to come and pick up my missing item. I explained that it was there mistake and I paid for delivery . They then blamed the Door Dash app for the mistake . I explained the delivery app drivers ONLY PICK YP WHAT THEY PREPARE . so aside from cold food and incomplete order they wanted to cancel my order a pay twice the delivery app to get my order correct . The worst aggravating experience... NEVER AGAIN people work hard for there money and ungrateful businesses such as this place don't deserve my hard earned money read more

One of the friendliest staff around and absolutely delicious meals, you must go try it and you will be sure you will keep going back. We went as a large party and were able to try several items. We started off with the homemade bread, both the olive and plain. The bread was so fresh and was better than any bakery I've had bread from. We also tried the fried calamari (great crisp) and the home made mozzarella. The mozzarella was better than mozzarella I had in Italy last year. Great pairing with the roasted veggies and light pesto sauce. For entrees we all had a variety of meals, mostly pasta dishes and the octopus, all very good. On my next trip back, we will be trying out the pizza. Portions are a great size, you will be sure to have some leftovers for the next day! read more

See all

OMG the food was amazing! The Pene alla Vodka was so good that I had to ask for more. 10/10 would recommend.The service was also amazing, they were so kind and friendly. 10/10.The ambiance was great too, making me feel at home. 10/10 would recommend all to come inside and take a look and eat their wonderful meals. read more

Danielle (co-owner, wife of mozzarella maker and daughter of the expert bread maker) seated us in the very very busy back room on Friday evening. Super friendly, extremely attentive wait staff. Yes this is a big family run restaurant that makes you feel like you've been invited to their home for a special dinner. DEFINITELY eat here, everything is so fresh and home made,completely AUTHENTIC Italian food. I can not put into words how much we enjoyed our experience here, fantastic appetizers, the entree's were prepared to absolute perfection and the zeppoles and cappuccino for a finish were THE BEST. This is in the top 3 of my favorite restaurants. DEFINITELY AUTHENTIC, THE BEST! EXCEPTIONAL read more

Prato Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

This is a hidden gem disguised as a basic pizza joint in the front of the house. The owners are happy to have you and the food is delicious! The ambiance isn't fancy but you'll enjoy the service and the food it'll become a go to spot. Make a reservation because it's not big and gets very busy on the weekends! Oh and the pizza is amazing too. read more

I tried the Penne Alla Vodka, amazing stuff. 10/10 would recommend. Service was spectacular, ambiance was perfect. The lighting, mood, and atmosphere felt amazing. Incredible restaurant!!! read more

I love this place! The food is good, atmosphere is quaint and customer service wonderful. So far, we have not had a bad experience even with our two kids (age 6 and 8). Made it to our list of favorites read more

Business changed hands earlier this year, I've only had the pizza which is on par with the previous owners.

Very good Italian food, best in the area have never had a bad meal here. It's our go to place to eat

Great pizza - the sauce is so good. Thats all ee e had there but worth the trip. Have gone there often for pizza