Okay. I hate that I have to leave this review... Timber Creek has always been a stand up place. But my recent experiences here have been awful. They just keep getting worse too! The girl I've encountered in this place has the worst attitude. She's stared at me (like stared me dead in the eyes for multiple minutes straight while I was ordering) and made me feel super uncomfortable. She's never acknowledged customers when I've been in there and saw her. Then she made me a sub today that I can only describe as scary. The lettuce was brown and the meat was slimy. I didn't even eat it. $15 out the window. The poor guy who was working with her was incredibly nice however was clearly not trained in the slightest. He didn't even know if they had mint ice cream. Let alone what was in it. He also didn't know how to use the cash register. And let's face it he was alone with Miss Personality and I would be scared to ask her a question too if I were in his shoes. Also the interior is beginning to look more and more like someone's garage sale. There's crap everywhere. The counter shouldn't be so cluttered with ratty dirty signs that you can't even pay your bill without have to step around the corner and almost put it in the register yourself. There was junk mail wedged in some of the signs too. Random pieces of paper advertising specials but could just be scraps of paper. I love the cabin decor but the grinch costume clearly being stored in the corner of the front window needs to go. As well as the two elf on the shelf toys that make reading the already cluttered menu difficult. The arcade games are a nice touch but shouldn't be right next to the register. There's so much going on in that corner and it makes it hard to order. I don't know what happened to this place. This was one of our favorite places especially in the summer. And was one of the reasons we moved here. read more

Timber Creek Pizza - The turkey sub I ordered. Very little lettuce and brown at that. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mills, Wisconsin

See all

Pizza was mid at best. Freezer quality pizza. It took 45 minutes for this pizza. They also gave it off to the wrong table twice. Staff were snotty and rude. Tables were dirty. Soda was flat, water came out pink. We regret not going to McDonalds read more

Ice cream board states $4.29 for single cones. Ordered 2 cones. Price was over $11.00. When we questioned it, we were told that was an old price, and the register has the updated prices. You can keep your ice cream cones. We will not be back If I could give zero stars, I would. read more

New Owner has changed Hawaiian pizza from BBQ sauce to Tomato sauce. Insists its the same as always but its not. Yuck...

Great pizza, delicious toppings and delivered with care and promptly. We are very glad Timber Creek is in Lake Mills.

I ordered on line a pizza and some sides and payed in advance. Got there to pick up, told to wait , got a few things , didn't get the pizza , waited a log time and could not get anyone to help , people walking by me a ton of times and no one asked if I needed help , finally got someone to answer me and took a long time to get my order Food was good but service was not the best read more

Went to Timber Creek Pizza and was welcomed by a wonderful employee named Kay. Not only did she patiently wait for me and my friend to goof up our order at least once, but she had a chipper attitude the entire duration we were there. Great little charm found in downtown Lake Mills. I would recommend their pizza and subs but I know that they have quite a few other options for food as well. It's right across the downtown park if you want to have an ice cream cone on the square. Worth a visit. read more

See all

Pricey.. nothing special but we were hungry and it was just "ok". I'm not a fan of thin crusts but if you are you will like this one.

Very expensive. I bought $50 worth of pizza for some of my employees and it was a very bad deal. I could eat 2 large by myself. A $5 Little Caesars is more pizza than 2 of Timber Creek's pizzas put together. read more

We wanted to grab something quick and fairly small to tide us over until dinner. I ordered a roast beef sandwich with cheese, and green peppers. Although I didn't order Mayo and lettuce it came with it. Even so, it was very delicious, and the bread is amazing! read more

Great pizza at a great price! Don't forget the ice cream. Looking forward to my next visit!

Pizza and lemonade, my two favorite things in this whole world. I can't get over how great this place is, their staff is great and they are super quick with orders. This isn't your typical one and done kind of place to be, as I've been to places like this and it definitely beats them all. The fact that it's right in the heart of Lake Mills is fantastic because whenever there are events happening downtown - deliciousness is a few steps away. I don't have much else to say about this place since anytime I've been here - it was a good experience. Good on you folks for keeping things groovy and sweet. I shall be back again soon for some more pizza and lemonade, can't get enough of that. Cheers, read more

Horrible service. We ordered food for delivery at 10:30 and they said it would be there by 11:30. 12:30 rolls around and there is still NO FOOD DELIVERED. We tried to call them multiple times and their mailbox was full. No contact about what time we would even get our food. Of course we prepaid and it was getting delivered to our work which we leave by 12:45 on Fridays. Therefore no food, spent money on this place, no way to discuss a refund. ABSOLUTELY ridiculous. Would never order from here again. read more

I took my boys and headed over to Timber Creek Pizza today. We had a large cheese pizza, garlic bread and fountain drinks. Everything was delicious! Afterwards, we tried out the ice cream and it was very very good too. I don't know how this gets rated worse than 5 stars honestly, but everyone has their opinion. I met the owner and he was a very nice guy on top of having excellent food. Five stars from us! read more

From the first step of ordering for a business luncheon on Wednesday 12/16 to the finalization of the transaction today, I am thoroughly impressed with the service. Friendly and quick. My entire transaction was over the phone. The gentleman that originally took my order was so helpful and reassuring that my boss's order would arrive on time. It did! Then, I needed to contact today for a receipt and talked to Kay. Kay went above and beyond to get my my receipt. I can't say enough about this place. My boss likes it here but, the service makes me want to make the 2+ hour trip just to try it out myself. Keep doing what you do! read more

I can only speak for the ice cream at this place. Damn, that was good. Seriously some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Served with a smile. I went with a two-scoop waffle cone and got Birthday Cake and Cookies and Cream. They were everything I ever wanted in either. The Birthday Cake was packed full of that delicious cake flavor and tons of blue ribbon. Cookies and Cream was incredibly creamy and there was barely a bit of ice cream that wasn't covered in cookies. The portions were huge and the price was right. We came here after eating at nearby Water House as Van #1's lunch stop for Ragnar Relay Chicago. As good as Water House was, I think I'll bring the crew to Timber next time. They have a huge menu that caters to pizza, sandwich and veggie lovers. read more

Wow! Just ordered for the first time. Excellent!!!! Had a cheeseburger pizza garlic bread with cheese and a French dip all AMAZING! Yum can't believe this was the first time we ordered from timber creek ! Well first of many .... well done!! read more

I have had better, but then I grew up in Chicago. This was by no means the worse I have had, but it is far from the best. I had just moved in and lacking groceries and desire to make a meal I chose to order a pizza. I kept it simple, sausage and mushroom. The sausage was okay, not the best I have had but okay none the less. I ordered for pick up and it was ready when promised. The place has plenty of street parking and it was no problem getting in and out. The place was empty, but this may have been because it was almost closing time. I do believe the place warrants another visit and my rating may change as a result. But, given that the pizza options are few here this might be as good as it gets. read more

Love the food and atmosphere. You really can get a lot of different stuff and tje ice cream is phenomenal. Wish they started delivering earlier in the day. read more

Given that the restaurant is located in small town Wisconsin, I think it does a pretty good job. The service was prompt, the ice cream was terrific and the seating area was cozy and welcoming. The pizza we had, though, wasn't so great. It had way too much sauce on it and the sauce was very bland. The ingredients were piled to overflowing on our pizza, too. It was hard to know if the kids behind the counter had been taught how to make a pizza properly or if it was anything goes. I've been here before, though, and not had that same experience so I would definitely come back next time I'm in town and try again. Plus, as long as the ice cream stays, I know I won't be disappointed. read more

We have wanted to go here for the last two years and finally made it. People were coming in and getting ice cream in droves. We got pizza and it was pretty good, Thin crust and tasted great. Not the best I have ever had but I will definitely come back again and order the pizzam. The sub- sandwich's people were buying looked very good and were reasonable in price. Yes we will definitely be back! read more

We stopped here for the first time while visiting the local farmers market in Lake Mills. We were able to order right away, and the young lady at the counter was very friendly. We ordered a classic deluxe pizza with sausage, mushrooms, onions, green pepper and pepperoni. With the exception of the sausage, the ingredients were plentiful, including the cheese. The sauce was flavorful. It was brought to our table hot, which is very important to me. While not the best pizza I've ever had, it's good in comparison to many others within driving distance of Lake Mills. My main criticism is that it is a little bit too much "self service." I'd like to see table service and not to have to go get plates, dining ware, drinks, and condiments. The prices were reasonable, but above the fast-food/serve-yourself range. Again, I'd like more sausage and less self-service, but the overall experience justifies a return trip. read more

Got a Deluxe pizza bare any meat called to say something about little meat. The manager said that's how we do it. The the Deluxe we but on 1/2 OF THE MEAT WE REALLY ADD? NEVER Going back. read more

Horrible service... horrible pizza. Definitely don't recommend it. I have never felt like I was an inconvenience for ordering food until this evening! Both the person on the phone and the delivery person were rude and inconsiderate. read more

In Lake Mills under not so great circumstances - needed to find a quick place to eat, and this is very near where we were visiting. Their storefront lists pizza, tacos, and malts... Hmmm... Yeah - That pretty much sums it up. Sub-mediocre food - almost bowling alley-like... Hubby says it reminded him of "rodeo" food. I tried the spinach alfredo pizza with mushrooms and tomatoes; hubby had the nachos and a soft taco. the pizza was okay - the crust was nice and crisp, which I like, but overall, just sadly bland. Hubby's nachos made me chuckle - think of those round, cheap tortilla chips they serve you at the movie theater (or bowling alley.. or rodeo...), with that "cheese" that's dispensed from one of those metal contraptions that ketchup's dispensed from in fast food joints, then add some Hormel meat-chili and some jalapeños from a can, and voila! You have their nachos! The soft taco was like a sad, middle-school lunch taco. I really hate giving out a 1 star, so since the staff was nice enough, I'll give them 2. But really, the food is 1 star-quality. read more

See all

Nice people and a wide variety of subs and the pizza was good. Along with Sassy Cow ice cream

We love Timber Creek and make sure to stop by for pizza any time we are in town. So good! I love it that you can get the cheesy garlic bread on whole wheat bread. And my family ends every meal with the delicious ice cream. It's also always clean and the staff are super nice. Love! read more

My experience with Timber Creek has been nothing short of exceptional. I frequent this venue for pizza, subs, and ice cream, and have not once indulged without having expectations exceeded. The caliber of food and reasonable prices keep me and my oriental family returning time and again. In addition to the quality nourishment provided, the customer service and friendly employees are first class. I hold Timber Creek in only the highest regard. God Bless. read more

Timber Creek is alright. Their pizza is terrible. They never seem to make it right. One time it was too crispy/burned, another time the crust was soggy in the middle. Their subs are good though, especially the Italian one. They also have yummy ice cream. read more

Nice little lunch spot. Family owned. We indulged in the Philly cheese steak six inch with a bowl of chili. Chili was OK. Not great. Sandwich was very good however. Pretty reasonable price for a nicely put together and tasty Sammie. Worth the stop in little Lake Mills WI read more

I stopped in here with 5 buddies while we were passing through town. We all ordered subs and they were great. Fresh veggies, fresh bread, and huge portions! Best sub I've had in a while. Service was quick, too, despite having a lot of folks in the restaurant before and during our meal. Had to log in to add my review because these guys deserve more stars than they've been getting. Recommended! read more

Delicious food, especially the hot Philly turkey sub! My favorite place to go when I lived in Lake Mills. Absolutely, hands-down, the most HORRENDOUS service I've ever experienced in my life. The only reason I kept going back was the awesome food (minus the pizza....stick to the sandwiches and Mexican if you're not looking for disappointment). read more

Simple pizza, sub and ice cream shop but it was delicious. I can't go back to subway anymore. Got a pizza sub and tacos and it was great. Then came back on the way back thru town for ice cream. It has a nice "Northwoods" feel and was clean inside. Will definitely go back. read more

There pizza isn't the greatest, but I love going there for their subs. The beacon ranch sub is awesome. I also hear the Mullens ice cream is really good. The service is so-so, not the place to go if you're looking for fast food. I like the woody interior decoration as well. I prefer going here over Subway or Jimmy Johns because the subs are better and similarly priced. read more

The pizza is ok. I've had better. I now usually come in for the ice cream. Theu give large proportions and they have multiple flavors to choose from. All the ice cream is home made, which makes it so much better. For example, the cookie dough tou buy at the store cheaps out on how much cookie dough they give you, here there's plenty. I recommend going and trying the ice cream. read more

The pizza is delicious but way over priced. The high school girls behind the Counter should focus on helping the customer out rather than discuss gossip. Ordered pizza three times from them and got my order wrong 2/3 times. Can't deny the pizza is delicious. But why should I bother to pay that price if some high school girl is going to get my order wrong. Not a welcoming feeling. read more

Had a great visit to the cute little place tonight. Pizza was very good, prices were great. They have it all (almost); tacos, soups, subs, pizza, salads and a ton of flavors of ICE CREAM! Was busy the whole time, great experience! read more

We eat at timber creek every time we go to Bartels beach in the summer (we drive in from ixonia). We always get the taco pizza and it is awesome. One time it was overcooked and burned on the edges but the owner happened to be working that day and apologized and made us a new one with some free garlic bread to eat while we waited for the new pizza to cook. The ice cream is great to have during the summer and the timber creek nachos are great in the winter but we hardly ever are in town in the winter. Keep it up timber creek! read more

This is a tough review. We love timber creeks food and ice cream, but seriously people who work there you need to act like you want to be there. There is zero energy amongst the staff. Also, I feel they could add things to their menu such as Mozzerella Sticks, Cheese curds, even fries! Overall, we do like and recommend it but they need improvement in certain areas. read more

Order at the counter. Wait and wait for your food, which was fast food- pizza and subs. Coffee came out with meal. Out of shrimp for shrimp pizza, didn't tell us until we sat down. Out of Parmesan cheese shakers, which did not come out with pizzas, had to ask. Later came out with one when we were done eating. Had to ask for pepper sprinkles. Is this really a pizza place? Pizzas were pre-recorded thin crust, little sauce, tasted like grocery store frozen that they added toppings to. No anchovies. Expensive for area. Very little meat on subs for price. Toppings on pizza were cold. Carryout got food first, even the ones who ordered at counter instead of calling in. One carry out came back, they forgot salsa and sour cream for her taco salad. Had ice cream, mediocre, waffle cones not made there, altho nice ice cream selection. If this were not in sammie town America in an area with little competition, as well as a tourist spot, I doubt it would last. read more