If I could do zero stars I would. We went to this place on a Saturday St. Pattys Day weekend and they were closed and didn't even tell anyone. Do not recommend. Or any other bars in the city. read more

Do yourself a favor and don't go here. The food isn't worth the price (standard bar menu but not very good quality). But it all comes with a side of really, really bad service experience. Unless you're a local regular, you'll be treated like the cousin no one likes or wants to see at the family reunion. Here's a rundown of what I encountered: Waitress got our drink orders wrong, several times. Not a big deal. I can live with that. We all make mistakes. We asked for a few minutes to go over the menu. Didn't know that would be the last we'd see of her for a while (she decided to take a load off her feet and sit down and talk to the only other patron in a booth). Well she eventually returned, we placed our order and she fixed our screwed up drinks. Time passed and she brought our food but without silverware. Sadly, we had to interrupt her conversation with the several men sitting up at the bar playing quarters. We finished and awaited the bill. I elected to stay behind and pay the bill while the rest of my party left. Again, I had to wait until she was done talking to get my bill. Honestly, the quickest response I got was when she came back with my credit card to sign the bill. I can forgive the food. It's a local tavern. I more or less expected what I got. But the service? That was just bad. I mean really bad. And calling everyone baby or sweetie when you're obviously ignoring me isn't going to fool me. Really wanted to like this place, too. That was the bad part. read more

Great food, great drinks, and great service!!! Weather your coming for dinner or to enjoy a night out with friends. Tim's is the place to be in Gaylord read more

Timothy's Pub - Great service, great drinks, and amazing people!!! - Pubs Near Me - Gaylord, Michigan

Great service. Amazing food. I had the fried pickles spears which came out fresh and piping hot. Great seasoning and crunch! Then I had the cheese steak with French fries which was delicious and had plenty of cheese and flavor! But the best part of the entire meal was the dessert! Pumpkin sweet potato tart with brown sugar cinnamon ice cream! It's magical! And my waitress Laura was very attentive, they were a little busy and she was all over the place making sure everyone was taken care of. Parking lot is a little small but they have a wonderful fire place. Great little place! read more

Timothy's Pub - Pumpkin sweet potato tart with cinnamon brown sugar ice cream! - Pubs Near Me - Gaylord, Michigan

Last night I had one of the best prepared meals I have eaten. It was mahi mahi zinger. The fish was superb. The fresh spinach, red pepper, sun dried tomatoes simmered in wine was unbelievable. It was a perfect combo served with rice and Asian slaw. Thank you chef. read more

Timothy's is very unpretentious and has a great down to earth feel. Another reviewer likened it to Cheers, and that's pretty accurate. Had a good lunch here today. I tried the prime rib sandwich on toast points and my husband had a burger. My "sandwich" was a thick slice of prime rib, cooked perfectly, but only warm. It arrived with an au jus that hinted of Rosemary & was perfect for dipping, served hot, which warmed up the beef. Delicious! My husband's burger was juicy and cooked as requested. He said it was very good. The true gem of the place is Laura, the lone server at lunch. She was friendly, efficient and knowledgeable. A+ We will definitely be back! read more

We wanted to try something different so we decided on nachos and potato skins . I could of cooked it better then the cook and this pub . Staff was rude told me to sign my credit card slip and here is your order . Will never order from them again gross and inconsiderate staff . read more

Most fun pub in Gaylord, complete with northern logs and pool tables! Enjoy a complete menu with affordable beer and cocktails. Bar company and bartender, Kasi, are the best! When traveling from Indiana to Ontario... Tim's is our new favorite food AND fun stop. Thanks Kasi for the best evening ever! read more

The service at Timothy's Pub was wonderful. Our waitress was very kind, albeit forgetful, and very patient. The food on the other hand, either undercooked or still frozen. My sister was given the wrong thing twice, my brother in law had watered down tasteless fish, my boyfriend's appetizer was half-finished and my burger was burnt on the outside, and cold on the inside. To reiterate, service was great, kitchen was not. And don't get me started on the cleanliness. read more

Traveled to the area on business, the waiter was slightly rude and almost made us seem like we were a bother. The atmosphere was dark and drab. There was very little parking. The only reason I'm giving them a 2 star rating is due to the Long Island Iced Tea being strong. read more

Had a great Time at Timothy's, Especially with the Talent in the Bar. Herb is great, but I have to say Girls really know how to make a drink with a great fun attitude. Shout to Lisa,Kacie, and Britney. They made our nights. Our group looks forward every year to come stay and play and to say hi to the ones that makes that place great. The Yoopers' read more

Another Northern Michigan small town joint. Overwhelmed by a group on a Sunday afternoon even though we called ahead and they said it would be no problem. After 2 and 1/2 hours, we left with two people not receiving their food (including me). How on earth does this place get 4 stars? I will never be back. read more

Tim's is always a great place to stop and have a few adult beverages and/or dinner. Great location. The food is really good! The drinks are always well made! Kasi is the best bartender in town! Very cute and possibly single!! (Pick up the shovel or someone else will) She makes the best drinks in town. Lisa is slso a great bartender and cute but not as single as Kasi. They both make great drinks and both are very funny and always make you feel welcomed! We luv going into Tim's and seeing them behind the bar. Always a great time at Tim's read more

There were two large groups with the waitress so the bartender took our order. Amazingly fast service for drinks. Food came out almost as fast. Food was good for pub food - comfort food read more

A quintessential, small town local bar! Staff is friendly, beer is cold, and they've got darts got those interested!

Awesome food. Best fried pickles my wife and I have ever had. Ate here twice this week, all the food and service was outstanding.

This is an amazing bar, highly recommend to any person traveling to Gaylord. Great drinks and fun karaoke!!!

Wonderful food and friendly staff. Brat & mushroom burgers were amazing. Highly recommend it.

Always a stop when I visit Gaylord. The staff is amazing- warm and friendly. The food is delicious and prices are amazing.

Good food and nice staff. It is truly just a little joint, so don't expect a ton of bells and whistles, but it has the basics and is a ice place to go watch the game and have some beer and bar food. read more

Love the prime rib sandwich with horsey sauce. Great people! Wonderful place to eat.

Have stopped here twice on trips and have not been disappointed. Has a nice atmosphere to it. Heavy wooded walls and posts which I like. The wait staff is very friendly and they will cook your burgers to order (med rare for me). Family friendly. We had kids ranging from 9-16. Sure, it is bar food, but good tasting, friendly staff, good atmosphere = 5 stars for the type of place it is. read more

The food was ok. The fish and chips were very filling but the fish had way too much breading. I ordered three fillets as it was only $1 more for the third one. I would probably not go there again but you might have a better experience. Be aware it is basically a bar. The bathroom was in desperate need of cleaning and updating. The waitress and bar tender was very friendly and improved the bars lack or atmosphere. read more

Cozy atmosphere and friendly staff...had their clam strips...large and hand breaded...absolutely the best!

Stopped in for lunch with some friends this week. Typical up north bar, looked clean,. waitress was very friendly, had the prime rib sandwich, perfect...onion rings were typical fast food. they had a soup called pulled pork soup, i had a little taste and it was outstanding, can't wait to get back and have a bowl. If all the food is as good as the prime rib sandwich and the pulled pork soup This pub is a winner... read more

Great lunch! Tiny little place and the parking isn't great BUT the food is fresh and worth the visit. I had the open face prime rib sandwich and it was excellent. Soup was fresh and the hamburgers are made with fresh ingrediants. If you can stop in and give them a try. Great little hole in the wall. read more

Not from Gaylord. Stopped at Timothy's Pub after being turned away from Mancino's 10 min before their closing time (wasn't happy). Glad it happened. Timothy's food was very good and the service couldn't have been better. Friendly, warm, excellent/funny server. Will return next time in area. Kitchen IS open til midnight- won't be turned away there!! read more

This is a great place for lunch. My wife and I are on Otsego Lake for the summer every year and eat in town often. Timothy's Pub is one our two favorite places in town to stop for lunch. Laura, the weekday waitress is reason enough to stop in, but the food is really good as well. You just can't beat good people and good food! read more

Kasi and Lisa are the best around!! They are so much fun and very attentive!! When I look around the bar I'm super excited to see all the looks on people's faces!! What a friendly and great atmosphere!! They are the one and only reason we keep coming back!! Best bartenders ever!!!!! read more

Don't get me wrong, this is a hole in the wall. But everytime I go in, I get fast service. Generally, I get the worst service 'up north ', slow, people don't know what they're doing, definitely the B Crew employees. But at Timothy's, they're fast, friendly. Bartenders are talkative and nice. Good drinks. Now the food is bar food, the drink choices are limited but for a beer, shot, easy cocktail and some bar food and quick nice service, this is the place. read more

My wife and I stopped here for some appetizers and drinks firings Red Wings game. The place had a really nice atmosphere. It was a little hard to see the game, but everything else was good. The beers were cheap and the nacho supreme was very good. The service was really good and everyone was friendly. Overall it's a nice little hole in the wall bar. read more

Stopped here for lunch, small parking lot. The food was delicious. Had the Ruben and minestrone soup, homemade very good. Service was excellent. read more

Great food and great atmosphere! Excellent service from Tressa. Hit 10x kicker on Keno. Good day. Highly recommend

Sporting the smallest bar bathroom just about anywhere........Timothy's makes up for it with it's fish and chips dinners. ........good bar food, friendly atmosphere and low key clientele (though many golfers in the summer!) Priced nicely, right downtown Gaylord, and the Tigers' games are on........can also play a little KENO, if you're so inclined...... read more

My husband and I were greeted by the friendliest waitress Laura. She obviously likes her job. We had the fish n chips. Served with great coleslaw & malt vinegar, lemon wedge, fries. Just the right amount of batter on the fish. We enjoyed very much the food & log cabin decor. We'll be back. read more

Not a bad place, kinda noisy on the weekends. 90% of the crowd is 30 plus, but the younger people seem to run the jukebox and rap gets old fast. My biggest issue is that my son has gotten food poisoning twice from there. Probably never going back. read more

So much bang for so little buck. This is as solid a choice you can get as far as good food goes in Gaylord. My husband and I are here for a while on our honeymoon and trying lots of different restaurants and this is by far the best restaurant and bar we've stopped at. The prices are so good, you'd almost expect lower quality food for what you pay, but you get some really top-notch stuff. The service is great too! Our food came out in no time and our waitress was genuinely friendly and enhanced the whole experience. My husband had a sausage burger with sauerkraut and I had a bacon, spinach, bleu cheese, and sundried tomato wrap and both were to die for. We also shared some delicious mozzarella sticks which she didn't hesitate to give us two dipping sauces for when we couldn't decide between them. Not only that but the pints of on tap beer were an amazing price of $3.00 per pint. We both had the Horny Monk and when the bill came we were surprised at how great a deal it was for such a big amazing meal. We'll be back for sure. read more

I found this place thanks to Google and then went into yelp. I was in the Gaylord area for a child's sporting event and wanted someplace to eat at afterwards. It was the only restaurant I could find that had all positive reviews. My husbands name is Timothy, so I thought why not?? It was well worth it, the food was very good. Had the reuben, corned beef was nice and tender. No gross fat or overcooked at all. My daughter had chicken tenders, said they were cooked perfect and the homemade ranch was very tasty. The only downside is their lack of parking and the fact that their bathroom is tiny. I walk with a cane and the bathroom was far from handicap accessible at all. The waitress was very nice, when I got her to slow down so I could tell her why we chose this place. She was running around a little crazy like, and I didn't think they were busy at all. But, all in all you should definately eat there. All thumbs up. read more

We were looking for a late night dinner and some music. We watched as three other tables that came in after us were given menus before us. When we finally were waited on, Shawna, the server, brought us one menu for three people. We had to ask for two more menus to be brought. After we ordered and our food was brought to the table, we were never offered silverware to eat with. Again, after we asked, Shawna brought one set of silverware for the three of us. Really?! Finally, after receiving more silverware, my husband inquired if the owner was present. The server actually asked him, "Why, are you trying to get me into trouble.?" To finish off our awful dining experience, they turned off the jukebox after only a couple of our songs played (we had picked 15 to play). When we asked why, we were given a lame explanation. When we asked for our money back, we were told "No, you are out of luck," by Lisa, the head bartender. As we walked out the door, a male standing by the bar, laughed at us and said "Hey, how's that playlist?! We will NEVER step foot in Timothy's Pub again. WHAT A JOKE! read more