10/10 service, food, atmosphere! We called and ordered pick up, we wanted to go back every chance…read morebut ultimately decided to try other places. We kept saying "not as good as Cruizzers". We will DEFINITELY be coming back when we are in the area! We had pizza, pasta and cheese bread! P.S. they have the GOOD ranch! And the 16 inch pizza is perfect for a big family!

We visited on a Saturday night and can say it's one of the better places we ate in Keystone…read more The staff is 5/5 stars--very friendly and helpful. We got the buffalo chicken pizza, a caesar salad and cheese pizza. It is pan pizza so the bottom and sides get crispy and there's not a traditional crust around the edge. The salad was basic but fresh and a good accompaniment to the pizza. The pizza came out pretty quick and was hot and fresh. I don't think the buffalo chicken pizza needed the sausage on it and could have used some blue cheese or a drizzle of ranch or something, but that's honestly personal preference (my husband had no complaints). It's a good value for the money and we all left full and satisfied.

Actually the BEST PIZZA I have ever had and I've traveled 35 states. The crust is perfectly…read morecrunchy, soooo much toppings (I had the Hawaiian with Cashew) cooked perfectly and priced affordable! There is seating outdoors as well but it was too windy to sit out there. I also left my baseball cap there and called them one minute before they closed and was told they couldn't find it, which was really disturbing to me cause I loved my hat. About five minutes later I get a voicemail saying that they did find it. It had been put where they don't usually put Lost and found things, so appreciated them doing that. I just have to wait two days to go back and get it. ***and to the reviewer who gave them a low score, you ordered a VEGGIE pizza! That's your issue!!

Was at the Custer Visitor Center asking for a place to eat and Mary Beth recommended this…read morerestaurant so we came to try it out. Walked in and saw sports stuff everywhere on the walls from Ali to great baseball players, basketball players like Magic , Bird, Ty Cobb, Babe Ruth and much more, and it appears the owner is a K.C. Chiefs fan. One orders the pizza at the counter, is given a number and the pizza brought to your table when ready and didn't take too long and is handmade when ordered. We (3 couples) ordered and really enjoyed our pizzas. Don't know if we will ever vacation here again but for those who do, we definitely recommend eating here if you like pizza!

Stopped in after a day of hiking and wildlife viewing. Ordered a medium pepperoni pizza. The…read moreservice was prompt and pleasant. The pizza was very tasty and the size was on mark.

Over 4 stars on Yelp and Google? Unbelievable! I hope I caught them on a bad day. The pizzas looked…read moregood when they came out, but the second you picked up a slice the toppings and cheese slid completely off. No cheese pull, no structure, just a soggy undercooked mess in the middle. The crust was the biggest issue. What looked like a stuffed crust was really just thick undercooked dough that never fully baked through. It made the pizza feel heavy and gummy instead of crispy or chewy. The pepperoni pizza was honestly ridiculous. It had maybe four giant pepperoni slices on the entire pie, so every other bite was just plain cheese and undercooked dough. For almost $45 a pizza, this was a huge disappointment.

The pizza was extremely fresh and delicious. I usually leave the crust, but it was so good that I…read morehad to eat it.

Me and my family are traveling. We stopped to get something quick to eat. This place didn't…read moredisappoint my taste buds. The service was quick and pleasant. They were short on staff, but the pizza came out quickly. We sat outside listening to some music and enjoying the cool but warm air. Too bad we live too far to come in and eat more of this delicious pizza. Very cheesy with parmesan crust. Thank you, I hope this review will bring more visitors to your comforting place.

We ordered to-go around 4:45pm on a weekday and it was ready by 5:15pm. The pick up was quick and…read moreeasy and they accept credit card. We ordered four large pizzas and three servings of the large strawberry field salad. The margarita pizza was popular along with the Hawaiian. The crust is chewy and reminiscent of a good New York style pizza. The meat added to the pizza and toppings were generous and filling. It was about $25-30 a pizza and $15 for salads. The strawberry salad was a hit and included strawberries, apples, and pecans. Good pricing for the area, especially the quality. It fed 12 people easily. Absolutely would come back!

Another great meal! First night had the Salame Piccante pizza. Had the salads tonight. Full house…read moresalad with chicken $17. Strawberry green salad with chicken $18, leaving 2 people too full for one of their yummy desserts. Enjoy!

Took my granddaughter here for lunch while visiting from California. Food was very good and so was…read morethe service. Very friendly and great vibes. Would definitely recommend.

I was so grateful to find a place that had some gluten free items especially pizza! I would give…read morethe pizza a solid B plus. I was pleased with the crust and amount of cheese and pepperoni I just was not a huge fan of the type of sauce used. But still solid pizza for me. And again just happy to even have an option. I also super loved that they had things like cane sugar sodas I got this awesome rootbeer from 1919! Ryan got a cider and he got some cheesy bread. The buffalo dip was a good flavor. And it is in a cute neighborhood here we were able to walk around and explore while we are here for his work in Rapid City South Dakota! The people here seemed friendly and got us everything we needed. We would definitely come back here. Looks like they also do things like trivia and other fun events!

Best pizza in town! Everyone was nice and prompt! We didn't eat inside but it looked clean!read more

For some reason the system is down that we couldn't order online but we really wanted to try this…read morepizza so my husband went in and ordered and brought pizza home. It was so good totally delicious. I don't know what the ambience was but I imagine decent so I will give them five stars based on the fact that we drove to get it brought it home and it tasted gourmet. Thanks Pauly's! We got the chicken Alfredo and the Pollys three meat special! Yummy

Fantastic food!!!!!!!!! And the same for the service. The girl who initially took our payment is…read moreSara. She was incredibly sweet but other people kept coming by to offer any help we may have needed which we did not need anything. We had a made to order pizza and a buffalo burger which was so juicy and perfectly cooked. The fries were not overly salty and were perfect in my opinion. The restaurant was clean and odor free. Prices are comparable to the area. Bonus-organic store is attached to the restaurant so you can get some shopping done too. Although I did find the organic food prices of the grocery store to be a little costly.

We came here because we saw bloggers and road trip videos recommending it as the best burger joint…read more However, upon arrival, we discovered that it had changed ownership and was now exclusively serving pizza under the same owner which is a bit disapppointing. Despite the unexpected change, the pizza options were surprisingly delicious. It's a self-service setup. If you're open to trying pizza instead of a burger, I would recommend giving it a try.

Wow. Great Pizza in Spearfish SD. Outstanding beer selection as well. Salads were done very…read morewell. It's one thing to be able to deliver a stellar hot 'pie'. It's a whole other level of skill to do it with a unique cold beer and a great salad - that at least makes me feel healthy eating it. But, be sure to bring CA$HOLA.... They don't take plastic. Fear not however, they have an ATM on site. Grab a beer & a Build you own pie, and slow down and enjoy life in SD... Right HERE!

Been coming for years but the service has gone downhill. Had to wait an hour and 20 minutes for…read morefood. Never got checked on to refresh drinks during our wait. Definitely don't go here if you're in a hurry. Pizza is good, it's cash only business, and poor wait times.