Good, casual dining restaurant. Fast and friendly service. The location in Montgomery Village is great, especially since after dinner you can take a walk around the outdoor shopping center and window shop. read more

Gosh I miss the location in San Rafael but it was hard to park sometimes. But now I can enjoy the same great items in Santa Rosa right off Farmers Lane in that cute mall. Bonus Happy Hour weekdays from 3-6 after a nice afternoon picking up new linens, some garden items and birthday cards - I keep a stash. They have incredible pizzas with that fresh soft crust. I like the bruschetta and salads - had an eggplant bruschetta and a classic tomato basil with fresh mozzarella. The beef meatballs say all beef and come in a nice tomato sauce thinking these are ok for all you keto fans! $4 draft beers and $5 wines during happy hour. The tiramisu is good too. Friendly staff, great service and booths! Sorry, I have a love for booths. The catering manager Mara is also super helpful and friendly if you have a work event or need help with a party she can make it happen. Excited to try some of the new specials. read more

5 stars cause they told us to... Margherita was really good though... Everyone else thought their food was good as well... read more

Tomatina - Prices - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

I would definitely come here again! I thought the food was really good with plenty of options on the menu. I tried the Shrimp Pomodoro (pictured below). It was spicy but good! The service was friendly and made the experience pleasant. It looks like they remodeled the restaurant recently as most of the interior looks new. read more

Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

I ate at Tomatina's on 11/11/23 and had their lobster ravioli $29.95. The tomato sauce over powered the delicate flavor of the small lobster pieces. The ravioli was delicious and the amount of food was very generous. The service was very good. I wasn't aware that they are now serving brunch from 10 AM until 2 PM on Saturday and Sunday. I saw the eggs Benedict on focaccia bread, and it look like a winner. read more

Tomatina - Lobster ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

excellent food, nice atmosphere, attentive service and a good value overall. We will definitely be back with friends and family

Just came here for the first time in a while was! Food was really good! The pasta was amazing the sauce was to die for amazingly creamy, the cocktails are yummy. Will definitely come back again. We loved all of our food and ate all of it. We loved the decor the place is amazing read more

See all

My husband and I came in because I have been wanting to give it a try. Sunday evening, not busy. Wait staff was pleasant and attentive. Hard peach Lemonade was tasty. I ordered the chicken marsala , good but very small serving of chicken and the marsala sauce was somewhat gelled. My husband had spaghetti and meatballs and said it was alright. We didn't have dessert but I did hear from a local fb page that the tiramisu was really good. read more

See all

Great service, excellent food. The drink I ordered was also delicious. The portions and price were good compared to other places. I will definitely go back again. read more

Great pasta options- the sauces are really good. Despite always being busy, the service is still top-notch. I saw the manager working just as hard as everyone else to make sure everyone was happy and satisfied. I liked seeing everyone work together no matter what title they have! The tiramiso is incredible! read more

My wife and I stopped in here for an afternoon lunch on Sunday. My wife ordered a cup of minestrone soup (excellent!) and a personal sized meatball pizza (excellent!) that is about the size of a Round Table medium pizza. I ordered a personal calzone that comes with mozzarella cheese and you can customize with up to three toppings. I chose pepperoni, fennel sausage and pancetta. (excellent!). It came with a basic salad with oil and vinegar dressing and some sauce for dipping. Hey Mary's... you definitely need to step up your game! I'm very happy we decided to try it here again. Improvements have been made and I'm happy to report that we'll certainly be back again! read more

Tomatina - It was so good I almost forgot to get pictures until I was half done! - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Gave it another try and I'm glad I did. Like before, Tomatina provided a warm, welcome atmosphere where I enjoyed a night of friends, tasty wine, and savory meatballs. Excellent combo! The restaurant was busy on its own so our large group was a bit overwhelming...but you never saw it on the faces of the friendly staff. They cleared, they served, they smiled. Grace under pressure! Food: Meatballs! They were flavorful on their own but the tomato-y sauce and sprinkle of parmesan made it even better. I went a little crazy with them. Drink: I was pleasantly surprised by their "house white" which was filled with notes of grapefruit, lemon and ....heck, I'm not fancy. I just liked the wine. It was a Pinot Gris. Atmosphere: So many various groups of people from families with small kids to older friends, everyone seeming to enjoy themselves and the food! The bar offered a TV to catch the game if so desired. All in all, I think it's grown on me! read more

Great place for lunch. Lots of solid food options (i.e. pasta, pizza, calzone, salads). I love Italian food so the entire menu sounded good to me. I ended up ordering Mama's Spaghetti and Meatballs (the regular order, not the lunch). The food was tasty and the service was good. Staff often came by to check in on us. If I'm ever back in Santa Rosa, and I'm craving pasta, I'd come back. read more

Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Service was terrible and the food was equally as bad. Horrible. Plus it was so cold inside that we had to eat with our coats on.

Came in for a few drinks the general manager Jessica is so nice and kind and friendly they have great drinks and food. Dark pink drink is raspberry smash it is so good and sweet. Doesn't even taste like alcohol. read more

I was fiendin for Italian food one night and my gf recommended this place and boy am I glad she did. This place is up on my ranks of great Italian food. The ordering system was fun. You scan this QR code and it takes you to a website where you order your items and the order gets sent to the kitchen. Great system imo. I ordered the build your own pasta and the Mint Vanilla Lemonade (heavenly btw). The food was great and the environment was even greater. Cmon down y'all they got the freakin Gabagool. read more

Tomatina - Pasta and Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

I drove all the way from Petaluma for the Caesar Piadine and when I got home, I got a caprese crust with pesto on it :( Really wishing I had that garlic sauce read more

The place is dead and service was still mediocre. They were out of cheese ravioli, super weird. They were out of vanilla ice cream at 6pm on a weekend. Bizarre since clearly nobody was there eating it all up. Did management stop caring about this place? What happened? It used to be packed, and service was a lot faster. Server was very unsure of everything, had no confidence. After several similar experiences with feeling like the place had gone downhill, I'm left baffled. What happened? read more

This tired restaurant needs help. The signs aren't good. Rude service and a worn out interior. I felt like I had walked into an Italian Denny's. Don't get me wrong I love a good Denny's meal, but I know what my expectations are. I was excited about the cantaloupe and prosciutto starter on the menu. What showed up was a plate of disappointment with side of tears. It's melon season and not hard to get ripe melons. Ours was tough and tasteless. The prosciutto was not the best and whatever the Demi-glaze they had overpowered the the whole plate . A little dressing goes a long way folks. On to the anti-pasti chopped salad was drenched in dressing. It reminded me of a Italian coleslaw. Again a little dressing goes a long way. The Bolognese pene pasta was tasteless. I LOVE bolognese sauce and this one left me disappointed. The server was rude and would have rather been somewhere else. Smiles are free folks. So... we won't be going here again and with the changes occurring at Montgomery Village Tomatina might not be around either. If you like good Italian food go somewhere else. read more

This was our first visit here and we ordered, the cauliflower and corn appetizer it was spicy and delicious. Main course I had shrimp pomodoro and it was delicious, I had enough for lunch the next day. My hubby had pizza and added pepperoni, salami and meatballs and he said the meatballs were the best he has had in a long time. Can not wait to go back again. I forgot our services name but he was a sweet young man that had great customer service skills. read more

Charged $15.25 for a "large" Caesar salad. What a joke. This place is a rip off and not even great food for the price. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

Tomatina - "Large" Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

We came into the restaurant and we could sit anywhere. I selected a drink and was told they cannot make it, they don't have the ingredients. I ordered a sparkling lemonade which is fabulous! My husband drinking water and had to ask for refill. We were waiting on food and the manager sat directly behind us and eat his food and had his cell phone on high and was watch a video- extremely disruptive and thoughtless! This is management - do by example???!! The server is running around trying to service guest and the manager just sits there watching him the weeds!! Again managed by example???? read more

Tomatina - Mozerralla Caprese with flatbread & pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

I have tried to give this place many many chances. I don't appreciate being rushed the second you put down your fork. Your plate is picked up. and your server when you ask for more coffee, you want more coffee again. I want to help and support but when you have something like this in Montgomery Village, they need to go. read more

Tomatina still earns a solid 4 stars for their reliable menu at reasonable prices. We love going for happy hour drinks and appetizers. The Margarita Rosa cocktail is excellent! The crispy calamari is also great, but I wish they were more consistent on just rings or rings and tentacles. Take out is always very quick and convenient for a quality meal, and they frequently offer "family style" take out specials. They also run a lot of seasonal promotions, drinks, and dishes. read more

Not what I expected much better a few years ago. not what you expect. , the service I found was fair to good. The pasta I felt wasn't cooked enough. It was tough. The salmon was overcooked. The raviolis were decent. It was good other than that I was expecting more compared to what I experienced in this location plus some other locations of the same franchise. Also, considering the high price they charge for everything I should've read the reviews earlier seeing so few stars and seen that the place was empty. There was three tables with customers. read more

I took my mother to lunch a while back and right away was impressed by the attention we got. We were quickly seated and asked for our drink order. Drinks came promptly after. For our orders, I had the Chicken Parmesan and she had a spinach salad (if i remember correctly). Again, the server was attentive and polite and service was quick. The food was amazing. Not too salty, not too bland. A perfect balance. Definitely need to check it out again! read more

Hello, Hope the reader is having a sound day. Pedro, efficient, excellent service, kind, respectful, resourceful and timely. Shelby, likewise... Thank you, each of you! read more

We've never eaten in, only carry-out and delivery. The food is decent. They should add the "Summer Pappardelle" to the menu full time as it's arguably the best pasta dish in their menu. Total honesty, 95% of the orders I make here are when that dish is on the menu. read more

No complaints about the food, or the service. As a matter of fact... All of the staff was extremely friendly! We've been ordering from door dash for the last couple of years from them, and last night we decided to finally drive on in and eat at a restaurant the old fashioned way! Haha Anyways, food was good (we ordered way to much lol) service was great, I wouldn't say it has a super Italian ambiance if that's what you're looking for, but if you want some Italian that doesn't suck... and with nice people, this is the place to go to! read more

We went to Tomatina Saturday for a quick meal on the way to see Roseanne Cash. The service was fine. My partner had the chicken parmesan while I had the seafood pasta entree. We opened with the fried calamari, our go to appetizer at Italian restaurants. First, we have never had such rubbery calamari. While the flavor was fine, we had to chew, chew and chew it. It was completely unacceptable. That said the chicken parmesan and the seafood pasta were both excellent - assuming of course you removed the rubber squid from the seafood. The marinara was some of the best we've had. Also, my partner ordered sangria which was copious and quite tasty and while the wine I ordered was fine the portion was puny - maybe 4 ounces per glass. We will probably go back but avoid the calamari dishes, bring our own wine and probably give it another star or two. read more

Wow. Have the mighty fallen at Tomatina? My lovely wife and I have ordered several delivery meals from Tomatina while sheltering in place. We have enjoyed the food immensely every time -- until tonight. We ordered linguine with tomato cream sauce (a favorite) and a side of creamy pesto. We got linguine with creamy pesto and a side of creamy pesto. Not promising. We decided to try the pasta, even though it was made incorrectly. It was overcooked and under-seasoned, and the portion.much smaller than previous editions of the same dish. The meatballs we also ordered (another favorite) were cold and under-seasoned as well, and the accompanying, usually delicious pugliese bread tasted dry and day-old. Even the caramel sauce provided with the apple crisp tasted burnt, not caramelized. Not at all the quality we're used to from Tomatina. Your mileage may vary. We can but hope. read more

Today I had salad was very good! The cheese pizza is the worst I have ever had. Restaurant May have other good items and service good. I do not recommend the pizza! read more

Been coming here for a few years and food and staff are awesome great service overall definitely recommended read more

Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Our Server Alex was the best. Food was delicious. My boyfriend and I ordered the personal pizza from the happy hour menu, and it came out so fast. I ordered the hard peach lemonade off her recommendation. Sooo good! :) read more

Tomatina - Hard Peach Lemonade - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Service is great and friendly. My favorite items are the garlic rolls and baked bolognese. Happy hour from 3-7 pm is great prices. Kids eat free on Thursdays. My nephews favorite is the spaghetti and meatballs. He requests we come here at least once a week. When we are busy and order to go, the take and bake pizzas are the best! The restaurant has a cozy Italian type of feel. read more

We DoorDashed some food for the first time from this establishment and for the most part the the food tasted pretty good. The chicken parm was on point and the bruschetta was good as well. We also ordered some Garlic rolls which had great flavor but they were soaking in olive oil and soggy at the bottom (I know part of the reason is the time it took to deliver but there was way to much oil). The most disappointing meal was the Chicken Alfredo. The sauce had good flavor but it had the consistency of water and the amount of sauce they gave us was minuscule. The entire dish itself was on the small side (for an almost 20 dollar meal anyway). Because of the lacking of sauce, both the pasta and the chicken was quite dry. Not one to complain usually and I'm not going to give up on this place. I look forward to going into the establishment and trying the food fresh. I just won't order the Alfredo! read more

Tomatina - Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Living close to Montgomery village has its perks and Tomatina is one of them. This is our favorite spot for picking up quick healthy Italian food. I have not tried anything on the menu that I haven't enjoyed. The menu isn't that long, which is usually a sign of a restaurant that knows what it's doing. On that menu: The piadines are excellent; fresh bread, fresh produce and high quality ingredients. Same goes for all the pizzas on their menu. The meatballs and the Bolognese are otherworldly. My partner makes the world greatest meatballs and Bolognese sauce at home (when she has time, which not very often) and Tomatina's are very comparable. Pastas are great too. One should try their baked Penne and (if available) their seasonal special. read more

When you walk in, it feels like a generic chain restaurant. The food is pretty good. I had a Piadine, which is flat bread sandwich with a protein and salad inside. It was good. The others in my party had Calzones. I thought they were a little small and dry. Our server was attentive and helpful. If I was in the area and wanted a reasonably priced lunch or dinner, I would probably go there again. Our bill for 4 was $105 without tip read more

Excellent service and food! Try the trio pasta it was to die for. One of the Italian restaurants I Have been to. You must try this restaurant. read more

So it's was a nice lunch with happy hour to boost. Staff was nice and attentive. Food was wonderful. Drinks to simply die for read more

Tomatina - Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California