The pizza was tasty! Got the cold cut sub...came with no mayo, no oil and vinegar! Dry!

Stopped in for a late night pie and ended up being great food and a very classic pizza experience. The staff were friendly and the Hawaiian pizza was 7/10. Very cheesy with a crispy crust. read more

Pizza was good, lots of toppings! Some toppings were unique and delicious. Order was ready super fast.

Ambiance definitely super dirty place, woman's restroom was disgusting and all eating area. Service- no personality of the young gentleman at the register. Pizza was good and chicken wings were ok. Invest in making the ambience better and I would recommend read more

See all

We LOVE this place. Recommend pre-ordering before you get there, there is always a bit of a wait, especially around tourist season but it is worth the wait! They also have gluten free pizza which is very good. read more

We enjoyed the wings and the gyro. Order was completed quickly and the service was friendly.

Quick service for a Saturday evening. Pizza was very good and done to perfection. Would highly recommend.

We got dinner here. The pizza is pan pizza style. It was good. We also had the onion fries which were unique and really good. The Greek salad was enjoyable as well. It was a Friday night so it was very busy. We sat at a table outside. read more

The service was friendly and nice and the atmosphere is that of a small town. My wife and I both thought the pizza was very bland tasting. Maybe our taste buds were just off that night but we both agreed that it needed more spices. read more

The pizza was okay. There are unique ideas for different pizza options on the menu. We arrived an hour and 45 minutes before closing time. Our food took about 45 minutes to make, and by the time we received our food, the staff was vacuuming the area in which we were seated. Turning over chairs on top of tables and telling the additional customers that were coming in at that time that the dining area was closing in 30 minutes and that they needed to place their order, Otherwise they would not be served. This came across the dining area very loudly. I am not from the area, but this is very inconsiderate to start cleaning where other people are still eating, especially when they were there well before closing time. Not to mention the dust from the vacuum cleaner made me want to run. The vibe of the place had 70's or 80's rock 'n' roll playing really loud and you could just smell cigarette smoke coming from somewhere. Maybe this place is a staple for picking up food for a take out night. But I would never go back. read more

By far the best pizza I ever had. It was so delicious! perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. Not to greasy either like some pizza is. Would definitely recommend and I will definitely get it again the next time I'm in Gettysburg. read more

Bangin! Nice buttery crust, free refills, few brews on tap. They stay cleaning! Every time we eat here the dude is on the push vacuum, prolly cause they're always busy. Killwins ice cream few doors down is a seasonal favorite too. Tommy's Pizza is sadly a once a week thing read more

Tommy's Pizza - Sorry.. was too yummy couldn't get a pic fast enough - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Great service and great pizza, and reasonable prices...the best in the Gettysburg area.

Pizza was pretty good especially if you like Doughey crust! The onion fries were to die for & have me dreaming about them ever since read more

Tommy's Pizza - Half pepperoni half cheese pizza. Onion fries & mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

If star ratings were just based on food they would get a 5! However, their customer service is horrid! They offer delivery service but EVERYTIME Ive called to get it delivered I have been Rudely Informed they aren't delivering or they are finished delivering for the day. I get not delivering after a certain time at night, but I'm taking no less then an hour and a half before they close! Oh and nub work is right across the street. I can't always leave my job to go get pizza. If you aren't willing to deliver don't offer it. Also there is a polite way to State this instead of the ignorant way your employees choose to. Just a thought. read more

My husband & I went to Tommy's Pizza today for lunch, we both had the Eggplant Parmesan Sub, Do yourself a favor, stick to the Pizza ! The eggplant was greasy & Soo overcooked, Very dry & Hard, even the Sub Roll was Hard, the only flavor I tasted was the Grease the poor Eggplant was cooked in. read more

White pizza is very good The service can be a bit slow but there's lots of hungry people to feed! I like that it's a laid back place and has a few televisions to keep people busy while waiting. The last time we visited there was a lot of kids so it can be a loud but fun place. read more

Unassuming pizza spot that ended up being quite good! The staff were super friendly and the pizza was great (a little too cheesy, but I know that's an unpopular opinion haha). Would recommend! read more

Pizza is fantastic; dough is special, tomato sauce is on the sweet side, which I prefer and the cheese is perfect. My daughter got a Greek salad and she recommends adding grilled chicken. I've been in the area for over 20 years, had all the pizzas and this is the best pizza within 20 miles. Even better, it's right across the street from the Soldiers National Cemetery in Gettysburg. Family owned business, what else could you want ? Enjoy. read more

We were in Gettysburg over Christmas and stopped in to Tommy's Pizza crust was perfect toppings excellent we just had to add the oregano that was on the table. We loved it service was great you order at the counter beer was delicious need I say more read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

I got a cheeseburger, sub,onion fries and mozzarella sticks, it was delicious, I haven't had a good pizza/sub shop that was delicious as Tommy's Pizza!! read more

Enjoyed the subs on Friday and went back for a white pizza tonight. Great subs and pizza. Their crust is very good. Will go back when I visit Gettysburg again read more

We are from out of town visiting and read raving reviews we had to try this place. We waited a long time and our number was never called.. we had to go up there and remind them of our number and what our order even was. We ordered two large pizzas and neither were cooked all the way through. The pizzas were very doughy and a complete waste of the $40 I paid for them. Horrible experience read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Brought friends here for lunch after traveling around and we walked in it smelt good was looking forward to it. The white lady with brown hair and glasses needs a new job nothing but $hit talking and being rude to customers. we ordered the chicken parm sandwich which was also HORRIBLE. that doesn't deserve the name chicken parm. i wouldn't recommend this to anyone unless they ordered mozzarella sticks. that was the only good thing about this place. read more

We ordered our pizza and then sat outside to wait for our number to be called. When our number was called we went in to get our food but another person had taken our order. Then when this same person's number was called they came up and got their food too. The worker behind the counter said we can't say anything to them and let them have both orders. What!!!?? So if you want free food just go up to the counter when a number is called and pick up someone else's food. read more

Tommy's Pizza is a pretty average pizza place. The pizza isn't too bad, but the service wasn't the best. It took roughly 25 minutes to make one pizza. Honestly, that's longer than most real restaurants, so I definitely was taken aback by this long prep time, considering so many people behind the counter seemed to be screwing around. Definitely need to improve their service. We got the Buffalo Chicken pizza, which was basically a pizza with chicken on it, and then they poured tabasco sauce on top. The pizza was a little but too oily, but overall the pizza was satisfactory. A little bit better than a Domino's, but not by too much. Overall, its convenient location is definitely why people come here. It's located right next to the national park, but I would recommend calling in advance to place your order so you don't have to wait inside the restaurant. Go see the monuments as they (slowly) prepare your meal. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

"Tommy's Tiny Pizza" is our new name for this place. Ordered a large one topping pizza and got a 13" pie for over $16. We've ordered pizza here before and remembered them being larger so I asked the guy at the checkout counter if what we received was indeed a large and he said "yes". Perfect example of "shrinkflation" I guess. Not paying $16 for a tiny pizza again but gave them two stars because it really does taste better than the chain restaurants. read more

Food was ok. Self service, and self clean. I don't eat pizza, so it was a non-event for me.

The food was just ok, nothing to get excited about. Would I eat here again? The pizza was a smidge soft crust for me.

We ordered a small pizza for lunch, with two soda's. $14. The pizza is raised much like Rochester pizza where most in this region come flat. Sauce is sweet. Cheese is excellent quality. Very hot to service. Recommend higher than most pizza restaurant's in the area. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Small pizza slice . - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

The pizza was out of this world. Really good crust, sauce was sweet but really good. We were taking it to go but then we saw it come out of oven and couldn't wait to eat so we stayed in dining room and ate it. Really a good looking pie and tasted even better. read more

I've never been a fan of buffalo chicken pizza; however, Tommy's makes a great one. Highly recommended by a student whose grandma gets that pizza all the time, we had to check it out. The chicken strips are the dry, grilled strips you find on your Caesar salad (the ones I DO like); melted bleu cheese, and a drizzle of the buffalo sauce on top. The crust itself is quite garlic-y, too. The sauce isn't too much, but I wouldn't mind more of it. It was so melty and packed a lot of flavor to it - too bad we ordered a small instead of a large! The place also makes your pizza to order, so you do have to wait at a minimum of 20 minutes. Their tomato sauce is sweeter than most pizza joints, but it's still tasty (I really liked their pepperoni with a dash of hot chili flakes and parm). Definitely a solid place to go to in Gettysburg if you're craving for some pizza flair. +buffalo chicken pizza read more

Pizza was good. Ordered it by the slice. Added broccoli. Legit half a head of broccoli on that bad boi.

YUMMY!! First time here, got 2 pizzas to go, 20 mins, tastes great! Friendly people, feels like Cheers where everybody knows your name. Pepperoni was good and the veggie pizza. Will be back! read more

See all

I have to give this place a 3 despite really wanting to make it more. Now I understand from the reviews here the sauce is an acquired taste which I can't help but agree to, I think it's unique and I'm happy about that but I wasn't amazingly in love. I just didn't think it was an amazing slice, although like I said it was unique and I thought it was a decent enough slice for a 3. read more

The pizza was excellent. Had a lot of toppings on the supreme. It was a nice casual setting to enjoy the food. Parking is limited. Would go back again. read more

Wow. I was here 3 years ago and dismissed this place and didn't stop in. Big mistake. Pizza was fantastic. Wife and I split a small pie and both wished we had ordered a larger pie after we finished. Crust was fantastic!!!!! As an added bonus they are into good craft brew and we were able to entire local PA brewery offerings!!!! We will certainly be back and would recommend to anyone in town!!! read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

I ordered a chicken parmesan sub today for dinner. The sub was so incredibly dry, it was hardly edible. The fries were flavorless and dry too. We've had the pizza before and that was great! Should have stuck with that. read more

The best thing about Tommy's pizza is the sauce. Good on the pizza. Perfectly used on the subs. Recommend the Italian Steak Sub with onions and peppers. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

OMG This place is Great! First of all, the value is outstanding! We got a large mushroom and sausage pizza and it was DELICIOUS. Some say the sauce is too sweet, and I'm really sensitive to overly sweet. This was sauce was perfect to us. We also got some ciders that they had on tap. What an awesome place. Sat in a booth that was comfortable and the restaurant was clean. Good counter service. Just great! Would totally go again. read more