Got to go here when in town for Thanksgiving. Was great quality and many options. Would get again…read moreif in town. I liked the chicken parm Stromboli and chicken broccoli pizza

Was a good place at one time. Went in to place an order for a couple pies about a month ago at 8pm…read more Person behind the counter told me they shut off the oven because they close at 9pm and can't take pizza order. I left and placed an order at another pizza place 15 minutes later who was still taking orders. Tonight I attempted to call Mateos to place an order. It sounded like the phone was picked up and hung up. I called back 2 more times and got the same result. I see on their website you can place an order online, which costs a fee. The order has to be paid by credit card. No thanks! Mateo's just lost a customer. With the way rents are, they should not be turning away business.

I can't even comment on the food from this place, as I never received it, but was still charged for…read moreit. I was out running errands and decided to order from their website (and also pay in advance), thinking I could stop by and pick up my order on my way home. Both their website and Yelp listing showed that they were open. I also received an order status text saying my food was being prepared and approximate time it would be ready. When I arrived at the restaurant, the owner was just getting there and letting himself in. He said he had canceled my order since they weren't open yet, but if I wanted to come back in two hours I could order then, I said no thank you and told him to cancel it, to which he said "ok." I found out later that night that the order had not been canceled, and they processed the payment for anyway. Apparently their website orders are processed through the Slice app. I contacted Slice and was told they couldn't do anything about a refund and that I would have to obtain it through the restaurant owner. The restaurant owner in turn told me he couldn't do anything about it and that I would have to contact Slice. I was screwed out of about $25 while they pointed their fingers at each other. So buyer beware - avoid ordering through their website. And to the restaurant owner, maybe get your business off the freaking internet, since you clearly don't know how to navigate it!! And while I'm here, I can comment on the establishment itself: their use of the quaint word "cafe" in their business name is ridiculous - the place is a hole. I guess it used to be a nice restaurant, but changed ownership, so maybe only pay attention to reviews after 2024.

Run, don't walk from this sorry excuse for a pizza place. Don't be fooled like me by the ratings on…read morethis website and others that were accrued by the previous owners. The pizza that I was served was awful, and I was charged about $24 for some sad Indian food that was basically a samosa and some kind of "chicken patty". My first clue that both types of food were going to be awful is that I've never been to a pizza place that serves Indian food or vice versa.

Had a wonderful experience with my sister Wednesday evening visiting with Johnny. Super…read moreknowledgeable and so interesting to hear his experiences regarding the beer industry! Pizza was delicious as was the IPA. Highly recommend experiencing Night School!

Really enjoyed our experience here we will definitely be back. There is a nice paddling put in…read moreright down the street. We ordered the smash burgers she got the single I got the double, so two patties for me. Mine were really juicy and flavorful hers was overcooked. They did not ask for temperature I guess normally would smash burgers they don't. We also got a slice of pizza each she got plain cheese I got pepperoni. The texture of the pizza was nice and crunchy very strong pepperoni flavor I loved it. Her slice wasn't that great because the cheese or sauce flavor it wasn't amazing, I guess my pepperonis dominated the flavor of my pizza which I was very happy with since I love pepperoni. I got an amazing West Coast IPA called West Friend from there, which I would definitely get again thank you for making that style of beer!

Same order same price 1/3 the size. No longer a customer asked them they said they don't make a…read morelarge. Also I talked to the owner same one from the week before.

I love this pizzeria! The pizza is the best in town, and it's consistently delicious. I recommend,…read morenever had a problem with the service.

This place was incredible!…read more To start, we opted for the combo option of the 3 antipasto: white beans, Castelvetrano olives, and spicy giardiniera (which was perfectly pickled and spicy - the banana pepper was cold, juicy & crisp) The stracciatella cheese side was a must for me & my favorite dish of the night. It's drizzled with honey and served with their warm focaccia bread that has flaky sea salt on top- so good! The Medusa pizza was delicious as well. For dessert, the ricotta semolina cake was perfectly executed. Topped with a candied citrus- went perfectly with the fresh cream. Recommend sitting at the booth in front of the fireplace. Super cozy & warm.

This place adds a 20% tip to your bill regardless of the party size - what a turn off! We tip 20%…read moreusually anyway but when it's decided for you, regardless of how happy or not you were with the service? What gives you the right!! And then the check has "additional tip" line. Go ef yourself. Oh and I love this - the back of the menu says 20% service fee is added to all orders, "no tipping is necessary" hahaha what a joke.

Love the pizza here! Also, Pickles are crisp, dilly, and muy delicioso. The only establishment I…read moreknow that sells MOXIE. Great value and the staff is so friendly. I grew up getting a slice from Tony's at the mountain every weekend from Pam and the crew. That tradition is still alive and well and this location on rt. 100 makes an easy pick up. Had to snag a pic with the lovely lady as well.

Always great service and good food / a family favorite, especially the wings, pizza and sandwiches.read more

Let me tell you; after living in NYC, and talking pizza in the Catskills, I've slowly come to the…read morerealization that I am a pizza snob. There is pizza rivalry between this spot and Mama's in hunter. THIS PLACE, however, makes the best grandma slice I've ever had. While it's prepared untraditionally (thin crust), I strongly encourage anyone to try it!!! When it comes to a basic slice... ehhh I still veer on the side of Mama's, because they use sesame seeds in their crust (hint*). Get pizza here though!! Also, all these salty people saying they know NYC pizza.. pizza is pizza, stfu! It's either good or it's not! Straight facts

Pretty good local pizza. We had the meat lovers which tasted great. Worth a try in the area.read more

Pizza was trash. Crispy bottom, crust hard as a rock. Gooey bread layer. Cheese wasn't bad…read more Pepperoni wasn't really situated into the cheese, more just dropped on top. I think it's best to try something other than the pizza :(

Really, really bad pizza. Ellio's pizza is better than this poor imitation of a pizzaread more

Great variety of food cooked fresh. I enjoyed the deluxe…read morepizza dB look forward to try all the Mexican specialties . I can't wait, my new favorite. Place when I come to windham.

I just got my delivery order and I wish they would come take it back and give me my $30 back. I…read moreordered a large buffalo chicken pizza that was priced at $18.99 on the google menu. It arrives and it's over $29. The driver kept my receipt. There is no red sauce, minimal buffalo sauce and no blue cheese. I will never order again!! I called the store and I'm told that they have charged the delivery fee of $10 for 14 years well that's news to me since this is my first & last delivery. Save yourself the trouble and order earlier from Barnwood for delivery or two brothers for pick up.

We went on Memorial Day to celebrate a birthday. The birthday girl is gluten free. The gluten free…read morechocolate cake was fantastic. She loved it. Thank you to our server Franny for recommending it.

Stopped here last night for dinner and had a great experience. The roadhouse wings are so good!! I…read morereally enjoyed the black bean burger, very flavorful. Our waitress was very nice and attentive.