Came here on a cool summer Friday night with a group of 10 for dinner and some drinks. No issues getting a table in the covered tent towards the back. That being said, parking around here is generally not great and make sure you look out for a few scattered no parking signs! Wait staff was friendly and very helpful, although a little bit slow to get us our food it seemed. Getting to the food though, we had the soft pretzel, beef nachos, and mozzarella sticks to start. Nothing that would blow your socks off, but good quality bar snacks for sure. As for dinner I had their signature which is LARGE and IN CHARGE while my girlfriend had the all dya egg sandwich, each with a side of fries. I think everything could have used a bit more salt, and that is coming from someone with a salt sensitive pallete, but also shockingly, I think the oddball of the egg sandwich was actually the star of the show, but maybe that is just the Long Islander in me talking. Although I just stuck to tried and true coors light, the cocktails looked good and didn't skimp on the pours, which is always a plus. The real attraction of this place though is the nautical charm right along the canal. Hell, if you have a boat, you can even dock right on the premise and likely have a better shot of finding a spot there than on the street for your car. The vibe was chill with some live music playing too, but not too loud where you wouldn't be able to just chat with friends comfortably. Definitely a place I'd look to come back to for hanging out, especially if you've got a nice day on your hands. read more

Toomey's Tavern - Toomey's Burger - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

The bartenders are absolute wonderful. The people who visit this establishment are very friendly even though it's a neighborhood bar. The live music was great. They even played some old school Irish tunes that I was brought up with read more

Toomey's Tavern - Mayor of the bar. Sooo cute and friendly and well behaved - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

If they don't take credit cards in the outside bar ... there should be signs! That killed it all!

Food was ok. Service was terrible like some sort of stupid frat house. Employees were more interested in their own fraternization than the customers. Atmosphere was nice outside because of the waterfront. Won't go back. read more

Will never come back here again..waited 30 mins for appetizers and was waiting for another hour and ended up leaving because we never received our food meanwhile EVERYONE who came after us received their food ..oh and their alcoholic drinks SUCK!! 0/10 ..oh and the manager seemed like she was drunk ..do yourself a favor and go somewhere else read more

Cute neighborhood gem, as long as you know what to expect you're good. Not fancy, very laid back and casual. This is def a spot for the locals - reasonably priced and best visited in the warmer months, when you can grab a table on the back deck overlooking the canal read more

Toomey's Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Went to Toomey's for a Sunday lunch. Ordered lunch and waited for over 30 minutes when server came back to apologize that the order was "not placed". After waiting for another 30-45 minutes our food arrived over cooked and not very appealing. Asked for check and was ready to pay but server no where to be found. Finally provide another server with our payment. If you decide to go, great location on the water, good to watch games, cold beers, appetizers may be passable, but don't expect fast service. Hoping other servers provide better service. read more

Went to go put something out in my car after being here for hours.. bouncer wouldn't let me back in and tried saying I needed to tip him to let me back in. A nice patron intervened telling him to let me back in since I had just gone out (the place was empty). Once he let me back in, my friend was doing a breathalyzer test to make sure they were good to drive, and he came in and ripped it out of her mouth. ??? read more

Came here on a warm summer day. We wanted something on the water. We sat in a covered area. We arrived at 12:00 for lunch, we were seated right away. Our waitress gave us water and we ordered our drinks. About twenty minutes went by and we asked to order two appetizers. The waitress did not check in with us or take our lunch order. We flagged her over once again to place our lunch order. About an hour went by and our lunch was still not served, no refills on drinks or water were given. I left with such a headache and we were all overheated, and thirsty. Service was awful even after we let them know our concerns. read more

Awesome food, great ambiance and the drinks are on point! Staff was super friendly and overall great experience.

2.5 stars - Nice relaxed vibe, great location waterside and friendly service. They used to have lawn games like cornhole and giant Jenga, but I didn't see these available today. Unbelievably slow service, and you will wait forever for your food. So, just be prepared for that. We came for Taco Tuesday, and the prices per taco are very fair. You can get chicken, beef, shrimp, or fish (cod). The taco is available in soft flour tortilla or hard corn tortillas. The tacos are just OK, topped with shredded cheddar, iceberg lettuce, tomato, and some sort of chipotle sauce. Pretty standard bar food in my opinion but a good spot if you're not hungry and are willing to take your time. read more

Toomey's Tavern - Pretzel with cheese sauce - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

I came here last night for the first time! It's a cute dive bar on the water, and they play great music (mainly country). We didn't get any food here, but we grabbed a couple drinks and hung out for a bit. Vibes are awesome, and the people are all friendly. I'm glad I know about this spot now because I'll be coming here a lot during the summer. read more

Toomey's Tavern - two cups of beer on a table - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

We got our drinks Everything was normal. Five hours we were there it was. It was four and we end up there at at 7 o'clock and we still never got our food service was very bad and there is dog hair going everywhere cause there's dogs and then the porta potty is next to the kitchen and we took the drink to go we only pay for the drinks read more

My husband and I went to toomeys the past 2 fridays. It is so nice on the water and the bands are entertaining. Tonight we ordered 2 buckets of corona. On the menu, it lists buckets $25 for domestic & $30 for imported. On the bill it said 2 buckets= $70. I asked the waitress and she said it is $35 each when there is a band. If that is the case, they should have a different menu they hand out when they have a band or it should be noted that the price goes up. We didn't really need the 2nd bucket. I only had 1 beer from each and we actually had 1 we didn't even touch. I think it will be a while before I return bc being charged more than what is printed on the menu really left a bad taste in my mouth. read more

Ambiance is good. Food is awful. Go across the street to Liam's Landing for the food. read more

Had lunch with friends very good service and food. will definately return very nice for a dive bar.

With Hurricane (pardon me) Tropical Storm Henri about to hit Long Island, we were rather blessed to enjoy some beverages, a little Nosh and live music before it all became a wash out later that evening. The calm before the storm as they say. Loss of a star for two reasons.... A full patio of patrons and only one server( who really did kick it up a notch, never saw her flinch or twitch but that is a faux pas on the management for not staffing accordingly. The other reason was the "baked clams" which I didn't eat because of the bacon, but my friend reported they were a little too full of bread crumbs and not cooked well. However, a fellow seated behind us raved about them and the burgers. So, I shall leave it to you to make your own decision. I had the Bavarian Pretzel and it was HUGE. Could probably feed a small village with it. Came with mustard, melted dipping cheese and chili.... (?) that's a new one. But, if you are a boat owner and want to pull up dockside or a land lover who wants to feel a little tropical for an hour or two, this family friendly, live music boasting joint is for you. Street parking, aptly priced. Nice heavy pours from the bar. Cheers Matey's read more

Toomey's Tavern - a clock on the side of a building - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

Local dive bar. Owner and staff always very friendly. Great summer spot to hang and listen to bands. Hard to park a boat unless you're very experienced but fun to watch people who aren't trying to park. read more

I had my son take us there for my Birthday.Had a lot of fun. We got there a little early but it started off well the water was right there they we're pulling in on boats and jet skis. The band started to play we ordered drinks and appetizers. The music was good the drinks were good the food was good. It was a great time and will definitely be back. The band that played was burn unit they were really good.!!! read more

Don't know how this restaurant has good reviews I've been there twice and the first time the food was cold and I had a hair.in my meal the second time the service was terrible and the food was too will not be going back ever again . read more

A band we follow played here yesterday from 4 through 8 pm, so we thought we'd stop by for dinner, drinks, and great music. Fivestone played excellent music, but we did not have dinner. Why? Because the hostess refused to seat us outdoors near the band because we were too small of a party (2), but she said we could be seated in the enclosed tent in the back, where we could not really hear the band nor dance. We bought some drinks and enjoyed the band but started noticing a couple sitting at Table 21 and not eating, two people being led to Table 24 by the hostess, and another couple just strolling in and seating themselves at Table 29. Meanwhile, we had to stand the entire time. Judging by many of the other comments regarding food and service, we're glad we did not have dinner here that night. To be sure, we will never return. read more

Great place for a burger and brew. Or anything else as the food is quite good. Being right on the water. Wifey and I had a good evening. read more

Toomey's Tavern - people sitting at tables outside - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

Was in the area visiting family and we stopped in for a bite and some drinks. Very slow service for crap food. Waited so long just for it to come out cold. Not a very friendly staff either, which is why I felt the need to post this review. My cousin said they will not be returning and there are better dives in the area. read more

Had a terrible experience at this place. We had a server named Natalie. She took so long to come to our table to see if we wanted drinks. We ordered and we waited over an hour for our food. In that time the server never came back to our table to see if we needed anything. After we finally got our food and another drink, she disappeared again and we were waiting for our bill. We had go into the restaurant twice to find her- once to get bill and once to get our credit card back. She was not attentive at all. read more

My friends and I went to this place on a Sunday afternoon. This was my second time here. The place was packed, but luckily we were able to get a table. We decided to order food and drinks. We ordered wings, nachos, mozzarella sticks, baked clams and steak sandwiches. The food wasn't the greatest and was just mediocre. My friend asked for blue cheese with his wings and when his wings came out they forgot the blue cheese. He had to ask again and waited awhile till he got it. When I ordered my steak sandwich, I asked for sweet potato fries. I instead got regular fries. I told the waitress and she gave me a plate of sweet potato fries on the house. The service in this place was extremely slow that day. My friends and I waited a little over an hour to get our food. When I asked a bus boy about the wait for the food, he said that the kitchen was backed up. Then we waited almost another hour to get the check. My friend had to flag the waitress down just so we could get the bill. Now I totally understand that restaurants (especially this place) get packed over the summer when it's nice out, but then the owner/manager should have enough staff to service everyone within the appropriate time frame. Not sure I'll be going back anytime soon and if I do it'll be only for a drink. read more

Steak quesadilla tasted like dog food, it was basically the scraps of steak that they don't serve to people inside of it. It was all fatty small mushy pieces. I ate 2 bites to try it and the waitress, Natalie, who also claims she's the manager, tells me it looks like I ate half of it. I honestly was taken back that she needed to challenge me instead of believing me that I said it tasted horrible. Why would I lie? She acted like I ordered it just to send it back. I would've definitely been more understanding if her attitude wasn't literally so rude. Any questions I asked she was so annoyed to answer and she didn't even know the answer to simple questions like is the shrimp frozen, but yet she's "the manager". She huffed and puffed and gave us a nasty look that she had to take it off the bill. Even the clams weren't good or my rocket fuel but I guess it was a lesson learned never to come here again. Everything is just thrown together really fast they don't care about quality. read more

Toomey's Tavern - a plate of food - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

Toomey's is fabulous. We have came there a couple of times and we love it. This place has all the little secrets in a hidden place. read more

Toomey's Tavern - Loads of fun. Love this place. - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

You got your regulars, you got your newbies and everyone makes you feel at home and I promise you, you'll become a regular. Location can't be any better if you want to pull up your boat or by car and the food is unbelievable (baked clams)..... they might be pretty good just a hint. Summer time vibe with the outdoor bar and live music can't be beat! read more

Toomey's Tavern - a view of the sunset - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

Food was delicious. Had three or four different items on the menu so far and love them all. Fish and burger very good I just called them the Danny band they were amazing Danny lloydman Danny Langdon thanks for that day was a highlight of the summer. Amazing just amazing what a night and what a day that was with them. Have been back once or twice we'll try to make it there many more times read more

I moved to Amityville a year ago and received a gift certificate for Toomey's and finally was able to go and use it. I never looked at the gift certificate and when we paid using our gift card we were told it expired 2 months prior. Both the manager and owner refused to allow us to use it. Yes it was expired but only 2 months. I can't believe they would not honor the gift certificate I good faith. Now I will never go back and make sure no I know goes there. The place is a trashy place. Both the owner and clients were drunk. The place was dirty and I also got sick from the food. read more

Fun place on the canal for locals. Lots of outdoor seating, great for COVID! Staff was nice and good entertainment. Nachos and my speciality drink were great! We both got a chicken wrap, it was pretty good read more

Toomey's Tavern - people sitting at picnic tables under umbrellas - Seafood Near Me - Amityville, New York

See all

Such a cute little casual place. Went with two other couples and we had such a great time! The food was pretty good and drinks too. What was awesome was the atmosphere. ***** best part of all....they allow dogs!!!!***** Now I can bring my little guy Omg the owners dog ran around the deck! So cute! We will def be back! read more

I visited to Toomey's for lunch last Saturday. Both me and my friend had the burger.We both thought it was very good made and the fries were too. The ambience is quite nice and it was a perfect August summer day, watching the boats There is plenty of outside seating, a tiki bar and a band. The staff is courteous and helpful.There is ample parking and there is an inside bar and seating. This was my first to this business. I hear Toomey's has a lot of history and I can see why people go here. If you are in the area stop by, you will not be disappointed. G read more

food and staff are great. especially when i witnessed what seemed to be a regular named "debbie" go after two young girls coming out of the bathroom for no reason. the staff handled it wonderfully holding the aggressive woman back allowing the girls to return to their table. it's a shame to see a "regular" of a restaurant disrespect paying respectful costumers! read more

Terrible service. I really wanted to like this place but i got one round of drinks and mozzarella sticks in about an hour and a half, after the server initially didn't even know we were her table. Meanwhile, other tables were well taken care of by other servers. It's a shame that after the pandemic, service businesses don't understand that we go to work, make money, and CHOOSE to patronize a business yet they can't even be bothered to do their job on what looked like a average volume afternoon. Save your money and take it somewhere they care about how you spend your free time and money. read more

I'm a local resident in Amity Harbor. I've been coming here for years... Richie, the owner rocks. Keeps me coming back because he's got the best live entertainment like the band bad sandwich. Now here in the winter time, Brian, in the absence of Richie, runs the place so well that I forget that it's not the warmer months where everybody wants to be here. I still come here like clockwork on Sundays thanks to Brian. Please give Brian kudos and the big pat on the back for the amazing job he does, and he deserves a raise! If you don't give them the raise he deserves, I'm currently hiring and I love finding amazing talent in town... Cheers keep up the great work! read more

Cute bar on canal in Amityville. Decent beer and cocktail list. It was busy so food took awhile but was worth the wait. California chicken wrap with avocado bacon and chipotle Mayo. Forgot pic but a decent size and. Ot over priced. Rum punch was served in pint size cup and refreshing read more

Neighborhood bar with music nightly - no cover. As with many of these places, the bands think louder is better (the opposite is true). New owners have moved some of the riff-raff out.... read more

See all

I love trying new places with my girl so I found this place on google and I'm glad I did. They have live music, indoor and outdoor dining, beautiful views and seats right on the water. My first time going there our servers name was Anne, she's lovely ! Always smiling great recommendations on the and all around a great employee, I've been back several times, I recommend trying the Shrimp quesadilla and for dessert the fried cheese cake. Looking forward to dining again here in the near future ! read more

My husband and I have been here a few times. It's a dive bar scenario but for a quick night out it's a fun place to be. It's on the canal and normally there is live music but not sure how this summer will look like due to the Pandemic. If you are looking for some fish and chips, clams, some beer or other fun drinks head over and enjoy the outdoor seating! read more