Over time, I've now had both styles of pizza, lasagna, and a salad. Everything has been excellent. I am not sure what goes into their ranch dressing but it's addictive. Last night when I stopped in one of the owners was eating with his adorable family. His girls are the cutest. 10/10 highly recommend. read more

Had this on our "want to go" list. Had been trying to get here for the longest. Bad decision. We sat there for an hour waiting on two 10" pies. We understood that they're made from scratch, but there were others getting their pizzas before us that arrived WELL after we did. We got up to leave and explained to the staff that we were waiting too long. We did have places to be afterwards, but waiting over an hour is too much. What's worse is that we only got "I'm sorry" & "I understand". No "how can we make this right". We ended up getting the pizzas to go as we were starving but no type of discount, extra whatever or anything. Just "pay for I guess". Also, fiancés pizza had mushrooms on it after asking for them to be removed. We will not be back. Huge let down. read more

We're went here tonight as we're visiting Birmingham for the week and was craving decent pizza. This place came up with high ratings and not too far from the hotel where we're staying at. The place was pretty busy, so I always take that as a good sign. They were very friendly and sat us down right away. The server came with the menu, was very enthusiastic and friendly. Took our order and gave us an ETA on the food. When it came, it was the wrong order. She apologized profusely and said they're putting a rush on the replacement order. A few minutes after the correct order came, the manager came over to our table and apologized some more and offered us a discount on our order. Certainly unexpected but much appreciated! The pizza was great as well! Highly recommended!! I just wish I took pics to post though. read more

I decided to try the Chicago deep dish Carne pizza, loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, and Canadian bacon. Honestly, all that pork made it a little too salty for my taste, but overall the pizza itself was really good. Next time, I'll definitely go with different toppings because I actually did enjoy it a lot. I can totally see why this place was packed when I came in. The staff were super friendly, and the spot had that cozy, mom-and-pop feel that I really appreciate read more

See all

Amazing deep dish Chicago pizza. Never had it before. We were blown away. Must try if you are in the area. We got the traditional except we subbed the Italian sausage for pepperoni. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Sign - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

See all

I finally had a chance to try Tortugas Pizza. Wow!! The deep dish we ordered was amazing. Tons of cheese and meat and the pie was cooked perfectly. I had a great conversation with Josh one of the managers. I can't believe this place has been in business for 24 years and I have been missing out on some phenomenal pizza. Definitely coming back really soon. Can't wait to bring my friends and family here. Cheers to 24 years in business and cranking out some phenomenal pies. read more

See all

Good Food, Took a while to receive the food, but we should have called it in. I know better next time

Great pizza and they serve beer in ice cold mugs which is great. I'll definitely be back.

Relatively new to the area, I see their sign every time I'm on 150. Seven neighbors out for dinner and this was the choice. Excited to finally go! Fantastic little place tucked into a strip mall with 3 curbside tables they happily brought together for us. (They wiped the tables and all the chairs so we wouldn't have to sit on any pollen. Very thoughtful!) They occupy two spaces in the strip mall. It appears one side is primarily the kitchen with a few tables and the other side is mostly seating. Having lived in the Chicago area for 10+ years I loved all the Chicago memorabilia! Our server could not have been nicer. We ordered two large Traditional pizzas, two people had house salads that looked freshly made (and received very good reviews), some had wine, others had soft drinks. Sturdy-enough paper plates and real utensils, not plastic. She gave us a progress update when she came out to offer refills and she was spot on. Pizzas arrived hot, cut into squares, super cheesy and yummy looking. They were delicious! The onion and green pepper were plentiful and easy to find if those aren't your favorite toppings. The sausage was very tasty, and the crust was perfect. (We ordered the one that is more like a hand-tossed rather than the deep dish.) The evening? Lovely, temps perfect, service thoughtful and attentive, food delicious...great little place! I honestly can't wait to go back!! read more

Tortugas absolutely lives up to its reputation as a gorgeous small pizzeria with mouthwatering pizzas at a fair and reasonable price. All of their pizzas are made fresh, most of them being made right when you order. The staff were beyond friendly and always came out to inform me on the progress of my order. The thin-crust pizza slices I got were absolutely delicious and straight out of the oven. I was unable to get a Chicago style pizza while in the restaurant but I got one to-go and it was fantastic. I highly recommend Tortugas in Hoover for anyone looking for some absolutely amazing pizza read more

See all

Stopped in while staying over night on our way to Florida for vacation and I'm glad we did!!! Thin crust was flaky and airy in all the right ways!! read more

Tortugas Pizza is some of the best pizza I've ever eaten ! The red sauce not only delicious but to me unique. It's like an Italian Granny has been cooking this forever....and very consistently delicious. I was in a situation whereas I had to order this by delivery last night. I found this available through Instacart and appears to be teamed up with Uber on this delivery. Regardless, the delivery was as ordered and the food was still warm upon arrival from the Hoover HWY 150 location to Liberty Park. Now being a seasoned customer, it has been impossible for me to place an order from Tortugas without getting the stuffed pizza with red sauce. I prefer this stuffed pizza with garlic and Italian sausage. This order also had green bell peppers. I will continue to be a loyal customer and fan of Tortugas as long as they keep making delicious food. By the way, about 8 years ago...crazy circumstances left me with 3 whole loafs of that incredible Leidenheimer French Bread that's served in all the great restaurants in New Orleans. I had an employee get me 3 loafs of this bread from Publix in Gulf Shores. The loafs are at least 36" long. I was leaving work after 5pm and carried a couple loafs of this wonderful Leidenheimer bread to Tortugas downtown to the location near Good People Brewery and gave the owner a loaf if his use, if he used one to make 3 subs for me to go. He did and those subs too were incredible. I wish Leidenheimer bread was available in our location. The only place I've found it is when ordering PO Boys from THE ROUGAROUX Cajun joint in Avondale. read more

My wife and I have enjoyed Tortuga's for a long time. This time we paid around $45 for a pizza only to discover when we got home that it was chock full of raw onions and raw peppers. It absolutely ruined the pizza. We had to basically deconstruct the entire pie, to try and remove the raw veggies (especially the onions). Of course, this turned the pizza into a big mess. My wife sent the management a message on social media but did not get a response. We like Tortugas but we won't be getting another pizza there for a very long time after this experience. And, we'll either eat it at the store to ensure that any issues are dealt with or we'll ask them to skip the onions entirely read more

First time to try Tortuga's pizza and I am hooked. Great food and great service! I had the thin crust Carne special pizza, next time I will try the deep dish read more

Simple. This is the Best Pizza in Birmingham metro area. We eat here often and the food quality and service is always tops. I am a fan of the thin crust where my wife loves the deep dish. Tough to choose. :) read more

Pizza is my favorite food. It's also the one thing this Chicago girl doesn't order when out of town. However...I happen to be in AL and my brother said this place is Good. It hits the spot! It's cut just how I like at home...tavern style. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Cheese Pizza and Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

This is the best Chicago style you'll find! So thankful there's a place like this down in the Deep South. The staff is kind. The quality is great. Love this place! read more

Pizza is the best in Birmingham and they have the best service. Brought a 2 year old and newborn, they were so accommodating and gave 2 year old pizza dough to play with. The cheesy bread appetizer came out at the same time as pizza and what I assume is the manager said that should have come out earlier, let me take that off your bill. That is so nice!! Places these days usually don't acknowledge such without a complaint and it's so nice to have someone be proactive with service. read more

First time ever here I ordered their deep dish pizza Chicago style. The food was excellent. I opted for the one that you could finish cooking when you got home. The people were very friendly. The service was great. Nice little establishment would recommend a place you need to go read more

I was very pleased with Tortugas! The pizza pie was delicious! My father is from Chicago & was ecstatic to have authentic pie so close to his new home. The service was amazing, the waitress & owner were very nice. The ambiance is very cozy & feels like you're hanging out at a friend's house. We will definitely be back! read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Traditional Chicago Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

Hiked at Oak Mountain all day and was starving. A Yelp search for pizza led us to this place-just a little hole in the wall. They had great reviews, so we decided to try it. Walked in two minutes before closing, but they made our pizza before they shut down. I cannot remember when I've had a better pizza! Scrumptious-so good that we had to take a pic to post even tho we had already eaten several pieces. Seriously, if you get a chance, definitely try this place! We will be back-might be a new post-hike tradition. read more

See all

Times are wrong online! Arrived at 7 pm time online say 8 pm closing. Walked in and was told that's the downtown business with an attitude. Thank you but no thank you. Same issue posted on here 3 mos ago. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Look at those times - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

Just not great. The crust isn't corn meal. How is this a Chicago deep dish? The box was very very wet. Like a puddle. Probably the tomatoes they opted for on the vegetarian. Not a great decision. Everything was soggy. I've found 2 olive pits in the quarter of the pizza I ate. Get a new olive supplier. There is a crazy lack of cheese for Chicago style. Overall, a disappointment. Every city needs a giordanos. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - A lack of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

Best location of Tortugas is on HWY 280! Delicious, hot, fresh, nice attentive service each and every time!!

Love Chicago style pizza and Tortuga's stuffed pizza is one of my favorites. We get it to go so I can't really comment on service or ambiance. read more

We were passing through town, staying at a hotel near by, and needed dinner for a group of 6. I saw a few reviews and decided pizza was a safe bet for the three kids. The handwritten sign on the door said they closed at 7 pm on Fridays? We got there at 6:45 pm. Since there were people dining in and being seated, I felt okay with doing carry out. We got a lasagna, spinach salad, Italian salad, and 3 thin crust pizzas. Everything was delicious. I wanted to try the Chciago style deep-dish, but I was out numbered. There were a few that left the busy kitchen while we waited, and they looked amazing. The order was correct, the prices were reasonable, the service was friendly, and the food was worth spending time to write a review. I can understand why the place was doing a great business the night we rolled in. read more

Seriously this is the best stuffed pizza outside of Chicago. I have been to Chicago and had the stuffed pizza and this pizza at tortugas is true to Chicago. We have been coming here for years and years and I was scared they might not be able to make it through the early days of the pandemic but they have survived and I will keep coming!!! Thank you for the best pizza around and the sweetest owners who care about their customers! read more

See all

Holy hell...Glad this place is in Birmingham and not Chicago, it would have been ran out of Chicago a long time ago. Sauce was watery and bland, toppings were not par cooked and still raw in the pie, crust had no personality, whole thing needed another 10 minutes in the over. Dominos manages to get more flavor out of a pizza. Would not be surprised if Burt came and haunted this place for the shame. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Traditional deep dish. - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

The Chicago Style Pizza is Amazing!! They are huge, and the flavor is awesome. The sauce taste is very tangy and fresh....and the pizzas are full of topping and gooey cheese. The servers and owner were very friendly and attentive. The decor is very casual and nostalgic, and fun to look at. Definitely Will Be Back! read more

Great service is nice. Taste is a 7.5 Presentation 8.3 Crust is crispy. Staff is very friendly read more

Spent the night in Birmingham on our way to Gulf Shores and ordered to-go pizza here to eat at our hotel. My husband and I split a 12" Chicago stuffed pizza. We were both surprised by how good this was!! We were both pretty hungry and were so full with still a slice to spare. We would definitely eat here again if we're in the area!! Very fresh sauce, just overall tasty!! read more

Hands down the best stuffed pizza south of Chicago. I covered this restaurant in one of my first Yelp reviews ever. It was 2007. George W Bush was in the White House, Tony Petelos was mayor, and Highway 150 was largely undeveloped. I was a young Yelper with big ideas. This is the original Tortugas restaurant and it has stayed true to itself. It is the epitome of the neighborhood, family owned and operated business. The walls are covered with pictures of family, friends, and sports memorabilia. An allegiance to the Cubs is obvious. The owners are Carlos and Carol. They are friendly, and will ensure that you have a great experience. The stuffed pizzas are my "go to". The pizza slices are close to two inches high. The ingredients are fresh and tasty. The hand tossed dough is always cooked just right. I love the pizza sauce and especially the occasional pieces of crushed tomato or garlic. Delicious! read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama

Delicious pizza! Best around! We love Tortugas meat pizza.It's fabulous. The service is great and pizza is amazing! read more

Got the thick Chicago style pizza is fantastic! Got the carnivore pizza! Highly recommend!

The pizza was ok. I couldn't cut the thick crust with the utensils provided so had to eat the toppings separately... Too hot to pick up. The party at our table who used a credit card received their receipt and card back and the server hurried away. We had paid cash expecting change so that we could leave a 20% tip. Instead the server avoided us and kept the 33%. We don't mind the extra few bucks but do mind the subterfuge. read more

I'm not a "yelper" but I just love their Chicago style stuffed pizza. I have been eating there for years and It's always great! If you haven't tried it, please do. Fabulous! Great, friendly and pleasant staff always welcoming. read more

Today was family outing day. My husband and I decided to treat our boys' by trying out a new restaurant. My husband had heard great things about Tortugas so we decided to find out if it was worth the hype. Let me just say....definitely worth the hype. My husband is normally a thin crust pizza guy--which Tortugas has--but we decided we wanted to try the deep dish. We choose the 12" pizza, which was more than enough for us. We took home 3 slices. We got a cheese pizza with pepperoni and smoked sausage. It takes about 45 minutes for the deep dish to cook, which we already knew because we had read reviews. My husband, an avid Cardinals fan, had a discussion with the owner. They engaged in friendly banter about the rivalry between the Cubs & Cardinals. The owner also brought out dough that my boys played with while we waited. That was very thoughtful of her! It kept the kids from getting to restless while we waited. Also, while we waited, we were given complimentary garlic bread with marinara sauce. We demolished it; yes, it was really good. My youngest son wanted more. When the pizza was brought out, it looked like a pizza pie. Our waitress actually served the slices to us. This pizza is best eaten with a fork and knife to avoid a mess. This was absolutely the best deep dish pizza I've ever had. One slice was all my boys' and I needed. My husband had two. Our waitress boxed up our leftovers. The owner asked us how everything was and we were able to tell her it was superb. My husband and I were both really impressed by the food and service. We'll definitely come back! read more

See all

Excellent service!!! Pizza arrived hot to the table! Side salad was fresh and balsamic vinaigrette was excellent! However, if you're expecting totally Chicago style pizza, you may be disappointed. Sauce was watery and amount of cheese in the bottom layer was not typical. Sauce on top has large chunks of tomatoes vs all sauce. Waiter was working his first day at the restaurant and did a fantastic job of serving us! read more

Tortuga's is the best pizza in Birmingham! The deep dish pizzas take about 40 minutes to cook so plan ahead or call ahead for it to be ready when you arrive. The thin crust is also awesome. read more

One bite everyone knows the rules! Great place for pizza. A pizza can easily be split a couple of ways. They are huge and full of flavor. It does take a good 45 minutes to get a whole pizza so call ahead if you are in a rush or go by for lunch on the weekends for individual slices that are ready. Staff is super friendly and you'll leave very full. read more

Tortugas Homemade Pizza - #bhamfoodguy - Pizza Near Me - Hoover, Alabama