Food was a bit disappointing and Medicare at best. Not an authentic Italian restaurant at all. I would give lower stars but our server was extremely friendly and provided exceptional service. Overall, this is an overpriced tourist trap in my opinion. 2/5 - fried conch: bot bad but would not recommend or want to order again. It's essentially kind of like a crab cake but was not that appetizing at all. 2/5 Conch soup: tasted like marinara sauce heated up with potato's, carrot and very little conch meat. 5/5 the garlic bread: was actually quite taste. Soft, warm and flavorful. 4/5 sweet potato fries: can't go wrong with that 2.5/5 meat lover pizza. Crust was a bit burnt. Toppings were good but the sauce was kinda too sour and the dough was not good at all. 10/5: service. Our servicer truly was attentive and friendly. read more

See all

Unobtrusive little place, with stunningly good food. Stopped there on our way from Key West to Miami. I highly recommend the fish tacos, they were truly the best I've ever had. My husband had the lasagna and said it was the best he had ever eaten; the service was so friendly and prompt. I highly recommend this place, very well priced also. very cute atmosphere. read more

they got rid of all the delicious seafood Pasta on the menu when they changed from Triton to Lalo :-(

The food was absolutely delicious from start to finish. Just the right amount of fresh salad. Garlic rolls to die for. Delicious pasta dinners. The key lime pie was great and the cannolis were amazing. Even the coffee was delicious. Michelle did an awesome job. I highly recommend. read more

Triton Seafood Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

This place had the best Key Lime Pie and service in the Keys!!!! Quiet atmosphere, GREAT pasta and sauce!

Im giving it 5 stars because it truly was the best food we ate in the week that we stayed in Marathon. The blackened chicken in the alfredo sauce was done perfectly and seasoned well. We all had Italian dishes (cannelloni, alfredo, marinara, vodka sauce and pizza) and none of us were disappointed. The service was great as well. The building looks old but I recommend looking past that and try some delicious and fresh Italian dishes!! read more

This place definitely has some unique options from a lot of the Keys seafood places around, with a strong Italian twist (which is certainly hinted at in the name), so if that's what you're looking for then I'd definitely recommend coming here. To be honest we wouldn't have chosen to come here at all- we had picked another place originally for dinner but it ended up being closed and there weren't many other options by that time.. The service was a little slow honestly, my group of 3 were the only ones in there when we came. We were sat down and ordered already 15-20 minutes before another couple came in, and they received their food way before us and were constantly fussed on by the waiters and we probably had half the service, it was just really weird. But, once we did get our food the chef came out himself and introduced and talked to each table there so that was cool. I enjoyed the food overall. Give me seafood and pasta and I'll be pretty happy, and that's exactly what I got here. I think I got the shrimp fra diavolo? It was very spicy and I liked that, and the catch of the day my dad ordered was probably the best of our 3 dishes. The key lime pie was for sure the most unique, odd KLP I've tried. It almost had more of a rice pudding texture, and it certainly has a most different look, but it still had a really nice key lime kick so I was okay with it. I don't think I'd get it again, but it was worth a shot. In summation, I was fine with my visit here but not really overly thrilled. I guess take your chances! read more

See all

4 out of 5 only because of the service and a piece of, what I can only imagine is a steel wool brush from dishwashers. The service was dull and was wondering if she was just uncomfortable, nervous or just a robot. The food was incredible! The decor is out dated but who cares, I went for food! The food pics were taken after we all dug in! read more

See all

This was not a good dining experience. I had been looking for a seafood break and thought Italian would be perfect. The server was very friendly and nice. I hope she finds employment in a place more befitting . That and the starter salads were the best things about the restaurant. The small salad that comes with the entrees was a mixed greens base. The blue cheese dressing was very cheesy. It took a very long time to get our food. We were told twice it would be out shortly. And then we were checked on by another lady too who asked what we'd ordered. A couple that came in a half hour after us ate and were leaving while we were just starting our entrees. I'd ordered chicken Marsala. This dish doesn't usually have onions nor were they mentioned on the menu. I'd had my salad without onions. So I was surprised to find a ton of onions in the sauce -- more than the mushrooms -- all over my chicken and sadly mixed into my pasta, I scraped off the sauce and ate the chicken. The pasta was inedible as it was gummy and mushy. My husband had ordered their lasagna. He said it was just okay. It was chewy, not much meat, and kind of bland. We asked for the check. Before we had pulled out our credit card to pay, they'd rung up our bill including a fee for paying with a credit card. We asked about it. There's no notice on the door or the menu and no one said anything about it in advance. The server told us they'd just starting doing this. That if we went to the bar we could see a small sign by the register!!' WTF! If you go inside, you would be hard pressed to even find the register, let alone the sign. This was just as they say : Adding insult to injury, I had my husband pull through McDonald's afterwards. That should tell you all you need to know. read more

Triton Seafood Restaurant - Outside - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

All I've had is crab Pizza here, and unfortunately the last two times haven't been as good as 2019 when we first got it. It appears there's plenty of crab, but I think they're using regular crab vice the stronger seafood flavor of blue crab they used to use.. They also don't have arugula as an optional topping anymore. Without the blue crab it's just kinda meh. Their other dishes may be good, have not tried them. read more

This was the kind of dining experience where you were glad you stopped in because it was dead and your grateful to help a small business owner survive these tough times. You know your party of 8 will land a nice tip to your server who deserves it! I wish the food had been better, and it wasn't bad, it was just average, hence the 3 stars. We ordered several orders of garlic bread and they were good. I tried the Snapper Francese and my honey got the Grouper Al Funghi. I had food envy of his Grouper and wished I ordered it to. The Snapper was good, I just thought it could have used more flavor. read more

See all

So this is really a Spanish place masquerading as an Italian place. The music, ambiance and the cuisine have solid spanish flair about them. Don't get me wrong I love a great spanish place but I wanted Italian. The "baby octopus" salad... it should be called the bean salad with a few strips of adult octopus on it. It was a tasty bean salad but not a $17 good bean salad. After that we were scared to risk anything and played it safe with a pizza. The pizza was good. Crust was nice and the texture of the dough was good and the cook was complete. I thought toppings were as expected in quantity and composition. It was served nice and hot. Iced tea was a little watery but not over sugary. Service: The server was super polite and came by about every 2 minutes... :/ food was delivered in an acceptable time. All in all it was less than we were expecting and not likely on our do over list. In a pinch the pizza is way better than frozen supermarket pizza. Sorry no pics. I feel bad having to leave a review like this in this economy and with so many places struggling. But it is an honest one. You milage may vary... read more

Pizza was the best many years ago. We ordered pizza from them while staying in marathon repeatedly over the years. I ordered a pizza and called wife and told her to pick it up. They gave her three pizza and said that is what I ordered. At home I told my wife I only ordered one pizza. We took them back. They dropped one and gave to another customer. The staff seemed off, maybe started weekend there weekend a little early. Our pizza was not as ordered and was worst than a frozen pizza. Never again. read more

Ordered carry out conch pizza and the pizza itself was outstanding. Great flavor, perfect crust. Service was prompt and friendly both while ordering over the phone and when picking up. Very timely. Seating inside and out gave it the perfect feel for a vacation restaurant. Their menu is huge and I look forward to trying several of their other dishes. Reason it lacks the fifth star...online menu desperately needs an update. Pizza was ten dollars more than advertised. read more

We were there on 4/5/2022, a Tuesday. I was surprised at how empty the place was, given that many of the other restaurants in Marathon we had visited in the preceding 2 weeks were packed full every day of the week. It is a bit further out from the center of town than most, but it is worth the effort to get there. We had Hog Fish Ciciliano, Prosecco Bruit (a special of the day), and Tiramisu. The Hog Fish was really good. The Prosecco at $8.50/glass was a nice change of pace from the Pino Gregio we would otherwise have had. The only slight disappointment was the Tiramisu. The consistency was spot on, and the portion size was ample, but the taste just wasn't there. It definitely needed more coffee flavor. read more

Miss Michelle was an absolute doll. We had a party of 16 with a lot of little kids. Michelle was amazing. She was very kind and patient and she was so funny and lovely. I miss her already. We had a great time as a family and to have a server being so nice makes it so much better. The food was really good as well. That's important to know as well. I had the crab cakes dinner. Delicious! The conch fitters are to die for and the calamari was so good. My little 5 year old nephew ate all the calamari lol my Dad had the chicken parm dinner and he liked it so much. Next time I go to the Keys I'm gonna stop by Triton and see Michelle! Shoutout to the chef! read more

Triton Seafood Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Let me start by saying that me and my wife were a little skeptical about this place, but this place is the real deal. The calamari was fresh & crispy!(wow) & the pasta was al dente! Creamy and flavorful! The shrimp were fresh and very good. The French fries you can tell they cut them in house! Overall the atmosphere was good, the only downside we had was that our server wasn't the friendliest. I was going to give it a 4 star because of that but the food made up for her bad service. I would definitely recommend this spot to friends and family. Keep up the good food! read more

See all

Had a wonderful margarita pizza for lunch. The sauce tasted great, and the staff was very attentive and helpful. Key lime pie that was all made from scratch was also good. We've been in the Keys for a week, and this was the best tasting food all week. read more

I'm sorry to say that we did not have a good dinner. We ordered a lasagna bolognese which was ok. We also ordered a stuffed noodle with a meatball. The meat ball and stuff in the noodle was not a recognizable meat. I didn't send it back because we were the only patrons. I felt sorry for the waitstaff. Something drastically changed there, since we ate there a year ago and it was pretty good. read more

We have enjoyed some great meals in Marathon this week, then we ate here tonight. To be kind the Sauvignon Blanc was great! The food was mediocre at best. My lasagna was bland and chewy. My wife ordered Chicken Marsala which was drenched in chopped onions in the marsala and the chewy pasta was also saturated in onions.... my wife doesn't eat onions. (45 minutes to get these two dishes from the kitchen and they weren't that busy). When we had finished and our check was delivered, I noticed a NONCASH ADJUSTMENT CHARGE (2%) added to our bill. When questioned, our server stated that "he" just started the additional charge last week for credit charges. If we wanted to pay cash she could take it off. Now here's the interesting part: The check had been rung, including the NONCASH ADJUSTMENT, and brought to the table BEFORE I even pulled out my wallet, and before I pulled out my credit card. My wife pointed out there was no visible notification posted anywhere and our server said that there was a sign at the bar register. She also stated "he" is having new menus printed next week. We have dined at Cash only places, discounted meals if paying by cash, with no problems. This experience only added to the negative vibe of the food. Tri...somewhere else! read more

Triton Seafood Restaurant - Lasagna - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

spaghetti and meatballs came with 1 meatball so expensive my friend ordered shrimp on her pasta and got charged 10$ extra without knowing. horrible place don't come. read more

I had the most difficult day and was so fortunate to end it at this restaurant. A lovely woman named Michelle put a smile on my face and served me the most delicious food. Thank you Triton and thank you Michelle for bringing this horrible day to a positive ending. read more

Excellent Italian food! Very authentic, garlic nots, pasta primavera were great , but the tiramisu was spectacular!!! 5 stars!! Helen is a great! Very good at the personal touch and service.. read more

We had a wonderful meal at Triton. I had vodka sauce with penne and grilled chicken. It was outstanding! You know homemade sauce, when you taste it! This little spot has the best of both worlds. Italian and seafood. My fiancé had shrimp plate, also outstanding. When you get out of the car and smell garlic, you know you are in the right place! Michelle, our server, gave excellent service! Don't miss the garlic rolls!! read more

This is an unexpected find in Marathon. This corky little Italian restaurant has more of a neighborhood restaurant vibe than the typical "touristy" fish sandwich and pizza restaurant that seem to be the norm in this area. The food is solid, my favorite is the pasta pescatore, full of shrimp and muscles, clams and fish. Their conch fritters are the best in the Keys. Instead of a round gooey ball, they offer a flat, crispy patty of fritter that is the bomb. This place is a definite must try! read more

If you are in marathon in the Florida keys I haughty recommend Tritons!! HUGE portions and reasonably priced. I had the snapper livornese . Huge fish portions and love the sauce, capers and Kalamata olives. All entrees came with a salad, veggies and rice. The garlic knots were delicious and the conch ceviche was perfect. Lots of conch. Husband had the snapper fungi. Again great portions and said it was delicious. Great service. Only thing I didn't like was the unsweet tea, had a funny taste but still giving them 5 stars!!! read more

Last night's dinner, The Calamari appetizer was good. The garlic knots ,well looked like heat n serve bread with garlic butter and parmasean sprinkled. Party of 6 , table was available Some table settings at table. Appetizers brought out , no plates We got table settings for the rest of us from the next preset table. Alfredo Juanita: Lots of pasta little seafood in one dish Shrimp tail , one clump of lobster Another person had same dish 4 large shrimp no lobster, lots of pasta Tarter sauce for fish was runny not sure what it was . Just not impressed My eggplant dish was lots of cheese and sauce more pasta Sliced thin eggplant couldn't define, mushy . No would not recommend for the price point of 250.00 for 6 with 3 beverages and 3 waters to drink . Very disappointing read more

Fish was very good. Tasty, fresh, great seasoning. The cuisine has a Latin flavor. Kids enjoyed pizza and pasta. read more

Outstanding food at great prices prepared with love in the heart of the keys. Chef and owner Marvin Certa and his wife Jouna are fabulous. We really enjoy this place every time we come to our houseboat in Marathon. The dishes are generous and so tasty, and offered at a really good price. Go from 11 to 4 for the best deals! Margaritas are great too! My Awesome Husband says he could enjoy the snapper sandwich every single day. read more

See all

If you are in Marathon you have to come to this place, I love and can say they make the best Chicken Parmigiana I have ever eaten, my go to is snapper francese . 100% read more

The food was not good. The only thing that we got that was actually good was a side of fries. Couch fritters weren't bad just very chewy. Service was fine. Place was clean and nice on the inside. I personally won't be coming back. read more

Before I give my full review it is nice to have a restaurant accept debit credit cards after the hurricane that demolished the area. This is why I gave this place 4 stars Can't say it was extra extraordinary what I would say is that this restaurant is average for lunch. Between my friend and I we ordered sandwiches one of the being a cheesesteak sandwich which was a very basic, with a little bit of cheese that was melted onto The beef with very little flavoring and spices on the beef some onions and very little peppers, just A basic bread left me wondering whether I should just call it a steak sandwich instead of a Philly steak sandwich My friend ordered Parmesan chicken sandwich. The sandwich was warm not hot the fries was not even warm the chicken was generic and looked like it had just been pulled out of a bag the sauce was average not much on top of the chicken for portion there was very little mozzarella melted on top of the sauce as for the beard it was just a average biggie roll that had been toasted the fries were plain with no seasoning. Meals for lunch were adequate we didn't expect much a bigger lunch menu maybe it could have been better. Our waitress seem to be new job the order in which she took gave the service was a little bit off of gas in the restaurant our table check upon during our lunch experience to time The restroom need more attention to detail The sinks definitely need to be tidied up a lot of calcium deposit and a couple other aesthetics deafly need to be addressed Deafly will be back for dinner got to give it a try powder read more

Triton Seafood Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

This is one of those places that you could drive by a hundred times and not stop in, but once you do, you'll keep coming back. It doesn't look fancy on the outside, but the service from Michele and the amazing Italian food and seafood are absolutely outstanding. (In comparison, the next day we went to a highly touted, kitschy Keys well-reviewed seafood restaurant, and it didn't even compare to Triton!) I had the lasagna... it is usually what I order when trying a new Italian place. It's kind of my barometer. :) Michelle added perfectly cooked shrimp to her penne ala vodka. We were both so happy with our choices! We'll definitely be going back in the few weeks we're here, and we've already told a bunch of people about it, too. They have fantastic lunch specials that run until 4 pm, a full bar, and we can't wait to try their desserts when we go back. We were so stuffed with the lunch we had we didn't have any room at all for anything else. You'll love it! read more

My daughters and I went for dinner. We were greeted by a nice lady. She brought me two samples of their wine. We had the calamari. Spaghetti and Meatballs. Penne all's vodka garlic rolls were amazing Finished w Cannolis which were great Not a fancy restaurant. Meal was great will again Marvin the chef was nice as well read more

See all

Food was decent. My son had Penne Vodka with Lobster and I had the Hogfish special. The penne vodka was tasty but sauce was a little thin. Hoggish had a saffron sauce which I wasn't wild about but the fish was fresh. The entrees included a salad but lettuce was wilted like they prepared it early in the morning and it sat in fridge the entire day. The garlic rolls were fresh and hot out of the oven. The neighboring table ordered pizza, which looked very good and the people seemed to be enjoying it. Service was mediocre and the restaurant could use a complete redesign/renovation. One plus it has going for it is it is open later than most restaurants in Marathon. read more

If you're driving down Hwy 1 in Marathon and you see this place, turn in! Don't second guess yourself! Ask for Helen and get anything on the menu! I chose one of tonight's specials-hogfish, with pasta per her suggestion...did. not. disappoint!! read more

We ordered wings and fried mozzarella and were told delivery to hotel would be about 45 mins. Well after an hour we called to check and we're told (I think) that they didn't have the address right. We're at Fairfield Inn 1.2 miles from the restaurant! And the front desk recommended it ... so pretty sure they know where it is?! finally came and everything was cold. But the worse part is someone took a bite out of a wing and put it back in the container alerting the front desk staff not to recommend read more

This is a smaller place not on the water, which is probably why it doesn't get the love it should. Everything we had was amazing! Stuffed eggplant, lasagna, spaghetti ragu and meat lovers pizza were all delicious. The garlic rolls were hot, buttery and garlicky. The cannolis and tiramisu were the perfect ending. Our server Michelle was quick, attentive and funny. 10/10 recommend! read more

Bread was delicious and service was great. Ordered meatballs and Alfredo. There were onions in the Alfredo sauce which I wasn't expecting. Kids cheese pizza was a hit with the kids. We would come back again. read more

This is our second trip to Marathon, and we are always looking for good restaurants during our visit. Last night we found a GREAT one. We are from Philadelphia, so we know good Italian food, and my shrimp fra diavolo was some of the best I've had in a while. The shrimp were tender. There was lots of great sauce. And they were happy to serve it, as requested on fettuccine. We also met the chef Marvin and his wife Juana --- very nice. And we enjoyed watching the "family meal" they were serving to staff and family at the end of the night. A friendly place with great food. And don't miss the home made garlic rolls recommended by our waitress Ashlyn. read more