This REestaurant Bar is a JEM off the beaten path at mm20. It's worth a quick detour from US 1 to get a casual meal. Elegant facility clean and fresh. Wonderful menu with lots of varieties. The server staff was fabulous and very attentive. The drinks delicious. Extensive wine availability. I can't say enough about this wonderful dinner place. You must stop in! read more

Wow. First time visiting this restaurant. Everything was amazing. All the seafood dishes were great that our table ordered. Drinks were spot on and our server was professional. We'll be back. read more

A hidden treasure. Nestled in the small community subdivision, you are absolutely delighted when you open their door! The formal dinning area with an amazing patterned floor, tables made of designed wood, lighted wine display wall & a beautiful fireplace. The inside bar with its ocean blue color counter wrapping around to the outside bar, welcomes you to seat anywhere. The outside patio with a view of the channel intrigues you to stay and enjoy the local entertainment while watching manatees swim. Their food is delicious offering flavors of the tropics. Megan and Lara are top notch bartenders who greet you with smiles! read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - Octopus - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

See all

While touring Key West with friends, we had the pleasure of finding this restaurant in Sugarloaf Key! We stopped by for a few drinks in the afternoon and met Megan at the hostess podium. My friends and I were seated at the bar outside and we were served delicious fancy drinks. While speaking to residents, we were told that this restaurant has amazing food in the evening. I spoke to Megan and we made a quasi reservation for later that night. We came back for dinner and we're greeted by Megan again!. She seated us at a table and she was our waitress for the evening! Megan was wonderful! She was very attentive and made some great recommendations for food. We had several appetizers, our main course. We also has several drinks. Everything we orders was excellent. Megan made our experience even better than excellent! Definitely give this place a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - The outside bar and patio. - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

Came here on a Monday night and was seated right away without a reservation. The weather was nice so we opted to sit outside. A little darker than expected but it was okay. Our server for the night was good I will say that! Bread was served for the table and although the bread was delicious, the butter it came with was bad. I've never had butter taste like ice/water but imagine like a watered down version of butter... that's why we got. We just ate the bread alone. We ordered the Buffalo Bleu Cheese Brussel Sprouts and the Snail Cargot to start. The Snail Cargot was the worst escargot I've ever had. Dried out, bland and the dried cheese on top? Insulting. Once again -- just ended up eating the bread. The Brussel sprouts on the other hand were great. Not a flavor combo I expected to be good but it really was. This was the best dish of the night. As my entree I ordered the classic Caesar salad and added chicken. My bf ordered the Jerk Chicken Wings. The salad was good, came with a good amount of sauce and the croutons were good. Chicken was good as well. My bf said he liked the wings he had, but I didn't personally try them. He said they were good, not great. All in all, this place's specialty seems to be the bread. Other than that I wasn't very impressed. If I came back I would probably just order the Brussel sprouts again and that's it. read more

See all

Inside and outside dining, we dined outside since the weather was nice. Our server was friendly and gave us our menus, and took our drink order right away. I had the chicken sandwich and my husband had the fish and chips. We are definitely coming back again, food was delicious I forgot to take a before pic because I was starving but as you can see I devoured my sandwich! read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - Chicken sandwich eaten but you get the idea! - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

Quaint, friendly staff, delicious and fresh variety with super fresh seafood, chicken sandwich is the best we have had, and tons more! Full bar with a view! Don't miss it! Sits back in beautiful neighborhood. One of our favs! read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - Gorgeous view! - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

This was a very interesting evening. First off. We showed up with no reservation, just wanted to set the stage. After waiting about 15 minutes we got a table, in what looked like a bit overwhelmed restaurant. Three of us and one 7 year old. Server was quick to get waters and drinks, but then things stalled, big time . An hour after we ordered, still no food. Our server was pretty great, comped us an extra bottle of wine and expedited my granddaughters dinner . Much appreciated. When our food finally arrived everything was great. So, I understand that everyone has a bad day once in a while, and it's how you address the shortfalls that defines you. These guys did pretty well. As stressful as the meal was, our server was very professional and apologetic, and we still had a good evening. Not a 5 star event, but a solid 4. read more

I was told that this is a foodies restaurant. I am not one to post negative reviews about restaurants and I hate to complain. But I ordered the catch of the day which was grouper, it was extremely tough and ribber and did not flake apart at all...terrible! While the server was very good, they did not apologize or comp the meal, instead they brought out a huge heavy piece of bread pudding, it was supposed to be a Keylime dessert but it was just a heavy brick is bread and cream. It was obvious that the fish was not cooked properly or was it was not fresh grouper. Either way they should have comped me the meal. I will say that my husband's seafood pasta meal was very good. The ambience on the patio along with the live music was also very nice. read more

Highly recommend this restaurant. We ate here and the appetizers were great- burrata. They also had a lobster served like escargot ( lots of butter) which was fine, I didn't love it. I got the ahi tuna app and my husband got the stroganoff, he LOVED it. It was a great ambiance, they have a small res and then also a sports bar area? So could go either way. Server was very kind and even offered to clean our toddlers pacifier when it fell on the ground read more

We sat outside where there are thank goodness huge umbrellas because if the sun was beating down you would be cooked. The appetizer was octopus. The best I've ever had!! Very tender. Boyfriend loved it and it was the first time he's had it. We shared the lobster flat bread. Good but I've decided that spiney lobster is not my favorite. It's got to be in something to camouflage the flavor. Shared the seafood Alfredo that had shrimp, clams and mussels. Yummy! And plenty for the two of us. Service was good! read more

Chicken wings are so good here!! I have enjoyed everything I have eaten here! Great service! Cute outside seating on the marina side. Inside very nice also! read more

A absolute delight. The restaurant goes slightly off the main road, it is not in any way inconvenient to get to. The menu is excellent. (happy hour menu included.) the fresh specials are filled with excellent flavor profiles and the plating is wonderful. We go as often as we can read more

Came back with a group of ten again this year. Bent Prop does NOT disappoint! Great service, creative menu and lovely ambiance. Be sure to stop in if you are anywhere nearby. read more

Great place in a marina in Cudjoe gardens. Been twice and exceptional both times. Highly recommended

While the food itself was good, the service completely ruined the experience. We waited 45 minutes before our waitress finally came back to the table, only to tell us it would be another 8-10 minutes. After that, only half of our table's food arrived--and then another 20 minutes passed with nothing else coming out. At that point, the other half of our table gave up and left. The manager did comp the meal, which we appreciated, but unfortunately the snide and unnecessary comments from the wait staff afterward made the situation worse and felt unprofessional. Good food isn't enough to make up for extremely poor service and an uncomfortable atmosphere. Overall, it was a very disappointing experience. read more

Sat outdid Great food and service ! Not sure who the cranky reviewer was referring to. Brad was awesome. Shrimp & Grits Creamy Crab Soup Meatballs Chicken Sandwich Too full for desert so we took bread pudding to go. read more

Ordered the veal marsala. Sauce was light on marsala flavor but also very sweet. My husband's chicken was very good but very small like a Cornish hen. read more

Food Service and Ambiance was amazing. All the Employees are spot on. You never wait for a drink and Lara and Meg are just perfect at the bar. Martika is an awesome server and the food comes out in great timing. If you ever get a chance to speak to the owner Carolyn or the Manager Miranda give them Koodo's. read more

Excellent service! Love the new summer menu and cocktails! New wine list offers lovey choices to pair! Can't wait to go back!

My husband and I enjoyed the best meal in the Keys at The Bent Prop! We began with the grilled octopus paired with a Pinot Grigio. It was flavorful and delicious. We each had a pasta dish with shrimp. Not to be missed! Finished our meal with their key lime bread pudding. Service was friendly and attentive. We sat outside on the deck and enjoyed the view. Inside seating looked lovely. If you're looking for a five star experience, definitely try The Bent Prop! read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

So currently sitting here right now as i write this. I walk in with no reservations, was seated right away. Downside, have been ignored ever since. Not one person has came over to take my drink order, food order nothing! It has been over 15 minutes now! The place looks great and im sure the food is awesome i wish i could have some! Super disappointed in the staff and how blatantly ignored i have been. Definitely need to do better in staffing!!! read more

The Bent Prop has obviously worked hard to take its place among top restaurants on or near Cudjoe Key. Their food has been consistently super good, every time we go there with friends. The wait staff are great and some have been there a while. It's a solid option. We love the crispy buffalo chicken sandwich, the kids chicken tenders, burgers, wings and a lot of their main menu options are delish! The lobster entree was to die for. Keep it up BP!!! read more

Wonderful place!!! Don't let the name fool you. This is a classy, little Italian restaurant with a nice bar, great cocktails, extensive wine list and delicious food. I can't say enough about the fantastic staff!! Amazing experience, don't miss out. Shout out to Meggie, we love you even though the Packers won. GO BEARS. read more

Pretty excited to have this restaurant in the neighborhood. Nice atmosphere, good service, and the food was good. I will say I've had better fish sandwich's in the area (not entirely sure if it was fresh- as it was mildly fishy. To note, I'm very picky when it comes to fish in the keys). But overall, the experience was good and we will def be back. read more

See all

Nice, fun; outdoor bar is kind of clubby (In a good way;)). Good wine. Food is a break from grouper sandwiches.

Best restaurant in Cudjoe Key! Fantastic Food and service was great! I had the best grouper dinner ever with the mango salsa. Can't wait to go back. I would give it 10 stars. read more

the service, view and food were excellent. I had coconut yellow tail and asparagus. my husband had veal. would definitely go back.

Expensive, slow service, poor quality food. We will not return. We are locals so we have tried here more than once. read more

The food was very good and the staff were exceptionally friendly. The location is awesome with a fine dining experience inside or a beach bar atmosphere near the water. Prices are high. read more

We had such an amazing dinner at The Bent Prop! The atmosphere was so inviting and cute. We started with the calamari and tuna appetizers, and then had the chef cook our catch three different ways: lemon caper style, blackened, and fried. Our delicious fish was accompanied by rice, grits and vegetables served family style. The food was outstanding and the service was excellent. Would definitely recommend. read more

Great hidden gem in Cudjoe Key. We had a burger and lamb chops that were perfectly cooked and delicious . Ample portions. Not very expensive. Excellent service and ambiance. Highly recommended read more

I can't say enough good things about this place. The burrata appetizer with the mozzarella cheese and basil and arugula was beyond delicious and an amazing recommendation from Anna. The Cuban sandwich was delicious as well as the fried that came with it. Our Server Anna did an amazing job. The. Crazy lady lager and the. Local IPA were both quite delicious also. Side note- the restaurant is by a launch ramp which is alway entertaining. read more

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill - Burrata Appetizer - Bars Near Me - Cudjoe Key, Florida

See all

An absolute 10/10 experience! My husband and I have a 9 month old and a 2 year old and the staff was so friendly and accommodating. We sat outside and enjoyed the live music, or you can opt for the cool a/c and dine inside. There's also a great indoor/outdoor bar to go and enjoy an ice cold drink and hang out. The food was some of the best we've had in the keys! We shared the wedge salad which was phenomenal and I had the coconut encrusted snowy grouper special and it knocked my socks off. The owner was there and was so friendly and there were a few nice ladies who were regulars that were so friendly and sweet with our boys. We can't wait to go back! read more

This place was awesome. Great atmosphere with the outside waterfront tables and a nice interior. The food was incredible. Highly recommend!

I haven't ever left a review on a restaurant but this one was worth it. The food and service were excellent. The beef tenderloin stroganoff was to die for. My husband got the seafood pasta and loved it as well. read more

Been here a few times and seems it has been going down hill and after this last visit on New Year's we won't be coming back. We ordered our food and after an hour of waiting we were told that they had run out of the steaks and needed to order something else. We were asked, by I believe the manager if we were locals or just visitors and when we said locals he was caught off guard. Our waiter was pleasant at was trying his best to be accommodating but it was difficult for the poor guy. Sorry Bent Prop you have lost a customer. read more

See all

Good food and the service is great. Nice location outside and inside is lovely as well. Happy hour is a bargain By boat or by car

A gem of a restaurant and a must visit when you are down in the Lower Keys. Most authentic Maryland crab soup you'll find anywhere outside of the Chesapeake Bay. Wide range of entrées - all fresh food. Their catch of the day is always amazing. So many delicious choices, wish they were a tapas restaurant so I could have all my favorites every time we visit. read more

I gave such a good review earlier but after have one VERY HIGH priced dinner and another day trying to come back for apps I have to say the chef will be the reason they do not do well. Not willing to make any changes or simply cheesy fries - who can't make cheesy fries. You already have it on the menu for happy hour. The dinner also takes. FOREVER! I hate this but they need more time and a chef that at least makes what is on the menu and is willing to make simple things for customers read more

See all