We go to the Tuckahoe Inn several times each year, always in the summer... so we can sit out back overlooking the Tuckahoe River in the area they call their Back Bay Cafe, which is located right on the water, with comfortable tables, chairs and umbrellas. And a wait staff dedicated to the outdoor area. And a dedicated outdoor bar. It is absolutely a lovely place to eat in a relaxed outdoor atmosphere. The food is always outstanding, prepared to the standards of owner/master chef Tyson Merryman. Today I had their fajitas, a few weeks ago I had their Ahi tuna salad. Perfection. The wait staff is always friendly and attentive. I guess the highest praise I can give is... I keep coming back for more. Try it, you'll like it. read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Fajitas. Delicious. - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

See all

Ambiance is lovely outdoor location for dinning and or having a drink at the bar. My barkeep was manner-able/polite, my soup was good. However the clams had no flavor... the view and the soup get them three stars. read more

See all

Always the food and the service are fabulous! And the views!!!! However this time my filet was not a filet. It was a porterhouse without the bone. Just as delicious. But I wish they would have said. " we're out of fillets, but we have a porterhouse." and then adjusted the price accordingly. read more

My told me about a special the Tuckahoe was running. $25 from 12-4pm daily. Special menu but a lot of things on there (see my pic). My wife love prime rib and that was on the menu so off we went. Special includes soup or salad, entree and dessert (several choices). I opted for a cheesesteak off the regular menu as I sort of remembered it was very good. Well my memory was correct. Cheesesteak was excellent! High quality meat on a fresh delicious roll and just the right amount of cheese. Fries were excellent as well. My wife enjoyed her prime rib and was served perfect medium rare as she requested. We both enjoyed the bread pudding dessert which was enough for two. It tasted like a warm, moist cinnamon bun and covered in a warm vanilla syrup-YUM! I will order this any time. $43 not including tip and a perfect view of the bay read more

See all

Cute place. Nicely decorated for Christmas. We couldn't get the full experience because it was winter time and dark so some other time we will go back and see the view and the outdoor areas. I thought the food was good. It was decent. I had the fillet with crab meat and shrimp. I especially liked that I noticed that they had an outdoor cat house, taking care of the stray cats in the winter is something I do at my home in Pennsylvania so they get extra points for that. read more

See all

Been going here for years for my birthday With 15 plus people but this year whoever answers the phones is nasty. We'll take our business elsewhere. Thanks for the previous years of 5 stars Don't take much to be respectful read more

My partner and I had the petite seafood combination. It was amazing. Really good value for the price. Everything was delicious and so well seasoned. The only thing better was the service. Our waiter Danny P was so polite. He provided outstanding service. We will be back! read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Petite seafood combo on the 3 for $25 menu 12 - 4 - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

Packed evening at the Tuckahoe Inn for our party of 4. We had a great table on the porch by the window with a nice view but it was so loud it was often hard to hear each other. Service was very good. No apps for us tonight. Dinner salads are included. Pretty much bagged greens mix. Definitely not a fresh made/chopped dinner salad. Entrees came with new potatoes and green beans. My friend loved his filet mignon. The red snapper was enjoyed as well. I tried the flounder stuffed with crab imperial. The crab was tasty but the flounder overcooked and very bland. I wouldn't order it again. read more

Our Server Kerri was wonderful and the entire staff was warm and friendly. Kerri answered all of our questions, and staff circulated and checked on everyone in what was a warm and fun atmosphere for a first time diner. Our drinks and water were refreshed without asking, which is great! The Dining Room was clean and the Ladies Powder Room was well stocked. Our salad greens were fresh and the blue cheese dressing was cold and freshly made. We started with the Crab Imperial Onion Rings (which were crispy inside and topped with creamy and hot Crab Imperial, then split The crab cakes which were perfectly done. There's a nominal fee (less than $8) to split the meal, but totally worth it because each diner receives a crab cake (which is rather large and made with real crab meat) along with an ample serving of the two sides that come with the meal. (We chose the mixed vegetables and roasted potatoes which were cooked perfectly. The veggies were crisp but not hard and the potatoes were soft but not mushy.) Overall, 10 out of 10! (And we look forward to visiting again soon.) read more

Had a really nice night out for dinner on the water. It's a limited menu outside but the atmosphere is worth it. I had the crab cake sandwich with the corn salad and my partner had the French dip with fries. The crab cake sandwich was good, I wasn't crazy about the corn salad. The French dip sandwich was huge and the fries were really good. Service was great and the views were beautiful. Going back in the winter to try the inside menu. read more

Food excellent, atmosphere excellent and our server Caitlin was EXCELLENT. Our group of 7 had a reservation and our server allowed us to have 4 separate checks read more

A group of us went there last night, we had a reservation, there was a mix up with the count, it was a reservation for 9 they set the table for 8 then made a big to do about 1 seat. They split our party, totally unexceptionable, there was NO reason why they couldn't accommodate 1 more seat. The host was very rude to us, I don't know if he's the owner or not, but he needs to work on his people skills. That being said, the food?..cold, hard brussel sprouts, the menu said red bliss potatoes, they gave us au gratin potatoes, no explanation, when I told the waitress I couldn't eat them because of the cheese she said that's all they had. I had the prime rib, the steak knives are in desperate need of sharpening. You're lucky I'm giving you a 1 star read more

We stopped in for a dinner on the way to the shore. First visit, and we would recommend the Tuckahoe Inn! Nice, old school ambience, very friendly and attentive service from Marcello and other staff. We enjoyed our crab cakes and Maryland chicken with crab entrees. read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Crab Cakes - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

Visited on a recommendation. Happy hour was happening inside at the bar from 3-5pm. It was pretty busy, but we were able to get a high top table to have some happy hour drinks and appetizers. I had the Tuckahoe Tomahawk drink and bruschetta. My only negative comment on the inside was that it smelled pretty weird, and not in a good way ha. We also decided to check out the outdoor dining which is a different menu than inside and does not offer happy hour. They did have crossover on some menu items though. The view was so nice and they had some great live music. Excellent spot to grab a meal and drinks! read more

See all

I was so excited to revisit the Tuckahoe Inn for dinner during our vacation and sadly, it was totally disappointing. I ordered the Broiled Seafood Platter consisting of shrimp, scallops, lobster, and crab stuffed flounder. The lobster came out like rubber, the scallops were tasteless minus the paprika seasoning and the crab stuffed flounder was mush. I also ordered a glass of their recommended red wine and it tasted like water. our server Emily was a gem however, and exchanged the wine for a beer and removed the platter from our bill after i showed her the consistency of the lobster. We will not be returning read more

We've been enjoying Great meals and family gatherings at the tuckahoe inn for many years. There is ABSOLUTELY no better dining, service, or ambience anywhere!!!! read more

This place has decent crab cakes. I mean there aren't a lot of restaurant in this neighborhood, first of all. But they do make decent food. Price is okay. It seems that this place is always packed--at least the parking lot is. read more

See all

The food wasn't very good. My chicken parm looked like something they unboxed and put on the plate. It was dry and rubbery. The pasta wasn't seasoned. My wife's prime rib was over cooked, and over seasoned (way too salty). I do not recommend. We won't be going back. read more

10/10 experience- get the crab imperial onion rings and shrimp crab and filet mignon - server Meghan was absolutely delightful and so helpful read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Espresso martini and dirty martini - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

The food was excellent! Service was great and the atmosphere was festive!I would highly recommend this red as it exceeded my expectations! read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Our family of 12 - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

See all

Solid food, good atmosphere, altogether a decent spot. Have had some issues with wait times and service being a bit rude - the last time we were there the hostess blamed us for not answering the text alert that our table was ready, but we then showed her our phone directly and it turns out they never sent it to us. Still an ok spot! Review from 6/8 read more

Tuckahoe Inn - Crab cake sandwich - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

Went on Easter Sunday - was so very busy - but the food and service were outstanding - we did not feel rushed as there was nice spacing between courses. Would highly recommend! read more

Service and Ambiance were on point. From the hostess to our server and bus boy all was fine there. Food was awful. Clams casino used chopped clams with lots of peppers and breading. Calamari was very over cooked and Cesar salads were ok but dressing was jarred. My husband's stuffed flounder was mushy with no flavor, but he said veggies and potatoes were good. My snapper was swimming in some liquid that made the whole dish soggy and flavorless. Veggies were ok. read more

Came here for Saturday night dinner and made sure to make a reservations in you plan on coming during the weekend. We had a reservation and came half hour early and were seated promptly. Service and atmosphere was excellent. Try the calamari and try the filet. Both came out excellent and cooked to perfection. Definitely try the triple chocolate cheesecake for dessert. Also the homemade ice tea is very good and refreshing. Only thing is parking is difficult but you can park in street. read more

Dan our waiter was 5 stars, attentive and very accommodating. Is was an Easter menu We had shrimp and clams casino apps, average Main course we had salmon and two filet mignon dinners, the salmon was very good, the filets were not filets they were more like hunks of rib roast, very chewy and extremely fatty had to pick around to get a bite of meat. The desserts were very good. The view is very nice. read more

I visited Tuckahoe Inn last night for a friend's birthday dinner and we had a good time. Our server Katie was great and was very kind. There are many options on the menu and their specials were also interesting. The restaurant is pretty big and has a nice view of the bay. There was also live music being played in another room and I enjoyed that too! We ordered the Crab Onion Rings & Calamari as our appetizers and both were pretty average. I liked the Crab Onion Rings more than the calamari but I do wish the crab was somehow separate from the onion rings because I wanted the onion rings to be crispier. The calamari was also just okay. I really liked the sauces drizzled on top but the calamari was a bit chewy. I ordered the Chicken Parm as my entree which I enjoyed, but I'm not a fan of angel hair pasta, so the chicken was delicious and the pasta was okay. My friends both got the cheeseburger on the specials menu and that came on a pretzel bun. We all had a great time and had great service, but the food was fairly average. I'd still go again though so you will probably have a good time too! read more

See all

What a great way to spend a quiet, relaxed afternoon. We went to the Tuckahoe Inn for a late lunch/early dinner. We were meeting some others so sat outside by the bay. Sunny day...warm weather...quiet, peaceful. When the others showed up, I was ready to stay outside and enjoy the peace (take a nap), but they talked me into going in to eat (another of my favorite pastimes). And I sm glad they did. We were still in time for the afternoon specials - and special they were. I ordered the queen cut prime rib -believe me, it was plenty for me. The salad was fresh and delicious. Dessert was a disappointment - I didn't have room and had it to go. Ice cream does not travel that well. One other had the broiled flounder and said it was very fresh and flavorable. Another had the chicken parm....she devoured it! Food great...ambience great...time was great. Looking forward to the next visit. read more

This is the perfect place to have dinner at the owner is the most amazing person you will ever meet the food is amazing the view is amazing. Tuckahoe Inn is a well kept secret. Private location on the water in lovely Beesleys Point New Jersey read more

Scratching our heads at these negative reviews. Amazing service and meals. Not one single complaint from our table of 4. Can confirm the crab cake did not taste like sawdust. :) 2 apps, 4 entrees...all excellent. And so much food we all have lunch for tomorrow. read more

Daily Specials on m-f 12-3 excellent food. Host & wait staff very welcoming & attentive, food is very good. Soups, crab cake, sea food, entrees, salads all nicely prepared. Desserts are great ~ bread pudding is outstanding. Plenty of parking. Overall really nice enjoyable dining experience always. read more

Excellent food service and the view!!!!' Highly recommended! Prices are reasonable. It's worth the 25 mile drive from Cape May. Try not to go on a Saturday. But Sunday they do have old time favorites. Like a Turkey dinner with all the trimmings. read more

We had a great meal on a Sunday night. Their 3 for $25 is simply amazing!! Food was very good and very generous portions. Their clam chowder was great and the prime rib was perfect. Loved the restaurant's decoration and seating. The service was amazing and very professional. Highly recommend a visit if you're in Ocean City read more

It was alright. I wasn't super impressed teebs. Service was very good and quick the food didn't wow me. I liked the vibe tho and had fun with my friends!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Delicious meal and beautiful decor. Can't wait to go back during the Christmas holidays

Well I havnt been here for years and went for a family dinner of 20. I was quickly reminded why I stopped going. All the drinks came out and most were not made well. A lot of us ordered the lobster bisque. We all agreed it was trash. Ive had better at diners. The calamari was just weird with all kinds of extra ingredients. Most who tried it didnt like it and said with all the crap on it it was still somehow bland Many ordered crabcakes. All filler and not good for over $30. I tried it. Trash. Like slightly crabby mush. My wife got filet. Wanted it medium...it was well done. Like 6 of us got NYS steaks and had to put salt and pepper on it and still was not flavorful. Didnt help most were overcooked. Mine tasted like a dirty grill. Sides were barely catering quality. The prices they charge for this subpar food is ridiculous. The waiter was passing drinks over us. I had water spilled on me twice and soda once. WTF. Others said he dripped water all over them as well. He was good otherwise just needs to be more careful. The ambiance is fine...same as always. I liked the clams casino. It was also hot as heck inside and outside smelled like an outhouse. I could go on but I'll leave this one for the tourist. read more

Definitely not worth the money. Our first (and last) visit. Oysters were very good, bread is good, burrata was good. Shrimp cocktail was mushy, filet mignon was very tough even though only cooked medium. Desserts were okay. $235 pre tip and nah I would never come back. Ambiance is awful. Flies flying around all over (definitely not high scale) and the waiters literally running through the dining room. So weird! read more

I liked the atmosphere and the view. We went for a late lunch around 2:30 pm Saturday 1.14.23. Service was more than satisfactory. We had two J. Lohr Cabs, 1 Riesling, Burrata app, Buffalo Shrimp, Crab Cake Entree, and Filet with Shrimp and Crab Imperial. $140 total without tip. The good- Crab Cakes were low filler and quality lump crab. I liked the vegetables on the side. They were fresh and cooked al dente. All the food lacked seasoning in a big way. I was underwhelmed overall. My dining partner said the filet meal tasted like nothing. That is sad considering it was topped with crab imperial and had shrimp on the side. The place was pretty busy for an afternoon in the Winter on a biting weather day! I did notice most of the patrons were way older than us. I am 50! Perhaps that is where the mild seasoning decisions originate. This is a bit of a drive for us so we probably won't be returning anytime soon. read more

Went here last week with a party of 17. Everything was great! East parking. Clean restrooms. Excellent food at reasonable prices. The service was excellent, from the hostess to the waiter to the bus boys. Definitely recommend. read more

Food was good service was good and nice view too windy to eat outdoors but maybe next time

Overall rating: 1.9 stars out of 5 stars! Rather disappointing. Last time I was there was in the early '90's. This place has not improved nor even stayed the same. It's on a downhill slide! Visit Day/Time: 8 pm on a Saturday. Nov. 11, 2023 Wait for table time: 5 mins. with reservations. Ambience: An old, large Jersey Shore dining institution. A local mainstay, but Just an old clunker that really needs updating! It appears to have a very large full-service bar that is crowded. Local entertainment(?) provided. Menu Selections: Provides a limited selection for all, but a typical Jersey diner would have a better selection. Obviously, the people of Marmora/Beasley Point just don't know that there are better places to go to for Dinner. Prices: $ 25 to 35 average per person, no drinks. Food ordered and served: Crab Cakes diner and Roast Turkey diner. Crab cakes were rather good. Hard, tasteless green beans Turkey appeared rather brownish and had an off-taste, mashed potatoes were the powered type and watery. Green beans were somewhat hard/tasteless and the stuffing was tasteless. The best item on the plate was the canned/jelled cranberry sauce. Service: Slow, lacked attentiveness. Best bets: None that was observable. Issues: This place is far outdated, needs interior and MENU updating. Avoids: Everything. Would we go back? Nope, unless fully updated, or burnt to the ground and rebuilt. Reason(s) to go (or not go) there: Refer to above comments. Follow-Ups, if any: None yet. read more

Tuckahoe Inn - MENU - Back - New American Near Me - Marmora, New Jersey

See all