Great local Italian place in town! It's not very big, but that makes it homey and cozy. Very nice wait staff and the service was really good. As for the food we had a number of dishes - pasta with shrimp, a special fish selection (cod) and octopus. All were very yummy, fresh and made well. Also had a few spicy margarita's and wine so the drinks are also approved! I look forward to going back and trying more dishes. read more

I went last Sunday to celebrate my 50th birthday with my friends and it was amazing. Fried calamari and octopus was a top notch. Also Bake clams. I had the filet mignon and it was out of this world. My friends ordered the pork chops and most of them got the branzino. Everything was delicious. The restaurant is beautiful and cozy as Tracey, Ari, and Danny were friendly, welcoming and helpful. I recommend it and I would definitely go back again read more

Tutti Noi - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Tutti Noi is by far the best restaurant in the Oceanside, RVC, Merrick, area! Their food is so fresh & delicious - clean, organic ingredients. The service is on point as well. Once you taste their food, you will get it! Chicken Parm is perfect!! light & perfectly seasoned! not heavy! I have tried almost everything on the menu - every dish is better than the next! A MUST!! read more

My friend and I have been wanting to try this place ever since it opened. Every time we tried to go, it was closed, so just keep in mind that they're not opened on Mondays or Tuesdays. We went on a Thursday night and there were a couple tables open, but we decided to sit at the bar instead. It's a small restaurant though, so I'd recommend making a reservation when you go just to be safe! The bartender was super nice and he really went into detail about the restaurant. It seems that they really care about their customers and the ingredients they use in their food, which most places don't care for. We got the baked clams, orecchiette barese, and chicken capricciosa. Everything was delicious, but the chicken capricciosa was absolutely incredible! Overall, this was a really nice spot, and I would definitely come back! read more

See all

Beautiful place with great service and delicious, elevated cuisine!!! We really enjoyed our time there. Can't wait to bring friends and family to experience it. read more

Always a 5 star meal, fresh ingredients, made fresh coupled with great service and a neighborly feel. Never disappoints.

Love this place . The setting is intimate. The food is first rate and the owners and staff are caring and attentive.

Food was very good. Service was exceptional. Modern, tasteful decor. Contrary to some reviewers I found the owner refreshing. She cares about her restaurant and the experience of her patrons. My experience in Long Beach and vicinity has been mediocre restaurants. Owners seem to be too intimidated or apathetic and allow obnoxious, noisy customers to spoil everybody else's evening. Who presumes to order a meal when they have forgotten their wallet, as one reviewer criticized? Some of these reviewers obviously do not frequent finer restaurants. All in all a solid dining venue, certainly superior to other local options. A bit pricy, but ingredients are organic and I saw no sign of cutting corners. As I commented earlier. This seems to be a restauranteur who aspires to provide a quality dining experience and spares no effort to that end. read more

I came here explicitly for the Cacio e Pepe, which is one of the Four Pastas of Rome. Pasta Alla Gricia, Pasta Carbonara and Pasta Amarcitiana are the other three. Tutti Noi deviated from the traditional recipe: spaghetti, parmigiano and cracked black pepper. This is because the chef added pancetta and arugula to enhance the dish. The dish was delicious because the spaghetti was cooked to perfection, and all ingredients complimented each other well. It came out in 20 minutes, and the portion was huge. I had to take some home in a doggy bag. Staff was friendly, and they delivered outstanding customer service. I will definitely be coming back to Tutti Noi to try other items on the menu. Maybe I will try a different Pasta of Rome. read more

Tutti Noi - Cacio e Pepe with pancetta and arugula - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Went here on a dinner date Sunday night and it was a 5-star experience through and through. I called ahead to see if they had space for two and was given a very warm "Come on in, we'll save you a spot!" welcome from Tracy, who is one of the owners. Awesome start to the evening! As soon as you walk in, you immediately notice the restaurant's beautiful ambiance. I would describe it a simple yet elegant, in the best sense of both (if that makes sense). It is immediately obvious how much thought and care they put into every subtle detail, from the lighting, to the chandeliers, to the wall decor, and of course, to the food. Our waiter, whom I believe is named Franklin, was outstanding! He was courteous, charming, and extremely attentive. One of the many moments that highlighted his level of service and unique touch came right after our server assistant placed our appetizer on the table, which was an eggplant tower with the prosciutto di parma on the side. My date had mentioned she was vegetarian earlier (hence the meat on the side) and as Franklin passed by our table, he smoothly and gently moved the plate of prosciutto away from her and placed it much closer to me, before giving a quick smile and head nod as he floated away. As for the food, it was as outstanding as the service. The presentation of the eggplant tower was something you might see in a competitive cooking competition. It consists of house-made prosciutto, mozzarella, eggplant caponata, artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, olives. Each ingredient is carefully layered on top of one another, which results in a beautiful feat of gastronomic architecture that is bursting with flavor. While our instincts were to devour it after the first bite, it's the kind of dish you want to take your time with and savor for as long as possible. For my entre, I ordered the classic Italian dish, the Veal Parmigiano . The veal was a massive portion and was accompanied by a hefty side of linguini marinara. One really cool detail (at least to me) was how the Chef deliberately chopped the basil to different sizes for both the veal and the pasta, as opposed to simply sprinkling it on top of the entire dish. To say I was such a happy camper from the first bite to the last in a understatement. I truly can't wait to come back and order it again.. and again.. and again. For dessert, we shared the house-made cannoli which is made with impastata cheese, dried fruit and pistachios. It was definitely a good enough size for two and while we were already full, it had us contemplating ordering another. To quote my date, "This was the best Italian food I've ever had.. even better than any restaurant I've been to in Little Italy!" --- Spark notes: Amazing service; outstanding food; the Antipasto Freddo (eggplant tower) and Veal Parmigiano are a must! read more

See all

Unfortunately the owner Tracey Sabella refuses to honor gift certificates that were purchased alleging they are "too old". This has happened to multiple people including myself. I am able to provide the receipt for the gift card but to no avail. Can not recommend this place. read more

Tutti Noi - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

My first time there was very nice. Nice personal, very nice place, and even better food! Very good selections from wine and also very impressive menu of cocktails. Had a nice time and coming back soon to try different food. read more

Tutti Noi - Inside - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Fabulous, just fabulous! Beautiful ambiance, intimate space, professional and personal service, and excellent food and beverages! What more could you want?! Went twice within a week, with friends who came all the way from Brooklyn and loved it, and as a couple. Tracey friendly and welcoming at front of the house with her keen and beautiful design skills and her daughter Taylor making fantastic cocktails, plus Artie cooking amazing fresh and delicious food. Must go! Can't wait to return! read more

Tutti Noi - Sorry, we ate it all!! Shared Caesar salad, Cacio é pepe, Gamberi Calabresi, and Calamari grigliati. So good!! - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Food was great, nice small family friendly place. If you're in the area its a good option.

I'm not a big fan of crowds, so I put trying this restaurant, but I may have waited too long. Definitely a cute local place, service was very good in, but the food was disappointing. We had three appetizers. The only one I could say that was notable was the clams in broth. Then, two entrées, both were over cooked. The fish truly was a disappointment in that it was very overcooked and truly liked any flavor. Perhaps if I go back with lower expectations, I might enjoy it more but at this time I don't know if I'll be going back. read more

Loved it!!! Food is delicious!!! Loved the atmosphere, great spot!!! Sunday sauce is very close to home. read more

Celebrated Mother's Day with my Aunt and Sister Quaint, comfortable with a family atmosphere Food was fresh, tasty & adequate portions cooked to perfection We will return with more family and friends. read more

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED On August 29, 2019, I hosted a dinner for 8 at this outstanding new Italian restaurant. There is a parking lot in the rear of the restaurant as well as a muni lot behind the businesses on the next block south so parking should present no challenges. The friendly hostess greeted me and I stepped up to the bar to enjoy a great Grey Goose Vodka Martini. Insofar as I arrived early I had time to enjoy a beer as well. I was tired of the typical Peroni or Morretti so my very pleasant bartender steered me to a lager style Birra Antoniana. It is a great beer. Try it. The restaurant seated our group immediately at our 7:00 reservation time. The dining room was relatively small but attractive, as was the sparkling new bar. Our server, whose name escapes me, was terrific and very attentive the entire evening. I started my meal with the Baked Clams Oreganata. Those eight babies were fresh and perfectly seasoned. I loved them...but not as much as my first love, Veal Osso Buco, available at the very reasonable price of $40.00 ($15 less than Giulio Cesare). I loved the Osso Buco!! It was a HUGE shank accompanied by delicious Saffron Risotto in the classic manner. The veal meat was tender as butter. There was also a lot of marrow. I cannot remember a better Osso Buco experience. I finished my meal with Vanilla Affogato which was creamy and luscious. Another winner!!! My fellow diners enjoyed the Fried Calamari, the Burrata App, Penne Minestra, Branzino, Salmon, Linguine Pescatore and Cacio E. Pepe. As to desserts, the Nutella Affogato, Italian Ricotta Cheese Cake and Tartufo. I I left Tutti Noi VERY SATISFIED. BOTTOM LINE: Tutti Noi, despite its short existence, is already one of the best Italian restaurants on the South Shore. read more

See all

I go to Tutti Noi often. They continue to provide excellent food and service. They are consistent. The owners do their best to provide a great dining experience. Helen does an amazing job as well. Unfortunately there was a couple in there tonight that tried to sabotage their business. The male was even aggressive standing up over the female owner. Tutti Noi is a local business trying their best. read more

This spot had an absolutely amazing salad special when I went here for dinner (strawberries and peaches, absolutely delightful) I enjoyed clams oreganata as an appetizer along with some mozzarella and tomatoes. I was blown away by the tasty homemade tartufo for dessert. Will be back. read more

I had what was, hands down, the best meal I've ever had in Oceanside. Started with a pair of appetizers -- a tender grilled octopus and then an antipasti platter that included the most amazing fresh mozzarella that I've ever tasted. I'm serious. Next year for my birthday, forget the cake; get me a large platter of this mozzarella with a couple of slices of prosciutto on top. The two mains we had were also really well done, a grilled salmon that remained flavorful and juicy; and the tortellini bolognese bianco -- a cream sauce absolutely loaded with sausage, mushrooms and peas. For dessert, an authentic Italian cheesecake that was only surpassed by what my Nonna used to make, and a perfectly brewed espresso. read more

See all

Over rated, and underwhelmed. Prices too high, Food is only so-so, and the owner is not very friendly. You could do better. read more

abnoxious owner. i asked to settle with apple pay which is the pretty standard everywhere else, she abnoxiously yelled "No" for the entire restaurant to hear. I usually bring my wallet but forgot it this time. As a senior leader for the biggest employer in oceanside, I find that sort of judgmental behavior repulsive and will never visit again. I used to come to this place regularly and the food is always great. Word to the wise, never judge a book by its cover. read more

I absolutely loved this place!!!! Love the chic atmosphere and the food was great! My fav was that they had gluten free pasta and dessert! I can't wait to go back!!! read more

See all

Everything we tried was excellent. Appetizers, salads main dishes and dessert met our expectations. read more

Exceptional restaurant ! The food, service and ambiance is perfect! Make a reservation today!

Wonderful food and atmosphere. Combined bar and tables. Chicken capriccio was amazing. One of the best places I've found in Oceanside. Highly recommend. Yum! read more

I highly recommend this amazing restaurant. We hosted our daughter's engagement celebration this past Sunday and it was absolutely incredible. Tracey and her staff made this an unforgettable party. The food, decorations and service was a 10 out of 10. Thank you Tracey for making this so special. read more

Not a Fan, the food is ok, the service, and the hostess is not! Would I come back? Defiantly Not. read more

Celebrated my brother's high school graduation. Food was excellent. Service was better! Elegant & elevated ambiance. Loved the music playing in the restaurant. Would be really nice for a date night! read more

Owner and wait staff friendly, atmosphere cozy, food very good, Clams Oreganato excellent. We felt, however, that prices were a bit high for an Italian restaurant. read more

Went here the first time and it was fabulous! Service was superb and food was exceptional. Yes, I am a foodie and I have found my new fabulous place in my backyard! read more

Honestly one of the best meals and service I've had a long time! Truly stellar the food was off the charts, my husband had the veal chop special and I had the veal Marsala while our friend had the chicken Marsala flavor depth, fresh ingredients, amazing!! Great staff and Oceanside's best kept secret read more

Food was so fresh and delicious. Drinks were amazing as well. service was impeccable. And really Enjoyed the atmosphere. Local gem! read more

Excellent food. The wait staff was very attentive & followed the social distancing protocol. I would definitely go back. The burrata and beet salad was so fresh and delicious I need to have it again... soon! read more

Food was great but waited 45 minutes for our table. No drinks were offered for our wait. Water was offered but we wanted tap water and were charged $9 for water. As we sat at the bar waiting for our table, we waited 15/20 minutes before the bartender took our drink order. We felt no one was acknowledging us for our wait. Terrible management :(((The owners took no responsibility! very curt! Sad to be an Oceanside resident and be treated this way! read more

My boyfriend & I LOVE eating here. The owner is so nice and accommodating. The food is delicious! I recommend ordering the Paccheri Affumacante. We order it every time because it is beyond delicious. The eggplant tower is a great appetizer as well. read more

Tutti Noi - Home made cheesecake - Italian Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Stacy was outstanding and the food and cocktails were also fantastic! Everyone there were so friendly and accommodating to our group of 6. We had a blast, enjoyed the gnocchi special app, mussels, clams & sausage, caprese to share. Will be back for sure! read more

Grilled calamari was insane!!! Bronzino and salmon.... delicious! Drinks are incredible! Spicy blood orange, Just the right amount of heat! Katlyn makes the drinks perfect. Decor is beautiful. Parking in the back. A must try!!! read more

OK food, with a nice bar, but the prices are too high and the Owner is too Rude. There are plenty of other place to spend your money